10 Hugely Underrated 2013 Video Games

In games more so than any other medium, we put so much stock in the opinions of reviews because, after all, a video game costs £40 a pop, and we want to know we're going to get our money's worth. We obsess over MetaCritic scores and judge a game almost solely on those merits it seems sometimes, when the truth is, believe it or not, sometimes the critics got it wrong. Though a score of below 70 is generally regarded as the critical kiss of death for most games, it is curious that even some of the games on this list managed to reach well into the 80s. So how are they underrated, then? Not everything quite hinges on critics, and sometimes a fanbase is so vocal in their commitment to everything that came before, that not even endorsements across the board from the most prominent video game sites can change their minds. Underrated either by critics or gamers, these titles deserve a second chance if you're stuck for games to play in this new year drought period. And of course, if there are any I missed or any you disagree with, let's argue in the comments!

10. Metro: Last Light

MetaCritic Score: 80-82 It's baffling to me that more wasn't made of Metro: Last Light upon release. It came out during the summer, with very little competition to speak of, and though its first-week sales smoked Metro 2033's lifetime US sales, it very quickly dropped out of the gaming conversation despite being one of the most moodily atmospheric games of the whole year. Critics loved its combination of bleak visuals and haunting storytelling, yet I was surprised it didn't enter the various Game of the Year debates a little more fiercely. I don't know a single other person in my real life social circles who has actually played the game, and what a title they're missing out on. It's not exactly like this sort of subject matter is niche, either. Who doesn't love a post-apocalyptic shooter? Instead, I couldn't help but think that the release of the similarly impressive Bioshock Infinite a few months earlier effectively stole its thunder and gave gamers their fill of sci-fi FPS thrills.

9. Remember Me

MetaCritic Score: 65-72 It's depressing to think that this time last year, Remember Me was one of the most anticipated titles of 2013, with many expecting that it and Watch Dogs would be up for Game of the Year awards by year's end. Ironic it is then that Watch Dogs dashed to 2014, and Remember Me was lambasted by a large quarter of critics and gamers. The only question I have is, "Why?". Despite being unfortunately named after a horrific Robert Pattinson film, the game was praised for its inventive visuals and the Memory Remix mechanic, but the story, platforming and action sequences were especially criticised for being generic and buggy. I played through Remember Me in just a few short days, and absolutely fell in love with it. The ambition, and the brilliance of the Memory Remix concept, in which you have to reconstruct a victim's memories in order to manipulate their behaviour accordingly, was ground-breaking to say the least. As for the other criticisms, I can't say I encountered them in my playthrough. Combat in particular was a load of fun, and the feeling of progression as Nilin became more and more of a badass was a joy to behold.

8. Splinter Cell: Blacklist

MetaCritic Score: 75-84 Splinter Cell: Blacklist received broadly positive reviews pretty much on par with the previous game, Conviction, though complaints included the re-casting of Sam Fisher's esteemed voice actor, Michael Ironside (a fair complaint), and the "casualisation" of the series by opening the game up to more players, in allowing them to choose either the action route or the stealth route. In spite of solid reviews, the game did not sell well, and looking at the venom-filled posts on various message boards around the web from Splinter Cell purists, it's easy to see why. But sit down and actually play the game for a few hours. Though there's more choice, you can still play the game however you want, and the original stealth elements don't really suffer just because players aren't boxed into one mode of play anymore. Yes, it sucks that Sam Fisher now sounds like an 18 year old, but the core elements of the game are as slick and entertaining as they have ever been.

7. Sniper: Ghost Warrior II

MetaCritic Score: 52 I expect this is the game on my list that I'm going to struggle the most to convince you to play. After all, the first Sniper: Ghost Warrior game didn't exactly score well with critics (scores range from 45-55), so why would anyone take a shot (pardon the pun) at part 2? Well, I have never played the original game either, but I decided to take a crack at this one after finding it in a sale, and I don't regret it one bit. The gameplay mechanics are simple: you are a sniper, you're assigned targets, you occasionally have to avoid enemies in stealth sections, and you then move onto the next level. The game isn't particularly long, but more so than any other game I've played, it made me feel truly immersed in the art of sniping, having to take account of various environmental factors like wind and visibility before taking the crucial shot. It's no great shakes as far as characters and story are concerned, but it's pure wish fulfillment for anyone whose favourite FPS class is the sniper.

6. Saints Row IV

MetaCritic Score: 76-86 Like a few other games on this list, Saints Row IV was critically acclaimed, and also did well commercially, with the PC version alone selling triple the number of copies of the previous game, Saints Row: The Third. Why, then, is it underrated? It's this constant association given to it by players that it's little more than a lesser younger brother of Grand Theft Auto, and the fact it came out a mere month before GTA certainly didn't help those comparisons. Saints Row IV is as barmy and hilariously politically incorrect as anyone will tell you, but it's also far more clever than its dumb reputation will suggest. The sly (and not so sly) pop culture references, the cutting dialogue and so on may not have the satirical precision of the GTA games, but it's devilishly smart all by itself. I for one can't wait to see what Volition can cook up for Saints Row V.

