10 Beloved Video Game Moments That Would Be Too Offensive In 2017
Oh, Final Fantasy VII, you've not aged well...
In gaming, progression tends to happen far faster than any other entertainment medium. Just at time of writing, Bioware are profusely apologising for the portrayal of a transgender character in Mass Effect Andromeda, patching in new dialogue, responses and ways to interact with them, all as a direct response to specific conversations they've had with consumers since launch.
It's not the first time, either. Tekken's Katsuhiro Harada walked back the implementation of various 'swimsuit' costumes for Tekken 7 after a minor outcry on Twitter, The Punisher's various torture scenes were forced to ship with a black and white filter in 2005, and even Rockstar changed the name of Bully to 'Canis Canem Edit' in the UK after controversy swelled around what many assumed would be a game that glorified child violence.
Spoiler: It wasn't anything of the sort.
Whilst the debates surrounding what is acceptable, offensive or morally questionable tend to get new candidates every day, gaming as a medium has a history forever linked to immaturity, or the whims of "a teenager living in their mom's basement". To that end, there are a ton of enjoyable, fantastic and totally acceptable moments from their respective times, that would get immediately shut down today...
10. Punching Khalisah Al-Jilani In Mass Effect
At the time: A ridiculous and unexpectedly hilarious scene, where upon gaining Spectre status and being welcomed by the Alliance military and the Citadel Council, you're granted a multitude of interviews with one Khalisah Al-Jilani; a mostly chirpy and talkative reporter looking for a 'scoop', who the game lets you punch square in the face if you don't like her manner of speaking.
Mass Effect's community and Bioware themselves acknowledged the scene's positive response, making Al-Jilani a returning character - one you can punch in the sequels, yet in ME3, she'll attempt to duck your first blow, only to be levelled by the second. Less anything relating to gender and more how we'd all like to treat the gutter press, this is one of the most 'GIF'd' moments in gaming history.
Now: Poor taste. Why did Al-Jilani have to be female? Of course the 'annoying' reporter would be female, and of course the option to resort to violence would present itself after only a handful of questions.
There aren't any other characters in the original Mass Effect whose interactions you can end by punching them in the face, thereby Mass Effect is labelled as a game that promotes violence against women. And she's of asian descent too, so throw 'glorifying racial abuse' in there, too. Disgusting.
9. Call Of Duty's AC-130 Drone Cam
At the time: We collectively marvelled at just how lifelike and incredibly realistic Modern Warfare's drone-cam level looked. Blasting all those white blips into smithereens was a literal and figurative blast - one that helped cement Call of Duty 4 as one of the finest military shooters of all time.
Now: Thanks to the proliferation of drone strikes taking so many innocent lives in the real world, games like Spec-Ops: The Line and This War of Mine have addressed the desensitising effects of using them and/or the fallout of conflicts in general. Mainly thanks to a mix of progress made through gaming as a medium and the altered landscape of how drones as an aspect of war are received, including a sequence that lets the player enjoy seeing the world in literal black and white would never end well.
The Modern Warfare remake skirted by on the fact it was re-rendering something from years gone by, but the political and global climate isn't in a place where anybody even remotely aware of overseas conflicts and the impact of drones could play with a guilt-free conscience.
8. Identifying Meryl Through Her Bum-Wiggle In Metal Gear Solid
At the time: Another aspect of "Oh, you!" in regards to how Hideo Kojima portrays the majority of his women, even back in 1998 this was seen as more than a little perverted. You're literally playing as this super-secret soldier attempting to stop total nuclear annihilation, and the doctor you're getting your intel from states that your next port of call is to identify a soldier thanks to the way she "kind of wiggles her behind."
Cut to when you're in a room full of guards and Konami over-animated the hip-twiddling of one particular character model, forcing you to enter first-person and suss out which of the oscillating derrieres is the one you want.
