10 Highest-Rated Video Games On Metacritic - Ranked

Because the second best game of all time ISN'T Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2.

Video Games Metacritic
Metacritic/Rockstar/Nintendo/Microsoft/Activision

As a source of information, Metacritic is both incredibly helpful and disastrously useless if you're wanting anything other than a base "Yup, it's good/meh/bad!" takeaway. Because over time, the site has ostensibly become to games what Rotten Tomatoes is to film - an aggregate compilation of every major review under the sun, kicking out a reflective percentage regardless of reasoning, nuance or discourse.

Thing is, as all gamers know, if anyone's ever asked your opinion on a title, you're highly unlikely to say, "It's a 6/10 game" before walking off. These cumulative totals go all the way back to their respective developers too, as various executives monitor Metacritic scores as a means to award the dev team a bonus or reward.

Imagine that: You put the time in and finish the job after years of hard work, but it's only really worth something if the world responds immediately.

Such is one of the more subtler problems with the site, but you also have the issue of games being championed for all sorts of contextual/timely reasons that wouldn't hold up in retrospect, or for pioneering a certain mechanic that would then be perfected elsewhere.

Indeed, Metacritic scores are a solid starting point, but when it comes to analysing the all-round top 10 in 2017, just how accurate has it become?


10. Grand Theft Auto IV

GTA 4 IV
Rockstar

Metacritic Score: 98

Though it actually lands a third spot on the overall Metacritic ranking, I'm bumping GTA IV all the way back to here, simply because it stands out as one of Rockstar's biggest risks that didn't pay off overall.

Even in retrospect, you have to wonder what critics were latching onto for such an incredibly high ranking. Yes, the freeform experimental mission structure was intact and Niko's story was far more deftly written than the likes of Tommy Vercetti and CJ, but the driving went down in history as being supremely unwieldy - not to mention the annoyance of maintaining social links with various characters and the game's overtly naff brown n' grey colour palette.

In short, it just wasn't fun to play, and though Rockstar shot for a more Michael Mann-esque production and they mostly hit it tone-wise - this just didn't feel fun, nor did it play like what we imagine GTA feeling like as an experience.


9. Grand Theft Auto V

gta v
Rockstar

Metacritic Score: 97

You can't talk about how much of a one-off GTA IV was, without the back-pedalling, "Sorry! So sorry, we'll get it right this time!" feel of GTA V.

Evidently its production budget was an unlimited one, seeing Rockstar polish off everything from immaculately rendered mountainsides to intricate A.I. scripts, animation and minigames like tennis or cycling.

The only issue was, they didn't address the portions of gameplay that mattered. Shooting and melee combat still felt serviceable and floaty respectively, with basic cover mechanics and unlikeable characters meaning outside the world detail and feel of that hefty production budget, there was nothing to latch onto.

Objectively it's a landmark release and an achievement in pure game design, but against the characterful likes of Vice City and San Andreas, would be nobody's first choice.


8. Perfect Dark

perfect dark
Rare

Metacritic Score: 97

GoldenEye might have pioneered first-person shooting on consoles - along a truly experimental local multiplayer mode that literally had never been done before - but it was Perfect Dark that ushered in the millennium with the finest shooting Rare has ever put together.

Rolling together the base feel of GoldenEye but speeding it up, adding a co-op campaign, bots to the multiplayer for larger scale skirmishes and letting you get your hands on even more satisfying weapons, many of Perfect Dark's high scores come from it being the premiere first-person shooter on the market.

You have to remember this was a time before Halo and Call of Duty, though what Rare accomplished was one of the most recommendable and simply playable games of all time - one that's worth a blast today, if only to see the refinement of first-person shooters on console thereafter.


7. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2

Tony Hawks Pro Skater 2
Neversoft

Metacritic Score: 98

Though THPS 3 would improve on one of the finest gameplay formulas of all, it had to start somewhere. And for all of us who remember the cultural movement of Tony Hawk's fandom at the time, THPS 2 was the game that improved on the original in every possible way.

Bigger levels, more skaters, more opportunities to combine your moves and even the ability to create your own levels. It was a veritable feast of skate-gaming goodness, the perfect local multiplayer game and a sumptuously playable single player experience all in one.

The soundtrack remains one of the finest collections of songs in gaming history too - a solid mix of Rage Against the Machine, Papa Roach and Anthrax rattling through your earholes as you soared through the air.

In short it was a game that defined a generation, but in a wider context, this helped get people outside and onto skateboards, encouraged millions to check out the requisite bands on the soundtrack, and ensured we sunk literal hundreds of hours trying to nail every high score.

A monumental achievement and you can play as Spider-Man, but the second-best game of all time. Not quite.


6. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3
Activision

Metacritic Score: 97

Neversoft could absolutely have played everything safe, releasing THPS 3 as 'more of the same' - lord knows it's what someone like Ubisoft would've done, had they been in charge.

Thankfully, they not only ticked the basic boxes, but improved on the Pro Skater gameplay in the most important ways possible. Everything from adding revert transitions to transitioning grinds without jumping meant you could chain together even longer lines, the whole process putting you in a trance-like state as you see not the level, but only places to leap from, grind, land and repeat.

