10 Best Lord Of The Rings Video Games

Tolkien's masterwork has seen many different genres across the years - but which of them were the best?

It stands to reason that J.R.R. Tolkien's meticulously crafted and endlessly enjoyable fantasy masterwork remains the high-point for the genre even to this day. With each race, character, weapon, square of turf and everything in between having rich backstories alongside motivations that ensure no group of readers share the exactly the same favourite aspects, there's a wealth of stories to be told throughout Middle-earth. Over the years we've seen the most games under the LOTR banner emerge on consoles since the movies helped prove that when it's done well, the fantasy genre and all its trappings can be one of the greatest in all of cinema, as well as transferring across into a select number of great games. Whilst Star Wars adaptations rarely hit the mark, due to the amount of themes and elements to draw from, the various 'Rings titles have seen a great many different efforts that have faired pretty well both critically and with fans. From the epic score that everyone knows off by heart to the plethora of characters within which we all have individual favourites - alongside great lines of dialogue that help elevate each flick into legendary status - The Lord of the Rings new-age template for fantasy action is something that when treated with care, can easily translate into some of the best gaming experiences for any fan too.

10. The Lord Of The Rings: Conquest

Remember Star Wars: Battlefront? Even though it's been a while since we've seen an iteration on the series and there's one on the distant horizon, not enough games have done third-person squad-based combat on such an epic scale. Enter Conquest, Battlefront-developer Pandemic's attempt at transferring the majority of the gameplay mechanics from their flagship franchise to another. Although this 're-skin' is incredibly obvious in everything from the movement animation to the overall scope of the battles themselves, when you're offering alternate takes on the mythology like playing as Sauron's forces and storming the Shire, it's worth the price alone. Gameplay-wise combat feels extremely meaty and purposeful regardless of whether you're playing as good or evil, alongside ticking fantastical fan-boy boxes by letting you unlock Sauron himself or the mighty Balrog for use in the field. Like Battlefront the whole thing really comes into its own when you take it online, where you'll see such girlish scream-inducing delights as a cave troll fighting an Ent or your entire army mounting Wargs to take down the opposition. Despite the repetitive combat that jarred with some players, overall it still manages to recreate the epic scope of the on-screen battles better than the vast majority of the competition.

9. The Hobbit

Whilst it seems the newer Hobbit trilogy is still dividing haters from those who love it due to wanting to be immersed in more silver-screen Tolkien lore, aside from this and the hilariously loveable 1977 film the original book has rarely been done justice outside of its own pages. Coming out right when we were throughly engulfed in Return of the King-fever, Vivendi's cutesy tale of a less weathered Bilbo just couldn't contend with the might of EA's movie/game tie-in (but more on that later). Instead thanks to some easily enjoyable by-the-numbers platforming and combat that could be a little unresponsive at times, the charming aesthetic that permeated cutscenes and character-designs couldn't excel this into the eyes of the mainstream. Still, for many who grew up reading the book in school or had checked it out following the movies, this more humourous tale was enjoyable purely off the idea of controlling Bilbo and realising all those ideas of what the characters and lands must look like in a video game for the first time.

8. Guardians Of Middle-Earth

Chances are if Monolith released their console-MOBA in 2014 - thanks to the mass-coverage DOTA 2 has received as a televised video game e-sport - it'd fare much better than it did two years ago. Featuring one of the most over-the-top (and potentially insulting depending on how closely guarded you like your LOTR lore) introductory cutscenes, this top-down strategy title was too ahead of its time for its own good. 'Massive Online Battle Arena's are traditionally played on PC, as with the fidelity of mouse and keyboard control it's much easier to micro-manage crunching stats, planning attacks and coordinating scores of units at the same time. Going off the varying reviews this received on launch, it seemed critics either loved or hated it to drastically different degrees because of this, even though the core experience was incredibly solid and rewardingly deep if you stuck with it. Guardians definitely didn't pull any punches when it came to dropping you in the thick of it and explaining tutorial mechanics at light-speed, but for those who already had the right mindset to soak up exactly how to unleash your rump-kicking Gandalf alongside scores of troops - it was a dream come true. Oh, and speaking of that intro: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rn-qlwlt4_s

