10 Best Baseball Video Games Of All Time

Where most step up to the plate and strikeout, these hit a home run.

MLB Slugfest
Midway Games

It's that time of year again, Spring is upon us and baseball is rearing its head. After what many consider one of the best World Series in years, the Chicago Cubs secured their first win in 108 years over the Cleveland Indians, and as a Cleveland native, that sentence still hurts to write. With a World Series that not only stretched to seven games but even to extra innings, there's sure to be a larger crowd flocking to MLB games over the next year.

What better way to celebrate the return of America's Pastime than with video games? There's no denying that over the years baseball video games have become less prominent, in part thanks to a decrease in popularity and Sony's stranglehold on the genre, but there was certainly a time where baseball games were a hot ticket item, with multiple releases coming from multiple publishers in the same year.

Of course, the MLB isn't the only place baseball can exist, and that's certainly a fact when it comes to the video game world. While most good baseball games released were licensed by the MLB, not all of them were. Expect to see a couple surprises on here as you move forward, and with that said, batter up, and let's take a swing at the best baseball games in video game history.


10. Wii Sports

wii sports
Nintendo

While not your traditional baseball game, Wii Sports did include one hell of a baseball mechanic. And thanks to being packaged with the Wii, almost anyone and everyone played it. There really was no better way to get used to the motion controls of the Wii than by spending hours bowling, playing tennis and smacking home runs in Wii Sports.

The baseball portion of Wii Sports had the most basic of controls - you didn't even control the fielding or base running, only the pitching and batting. Even with a serious lack of control over the game as a whole, that's not to say this game wasn't an immense amount of fun. There was nothing like having a whole group of people getting together and trying to see who could hit the most home runs in the hitting mini games. There was also nothing more satisfying than physically throwing a changeup and making your friend strikeout by a mile.

With no MLB license, no teams and no real players, Wii Sports was one of those anomalies that managed to be a fun and entertaining baseball game even without the hoopla of the MLB. Even if it was, at its core, nothing more than a hitting and pitching simulator. Thanks to a number of people who owned it, and how welcoming it was due to the easy gameplay, Wii Sports will go down as a fun and memorable experience to not only baseball fans and video game fans, but the general public as well.


9. Backyard Baseball 2003

Humongous Entertainment

Who would have thought a game that was essentially the video game equivalent to the movie The Sandlot would take off like it did.

Backyard Baseball wasn't your typical baseball game. For starters, back in the infancy of the series, it was exclusively played on Windows and Macintosh. Which led to a very basic, yet fun gameplay experience thanks to the left mouse button being responsible for nearly everything. The game also featured power-ups for both batters and pitchers.

For batters, they could lay down a Crazy Bunt which would have the ball bounce around erratically, or the underground hit which did exactly as the name implied, send a hit underground past the infielders for an easy hit. Pitchers could also throw screaming fast "fireball" pitches or even ones that froze mid-air on their way to the plate.

Gameplay aside, it was the presentation that made Backyard Baseball so memorable. Backyard Baseball had you playing as kids rather than adults. Even the MLB players were in kid form as opposed to their adult selves. Not to be outshined by the pros, the "neighborhood kids" had some A+ players in their ranks. No one will ever pass on picking up Pablo Sanchez as their first pick. The roster of 30 kids and 30 MLB players, all with varying stats, lead to a lot of variety when it came to picking your team schoolyard style.

While the presentation and elementary gameplay make this game seem like a child's game, it was certainly enjoyable by all who played it, not just children. Even though the game sees sporadic releases today, nothing will compare to its early days.


8. Mario Superstar Baseball

Nintendo

With a foot in multiple other major sports, it was only a matter of time before Mario took a swing at baseball. Somehow, no matter what the sport may be, Mario just always has a grasp on it as well.

The main draw from Mario Superstar Baseball was its challenge mode, which was essentially just its "season" mode but had a surprising amount of depth to it. In proper Mario fashion, you compete in a cup against multiple other teams led by Mario heroes and villains, eventually facing off against Bowser. Along the way, you would recruit players, captains and second captains from teams you beat, in turn beefing up your team to take on Bowser. Going from a team led by Mario and featuring nothing but minor characters to a team featuring the whole Mario Party gang felt beyond satisfying.