THPS 3 represents a studio at the peak of their abilities, tapping into a potent cultural movement that lets guest characters like Darth Maul and Wolverine sit next to the Hawkster and Rodney Mullen. The combos came thick and fast, the levels encouraged experimentation as you hunted to combo everything together into one ginormous line, and the soundtrack was once again, stellar.

It remains a crying shame that Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 was such a genuine tire fire, but these old-school instalments are still phenomenal.


5. SoulCalibur

soulcalibur 1999 dreamcast
Namco

Metacritic Score: 98

It might be Tekken that commands the spotlight whenever anyone thinks of Namco fighting games, but it's Soulcalibur that remains one of the most surprising and mechanically tight fighters of them all.

Chances are, this title's high scores are simply from the feel of Namco taking their face button-controlled fighting engine and refining it to comprise dedicated light and heavy attacks, a kick, grapples and a block. As such, immediately there was a more tactical bent to gameplay we didn't even know we wanted, yet fighting fans lapped it up.

Soulcalibur was one of the most played fighting games of the late 90s, a cherished Dreamcast classic, and has a core engine that's just as enjoyable today.


4. Super Mario Galaxy

Super Mario Galaxy
Nintendo

Metacritic Score: 97

There's an argument to be made that the 3D platformer is the quintessential video game. Just the right amount of story, plenty of level variation, a plethora of enjoyable abilities and characters you'll remember for the rest of your life.

Super Mario Galaxy absolutely fits that description, its control scheme also having a couple of motion-based flicks to dispatch enemies, alongside loading Mario into an interplanetary star-cannon and firing by shaking the Wiimote. Basically, it's a simplistic control scheme designed to put the focus on the worlds themselves; which more than works when you'll start getting fired between hugely varied planets every few moments.

Everything you love about Mario's landmark 3D movement is present and correct, with the sort of world variety and charm only Nintendo could put together from a decade of experimentation.

Super Mario Galaxy would be the finest 3D platformer of all time, but it was usurped by another, only three years later...


3. Super Mario Galaxy 2

super mario galaxy 2
Nintendo

Metacritic Score: 97

Yes, the only thing that could beat a Mario platformer is another Mario platformer, and though Galaxy 2 only refined the original when it came to gameplay, it's a quality of life improvement that means everything plays smoother and more seamless when it comes to firing through those always-alluring mini-planet levels.

Gone are the vast majority of hub areas and in is Yoshi, more power-ups, faster level transitions and a difficulty curve that taps back into the original trilogy of Marios i.e. Having stretches of traversing moving platforms that'll have your expectations for breakfast if you're not careful.

If you want an exemplary 3D platformer it's the first Super Mario Galaxy, but if you want the perfect one with a solid sense of challenge, it's this sequel.


2. The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time

legend of Ocarina Of Time
Nintendo

Metacritic Score: 99

For a whole generation of gamers, themselves maturing and growing across the 90s, Ocarina was the quintessential tale of fantasy escapism. A young unassuming child from the tucked-away Kokiri Forest, travelling through time and stopping an ancient evil, all the while mustering enough courage to press on in the face of an apocalypse he triggered by accident? That was one HELL of a premise to then explore an entire open-world of potential, characterful charm and item-based progression.

It was this beautiful blend of light RPG mechanics and age-old fairytale tropes that let millions of us get whisked away entirely to Hyrule; its monumental highs being just as enjoyable today as back in 1998 (though I'd recommend the 3DS remaster if you're coming in fresh).

Indeed, Ocarina of Time gave us everything from the first 3D take on the legendary Zelda formula, to medium-changing innovations like Z-targeting, which would change the face of third-person combat forever. It's the gorgeous soundtrack and masterful blend of challenge, player intuition and solid gameplay that makes Ocarina an all-time great though.


1. The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild

legend of zelda breath of the wild
Nintendo

Metacritic Score: 97

Ocarina of Time might have revolutionised the industry and made an entire generation feel humbled as the hero of Hyrule, but Breath of the Wild takes those core explorative lessons and revolutionises them for an entirely new audience.

Ostensibly embodying the more open template of the original 1986 Zelda, BotW sets you as an amnesiac Link looking to recover his memories and skills, all the while discovering how he fits into the in-world Legend of Zelda story the townsfolk love so much. Such a supremely clever narrative then lets you take as long as you like exploring the gorgeous world, getting better as a fighter, hunter, climber and battle-hardened tactician.

It creates a sense of naturalism behind the game's various goals that doesn't come from various goals plastered onscreen or thousands of map markers to hoover up. Instead, Breath of the Wild lets you uncover its world at your own pace - just like we did back in '86, 98 or any other time. Except now, you have one of the best sets of third-person action controls in gaming history.

When alls said and done you'll have gone from pawing at the game's various systems and taking down Bokoblins with a tree branch, to soaring through the air on the back of a breeze conjured from fire, triggering slow-motion and headshot'ing an entire platoon of high-rank enemies before finishing off any stragglers with your fully-powered Master Sword.

You'll do all of this of your own accord, with just the right amount of nudging from the invisible gaming hand that is Nintendo. Breath of the Wild is a modern reminder of why we game in the first place, and for that, has an immortal charm that'll only age with grace.

--

Let us know in the comments what order you would've had for Metacritic's most high-ranking games!


In this post: 
GTA V
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.