7. LEGO The Lord Of The Rings

If there's one thing we're seeing everywhere from the very idea of a Hobbit movie trilogy to endless Assassin's Creed and Call of Duty sequels, it's that when a creator is onto something that's lining their pockets with cash, restraint is the last thing on their mind. It's become the same in a handful of the LEGO titles too, as with very basic gameplay unless you're a fan of a particular franchise you're never going to check them out. Luckily LEGO LOTR is one of the good ones, as well as being one of the first LEGO titles to do away with the physical comedy aspect of the cutscenes, instead taking dialogue from the movies and reenacting scenes with characters' blocky counterparts. There are few things on this earth so perfectly put together and stupidly loveable as watching any number of scenes that were treated with so much seriousness on-screen, here re-appropriated in LEGO form. Developer Traveller's Tales are clearly huge Tolkien fans, and the whole production treats his creation with the utmost love and care, whilst poking fun at all the right scenes. It's worth checking out for Gandalf's "Fly, you fools!" and Lego Gollum alone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m_CvoG3nY3Q

6. The Lord Of The Rings: The Third Age

The genre that feels like the best fit for all your fantastical orc-slaying business, in 2004 EA moved away from the hack n' slashery of the movie tie-ins and instead into traditional turn-based RPG goodness. The result? The perfect combination of old school Final Fantasy combat brought to life thanks to EA's extremely hefty budget. Animations popped and flowed accordingly, menu-systems were easily accessible, and in a similar vein to LOTR: Conquest you could also switch sides for an additional evil-tinted campaign - providing an extremely competent RPG despite it's complete lack of innovation. For hardcore RPG fans the omission of loot and more in-depth character-management meant it didn't go over as a classic in the genre, but sometimes all that's needed is to perfect a formula rather than reinvent it, and for those who prefer their role-playing in alternating attack/defensive flavours, this was spot on.

5. The Lord Of The Rings: Battle For Middle-Earth II

Depending on how you like to control your battles, the Battle for Middle-earth games could be far more preferable to Conquest's behind-the-shoulder action-heavy perspective. Instead, taking the top-down RTS viewpoint allowed players to be their very own Eye of Sauron (albeit on the side of good as well as evil), commanding swathes of troops, creatures and armaments as you take the fight across the various lands and seas associated with the series. In a great turn there are a heap of locations licensed for the game that are yet to be seen properly in the movies, such as Mount Erebor, Ettenmoors and Mirkwood, with an overall production value that makes each battle feel lovingly crafted by designers who have a huge respect for the mythos. It's all too easy to forget just how much effort EA used to put into their games in light of broken messes like Battlefield limping out the door, but with a gargantuan amount of character models including everyone from Gollum to Sauron and even Tom Bombadil, this stupendously good sequel is the best use of your cash if you're already an RTS fan.

4. The Lord Of The Rings Online

It's all well and good having turn-based RPG gameplay or top-down RTS platoon-management - but what longtime cosplayers and fans of Tolkien's work have wished they could do for decades is actually live inside Middle-earth itself. With regular expansions coming out - the newest of which just being the Helms Deep add-on from last year - it's turned into a burgeoning community packed to the brim with locations from the books and movies, letting you create your own character and journey everywhere from The Shire to the gates of Mordor itself. Sure it's not as country population-rivalling as Warcraft - nor is the entire experience as polished - but being that WoW in itself is inspired so heavily from the Tolkien's epics, book readers and traditionalists are still to this day getting a kick out of living out their fantasies using appropriate lore terminology and landmarks.

