Us Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs

It's no Get Out, but still pretty good.

Us Lupita Nyong O
Universal

Jordan Peele's new horror film Us hits cinemas worldwide this weekend, and it's rather unsurprisingly been winning rave reviews from the vast majority of critics so far.

While some of the five-star notices might feel a tad on the overzealous side, Us is a very solid follow-up to Peele's Oscar-winning Get Out, even if it's going to be unavoidably hurt by the inevitable, endless comparisons to that sure-fire genre classic.

Peele's sophomore effort never quite slams into the same brilliantly subversive gear, but when considered among the typical standard of studio-released horror movies, this is a highly entertaining offering for the most part.

It's unlikely to become quite the same pop-culture and awards phenomenon that Get Out was, but it nevertheless cements Peele's talent for boundary-pushing work that asks its audience to pay attention and actively engage with the material.

It's definitely worth lowering your expectations a tad if you're expecting something on the level of Peele's previous film, but all the same, Get Out is a (mostly) entertaining follow-up...


Downs...

3. The Disappointing Lack Of Scares

Us 2019
Universal

Jordan Peele made it clear before the movie's release that Us would be far more of a straight-up horror film than Get Out, so it's a touch disappointing that it largely feels so lacking in scares and suspense.

In fact, Us is often more effective as a comedy than it is as a horror, with much of the central scenario revolving around fairly conventional home invasion set-pieces and, yes, even the occasional jump scare.

The presence of the Tethered doppelgängers is inherently creepy, for sure, but moment-to-moment the atmosphere is oddly lacking in dread or even basic tension.

Thankfully the cast and crew do their damn finest to keep the film compelling regardless, but if you were hoping that Peele might out himself as a master of tightly-wound thrills, you might be left a tad underwhelmed.


2. Jordan Peele's Surprisingly Messy Script

Us Lupita Nyong O
Universal

Easily the biggest issue with Us - or at least, its most divisive aspect - will be Jordan Peele's script, which while undeniably detailed and ambitious, doesn't feel remotely as water-tight as his Oscar-winning script for Get Out.

For starters, character and narrative logic is rather inconsistent throughout, and only increases as the pic's overlong 116-minute run-time trundles along.

Peele arguably gives his big conceit away a little too early, while a later section of the movie flatly over-explains details which would've been so much better left ambiguous.

And there's also one big reveal that's sure to split viewers right down the middle, if only because Peele eschews subtlety altogether and telegraphs it with an unexpected aggressiveness.

Us isn't a badly written movie by any means, but it does ultimately feel like a less-coherent jumble of intriguing yet half-baked ideas that don't really add up to a satisfying whole.

Needless to say, it's unlikely Peele will be repeating his prior Oscar love next year.


1. It's Nowhere Near As Good As Get Out

Us Lupita Nyong O Winston Duke
Universal

There's been an enormous tidal wave of hype surrounding Us, and given the hugely unexpected success of Get Out, it's no surprise at all.

But the marketing and the reviews may well be setting audiences up for disappointment, because this is categorically a lesser film than Peele's debut in almost every way.

If you're expecting another trenchant and devastatingly timely social commentary movie with genre trappings, Us instead offers a more opaque "message" while placing a greater focus on genre thrills, which ultimately don't feel anywhere near as nourishing.

But again, by any typical standard Us is a very solid movie, albeit one that's sure to leave some viewers reeling from their expectations of another Get Out.

These issues accepted, Us more often than not delivers a captivating, bewildering time at the movies, so here's everything it gets right...


Ups...

6. Lupita Nyong'o's Fantastic Performance

Us Lupita Nyong O
Universal

If there's any one reason to watch Us, it's absolutely Lupita Nyong'o, who undoubtedly gives one of the strongest performances of the year so far - a dual performance, in fact - as Adelaide and her Tethered equivalent.

The tricky nature of the movie's premise requires Nyong'o to make a lot of complex choices while also juggling the duality of her two characters, and she absolutely knocks it out of the park.

As both the wide-eyed, shell-shocked Adelaide and the obscenely creepy Red, Nyong'o is absolutely captivating, owning the screen at all times and easily propping the movie up even when the script falters.

