10 Disappointing Video Games That Never Lived Up To The Hype

What happened with GTA Definitive Edition just sucks.

GTA definitive edition
Rockstar

Marketing can often make or break any video game. No matter the quality, making the public aware of - and excited for - a game before release is the surefire method companies have used for decades, to make sure any new release is an instant smash.

Whilst many games deliver on the promises sold by the huge billboards and epic TV adverts, several titles that were hugely anticipated by the public sadly never quite lived up to the hype and legendary status built around them before release.

As a result, they hugely disappoint both casual and hardcore gamers, as well as reviewers who were all undersold on the original promises of the developers. In some cases the damage caused by sub par games failing to live up to the hype was enough to kill off entire franchises and all prospective sequels to what should have been classic games.

Technical issues can also be heavily responsible for killing the hype. This has come to the forefront in recent years with some mostly online games having huge server issues on launch preventing players from accessing elements of the game, and thus effectively killing all anticipation around release.

10. Duke Nukem Forever

Duke Nukem Forever
Gearbox Software

The oldest game on the list, 2011's Duke Nukem Forever has a long a troubled history. It was the sequel to the hugely popular Duke Nukem 3D released back in 1996 which was a pioneer in the 3d first person shooter genre.

Originally announced in 1997 there was so much initial hype for the game, even debuting a massively promising trailer at E3 in 1998 with a release promised that same year. What followed can only be described as pure chaos, as the development team switched game engines several times. Development of the game was even restarted from scratch in 2006 after years of flailing around.

The game then lingered in development hell for a full 14 years until it was bought by Gearbox Software, who finally finished it. Duke Nukem Forever was then heavily marketed with the launch of several tie-in mini games and online sites to promote such a long awaited release.

Upon launch however, it was quickly hailed as one of the most disappointing and worst games of the year. This was mostly down to obvious signs of its hellish development including outdated graphics, gameplay, level design, and frankly downright offensive and out of date humour.


9. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

Tony Hawks Pro Skater 5 Screen 10 Us 22jun15
Activision Blizzard

In a truly ironic twist of fate, the series which singlehandedly birthed the phenomenon of skateboarding games also made sure to well and truly kill it with the release of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 in 2015.

In the mid 2000s it was almost impossible to find anyone who didn't have a copy of either Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 or 4 in their collection, as the series was absolutely massive. Then in 2014, 12 years after the release of Pro Skater 4, fans were ecstatic at the announcement that the cult series would finally be receiving a sequel in 2015.

The sad truth of the matter however, was that the licensing deal Activision held to use the name and character of Tony Hawk was set to expire at the end of 2015. As a result the game was thrown together over a few months and released in an unfinished state to make sure Activision could squeeze every last penny out of the iconic brand.

Upon release, the game was slated for its outdated graphics that looked even worse than titles released over a decade ago. On release day the game was also totally unplayable without downloading an 8GB patch.

To date, THPS 5 is almost impossible to play due to numerous game breaking bugs that have never been fixed.


8. Assassin's Creed Unity

Assassins Creed Unity Arno Elise
Ubisoft

The successor to the widely acclaimed Assassin's Creed IV : Black Flag was a hugely anticipated release. Assassin's Creed : Unity was also set to be the first Assassin's Creed game developed specifically with the then next generation consoles of the Xbox One and PS4 in mind.

After an exciting reveal at E3 2014 including showcasing the new innovations made possible with the next generation consoles and an extensive promotional campaign, the game was released with well, a few issues.

Aside from the stunning visuals and character design which certainly did deliver, the game was put out in an unfinished state, with numerous nightmarish glitches hampering its release. There were also issues with the online mode of the game, with things being so bad Ubisoft ended up apologising.

Along with their apology, Ubisoft announced that the first DLC pack for the game would be made available for free as compensation. Another bizarre decision on the part of Ubisoft that angered fans was the lack of gender options for the creation of characters online.

This left gamers, journalists, and even fellow developers deeply disappointed with a game that was supposed to be the high point of the Assassin's Creed series at that point.


7. Fallout 76

fallout 76 brotherhood of steel
Bethesda

Released in 2018, Fallout 76 was announced as a hugely ambitious game which built upon the success of the gameplay of the previous entries but added the element of it being an online multiplayer game, similar to that of the likes of Grand Theft Auto Online.

Like the other entries on this list involving multiplayer elements, the game was massively unfinished at launch, with numerous connectivity and server issues. When reviewers and fans were actually able to play, although it looked like a Fallout game, 76 turned out to be a dull and uninspired experience which was only made worse by the numerous technical faults.

Several reviewers were so unenthusiastic, giving up partway through due to monotonous gameplay and technical issues. In response to the game's unfinished state, several reviewers ironically published unfinished reviews of Fallout 76.

Bethesda in response issued a patch update which at 50GB was nearly bigger than the game itself. This update then hilariously added even more bugs in some cases to this disaster of a game.


6. Star Fox Zero

Watch Dogs
Ubisoft

In another story of tragically long and troubled development, 2016's Star Fox Zero was designed to show off the full potential of the Wii U and its gamepad controller. Unfortunately however it ended up being a clunky, gimmicky experience which was hugely disappointing.

After originally announced in 2014, and briefly being shown off at E3 2014, the game was teased over several months across 2015.

As part of the promotion Nintendo also held a fan art competition for the game with the winners receiving Nintendo E-Shop credits. This competition helped generate a huge amount of hype for the game.

Sadly though, the forceful inclusion of the Wii U Gamepad led to a ridiculously awkward and difficult control scheme. Many critics noted that you had to play through the game twice just to get to grips with such an awkward feel, comprising aiming with gyroscopes alongside tracking other aspects on your TV. Another common criticism was the game's similarity to Star Fox 64, with the new game essentially a rehash of the first with very little new.

