10 Reasons Rocksteady's Next Arkham Game Should Be Batwoman

Forget Superman. Rocksteady should stay in Gotham for the next adventure...

Batwoman Arkham
DC Comics

Despite there being rumours surrounding both Rocksteady and Warner Bros. Montreal's next projects, the Arkham series has effectively been on ice for the past four years. There was Arkham VR, sure - and even Return to Arkham - but the point still stands that this is probably way longer than anyone initially envisioned they'd have to wait for another main entry in the franchise.

Over at Montreal, it's become clear that the studio's planned Suicide Squad game was scrapped around 2016. A project focused on Damian Wayne quickly followed, but it now looks as though the studio have shifted development to work on a sequel to 2013's underrated Batman: Arkham Origins, with the Court of Owls as the principle antagonists.

If you thought details were relatively hard to come by as far as Montreal are concerned however, then Rocksteady have practically gone silent. The studio remain tight-lipped and while there's been talk of games centred around Superman and the Justice League, those with insider knowledge refuse to budge.

While that might be the case, there's a character no one's brought up that would provide the perfect platform to further explore the Arkhamverse, and her name is Batwoman. So here's why Rocksteady should seriously contemplate a Batwoman title, even if they said they're done with Batman...


10. Arkham Knight Subtly Introduced Kate Kane

Batman: Arkham Knight included an all-time great Easter egg when it referenced Batman, doing so in a manner that contradicted DC editorial's decision to forbid Kate Kane's marriage with her longtime partner, Maggie Sawyer.

As Bruce makes his way to his answering machine in Wayne Tower, he can listen to voicemails from both Lex Luthor and Kate Kane. At the time the former seemed like it was a deliberate means of foreshadowing a Superman game - or at least a future Arkham title featuring Lex as a villain - so why did people treat the second exchange involving Kate any less significantly?

The obvious distinction to be made is that Lex is a decades-old character and a staple of the DC universe, but the decision to explicitly confirm Batwoman's presence is equally important. Remember, Maggie was a cop in Metropolis before she joined the GCPD, so there's already a link between the two there.

Either way, Rocksteady's nod towards Kate shouldn't be forgotten, and especially not given the way Arkham Knight ended.


9. Batman Is DONE After Arkham Knight's Ending

Batman arkham knight ending
Rocksteady

Without getting too bogged down in the ups and downs of Arkham Knight's story, the ending wasn't exactly the best. It sells Bruce Wayne succumbing to his dark side as something triumphant when it really isn't, and the ending tease of a nightmarish Batman was nowhere near as definitive as it should've been.

Still, it didn't not raise some interesting questions. But while they could be addressed by any character, they definitely won't be by Batman. The character is done as far as Arkham is concerned, but it's his legacy that matters more. Arkham Knight's DLC teased the various ways his allies reacted to his ostensible demise, but wouldn't it be interesting if an outside force tried to honour it instead?

In the comics, Kate Kane dons the Batwoman identity after the Dark Knight stops her from being mugged in the street. At the time, Kate felt as though she was without purpose. Batman came into her life and she vowed to honour that legacy in her own way come '52', when the Dark Knight disappeared alongside the rest of DC's Trinity.

Now that Bruce is gone in the Arkhamverse, Rocksteady could mirror her journey in the comics.


8. Arkham Knight's DLC Broached Some Really Interesting Questions

Batman Arkham Knight Nightwing GCPD Lockdown
Rocksteady

Despite the mixed response to Arkham Knight's finale, some of the post-game DLC did approach it in an interesting way. There was GCPD Lockdown - a segment where you played Nightwing to reclaim the GCPD building from criminals - Catwoman's Revenge, which followed the eponymous character as she settled her feud with Riddler; and A Flip of a Coin, which centred around Robin's efforts to apprehend Two-Face.

Out of these, there were only two that really tried to address the implications of Arkham Knight's ending, and those were the two that revolved around Robin and Nightwing. GCPD Lockdown saw Dick Grayson try to put out the fires left behind by the events of the main story, while the latter gave players a view into how Tim Drake was dealing with the Dark Knight's apparent death.

Bear in mind that Bruce Wayne kept his true fate a secret from his own family, and it's easy to see how Rocksteady could centre a story around them uncovering what really happened to Batman.

Who better to lead that than an outside force?


7. The Character Is On An Upward Trajectory

Batwoman Arrowverse
The CW

Despite only being introduced around a decade or so ago, Kate Kane is a character on the rise. Only Miles Morales and Spider-Gwen could claim to have a more meteoric rise on the cards, but Kate in particular is on the cusp of something special.

Later this year, TheCW will premiere their own Batwoman TV show featuring Ruby Rose in the title role. It looks really good, and one would hope that it would serve as a springboard for further adventures in live action, animation, and in video games.

Bizarrely, Kate Kane is without her own comics series at the moment. That has to change when the series premieres, especially given just how much potential she possesses.

Either way, it's clear that Rocksteady would do well to capitalise on a now resurgent interest in the character. The show is just the beginning.


6. No More Retreads Of Batman Villains

Mister Bones DC
DC Comics

Batwoman might not boast as formidable or as extensive a rogues gallery as Batman's, but it's one worth mining in the Arkhamverse.

To date, one of the biggest criticisms surrounding the Arkham series was that it tended to repeatedly use villains rather than introduce new ones. Joker, Harley Quinn, Bane, Riddler and Penguin are just a few of the characters that appeared extensively throughout the series, even though there were countless other Batman villains at their disposal.