The game itself also played exceptionally well. At no point while playing the game did it feel like Nintendo just tacked Mario's name onto a weak baseball game. You could tell there was time and effort put into the game. Which is truly no surprise because almost all Mario sports games come out playing better than the last. Over time, if Nintendo has been able to prove anything, it's that you don't need an MLB license to put out a good, fun and addictive baseball game.


7. The Bigs

The Bigs
2K Sports

The Bigs was exactly as its name implied, an absolutely over the top, arcade-style baseball game, and it aimed to big league every single other baseball game out on the market.

Back in 2007 when The Bigs was released, arcade style baseball had already been done. What The Bigs set out to do however, was put out a game that had that over the top action while at its roots still being a baseball game. Where other games took the absurdness and ran with it, The Bigs took what was true to baseball and just juiced it up a little bit.

One of the game modes that absolutely bled the arcade feel was Home Run Pinball. It had you standing in the middle of Times Square and blasting home run after home run into the many neon signs and TVs around. The more damage you caused, the more points you received. Not everything was about destruction however, the Rookie Challenge mode had you taking a rookie from the minors all the way to the bigs. It was your tried and true "started from the bottom" story, and it featured solid baseball gameplay while also allowing you to jump 16 feet in the air to rob a home run.

As short lived as The Bigs run was, only spawning one sequel, it was a game that many remember as their favourite over the top baseball game. With some saying it was only outdone by one other, earlier release...


6. MLB Slugfest: Loaded

Mlb Slugfest Loaded
Midway

Where The Bigs saw certain things and said "Let's dial it back a notch and keep the baseball feel," MLB Slugfest said, "Screw that, we're going to 11."

If you ever wanted to play a baseball game featuring an entire team of Sub-Zeros versus an entire team of Scorpions, which also allowed you to punch each other in the face then look no further. MLB Slugfest: Loaded was the pinnacle of lunacy when it came to baseball games. Here's the thing though, it absolutely worked. It was addicting, a blast to play and was a breath of fresh air in the sports game genre. Yes, Midway certainly had done such a thing before with other sports, notably football, but Slugfest was one of its best additions.

Outside of the fast paced and crazy gameplay, the amount of unlockable content in this game was one of the better parts of the game. You could play as teams consisting of dolphins, eagles, rodeo clowns and more. If you wanted to take these teams to Atlantis to play nine innings well guess what, you could. Throw in the fact that this is the only MLB licensed game to ever earn a T-rating in video game history, and you've got one of the most unique baseball games of all time.

Also while it may have been featured in a previous MLB Slugfest title, who could ever forget the mental metal version of "Take Me Out To The Ballgame."


5. Ken Griffey Jr.'s Slugfest

Ken Griffey Jrs Slugfest 05
Nintendo

Before the word slugfest was associated with minotaurs playing baseball, it had to do with Ken Griffey Jr., one of baseball's greats and part of the 2016 Hall of Fame class.

Back in 1999 baseball games were nothing like they are now, obviously due to how much video games have evolved since then. Ken Griffey Jr.'s Slugfest really didn't have all that much in it. It featured an exhibition mode, a season mode and a Home Run Derby mode and that's about it. Those three modes, however, were more than enough to keep you occupied and entertained. The season mode allowed for the trading of players and even tracked stats throughout the season. All things that are expected now, but incredible additions back then.

Slugfest, at the time, had one of the more unique hitting mechanics to grace a baseball game. Instead of simply timing the pitch and swinging, players had to move a "sweet spot" over where the pitch was coming as well as time the swing. The better the hitter, then the bigger the 'sweet spot," with Ken Griffey Jr. having one of the biggest "sweet spots" in the game to no one's surprise. Players could also switch the controls to simply timing the pitch which allowed for players of all skills to be able to play and have fun with the game.

To this day baseball fans still go back to this game for nine innings. Even if the graphics, rosters and more are outdated, it was a memorable and fun experience that is still enjoyable to play almost 20 years later, and no one will ever forget the insane voice over for the umpire.


4. Triple Play 2000 (PlayStation Version)

EA

Triple Play 2000 was the only game of the Triple Play series to release on both the PlayStation and the N64, and they probably would have saved themselves a lot of trouble if they canned that N64 version. It was slow, clunky and was eaten alive by critics all while the PlayStation version is looked upon as one of the best games in the series. Even if Sammy Sosa was featured on the cover over Mark McGwire after his 70 home run season, but I digress.

At the time, Triple Play 2000 was one of the best looking baseball games out there. Not only were the graphics great, but even the animations were better than the competition. Sammy Sosa would kiss and point to the sky after a home run just like he would, and even players could be seen chewing gum among many other little nuances.