With no port to Nintendo Switch which released a few months later, the game faded into obscurity as an abject failure.


5. No Man's Sky

No mans sky normandy
Hello Games

From personal experience, the hype train following this game was absolutely huge in 2013 when No Man's Sky was first revealed.

It was touted as an independent game that would feature an infinitely generated universe for players to explore with endless possibilities. It was hyped to show the true potential of the Playstation 4, and before release seemed to be one of the most unique game concepts in the world.

When the game eventually saw the light of day however in mid-2016, players and reviewers notice that whilst an infinite amount of new worlds were capable of being generated, they were all generated from the same set of assets. For example the same biomes and creatures would pop up from planet to planet, creating eerily similar-looking worlds and creatures. This unfortunately made the gameplay experience incredibly limiting.

The gameplay also turned out to be extremely repetitive. The main issue was that despite being able to travel to and generate a seemingly infinite number of worlds, you could only do the same thing on these worlds you could do on every other world.

In recent years thanks to several updates and ports to other consoles including the Xbox One and Nintendo Switch, the gameplay experienced has improved dramatically. Despite this the game still massively underdelivered on its initial promises of interstellar glory.


4. Resident Evil 6

Watch Dogs
Ubisoft

After the ultimate smash that was Resident Evil 4 along with the great success of the multiplayer elements of Resident Evil 5, Resident Evil 6 was set to be the biggest game in the series. For the first time players would have the option to play through 4 different campaigns featuring fan favourite protagonists from the series.

Upon release in 2012 however, fans received a very different game to the one initially promised. In a misguided assumption developer Capcom had decided that the survival horror market at the time was just way too small to be profitable. Instead they opted to take the game down the more action shooter orientated route to compete with the likes of Call Of Duty.

As a result the finished game was nothing more than a generic shooter that didn't feel anything like a Resident Evil game. Whilst the gameplay was fun and the game was well made, it just lacked the horror and the heart and the soul of the earlier games in what was a massive fall from grace for Capcom.

The reception of the game was so disastrous from fans that it forced the series to reinvent itself for 2017's Resident Evil 7, which ditched most of the action elements in favour of a more traditional survival horror.


3. Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy - Definitive Edition

GTA Definitive Edition San Andreas
Rockstar

The popularity of the trilogy of Grand Theft Auto games across the sixth generation consoles can't be understated. Grand Theft Auto 3, Grand Theft Auto Vice City, and Grand Theft Auto San Andreas were all smash hits upon release and revolutionised the third person shooter sandbox genre.

After much speculation, in August 2021 the game fans had long awaited was announced. This title would contain modern high definition remasters of the sixth generation Grand Theft Auto trilogy for modern consoles.

The release of the dream trilogy however quickly turned into a nightmare.

Upon release, the launcher for the games on PC was down a whole 28 hours. Console users didn't fare much better, as they soon realised what should be a loving remaster was instead a slapped together lesser version of classic games.

As well as featuring numerous glitches, the games also included several typos on signs, with famous locations markedly different from how they were in the originals. The rain in the game was also so thick, it meant you could barely see your character or the environment. Because of this, Youtube was flooded with videos full of nightmarish glitches in this sorry excuse of a video game.

As a result the game went on to massively damage Rockstar's reputation and their usually high standards for releasing content.


2. Watch Dogs

Watch Dogs
Ubisoft

After its initial announcement in 2012, the hype around Watch Dogs was absolutely huge following some incredible looking trailers.

At a time when the concept of hacking of major infrastructure was at the forefront of gaming with the popularity of the likes of Anonymous and Lizard Squad, Watch Dogs seemed to be a fascinating breath of fresh air in the action shooter landscape. Rather than just going in all guns blazing, Watch Dogs would have the player hacking their way into different scenarios and events.

The Ubisoft developed title however despite having excellent gameplay was let down by a truly bland story. All of the hacking elements in the game also seemed far to scripted and basic to be actually as enjoyable and inventive as promised in the trailers. Several fans and critics were also upset that the finished game seemingly looked nowhere near as good as the original trailers.

In true modern fashion the game was plagued with technical issues and bugs upon launch. It was also dubbed an inferior version of the hugely popular Grand Theft Auto 5 which had released the year before.

Despite its unsatisfying performance the game was popular enough to spawn several sequels. Unfortunately for Ubisoft the damage done due to the undelivered hype meant the franchise was never able to reach the heights that the developers and fans had hoped for.


1. Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077
CD Projekt RED

Even today, the mystery of how a catastrophe of this size was even able to occur is still up for debate, as the launch and promotion of 2020's Cyberpunk 2077 was nothing short of shambolic. Throughout 2020 it was near impossible to go on social media or see a bus or billboard that didn't have an ad for Cyberpunk 2077 on the side of it.

The game was initially announced way back in 2012, with the first trailers shown off in 2013 before a slew of delays saw it being released in late 2020.

After receiving numerous awards at E3, launch was disastrous, with performance so bad on consoles, many players sought refunds. Unable to obtain them, things went from bad to worse as Sony pulled Cyberpunk from the PlayStation Store altogether.

Cyberpunk 2077 then didn't return to the Playstation until Summer 2021, with both Xbox and PlayStation stores placing warnings on the game. Gamestop accepted returns of the game even if the box was opened, and offered full refunds due to such obvious and abundant quality issues.

In the coming months, the chaos got worse, as CDPR were accused of deliberately not providing reviewers with the console versions of the game, as they knew it would be slated. Another accusation came from investors, suing developers CD Projekt RED over how misled they also felt.

All of this led to CDPR losing 75% of their share value, reducing the company to a quarter of its worth before Cyberpunk 2077.


Contributor

Hey everyone, my name is Ruby, a geeky as anything trans girl passionate about music, film and science fiction.