By using Batwoman as a main protagonist, Rocksteady would have a unique opportunity. Not only would they be able to follow up on teases to characters like The Broker, Maxie Zeus and Prometheus, they'd be able to pool resources from Kate's rogues gallery too. Mister Bones is one such villain who could easily send Black Mask running for the hills, while her sister Alice is a no-brainer to appear too.

Add in criminal organisations like the Religion of Crime, and you have plenty of opportunities for new and exciting antagonists to get involved.


5. She Replaced Batman Once Before

Batman Batwoman
DC Comics

As was previously mentioned, Batwoman is no stranger to filling the Dark Knight's boots. She did so without the Bat-Family's approval during '52', and she'd surely be able to do so again in a video game setting.

The character works fine enough when working alongside the Dark Knight, but she's always been better when she's been allowed to play by her own rules. She bears the Caped Crusader's insignia, but she's very much her own hero and one who's come up against the Bat-Family before, when her friends and loved ones were placed in danger.

Point being, Kate's a genuine force. She's never been a sidekick, a side-act or a supporting character, and has instead only ever been the lead.

The likes of Nightwing, Robin and Batgirl have all done the same before, but whereas with them they all have to navigate Batman's shadow, Kate has never had such anxiety - at least not during her peak years.

She's her own hero, and one more than capable of leading a Triple-A release.


4. She'd Bring Arkham Back To Basics

Batwoman DC Rebirth
DC Comics

One of the biggest criticisms levelled at Arkham Knight was that it placed an emphasis on vehicle combat over the series' traditional tenets of stealth action and hand-to-hand combat. The Batmobile ended up being as much a burden as it was a valuable resource, and it split fans straight down the middle.

Kate Kane, on the other hand, possesses no such issue.

Kate comes from money, but she's not as resourceful as her cousin Bruce. Instead, she comes from a military background, and she's often incorporated her training as a soldier into how she conducts herself as Batwoman, adopting a more regimented approach to crimefighting than the Dark Knight.

Her arsenal is also more limited, with the character depending more so on her skills as an expert fighter and tactician to defeat her enemies. She doesn't drive a bat-tank, she can't depend on her own remote-controlled jet, and one would suspect Detective Mode isn't in her repertoire either.

With that in mind, Rocksteady could produce a more challenging version of their Arkham formula. Keep the open world if you must, but putting players in the shoes of someone without the Waynes' resources would be such an interesting change of pace.


3. She Deserves To Be More Than Just A Costume

Batgirl vs Batwoman
DC Comics

One of the biggest problems with a lot of comic book video games is that they can sometimes reduce an entire character to just another costume. It's what happened to John Stewart in the Injustice games, and while it didn't make too much of a difference, the Dick Grayson-themed Robin skins in Batman: Arkham Knight were pretty jarring given the Robin of that title was actually Tim Drake.

Likewise, with Batgirl, it could be argued that Rocksteady have the opportunity to just make a Batwoman skin and go from there. However, Kate Kane and Barbara Gordon are so different from each other that it wouldn't make any sense to adopt that approach - she deserves to be her own character, with her own model, dialogue, and personality.

There's been a tendency in Arkham following Origins to repeat animations across different characters. Deathstroke had some of Robin's staff attacks in the prequel, and most of Arkham Knight's characters shared a specific few takedown animations too.

The occasional repeat is fine, but Kane is her own fighter. She isn't Batman, she isn't Batgirl - she isn't like any of Batman's allies. That should be reflected in a game.


2. It Would Provide Some Much Needed LGBT* Representation

Batwoman Maggie Sawyer
DC Comics

LGBT* representation in video games is a topic close to many people's hearts, and for good reason. LGBT* rep in video games is rarely ever substantial, with developers either opting for piecemeal allusions to a character's given sexuality, or explicit depictions ranging from the cliched to just the completely offensive.

Kate Kane deserves better, and there's no doubt Rocksteady could be the ones to marshall her journey in the medium. All they have to do is mirror her depiction in the comics, and the medium would finally have a Triple-A title centred around a lesbian protagonist. It's well overdue, and while Arkham has never really broached romance in the past, there's no reason why they couldn't in Batwoman-centric Arkham title.

With Kate and Maggie engaged to be wed in Arkham Knight, they could even follow through with that and commit to their marriage in the game. When do we ever see married superhero couples anymore? Never - let alone in the comics themselves.

Factor in the Easter egg that referenced Renee Montoya, a GCPD detective who later becomes the Question, and who's a former flame of Kate's, and you have the chance for some genuinely valuable LGBT* rep in the Arkhamverse.


1. We'd See The Bat-Family From The Outside

Batwoman Red Hood
DC Comics

When it comes to video games, we've only ever seen the Bat-family from the inside, and mostly as their patriarch, the Dark Knight himself. However, as DC have often shown over the last few decades, it's often the Batman stories set outside of that circle that tend to be the most interesting. That proved to be the case with Gotham Central, and it was definitely the case with Batwoman.

The way things are, Rocksteady have a couple of options they could take with a game set after Arkham Knight. They could have players assume the role of Batman yet again, operating in the shadows while trying to avoid detection from his old allies, or they could do something genuinely different and focus on telling a story from a different perspective.

Superman would be a great way of doing that, given his friendship with Bruce, but given Rocksteady's understanding of Gotham as a whole, it just makes more sense for Kate to be that figure. Let players see the city through new eyes, commit to the new status-quo and do something genuinely different.

That's how a franchise innovates. Both narratively speaking and gameplay-wise.


How Well Do You Remember Arkham Knight?

Batman Arkham Knight
Rocksteady

1. Who Is The First Major Character You Encounter As Batman?

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.