10 Most Controversial Gaming Moments Of 2014 (So Far)

Trey Parker and Matt Stone don't just find themselves in the middle of controversy, they actively encourage and embrace it.

Southparkmain We're only halfway into the year, and there's already been a sizeable amount of gaming controversies that have hit the headlines. From debates surrounding marriage equality, to graphics that don't match up to the hype, the video game industry has been reliably churning out controversy at its usual, steady rate. 2013 was a difficult year to top in terms of controversy, thanks in no small part to the release of Sony and Microsoft's next-gen consoles. The two company's various announcements and counter-announcements made for a great console war, and we're a bit sad we'll have to wait another 8 or so years before the next bout of console hardware controversy. Fortunately for controversy lovers everywhere though, 2014 hasn't been a disappointment yet. The battle for next-gen supremacy is ongoing, as AAA developers everywhere fight to release the year's first 'must buy' title. Indie developers have also had their fair share of headlines too, with the hugely anticipated No Man's Sky breaking into even mainstream news reports worldwide. Now, in the wake of E3 and some of the biggest game releases of the year, it seems a good time to go over 10 of the most controversial moments of 2014 so far.

10. Same Sex Relationships 'Removed' From Tomodachi Life

Tomodachi Tomodachi Life is a pretty unusual title, even by Nintendo's standards. Taking place on an island full of 'Mii' avatars, the game is a life simulation title that primarily focuses on the relationships between the characters. It's possible to become rivals, best friends, or even get married to the various Miis. However, it is not possible to form a relationship with a Mii of the same gender. Now, this usually wouldn't be a particularly controversial issue, but reports emerged that the Japanese version of Tomodachi Life let players form same-sex relationships through a bug. The reports continued to state that Nintendo had gone on to patch this 'feature' out of the game entirely. Nintendo made a statement shortly after to clarify the incident, where it emerged that it was just a case of the story being lost in translation. It turned out Japanese players were just creating male Mii characters, but making them appear female, and the patch was totally unrelated. Regardless, there is an ongoing 'Miiquality' campaign for Nintendo to implement same-sex relationships.

9. Dungeon Keeper Features The Worst Aspects Of Free-To-Play

Dungeonkeeper The Dungeon Keeper franchise is one of the most beloved strategy series of all time. The games would see you building up a lair that defends against marauding heroes that attempt to steal treasure and kill your various monster minions. Dungeon Keeper II was the last 'real' entry in the series, released in 1999. Therefore, fans were excited to learn that a new Dungeon Keeper title would be released fifteen years later. Unfortunately, the excitement quickly turned to anger, after it emerged that the game would be named Dungeon Keeper Mobile, and would be free-to-play. Player fears were confirmed, after Dungeon Keeper Mobile launched with some of the worst examples of obnoxious free-to-play monetisation ever. Many reviewers found the game to be barely playable without investing significant amounts of money, and the game used cheap tricks to convince players to give the game a 5-star rating. Many saw Dungeon Keeper Mobile as an insult to the cult series, and the final straw for exploitative free-to-play games in general.

8. Study Claims That Video Games Can Make You Racist

Saintsrow Since the dawn of video games, there have been concerns regarding their cultural impact, though most claims have had no hard evidence to back them up. However, study details released earlier this year claimed that violent video games involving black characters can reinforce certain stereotypes. "Playing a violent video game as a black character reinforces harmful stereotypes that blacks are violent," claimed Brad Bushman, one of the co-authors of the study. "We found there are real consequences to having these stereotypes €“ it can lead to more aggressive behaviour." The study involved players being randomly assigned either a black or white character in the game Saints Row 2. They were then given the task of either breaking out of a prison or non-violently finding a chapel. Among other results, those who played with the black characters were more likely to agree with the statement that "It's really a matter of some people not trying hard enough; if blacks would only try harder they could be just as well off as whites." Wow.

7. No Playable Female Characters In Assassin's Creed: Unity

Assassinscreedunity Assassin's Creed fans were excited to learn that the latest in the franchise, Unity, would be the first in the series to feature four-player co-op in its campaign. The historical action-adventure title will take place in Paris during the French Revolution, and follows a group of assassins as they attempt to expose the powers behind the Revolution. Controversy ensued following the co-op announcement though, after it was revealed that there would be no playable female characters. The controversy wasn't so much due to this revelation, but because of Ubisoft's reasoning behind the decision. The developer claimed that featuring female characters would require "double the animations, it's double the voices, all that stuff and double the visual assets." The statement resulted in a sizeable backlash, with many criticising the wording that implied men were the starting point, with females as a disposable afterthought.

6. Torture And Sexual Violence In Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroes

Groundzeroes Metal Gear Solid creator Hideo Kojima has never been shy to controversy, and this year was no exception. Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroes acts as a short precursor to Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom, which will probably see a release at some point next year. Ground Zeroes courted controversy with its inclusion of an audio tape that depicts someone called 'Skullface' torturing, interrogating and raping. The sessions include the sounds of forced sex, gang rape, whipping, and even a bomb being forced inside a girl's abdomen. It was possible to deduce what Skullface had been up to from various guard's chatter and other sources, but the tape shocked players with its explicit demonstrations of the acts. Kojima responded to the negativity surrounding the tapes by stating, "I did kind of see it coming that people would react to this. But that doesn't change the message that I want to relay." Kojima believes that the tapes help players to understand Snake's feelings and motivations for his undertakings in The Phantom Pain. He concluded his statement by saying, "there are things that I really think that we cannot look away from."

