10 Hit Video Games That Were Totally Critic-Proof

Don't read the reviews!

Days Gone
Sony

It can be annoying when a reviewer criticises a game you love or praises one you hate. Yet reviews are an important part of the gaming industry.

Without reviews, game developers could just focus on using lots of money to create interesting looking trailers that get people to buy their games, without giving the proper care to the product they're selling.

That's not to say that all companies would phone it in if reviews didn't exist, but it would give them the opportunity to do so if they wanted.

Negative reviews just before or as a game is released allows players to avoid wasting their money on projects that didn't live up to their hype. This doesn't always work though, as sometimes a poorly reviewed game still somehow sells well.

At times, the hype surrounding a game is too strong to stop players purchasing it before reading reviews. Additionally, devoted fans of a long running franchise may ignore reviews completely because of their love for the series.

Whatever the reason, the games on the list survived the critics' onslaughts and still sold well.

10. Shadow The Hedgehog

Shadow The Hedgehog
Sega

When the first Sonic the Hedgehog game was released in 1991, it's unlikely that anyone thought the series would ever include guns - but Shadow the Hedgehog did just that.

Sega decided that they wanted to create a Sonic game that was edgier than previous instalments in the franchise.

This new approach to Sonic was not appreciated by critics with many finding the darker tone to be a strange alteration to the series.

The plot didn't help either, with reviewers finding it to be over complicated for a Sonic game. Critics also didn't like that Shadow the Hedgehog's 10 different endings were made redundant after players unlocked the true canon ending.

Regardless of the reviews, it still managed to sell over 2 million copies, showing that fans were interested in a new type of Sonic game. The popularity of the Shadow character also played a part in the strong sales.


9. Homefront

Homefront 2011
THQ

In 2011, Call of Duty was still the dominant first person shooter franchise on the market. Homefront was then released and presented an alternative to fans of the genre.

It's set in a dystopian future where an allied Korea has invaded the United States. The unique premise allowed the game to stand out.

Upon release though, the game received a mix response from critics with plenty unhappy with the length of the campaign, clocking in at a measly five hours. Reviewers also claimed that beyond the plot, Homefront didn't do enough to differentiate itself from other FPSs on the market at the time.

These criticisms did not deter interested players, as the game sold over 2.5 million copies leading to a sequel titled Homefront: The Revolution, released five years later.


8. No Man's Sky

No Mans Sky Sentinel Drone
Hello Games

It may seem weird for No Man's Sky to be on a list about 'Hit video games', as most people look at the launch of the sci-fi game to be a failure.

Critically, it was a disappointment as many reviewers identified a host of problems with the much anticipated game.

Reviewers found the gameplay dull since No Man's Sky never really had an objective; collecting resources and creating better equipment didn't really lead to anything. The only real objective in the game was to get to the centre of the galaxy, which only opened up a new galaxy to explore that was not much different from the previous one.

Numerous bugs that were found on the release of the game were also pointed out in reviews.

No Man's Sky's pre-release hype led to the game's great sales despite the negative critical response. Steam reported that during 2016, No Man's Sky was one of the platform's top 12 highest grossing games.


7. Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6 Chris Leon
Capcom

The fourth and fifth games in the Resident Evil series added more action elements into the franchise but Resident Evil 6 was the main series' first full-fledged action game.

Turning a beloved survival horror franchise into an action one was always going to invite backlash, and the mixed reviews of Resident Evil 6 illustrate that point.

Even when the title was reviewed as a shooter, critics had multiple complaints. One issue was the incorporation of a poor cover system that struggled to work a lot of the time. Resident Evil 6's melee system was also considered grossly overpowered.

Another criticism was that Resident Evil 6's four intertwining campaigns lacked consistency, with most critics claiming that Leon's was much better than the others.

Changing genres didn't stop the popular series from selling well though. While the sales started slowly, it was boosted from its re-release on the Xbox One and PS4 and ended up selling 9 million copies over its lifetime.


6. 50 Cent: Bulletproof

50 Cent Bulletproof
Genuine Games

Even prior to its release, 50 Cent: Bulletproof looked like a cash grab trying to take advantage of 50 Cent's popularity at the time.

The music and presentation of the game did receive some praise, but critics were not happy with the gameplay. Combat was seen as generic and the finicky aiming system in particular was criticised. Reviewers were also unhappy with the uninventive missions throughout the game.

