10 Reasons Silent Hill Is Better Than Resident Evil

The survival horror genre's taken a fair battering over recent years. You won't find many gamers who'd disagree that its best days have long since past. Oh sure, we've got titles like Amnesia and Slender popping up to remind us all that games are still capable of scaring the shit out of you; but obscure wee indie releases like that are few and far between. It makes you yearn for the golden age of the genre, when Japan seemed to pump out the next best thing in horror every second week. When actually scary games were major console releases, selling millions of copies. And what are the two big name franchises in survival horror? If you said Clock Tower and Fatal Frame then... Well honestly I admire your taste, but really it's Resident Evil and Silent Hill, isn't it? However much you want to argue that both have lost their way a wee bit in recent years (and they sure as hell have), it's undeniable that back in the day they were both pretty unbeatable. And as with most rival franchises, you've always got fans willing to argue that one is better than the other. And with Halloween having crept up on us again, I've been thinking about this. They both offer something a little different; Silent Hill's sheer psychological terror versus Resident Evil's B-movie jump scares. That's not easily comparable, but y'know... Silent Hill really is the more effective horror series. It knocks Resi into a pyramid-shaped hat. The first Resident Evil might have invented the term "survival horror" back in 1996, but it was Silent Hill that perfected it. Don't believe me? Here are ten reasons to convince you.

10. The Atmosphere

The Silent Hill series is a masterclass in atmospheric horror, slowly building up a sense of dread through pitch perfect use of camera angles, audio, brilliantly timed scares. Owing a great deal to the traditions of Japanese horror cinema, where creeping tension is valued above shock moments and visceral terror, Silent Hill nails the scary atmosphere perfectly. It keeps you right on the edge of your seat wondering what might come crawling out of the fog, if something dreadful waits around the next corner, whether you're just imagining those sounds getting closer and closer...

9. The Characters

Where Resident Evil has mostly put you in the shoes of highly trained special agents and muscle bound lunks over the years, Silent Hill instead gives you a series of deeply flawed protagonists, each with their own compelling and often shocking backstories to uncover. It's almost unfair to compare them: Resident Evil could hardly be called a character-driven series, after all. Its stellar cast of one-dimensional heroes and pantomime villains is entertaining enough, but it doesn't stand up to Silent Hill's set of tortured and believable personalities.

8. The Controls

Few survival horror games cover themselves in glory when it comes to control. One of the issues with utilising fixed camera angles and claustrophobic environments is that it can be pretty tricky to navigate clumsy characters around them, especially in moments of panic such as, say, when you're being attacked by vicious monsters. Still, you have to give the edge to Silent Hill again; its tighter controls were helped by more open environments, and offered less moments of screen-breaking frustration than Resi, which sometimes seemed to take pride in being stunningly awkward.

7. The Locations

While you could argue that Resident Evil has employed more variety in its locations over the years, setting the action everywhere from trains to volcanos to castles, Silent Hill's have undoubtably been scarier. Fittingly for the horror genre, it has you creeping through abandoned schools, hospitals, fairgrounds, keeping you on edge all the way. And that's not to mention the alternate dimension of the Otherworld, a twisted industrial nightmare where many of the series' most terrifying moments are to be had. I think, given the choice, most people would rather chance their luck in Racoon City's zombie-infested streets than wander one of Silent Hill's dreadful locations alone.

6. The Combat

Resi has always had a focus on weaponry. Even in the earlier titles, where ammo was often scarce, guns were readily available. Silent Hill plays things differently. Unlike with Resi, you rarely feel that you're at an advantage in combat. There are few guns, making blunt weapons your fall back option. And there's something inherently terrifying about going toe to toe with some twisted mass of shapeless horror as it jerks its way towards you. Resi's combat might be easier, more action packed, especially in recent years. But Silent Hill's reliance on melee weapons adds a feeling of helplessness and panic to fights, making them that much more scary.

5. The Stories

Resident Evil's plots have always had a charming B-movie feel to them. From the haunted houses and corporate scheming to the weird science and soap opera relationships, it's part of what makes the series so fun. And they always seem to end with an explosion. On the other hand the Silent Hill games weave a much more compelling narrative, focussing on the tortured pasts of the central characters, or the disturbing history of the town itself. Silent Hill 2 for instance is a masterclass in videogame storytelling, presenting a shocking psychological mystery that unravels along with the character's mind, and touches on difficult topics like incest and domestic abuse. Not exactly lightweight stuff.

4. The Audio

There are few games that utilise audio as effectively as those in the Silent Hill series. From the shrill and ominous air raid siren that heralds the transition to the Hellish Otherworld, to the jarring wails of radio static as monsters close in, it all makes up a huge part of the tense and terrifying atmosphere throughout. Music is chillingly effective as well, adding to the sinister sense of dread the series is famous for. Play a Silent Hill game with a decent set of headphones, and your nerves may never fully recover.

3. The Gameplay

Both series used to heavily employ the survival horror tropes of puzzle solving and monster dodging. But where Resident Evil has taken a head-first dive into action movie territory over the last few instalments, Silent Hill remains (for the most part) a traditional survival horror experience, with a slower pace and a strong focus on exploration and puzzle solving. And that's a good thing, especially when you're looking for something that'll scare you. Resident Evil seems to have jettisoned a sense of scariness in favour of bigger action set-pieces and ten times more gunplay.

2. The Monsters

When it comes to monsters, Silent Hill simply knocks it out of the park. Resident Evil's menagerie of mutants and zombies has given us some great moments. But there's very little that's truly disturbing in the same way as some of Silent Hill's creatures. Nothing kicks your fight or flight instinct into overdrive quite like the sight of a warped, knife wielding child sprinting at you in a darkened alley. Plus, they often have key symbolic importance, representing facets of the protagonist's own fears or weaknesses, giving a personal edge to the horrors that you're facing.

1. The Scares

But this is what it comes down to. As a series, Silent Hill is simply scarier than Resident Evil. From the psychological horror of the storylines to the use of audio to orchestrate terrifying moments, it perfectly blends so many elements to create some disturbing, disgusting, and downright scary games. Resident Evil has been responsible for some of the most memorably terrifying moments in gaming history (Everyone knows about that moments with the dogs). But where the Resident Evils delivered so well on the horror movie style scares and atmosphere, the Silent Hills produced a horror style that was both outright scary and disturbing, something that few games are capable of. To put it simply, Resident Evil messed with your nerves, Silent Hill messed with your mind. And there aren't many things more scary than that.

Contributor
Contributor

Glaswegian furball, professional time-waster, all round angry wee man.