5. South Park: The Stick Of Truth Gets Censored In Europe And Australia

Southparkcensor Trey Parker and Matt Stone don't just find themselves in the middle of controversy, they actively encourage and embrace it. So when their satirical RPG title South Park: The Stick of Truth proved to be too much for some, it didn't come as a huge surprise. The scenes in question involved two abortion mini-games and a scene in which various characters get violently anally probed. The scenes were censored in Europe and Australia by publisher Ubisoft, in what they called a "market decision". Stone and Parker shrugged off the censorship, calling it "not that big a deal." Affected copies also contained background images and text created by Stone and Parker themselves, in place of the censored scenes. Many of the replacement backgrounds are just as funny as the original scenes themselves, turning the joke back onto the censorship boards. Below is the full, uncensored probing scene in question. It's very graphic, so we'd advise discrete viewing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wQZ4Dw5I8I

4. Facebook Buys Oculus VR

The Oculus Rift is one of the best pieces of evidence that virtual reality is not just feasible, but available in the here and now. It started out as a grassroots campaign, raising just under two-and-a-half million in a highly successful KickStarter campaign. Backers were impressed with Oculus' device, which allows for almost unprecedented immersion in virtual environments. However, they were less impressed when it was announced that Facebook purchased their company for $2 billion. Oculus inventor Palmer Lucky claimed that Facebook had intentions aligned with their own, but many early supporters felt cheated and unappreciated by the move that saw the company being purchased before the final product had even been released. Lucky believes that the partnership with Facebook will "accelerate" their vision, and we're sure this injection of cash, along with the resources at Facebook's disposal, will result in a potentially better initial project. Despite these practicalities, we can't help but feel a little sad that virtual reality has already been dominated by the big guys before it's even begun.

3. Flappy Bird Gets Removed From App Stores

Flappybird Tap. Tap. Tap. Tap. Game over. Flappy Bird was one of gaming's biggest surprise success stories of the last couple of years, despite its extreme simplicity. However, it somehow became the most popular title across both the Android and Apple app stores, with its mix of high difficulty and compulsive, addictive qualities. Created in just two days by creator Dong Nguyen, Flappy Bird was making an estimated $50,000 a day, just from advertising revenue. An overnight phenomenon, people were sharing their Flappy Bird high scores and frustrations worldwide. Until, that is, when Nguyen suddenly decided to remove the game from all online app stores. 72865116 5b8fb154 B694 4517 Ad0e 0a79d224837b Initially, many suspected that the removal was due to legal issues, with the game's art assets strongly resembling those seen in Nintendo's Mario series. However, Nguyen quickly denied such rumours, stating that he removed it because it ruined his "simple life", and he couldn't "take this anymore." Fortunately for Flappy fanatics, he confirmed a few months later that he would be bringing the game back with some changes, although no date has been set.

2. EA Announces Battlefield: Hardline

Hardline EA's Battlefield 4 was one of the most controversial releases of last year, with its dodgy netcode and huge amounts of bugs and issues. Despite countless promises, many of the issues have not yet been resolved, leaving behind a large following that feels widely disenfranchised with the series. When EA announced Battlefield: Hardline earlier this year, the news wasn't exactly greeted with a resounding cheer. At first glance, Hardline seems to be taking the series in a fresh new direction, with a focus on the police and their war on crime. In practice though, the gameplay is almost painfully familiar to Battlefield 4 players. With the countless issues that still need to be resolved in Battlefield 4, many fans felt insulted by EA's decision to announce the next game in the series so soon. Additionally, considering how much players were pushed by the publishers into purchasing the various DLC packs for Battlefield 4, the price of entry to then hop onto the latest entry is pretty significant. If you want to try out Battlefield: Hardline now, then you can download the multiplayer beta from Origin, for free. The full game will be released on the 21st October.

1. Watch Dogs Gets Graphical Downgrade

For the past two years or so, there was one game on everyone's lips when it came to discussing the potential of next-gen gaming. Watch Dogs had a highly positive response upon first being announced, with its dynamic world and incredibly good looks. While Grand Theft Auto V looked to be a worthy entry in Rockstar's series, it was in Watch Dogs that people were hoping for a truly next-gen, open-world experience. When it was finally released after several delays, Watch Dogs was by no means a terrible game. However, it also wasn't quite the revelation that people were hoping for, and the phrase "Grand Theft Auto with hacking" was thrown around a lot. Above all though, the game just didn't look anywhere near as glorious as the early trailers and pre-release promotional material had suggested. Rumours that the game had received a graphical downgrade somewhere along development were confirmed, after a fan-made mod managed to unlock the graphical features that we first saw back at E3 2012. Everything that the mod unlocked, which included dynamic shadows, bokeh depth-of-field, light effects and increased rain density, were already hidden away in the game's code. This would make sense if it turned out most PCs couldn't actually utilise these visual effects, but many have reported that turning them on has made almost no difference to performance. Because all of the settings were already in the game's code, Ubisoft intentionally chose to give Watch Dogs a graphical downgrade, actively making it look worse than before. The reasons behind it all have yet to be revealed, but many fans have no doubt that something fishy went down during Watch Dogs' prolonged development.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Butler hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.