Now: It's true that Kojima is mostly being self-aware when it comes to portrayals of sexuality - he tends to go with a "I know you're thinking it, so here you go!" mentality - although that always only ever addresses a horny male demographic. In MGS' case, it's very hard to imagine a situation where a prominent, otherwise forthright and militaristic individual is identified by having the player stare directly at her backside, before chasing her into the toilets for an actual conversation.
Just look at the reaction to MGS V's Quiet, and that came after the world had adjusted to Mr. Kojima's 'portrayals' of the female form.
7. Cross-Dressing Cloud & Portrayals Of Gay Men In Final Fantasy VII

At the time: A joke played at both Cloud and any (assumed-to-be-male) player's expense, it's revealed the only way to get into one Don Corneo's mansion is by dressing as a couple of "babes", resulting in a fetch-quest that sees Cloud acquire the requisite materials. The sequence also includes a visit to Bro's Gym, where both Bro and his group of friends are played as suggestive, more predatory gay men - again for the sake of comedy.
(11:24 on the below video)
Now: Whilst one particular author has written a fantastic article about how Cloud donning a dress actually really helped them live a more comfortable life, there's no doubt this experience would be in the minority. As mentioned in the introduction, Bioware are patching out a character simply talking about their former name after transitioning to a new identity, never mind the idea of playing off the act of cross-dressing as 'hilariously awkward'.
Then there's the portrayal of gay men as being inherently predatory - an outdated mentality the likes of Richard Simmons made a career off - and in FF VII's case, a scene where Cloud gets involuntarily groped and felt up in a jacuzzi by a number of larger, burlier and more aggressive homosexuals.
Check out the clip above - it really is rather something when seen through a modern lens, and it'll be a miracle if the remake keeps this scene in any form.
6. Mortal Kombat's Fatalities
At the time: One of the very first 'nasties' of the video game era, Mortal Kombat was built to shock and offend. You have to remember, gaming was still seen as this "mom's basement" underground nerdy pastime - far away from the mass-marketed delights of Wii Sports or Call of Duty 4.
Such a mindset invited counter-culture, shock factor and boundary-pushing, thus, the uber-gory fatalities were born.
Now: The only reason people tend to 'be okay' with Mortal Kombat is through history alone. If a brand new fighting game arrived with the sorts of brain-mushing, intestine-flailing designs we saw in MK 9 and MK X today, it'd most likely go the way of 2015's Hatred.
There's definitely something to be said for pixellated viscera being somewhat more 'palatable' too, as it was in those first instalments, alongside the comedic character models and 'orb blood' the 2000s Mortal Kombat sequels implemented to keep more distance from reality. MK 9 and X represented a push towards entirely realistic musculature, skeletons, the spilling of guts and buckets of claret - all things that indicate one thing:
The more realistic we push graphics, the more awkward Mortal Kombat becomes.
5. Collectible 'Romance Cards' In The Witcher
At the time: Remember a time when you could go just one day without an online controversy or someone being 'offended'?
Me neither, but it was definitely before 2016. Back in 2007, CD Projekt RED included a game mechanic centred around 'Romance Cards'; the notion that Geralt would receive a collectible card for any female he slept with. Like some sort of 'calling card' for each individual person, it gave you a neat memento of every last relationship you could embark on - which in Geralt's case, was a lot.
Now: There's a good reason CD Projekt RED ditched the idea of these romance cards (also called 'sexcards') in both Witcher sequels: They quite literally objectify women, treating any sexual female interaction like the amassing of a card collection.
Witcher 2 and 3 certainly carried forward the explicit nudity featured in the original, but when it came to coming away from any interaction with a bizarrely awkward, half-naked 'collector's item'', that got kicked to the curb.
4. "You Go First" - Timesplitters: Future Perfect
(17:44 on the above video)
At the time: Having decided to explore a zombie-infested mansion together, main-man Cortez and wannabe Harley Quinn/cheerleader archetype Jo Beth team up, only to come up against a ladder leading down to what sounds like a huge horde of the undead. "You go first" says Jo Beth, leading to Cortez looking directly at her skirt, before agreeing.
A harmless acknowledgment on behalf of the developers saying, "We know, this is ridiculous clothing for a zombie-hunt", or something else entirely?