5. Killzone: Shadow Fall

MetaCritic Score: 74 I was one of the many gamers avidly refreshing the MetaCritic page on the day the PS4 review embargo broke, and I was paying particular attention to one of my pre-orders, Killzone: Shadow Fall. Though well reviewed for sure, it settled for a solid if not spectacular 74 rating, with critics praising the superb presentation and multiplayer, while decrying the scant story and thin characterisation. Shadow Fall was also the first next-gen game to cross the 1 million sales barrier, so the game is certainly not a failure by any means. However, it is underrated. Having blasted through the single player mode and spent countless hours racking up those challenges in multiplayer, I was left scratching my head as to why the game didn't amass a score in the 80s or even the 90s. The fiendishly addictive online would itself be worth throwing down £40 for, but the stunning solo offering is the first game I played to truly make me appreciate next-gen tech. It might not have much emotional resonance, but it's a visceral, thunderous shooter, and easily the best next-gen game I've played so far.

4. DmC: Devil May Cry

MetaCritic Score: 85-86 DmC is one of the major tragedies of 2013, because while critics were surprisingly positive in their praise, fans just couldn't seem to get on board with the radical aesthetic shifts that this franchise reboot fielded out. Yes, Dante looks ugly for most of the game, but pretty much everything else in this game is a significant improvement on the rest of the franchise. Still, it didn't seem to matter, as the game sold considerably less than Devil May Cry 4, making it an abject failure and likely ensuring we won't get a new DmC game anytime soon. If you were skeptical, I implore you to pick this game up and actually give it a go, especially as it's available dirt cheap now. The gameplay mechanics are out of this world and the irreverent tone of the story is hugely entertaining. It won't make you think or challenge you too much, but it's the meaning of the phrase "kick ass".

3. God Of War: Ascension

MetaCritic Score: 80 God of War: Ascension was the first game in the series to earn significant criticism for various elements, after the previous three games were widely acclaimed as some of the best titles on the PS2 and PS3. The bulk of the complaints were towards a less-refined feel than the previous games, a less compelling plot and a multiplayer mode that didn't necessarily feel like it belonged in the franchise. Also, the infamous Trial of Archimedes section late in the game was called out as being too difficult by many critics. I have to say, I expected the Trial of Archimedes to be so challenging that I flat out laughed out loud when I completed it on just my second attempt. I think those who found it too hard need to play on a lower difficulty or get some more practice in. Though I will concede that the game had more visual glitches than any of the other titles in the series, I found the multiplayer component to be a welcome addition, and something I hope to see them expand upon in the inevitable God of War IV on the PS4.

2. Crysis 3

MetaCritic Score: 76-77 Crysis 3, like the previous games in the series, was widely praised by the press for its stupendously amazing visual presentation, easily making it one of the best looking games of all time. However, a lot of the reviews also criticised the multiplayer mode, and particularly the enemy AI, which they saw as spotty and inconsistent. In addition, the game fell short of sales projections, making it less certain that a fourth game would be released, though I expect it still will be. There is nothing quite like Crysis 3 out there. If the first game was an ambitious if flawed outing, Crysis 2 built on that ambition by placing players in a concrete jungle, and then Crysis 3 is essentially the best of both worlds, hurling players between urban and rural locales while being able to take enemies down with an array of awesome Nanotech abilities. The Hunter Mode in multiplayer is also one of the most annoyingly addictive things I played in the last 12 months, a Last Man Standing-type mode, in which players have to fend off other online players who are wearing cloaked Nanosuits for as long as possible. So many tout these games as being style over substance, but I assure you that is not the case here.

1. Knack

MetaCritic Score: 55 But nothing was as woefully underrated this year as the PS4's Knack, created by the console's lead architect Mark Cerny himself. I was hesitant after seeing the less than stellar reviews and hearing complaints that the game was too difficult, largely because of some punishing checkpoints, which hurled players back up to 5 minutes at a time. Still, I finally took a chance on the game, and was shocked to find that it's easily one of the best PS4 games to date, and a stellar platformer all in its own right. It's safe to say that Knack is not for the weak of stomach or those who flinch at a challenge. You will die in Knack, and you will die a lot. My playthrough took about 10 hours, and I expect that at least 1/3 of that time was just replaying and replaying to get through those extra difficult sections. Sales wise, the game hilariously managed to outsell Super Mario 3D World in its first week, a game which holds a considerably higher MetaCritic score of 93 to date. Still, Knack is for me the year's ultimate case that the critics can get it wrong. It's not especially complex and the difficulty may annoy some, but if you want a game that'll test your reactions and prove a little more challenging than something like Rayman Legends, it's well worth a go indeed. What are your most underrated games of 2013? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.