3. Middle-Earth: Shadow Of Mordor

Depending on your definition of 'a Lord of the Rings game', this could easily be at the top spot, but we'd contest that it's the elements within the next two entries that elevate them above the many things Shadow does well. Coming completely out of nowhere to prove almost everybody wrong, so far Shadow has easily got itself in the running for Game of the Year - if not the generation - thanks to the perfect mix of meaty third-person movement, satisfyingly gory combat and a pretty complex brain underneath all the brawn. Lofty claims? Perhaps, but they're more a reflection on just how many standout titles there haven't been for the new consoles. Borrowing liberally from Assassin's Creed's general movement and Batman: Arkham's combat, Shadow of Mordor lets you get completely immersed in your half-human, half-spectral tale of vengeance. It's then that developer Monolith unravel the staggering amount of work they've put into everything from the reactionary world around you to enemy character designs, hero Talion's movements and the brilliantly original Nemesis system. It's their way of giving personalities to the enemies we'd usually not give a second thought about as they're dispatched across the land, but here unless you manage to take someone's head off, fallen foes will return with patched-up wounds and one hell of an axe to grind. It's one thing to see a character you've beaten with an arrow through the eye come back with a piece of metal grafted on, but another entirely to hear stories being told of your character "The Gravewalker" as some sort of orc-based night-terror - all thanks to how much of an impact you're having in the world throughout. In short, Shadow of Mordor is a huge achievement regardless of the title meaning that it's its own tale - as if it weren't for Tolkien's masterwork, it wouldn't exist in the first place.

2. The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers

For this and the next entry, feel free to switch them round depending on which movie you prefer, as with EA's two big movie tie-ins it's all going to come down to which set-piece from which film you enjoyed acting out more. As there's no EA Fellowship game - instead the multi-developer-created 2002 offering was a bit of a stinker - they then set about including all the big moments from the first movie as levels inside the Two Towers. It even opened with Isildur's battle against Sauron's army before zipping over to Aragorn tackling the Ringwraiths at Weathertop, easily being one of the coolest tutorial sections there's ever been. Fighting was responsive and combos were plentiful, but what really took the whole experience to another level was thanks to licensing the trilogy, Howard Shore's epic score was everywhere from backing every sword swing to padding out the menus in between fights. Not to mention there were great little cinematic touches where film footage would switch instantly to in-game, showing off the (at the time) stunning graphics. The big moment everyone talks about playing is also one of the big reasons people love the second movie the most - the battle of Helms Deep. In EA's version you fought to defend the gate in various spots, going from slashing through screenfuls of orcs next to the doors up to kicking ladders away atop the embattlements. With one of the cheat codes being to slow everything down to a crawl, watching the action unfold bit by bit as Shore's roaring theme thundered away underneath easily made this one of the best experiences any fan would ever have.

1. The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King

The best experience that is, unless you prefer Return of the King. For EA's second go-round they'd introduce even more playable characters, letting you take on the horde as a fully-voiced Sam, defending "Mr. Frodo" yourself with each sword swing. The Hobbits were great fun to control too, with plenty of rolling dodges and quick movements meaning you could dart between enemies in a blur of perfectly-animated amateur swordsmanship. Of course the refined animations didn't stop with just the Hobbits, we also got Gandalf the White - sporting an immeasurably badass combo of his white staff and sword. Remember that scene in Return where he leaps past Pippin to save him from a group of Uruk-Hai in a blur of blades and staff-thwacks? EA noticed it was one of the best moments too, putting you in charge of him to reenact the very same thing a few hundred times over across the level. With the development team building on their previous efforts the scope was increased tenfold, giving us things like fighting amongst the feet of a lumbering group of Ents, or the Minas Tirith fight that was every bit as jaw-dropping as in the film. Along with multiple background elements and the overall look we knew and loved from the movie, backed by that gorgeously anthemic and now-legendary score, ROTK is every bit as good in game form as on the silver screen. Which are your favourite Lord of the Rings games from over the years? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.