Now: There's a completely other way to take this scene - one that makes more sense, when you consider just how much Free Radical changed Jo Beth's design from Timesplitters 2 to Future Perfect - which is to say, a character that was a fairly harmless 'bookworm' had her boobs blown up, was given a shirt with 'SLUT' written across the front, some actual Dead or Alive-style boob-jiggle physics and a tiny skirt barely held together with a loose belt.
Viewing the character through the lens of eye candy and hyper sexualisation, it's more likely the 'gag' here is Cortez eyeing up Beth's skirt, acknowledging that if he goes down the ladder first, he can glare up it. Brilliant.
3. Every Mention Of Princess Peach In Super Mario Bros.
At the time: We didn't think anything of it. 'Saving the princess from a castle' is about as old a fantasy story as you can get. Altering the archetype to swap out a gallant knight for a porky plumber was itself seen as progressive, grounding Mario as one of the most loveable dudes in video games, not to mention giving him the heart of a saint.
Now: Even Disney acknowledged how much this story is born from male fantasy or a male gaze in general when they created 2011's Tangled. These days Nintendo have Peach be part of the main crew, or show her being far more action-oriented, even with her own games. Looking back though, the sole motive you have to proceed in Super Mario Bros. is the 'reclaiming' of Peach from Bowser - something that once you do so, ends the game immediately, as a mysterious 'we' refers to another questline.
Peach is played off as an object forever out of reach upon completion of any set of levels, not to mention this final screen, and whilst it's as fundamentally 'harmless' as this sort of story always was (depending on how much you read into it), releasing today with this threadbare a narrative would guarantee a substantial backlash.
2. GTA III's 'Kill The Prostitute To Get Your Money Back'
At the time: Rockstar really were gaming's 'naughty boys' for the majority of the 2000s, commanding the spotlight back when GTA went 3D.
Granted, in 2001, GTA III caused possibly the biggest uproar since DOOM, completely shaking the foundations of the industry in a way that we'd never fully come back from (in the best way possible, see every open-world game that emerged thereafter). See, although Rockstar were being overtly boundary-pushing in many respects, they were also delivering on some great gameplay mechanics, and a bold new vision on how to populate a game world - something the likes of Postal was nowhere near.
Now: Like Moral Kombat before it, the only reason people and the media overall are 'okay' with GTA, is because they've already put the franchise through the wringer over time. You could feel GTA V trying to cause controversy with its torture scenes and Trevor mutilating innocent people in cutscenes, but the world just didn't care anymore.
That said, hit the reset button and drop GTA III fresh out the oven, and you'd get all the outrage, the horror of sleeping with an (always female) prostitute i.e. assuming the otherwise blank slate protagonist is straight, and the fact the only prominent female on the entire first island is someone who wants to go shopping and clubbing.
Way to be straight white males, Rockstar.
1. Lara Croft's Character Model Being Explained Away As An Accident
At the time: Western culture didn't really know how to accurately explain or justify Lara Croft. Here we had one of the first female badass game characters ever - one that came with twin-pistols, a take-no-sh*t attitude, intelligence and a 'can-do' mentality - yet was also designed with the most oversized boobs in entertainment history and a waste about the size of her wrist.
Ultimately, it worked. Lara went everywhere from Lucozade commercials to the walls of every horny teenager, the explanation from the developers being that lead designer Toby Gard "accidentally" typed '150%' into the chest portion of her character model, rather than 15%.
Now: It's testament to just how much Bayonetta barely caught on as another 'icon' of gaming, that the gaming world can't justify overly sexualised characters anymore.
Ms. 'Netta had just as much to her as Lara in terms of not just being a walking pin-up model, but as a populace we've almost completely moved on from having characters with such OTT sexy parts, hence why Soul Calibur has also had to go away and rethink its life in regards to one Ivy Valentine.
--
Are there any other old-school gaming moments that were awesome at the time, yet are now just a LITTLE bit weird? Let us know in the comments!