X-Men: 10 Major Plot Holes Days Of Future Past Created

You were meant to bring balance to canon! Not destroy it!

Fans are still singing the praises of the latest instalment in the X-Men Franchise: Days Of Future Past, and with good reason. Bryan Singer's star studded movie was the most ambitious comic book film since the Avengers. It had possibly the largest cast ever assembled (too large in fact, sorry Rogue!), the always complicated time travel plot, the expectations of doing justice to the classic comic book of the same name and the task of redeeming the series after the regrettable Last Stand and Origins: Wolverine. Wouldn't you know? It was a rousing success! Featuring strong performances from all, some blinding battle scenes, a wonderful introduction to Quicksilver (Seriously, who saw that coming?) and a definitive end to the original trilogy, DOFP was one of the finest movies of the fourteen year spanning series. That said, when you have to tie together six previous movies, four of which were made by different directors, you have a strong task ahead of you. Introduce time travel into the mix, and you're just asking for trouble. The movie did a great job of writing out some of the less desirable parts of the X-Men universe, but not without creating some plot holes itself. So join us as we count down the ten biggest questions that DOFP raised instead of answering. Oh and of course SPOILERS! are everywhere.

10. How Is Charles Xavier Still Alive?

Fans have been asking this since the end of the Last Stand. After being disintegrated by Dark Phoenix, Xavier apparently survived by transferring his consciousness into the body of a coma patient in the care of his long time friend Dr Moira McTaggart. We say apparently because he appeared in his own body, alive and well (yet somehow still in a wheelchair) at the end of the Wolverine and at the beginning of DOFP. Nobody seemed at all surprised to see the Professor still among the living. Bryan Singer may have sneakily used time travel to undo Xavier's death in the Last Stand, but that doesn't explain how he was alive before Wolverine went back and changed history. We get that Singer was determined to ignore Brett Ratners movie (like the rest of us) but you can't just pick and choose what happened and what didn't!

9. How Did Wolverine Get His Adamantium Claws Back?

James Mangold's The Wolverine is generally considered an improvement over Gavin Hood's X-Men Origins: Wolverine (even if it did do to Silver Samurai what Origins did to Deadpool). Set after the events of the Last Stand, Wolverine travels to Japan to say goodbye to an old friend, only to lose his healing factor and end up on the run from the Yakuza. During the film's final battle scene, Wolverine gets his trademark adamantium claws chopped off by the Silver Samurai, but manages to regrow his original bone claws. The movie ends with a post credits scene where Wolverine is recruited by Magneto and the mysteriously still living Professor X. However in DOFP, Wolverine has his Adamantium claws back in the future scenes, as Kitty Pryde found out the hard way. It's highly unlikely that Wolverine would have volunteered for the Weapon X program again so we're forced to ask just how the hell he got those claws back?

8. How Did Magneto Get His Powers Back?

Magneto Powers Back Gif It seems we will never get an answer to this one. During the climax of the Last Stand, Magneto was injected with the Cure, which throughout the movie had effectively removed the powers of every mutant who had contact with it. However at the end we see the master of magnetism in the park manipulating a metal chess piece. The question is how? Did Magneto somehow develop a cure to the Cure? Is his DNA simply immune to it? Or is the Cure only temporary, eventually wearing off, no matter who is affected? Rogue also took the Cure in the Last Stand (in her case voluntarily) and it has been implied that she still has her powers in the future. We will have to wait for the extended cut to find out, but we definitely saw Erik using his powers during the final battle. Once again nobody seemed remotely curious about it. Presumably Bryan Singer made sure no questions were asked.

7. Who Is The Real Trask?

The film's main antagonist Bolivar Trask, creator of the mutant hunting Sentinels, is best known for his appearance in DOFP, but he actually appeared in the Last Stand first. Played by Bill Duke, this version is simply referred to as Trask, but Bryan Singer confirmed that he is in fact Bolivar. This raises several questions, the least of which is how he has aged so little in fifty years. The DOFP version of the character is played by Game of Thrones star Peter Dinklage, who obviously bares no resemblance to his Last Stand counterpart. Since that version played a major role in DOFP, whereas the Bill Duke version was only a minor character thrown in to an already overcrowded movie, hopefully few would have noticed the character in the Last Stand. Still, those of us who did notice demand answers. And we demand them now!

6. How Can Kitty Pryde Use Time Travel?

Another major plot hole that we were just asked to accept without question. Kitty Pryde has the incredibly convenient power to send individuals back in time, yet there was absolutely no mention of this in any of her previous appearances. Granted Bryan Singer was in a tough predicament. How does one feature big money draw Wolverine as the star, while staying faithful to the comic where Kitty Pryde was the one who traveled through time? He did the best he could and still made Kitty relevant to the plot, but it was rather lazy to offer no explanation. Has Kitty always had this power, or did she acquire it between movies? Maybe she always had time traveling powers and she just discovered them by accident... years after several tragic events where time travel would have really come in handy!