On top of the graphical enhancements, Triple Play 2000 also fine tweaked the gameplay to be even better and more responsive all while not getting too complicated. While batting you could either go for a bunt, normal swing or a power swing and holding certain directions would direct your hit. Again this all sounds like a no-brainer today, but at the time this was revolutionary.

The Triple Play series wouldn't last much longer after 2000, eventually being taken in a different direction by EA and becoming MVP Baseball in 2003. Triple Play 2000, however, will always be remembered by baseball fans as not only a highlight of the series but of baseball games in general.


3. World Series Baseball

Sega

World Series Baseball, released all the way back in 1994 by Sega, might be one of the most important baseball video games of all time. It was the first baseball game to have licenses from both the MLB and MLB Players Association. This allowed the game to not only feature all the teams from the MLB but to also include the names of all the players on those teams. Only a handful of games prior were even able to secure just one of the two licenses, let alone both. This led to, at the time, the most genuine baseball experience available in a video game.

The game's influences don't even end there either. On top of being the first game to secure both licenses, it was also the first to have realistic stadium replicas in game. AND it was the first baseball game to feature a "catcher's eye" camera angle, which became a staple in every single baseball game from then on out.

Even without 3D graphics, World Series Baseball was praised for its realistic presentation of baseball and paved the way for all baseball games that came after it. While it may be the most influential of all time, there are just a couple of games that managed to beat it out.


2. MLB 06: The Show

Midway

If you want to play an NFL game you buy Madden. If you want to play an NBA game you buy 2K. And if you want to play an MLB game you buy a PlayStation for The Show, because Sony's stranglehold on the genre is still running strong all these years later.

Back in 2006 the foundation was laid for the insurmountable franchise that is The Show. While competition was still out there back in 2006, none of it held a candle to what The Show was doing. Most notably was its addition of "The Show" mode, which saw you creating a player and taking him from the minors to the majors. You only controlled your player, and not the whole team, making you believe you were fully responsible for your own success. If you were a relief pitcher in the American League, the game would simulate until you came in to throw those few innings and that's it.

While the journey from cornfields to stadiums was a major selling point of the game, and highly advertised, it wasn't the only thing that stole the show. The season and franchise modes were both great, with the franchise mode letting you take control of virtually everything regarding your team, including vendor and ticket prices as done previously in a select number of games.

On top of the great modes, the gameplay was some of the best to come from a baseball game in recent years, only to be outdone by one game that had come out a year prior...


1. MVP Baseball 2005

Midway

MVP Baseball 2005 is widely considered to be the best baseball game of all time. Some listings on Amazon still have the game selling for $30 or more over a decade later. And the game is so widely touted as the best that modding communities are keeping the game alive and well on the PC with updated rosters, uniforms, stadiums and even walk up music after all this time. Such a cult following has surrounded this game because simply nothing else compares.

This game was absolutely bursting at the seems with content back in 2005 as well. It featured one of the most extensive list of teams, present and past. Each MLB team had their A, AA, and AAA affiliate included in the game along with players. Also included were 15 classic stadiums to pair with the 60+ legendary players and over 100 retro uniforms. MVP Baseball 2005 really offered it all.

The content wasn't a distraction from anything either, as the gameplay was easy to grab on to, responsive and addicting. The newest addition to the game was the "hitter's eye" which let hitters try to determine the type of pitch coming at them. The ball would turn a certain color as it left the pitchers hand signaling what type of pitch it was; white for fastball, red for breaking ball, green for off-speed pitches and so on. You could also keep track of the pitches so far for a batter, and what type they were with the press of a single button.

Franchise modes let you take total control of the owner and be responsible for the entire financial side of a baseball club and try to last 30 years in Owner mode, or take control of a manger and team in Dynasty mode for up to 120 seasons. Yes, 120 seasons. Which is the equivalent of over 19,000 regular season games. All while managing team morale, chemistry, salaries, lineups and more.

MVP Baseball 2005 was the last in the line of MLB licensed MVP games, but it's lived on for over a decade through strong fan support. With the amazing gameplay and content, it's truly no surprise as to why it's managed to cement itself in video game history.

--

What's the greatest baseball game in history? Let us know in the comments!


In this post: 
MLB
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Just a gamer with an unhealthy addiction to achievements, fantasy booking WWE events and watching 90's teen comedies.