The early Oscar talk surrounding her performance might be a tad overblown - it's no "Toni Collette in Hereditary" situation - but Nyong'o once again confirms herself to be an extraordinary talent, and the film would be a much tougher sell without her presence.


5. Its Thought-Provoking, Ambiguous Themes

Us Lupita Nyong O Winston Duke
Universal

Like Get Out, Us is a film which invites a wealth of interpretation from the viewer, and regardless of Peele's own intent when penning the script, audiences are naturally going to walk away with their own conclusions.

Thankfully Peele keeps the precise nature of his message ambiguous, beyond declaring pre-release that he was majorly concerned with the notion of "we're our own worst enemy."

That's certainly a major takeaway from the film, though given Peele's clear desire to pass comment on contemporary America through his work, there's also a metaphorical interpretation of class and existence within the current U.S. paradigm.

But again, the great strength of Us is in challenging the viewer to make sense of its more ambiguous and mysterious central themes compared to Get Out, which laid it out with comparative obviousness (though, one can argue, also greater effectiveness).

Messy though Peele's script is here, he should be commended for giving viewers plenty to ponder after the credits have rolled.


4. Jordan Peele's Meticulous Direction

Us 2019
Universal

While Us isn't as well-written as Get Out, it nevertheless sees a major uptick in the quality of Peele's direction.

While Get Out wasn't an especially remarkable movie from a directorial standpoint, Us feels decidedly more ambitious visually, with punchy shot selections and an abundance of images which stick firmly in the mind.

Much like Get Out, Peele uses visuals to hide key clues about the nature of the plot, which are sure to be make subsequent viewings extremely rewarding.

Knowing how deviously Peele constructed his previous film, it's undeniably fun scanning every frame of this movie and paying extra attention to every morsel of dialogue, seeking out hints for what might be unfolding.

Needless to say, Peele makes pretty much every shot of Us either stylish or information-dense, showing considerable growth as a filmmaker in the process.


3. The Strong Supporting Cast

Us Elizabeth Moss
Universal

Lupita Nyong'o may decisively steal the show, but every single performance in this movie delivers.

The obvious stand-out beyond Nyong'o is Winston Duke as her husband Gabe, who accounts for much of the film's humour, while Elizabeth Moss and Tim Heidecker are a riot as the couple's boozy, dysfunctional pals Kitty and Josh.

The film's two major child actors, Shahadi Wright Joseph and Evan Alex, also do splendid work as Adelaide and Gabe's children Zora and Jason, nailing the duality of their dual-roles as ably as their adult co-stars.

Simply, nobody's phoning things in here or doing even merely adequate work: everybody's bringing their A-game, and it elevates the end result significantly.


2. Mike Gioulakis' Excellent Cinematography

Us 2019
Universal

In addition to Peele's direction feeling more assured than in Get Out, this is also a far more handsome movie thanks to the efforts of cinematographer Mike Gioulakis.

Having worked on the likes of It Follows, Split and Glass in recent years, Gioulakis is well-versed in the genre and does a fantastic job making every frame of this film look as richly cinematic as possible.

The easy visual highlights include some sun-kissed exteriors later in the movie and a scene taking place on an escalator, both of which present extremely moody and vibrant images.

Between the cinematography, Peele's improved directorial eye and pin-sharp editing from Nicholas Monsour, this movie is a visually sumptuous effort in even its lesser moments.


1. The Clever Use Of Music

Us 2019
Universal

Us wouldn't be quite the same movie without its music, both in terms of Peele's use of pre-existing pop music and a cracking original score from returning Get Out composer Michael Abels.

For starters, Luniz's mid-90s rap classic "I Got 5 on It" is cleverly invoked and then subsequently remixed by Abels, while another memorable sequence in the film uses a certain classic tune from late-80s rap to hysterical effect.

Abels' score is the real star of the show, though, employing nerve-rattling string work and accounting for much of the film's mood even when the attempts at suspense aren't necessarily successful.

What did you think of Us? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Jordan Peele
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.