5. Why Did Xavier Originally Decide To Reopen The School?

When Wolverine goes back in time he discovers that Charles Xavier has seemingly given up his mission to provide a safe haven for runaway mutants. After Raven Darkholme's departure and the subsequent loss of his legs, Xavier became depressed, shut off and dependent on a drug that allowed him to walk at the cost of his powers. It's pretty grim. Wolverine tries and fails to talk him back around, but of course patience isn't his strong suit. He eventually decides to let Charles enter his mind, so that he can communicate with his future self, and only then does Charles fully understand the importance of his power and his mission to all of muntantkind. It's a powerful scene, but we do have to wonder: Before Wolverine ever arrived in the past, how did Xavier come to have this epiphany on his own? The Xavier we meet in the original trilogy showed no signs of ever having doubted himself, or fearing his powers. It's possible we suppose that it was the news of Raven assassinating Trask that woke him out of his depression, but we never actually got an explanation.

4. How Did Magneto Originally Escape The Pentagon?

The stand out scene of the movie is undoubtedly Quicksilver aiding the X-Men in breaking their nemesis Magneto out of the Pentagon. We're told that Erik was serving a life sentence for supposedly assassinating JFK. Turns out he was trying to save him, but that actually raises far more questions than we have time for. So Quicksilver busts Magneto out of his cell and then disappears for the rest of the film, despite proving himself to be extremely useful. But what we want to know is how Magneto escaped without Quicksilver? It was Wolverine who traveled back in time and convinced Charles and Hank McCoy to free Erik. It was Wolverine who suggested tracking down Quicksilver, and of course it was Quicksilver who played the most vital part of all. But if Wolverine never came back to the past, how did Erik originally escape his life sentence? Maybe Mystique could have broken him out, but we'll never know for sure. Also, we're being really nitpicky here, but when did Erik find the time to father a son? Especially one that only looks about ten years younger than him?

3. What Ever Happened To Magneto Anyway?

During the epilogue of the movie, we get to see the whole gang together again. Everyone is alive, Rogue makes it into the movie after all, even Kelsey Grammer stops by as Beast and Scott and Jean are back as well. But conspicuous by his absence is a character who is just as essential to this series as the titular heroes themselves, Magneto. We last see the young Erik escaping the scene at the end of the White House battle, where he will presumably bide his time until the events of X-Men (2000). The last time we see the Ian McKellan version is when he dies during the Sentinel's attack in the future, but of course that timeline no longer exists. So where does the X-Men's arch enemy fit into this happy new era that was created by Wolverine's actions. What happened to Mystique for that matter? Since the Last Stand no longer exists, Mystique was never cured, and so she would still posses her shape shifting abilities and presumably still be aligned with Magneto. We suppose the two of them could still be out there, but this was supposed to be the final appearance of the original cast so it's a crying shame that we may never see what became of them.

2. Is Jean Grey Still The Phoenix?

The other big news from the epilogue is that Jean Grey and Cyclops are still alive and that's something of a relief. That is until you realize that Jean's Phoenix powers (as defined in these movies) are still dormant in her subconscious. The assassination of Bolivar Trask and the creation of the Sentinels is completely unrelated to Jean becoming the Phoenix, and so Wolverine preventing the former, does not just automatically prevent the latter. Happy though the ending is, we're afraid Jean might still possess powers beyond her control and so Wolverine and Professor X will have to tread very carefully to avoid another incident like the last time. Then again if Bryan Singer were to bring back the original cast one last time and have a go at the Dark Phoenix movie he originally intended to make, then we would definitely allow him that chance.

1. Where Has Apocalypse Been This Whole Time?

We've been told that the new timeline created after DOFP will introduce long overdue X-Men foe En Sabah Nur AKA Apocalypse. The first mutant even appeared in the post credit scene along with his four horsemen. Excited though we all are at the prospect of Apocalypse making his proper big screen debut, we can't help but wonder where he has been all this time. Wolverine only changed history after 1973. Everything before then would remain exactly the same, including the post credits scene. That scene took place in Ancient Egypt, sometime around 300 BC. So naturally En Sabah Nur would have been around in some form long before Wolverine ever traveled back in time. Though Wolverine created an alternate timeline where Apocalypse will be a threat, his actions did not create Apocalypse himself. So where was he during the original trilogy, and the three spin offs? The 2016 movie will undoubtedly explain how he came to be in this new timeline, but we will forever question what he was up to during the original. Thanks for reading. Any other plot holes you noticed? Let us know below!

Contributor
Contributor

As a wrestling fan I've flown across the Atlantic for the last five years specifically to attend WrestleMania (28 and 30) as well as TNA, ROH, Evolve, Chikara and most recently PWG. I may have a problem! But if you're reading my work then you probably love wrestling too, so lets focus on that!