10 Reasons Nintendo Switch Online Is A Crushing Disappointment

Nintendo gonna Nintendo.

Nintendo Switch Online
Nintendo

Some 18 months after the Nintendo Switch first landed on shelves, Nintendo finally rolled out the platform's long-awaited online service this week, handily named Nintendo Switch Online.

It's fair to say that the early fan response has been, er, pretty rough, and justifiably so. It'd be silly to expect Nintendo to nail a home-run here given their historic lack of interest in consumer-friendly practises and bizarre allergy to online features, but even so, this is incredibly disappointing stuff.

It's entirely possible the company could turn things around in the future and make this a value-filled service, but right out of the gate it's not remotely appetising unless you have a strong nostalgia for the NES.

You can at least try out a 7-day trial for yourself to see how it all works - just remember to cancel that auto-renew! - though many Switch owners will inevitably be holding fire on this until they want to play Super Smash Bros. Ultimate near the end of the year.

As wonderful a machine as the Switch is, it's insanely frustrating that Nintendo has such a dated, obstinate aversion to moving with the times...


10. No Online Matchmaking Or Button Mapping For NES Games

Nintendo Switch NES
Nintendo

Here's a double whammy of irritating revelations right off the bat. First of all, though Nintendo has added online multiplayer features to their Netflix-like NES library, you're sadly only able to play online with those in your friends list.

If you were hoping to play some Ice Hockey with a total random, that sadly isn't possible as there's no matchmaking suite to speak of.

Considering most of us have busy lives and can't always find time to set up games with our pals, it's enormously disappointing that such an aggressive restriction has been imposed for no logical reason.

Another nagging issue is that there's currently no custom button mapping for NES titles, meaning you're stuck with default presets which don't always feel right. Again, this is a feature the exclusion of which is extremely puzzling given its incredible simplicity to implement.


9. Voice Chat Still Requires A Smartphone App

Splatoon 2 Voice Chat
Nintendo

Fans were outraged last year when it was revealed that they'd need to use a smartphone app in order to enjoy basic voice chat on Splatoon 2, and despite the addition of a paywall, the clunky system hasn't been improved upon at all.

Compounding the baffling fact that voice chat isn't contained within the Switch itself, the app only works with a limited selection of games at the moment, and when there are far superior alternatives like Discord, why would anyone really bother using it?

It's a voice chat solution so wilfully and unnecessarily obtuse it basically feels like a parody of Nintendo's worst, least consumer-friendly instincts.

One suspects their motivations are primarily concerned with "won't somebody think of the children!?", but given that their competitors have had in-console voice chat running smoothly for many, many years, it's an incredibly poor rationale.


8. Not All Games Support Cloud Save Backup

Nintendo Switch Online
Nintendo

The lack of cloud save support has been a major sticking point for even the Switch's most staunch defenders: if you lose your Switch or it breaks, your 300-hour Breath of the Wild save is toast and there's nothing you can do about it.

18 months after the console's release, Nintendo has finally provided cloud saves as part of its new online service, and while it is indeed stuck behind a paywall, it is at least available for those who desire it.

Unfortunately, though, cloud saves aren't supported for every Switch title, and there are some alarmingly popular games that won't allow players to back up their data. Most egregiously, Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu and Eevee, Splatoon 2, Fortnite, and FIFA 19 offer no cloud support, reportedly due to Nintendo's concerns over players manipulating saves in order to cheat.

Considering that Sony and Microsoft have offered full cloud support for years, it's a laughably flimsy excuse and extremely disappointing. It's especially frustrating as most online-heavy Switch games store player stats client-side, meaning there's no way to retain your hard-earned career data in the event something happens to your Switch.

And if this isn't bad enough, Nintendo will also delete your cloud saves if your subscription lapses, compared to Sony and Microsoft, who retain cloud saves for six months and forever respectively.


7. The NES Line-Up Is A Mixed Bag

Nintendo Switch Online NES
Nintendo

Switch Online has launched with a suite of 20 "classic" NES games, with nine more set to release before the end of 2018.

The current collection is honestly a bit of a mixed bag, for while there are solid-gold hits like Donkey Kong, Double Dragon, The Legend of Zelda and Super Mario, there are some rather dubious, ill-aged offerings such as Ice Climber, Balloon Fight and Ghosts ’N Goblins. Plus, some blatant bangers are conspicuously absent: Castlevania, Mega Man 2, Final Fantasy and so on.

Though the NES library will likely be looking pretty respectable a year from now, this isn't exactly a tantalising barrage of inaugural titles. Let's face it, bar the odd exception, you're likely to try each of these games for about 10 minutes before moving onto something else.


6. The "Special Offers" Are Insulting

Splatoon 2 Jersey
Nintendo

Nintendo promised ahead of their online service's launch that subscribers would benefit from "special offers", but on the basis of the first two introductory offers, they probably shouldn't have even bothered.