It's clear how this game sold well, since it came out when 50 Cent was at the highest point in his career. Additionally, the inclusion of Eminem and Dr. Dre further increased the interest in the game.

50 Cent: Bulletproof sold over one million copies despite the reviews and even spawned a sequel, 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand. The sequel received much more favourable reviews, but sales weren't nearly as good.


5. Enter The Matrix

Enter the Matrix
Infogrames

Many of the issues critics had with Enter The Matrix stemmed from it feeling rushed. A need for it to be released around the same time as The Matrix Reloaded could be the explanation for the game feeling incomplete.

The unfinished nature of the game was clear with the number of glitches that reviewers pointed out as it launched. Awkward animations, sound cutting out and console crashes were just some of the bugs Enter The Matrix released with.

While the cool action sequences displayed in the Matrix movies seem a perfect fit for a video game, Shiny Entertainment clearly struggled to incorporate them as reviewers found the gameplay to be generic and repetitive.

In the first week of release, Enter the Matrix already sold one million copies and would go on to sell over five million in its lifetime. Clearly releasing in conjunction with The Matrix Reloaded helped the game tap into the hype surrounding the movie and avoid being hurt by the critical backlash.


4. Mario & Sonic At The Olympic Games

Mario & Sonic at the Olympics
Nintendo

Mario and Sonic are two of the biggest gaming mascots ever and they finally came together in 2007's Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games.

This collaboration did not go over well with critics. Many of them were unimpressed that the first time the Mario and Sonic franchises came together was in an Olympics game as opposed to a platformer that they're both known for.

The criticism of the idea aside, reviewers still felt the game had issues. Multiple reviews noted that the controls were unnecessarily complicated for a party game. Also, a good deal of the events in the game were labelled as being too similar to each other by critics.

A collaboration of two classic franchises was too exciting to be hurt by negative reviews as the game sold five million copies in just its first three months.


3. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Aliens: Colonial Marines
Gearbox

Aliens: Colonial Marines tends to be regarded as one of the biggest let downs in recent gaming history.

Gameplay shown off prior to its release created an incredible amount of excitement. However, when it launched critics had an endless list of problems with the game.

A common issue that many reviews mentioned was the poor A.I for the Xenomorphs as they constantly ran right at players, meaning that the game lacked the tension seen in the Alien films. There was also a mountain of glitches in the game that made it almost unplayable.

Reviewers did not go easy on the graphics of the game either, as lighting, character animations and textures were all accused of being downgraded from the gameplay shown off before release.

A multitude of problems didn't stop the sci-fi shooter selling over 1.3 million copies, making it one of Sega's best selling games that year.


2. SimCity (2013)

SimCity 2013
EA

From a game that was almost unplayable to one that was genuinely unplayable on its launch. SimCity (2013) was a game that required a network connection to play but faulty EA servers meant players couldn't connect when it first released.

Reviews for this game were mixed as a few of them were written before the server issues and those reviews were subsequently downgraded when problems became apparent. Multiple sites held off on reviews of the game until the servers were fixed and they could really play the game.

It was a botch of a launch, but even after the initial server issues were sorted, the reviews still weren't glowing.

Some felt that the small city size was disappointing as it was smaller than what was previously available in older Sim City titles. The previous instalments of the series also included features that were missing in this game such as the ability to create a subway system which was mentioned in some reviews.

In spite of the negative response, the game still sold over two million copies and held a strong player base for a while.


1. Days Gone

Days Gone
Sony

While many critics liked some of the ideas in Days Gone, they felt that it under-delivered on its potential.

Plenty of reviews claimed that the game didn't feel particularly innovative and lacked original ideas beyond the inclusion of a bike in a zombie game.

This lack of ingenuity stretched to the combat - also seen as uninspiring. Multiple bugs didn't help the game's perception by critics either.

Additionally, reviewers had an issue with was the dull story as many felt that the narrative dragged on and wasn't well written.

The criticisms didn't stop Days Gone having the biggest physical sales launch of the year in the UK when it came out, while in Japan, it even outsold the successful God of War.

It seems the initial hype surrounding the game prior to release was too much to be slowed down by negative reviews.


In this post: 
Days Gone
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Ben Jessey hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.