The first offer gives members the opportunity to purchase a fancy NES-styled pair of Joy-Cons for the low, low price of $59.99. What a privilege. For peripherals that won't start shipping until just before Christmas.

Also, because Nintendo apparently hates money, you can only buy these controllers if you're a Nintendo Switch Online member, and you can only order one per account. We'll get into the asinine reason for this in a moment.

The other offer is only for 12-month NSO members, and it's a download code for some NSO-branded jerseys and shoes in Splatoon 2.

When you heard "special offers", you were probably thinking exclusive eShop discounts, right? This is how it works on both PSN and Xbox Live, and considering how stingy eShop offers routinely are, it'd actually be a pretty neat selling point for NSO. But alas, no.

The fine print does say that Nintendo "may" include product discounts in the future, but if you take that with anything less than a truck-load of salt, more fool you.


5. The NES Classic Controller Doesn't Work With Switch Games

Nintendo Switch NES
Nintendo

So, Nintendo is only allowing subscribers to their online service to purchase the NES-style Joy-Cons, and only one can be bought per paid-up account, then.

The reason for this, hilariously, is that the Joy-Cons only work with NES games, and furthermore, can only be attached to the Switch for charging: you need to detach them in order to play NES titles.

What's most insulting about all this is that despite lacking all the buttons, analog sticks, gyroscope and rumble of the regular Joy-Cons, and only working with NES games no less, it's still retailing for an absurd $60 bucks.

Effectively, the controllers are fully tied to your online subscription, making them a laughably overpriced indulgence reserved for fans who really, really love their nostalgia.

Granted this news isn't as depressing as other undercooked aspects of NSO - after all, just don't buy the controller - but it still feels crassly exploitative and amounts to appalling value-for-money.


4. No Sign Of SNES, N64, GameCube Or Wii Games

goldeneye 007 proximity mines
Rare

Nintendo fans were shocked when the beloved Virtual Console service was axed for the Nintendo Switch, and though the company did hint at an alternative being in the works, at present Nintendo Switch Online only offers NES games in its Netflix-like library.

Considering the limitations of the NES' line-up and the ludicrous number of classic titles from the SNES, N64, GameCube and Wii that would be a fantastic fit for the Switch, it's mind-boggling that Nintendo is dragging their feet on this and basically leaving money on the table.

Wouldn't it be way more appealing if the 20 games were drawn from all Nintendo platforms rather than just the NES? Instead it seems far more probable that Nintendo will eventually make more recent titles available at an extra cost, while maybe, just maybe, including the occasional N64 or GameCube game in the subscription library as a "treat."

Nintendo has a notorious problem with messaging, and the fact they're refusing to speak about the possibility of newer games joining the paid-for library means it's likely not happening in the way most would love to see.


3. There's Forced Online Check-Ins For NES Games

Nintendo Switch NES
Nintendo

If you want to keep playing the service's library of NES games, you'll be required to check-in online every 7 days in order to "authenticate" your subscription.

While there are probably precious few situations where you and your Switch will be away from the Internet for a week, it's still an unnecessary, anti-consumer restriction that's once again shamed by Sony and Microsoft's more permissive attitude (that is, having no online authentication for downloaded games).

Considering that NES games aren't exactly high-value commodities, it does seem like a pretty cheeky move. Again, it's a rare scenario for 99% of gamers, but a needless imposition all the same.


2. Nintendo Has Created A Paywall Without Justifying It

Mario Kart 8
Nintendo

Factoring all of these issues in, the worst thing about Nintendo Switch Online is simply the fact that Nintendo has put up a paywall for a previously free online suite and made only the scarcest, laziest attempt to justify it.

The company had 18 months to get this right, and to see it coming out of the gate so shockingly piecemeal is absolutely embarrassing. While Sony and Microsoft offer up a solid slate of "free" games every month for your subscription dues, a middling collection of retro titles just isn't enough to justify the price tag.

It may not be expensive at just £17.99/$19.99, but on the basis of its launch, the service will be more of a begrudged imposition to customers than a value-filled proposition.


1. ...But It's Probably Too Cheap For Its Own Good

Nintendo Switch Online
Nintendo

This may be an unpopular opinion, but the biggest fundamental issue with the Switch's online service is that it's probably not expensive enough. It's launching for roughly half the cost of its rival online subscriptions, which sounds great until you realise it's also going to place a ceiling on the amount of content Nintendo is willing to offer up.

If the service was, say, £29.99, it'd still be cheaper than PSN or XBL, but maybe we'd get a Switch indie game every month, or at least some more recent titles added to the classic library.

Instead, the current offering is so shockingly piecemeal and the online infrastructure so comically thin that it becomes abundantly clear you're just paying your subscription in order to smash down an arbitrary, unnecessary paywall.

What do you make of Nintendo Switch Online's launch? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.