10 Reasons The Video Game Industry Is Heading For Another Crash

When was the last time you were satisfied with a game on launch day?

Call of Duty Black ops 3 III
Activision

The Playstation 4 might have spent 18 months selling like there’s no tomorrow, but thanks to a timely price reduction in the last couple of months, the Xbox One is now starting to catch up. Both have sold far more than their predecessors from last generation had at the same point in their life-cycle, that's for sure.

It seems crazy then, to suggest that this might change - that gaming is heading for a major problem - but it has happened before, and to horrifying effect. 

In the late 70s and early 80s the saturation of the market - with too many consoles, the rise of home computers as a viable alternative and inferior products - led to the video game crash of 1983. Within two years, gaming revenues dropped from $3.2 billion dollars to just $100 million.

The final blow was the launch of E.T., widely regarded as one of the worst games ever made. It was a game so bad and overproduced that eventually it was buried in the desert like some kind of witchcraft.

With so much positive buzz and the money rolling in, gaming is currently riding the crest of a financial wave just as it was in the 1980s. But game developers are giving consumers fewer and fewer reasons to actually buy anything on launch day - not to mention those who do show faith, end up with genuinely broken and shoddy products as a reward.

In fact, you could say the cracks are already starting to show...

10. History Is Already Repeating Itself

Consoles picture
Wikimedia Commons

Firstly, there's too much competition within console gaming. At the moment Microsoft and Sony might be dominating, with Nintendo hanging around behind (just as they were in the 1980s, incidentally), but they aren’t the only ones on the market. Steam are launching their own home console-style Steamboxes in the next year, there are hundreds of different Android versions and both Apple TV and Amazon Fire TV are capable of playing games too. They might not be a threat to the big three right now, but it all starts somewhere.

Competition from outside the console market also didn't help in the 80s. But whereas then, they only had to deal with competition from home computers, now they are facing a challenge from mobile gaming as well. More and more consumers are being pulled towards these other gaming options. 

Steam has already perfected digital gaming, and although Microsoft saw their efforts to move towards a disc-less console fail dramatically at first, you can't deny how a situation where console manufacturers are replaced by a home computer/mobile-market structured framework would become the norm eventually.

It would definitely solve the pre-owned games model that publishers have been working to eradicate for years, anyway. Not only is the situation similar to the 1980s, but we've already seen the first casualties of this structure - say, remember THQ?


9. The Loss Of Mid-Tier Development

thq logo
thq

Game companies are sadly disappearing at an alarming rate. In 2012 over 20 went bankrupt, including long-running studios like Hudson Soft, Psygnosis and Rockstar Vancouver/Barking Dog. The list of games those studios created is endless, but they include the creators of Bomberman, WipeOut, Lemmings, Max Payne 3, Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning and City of Heroes.

The biggest fall came at the end of 2012 with the demise of THQ. This wasn’t a company slowly slipping into obscurity, instead they were an established studio still making various big games. They had lucrative licenses for Warhammer 40,000 and the annual WWE titles, with popular ongoing franchises such as Saints Row and Red Faction to boot. Despite all of this, with game production budgets spiralling out of control and a string of new IPs that just didn't catch on, the company filed for bankruptcy and those other franchises were sold off to the highest bidder.

Since then a number of other companies have gone too. Even Crytek, developer of one of the first exclusive games for Xbox One, have cut it close, with reports of unpaid wages in their UK office. Should this continue, more and more of the established gaming industry will disappear as we head straight into crash territory.

Why are so many games companies going bust? Well...


8. Unrealistic Expectations

577715

Sometimes games do badly, there is no avoiding that. However, when some companies are betting their future on the success of a game, that is what leads to bankruptcy. For THQ their last year in operation was hit by the dual poor performance of Homefront and Red Faction: Armageddon.

38 Studios sunk not only all their own money but a big pile from the state of Rhode Island into Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning. It sold 1.5 million, by many standards a success for a new IP from a fledgling studio. But they needed to sell twice that to just break even. 38 Studios went bankrupt and Rhode Island lost over $70 million worth of investment.

It doesn't always lead to bankruptcy though. The 2013 reboot of Tomb Raider was a great success, selling through 3.4 million copies in only four weeks. But even that wasn't enough as Square Enix was hoping for a ridiculous 14.9 million units between Tomb Raider, Hitman Absolution and Sleeping Dogs. Instead, they sold just under 9 million proving their market research was way, WAY off.

We all want new and exciting games, but you have to be realistic in your expectations. Just because Call of Duty or Skyrim sells well, it doesn't mean every FPS/fantasy RPG will. Meanwhile, the reasons not to buy games are mounting up...


7. The Endless Amount Of Broken Games

Assassins Creed Unity Glitch Face
Ubisoft

It might seem too easy to pick on Ubisoft after their disastrous 2014 showing, but Assassin’s Creed: Unity really is the most high-profile example of this. To give you some idea how broken the game was on release, even AFTER a day one patch, Ubi admitted that the player character might just fall through the ground or the game could crash if you try to play co-op - or you might not even make it past the main menu. 

It was so bad, the studio ended up giving away games as both compensation, and a way of dissuading anyone from suing over their broken products.

Of course, they weren't the only ones. Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare had problems preventing it from starting on both Xbox One and Playstation 4. Halo's Master Chief Collection launched with matchmaking problems which took months to rectify (although half a year later, Halo's official Championship Series had to have matches cancelled due to it still not connecting). 

In the last few years alone, SimCity, Battlefield 4, Drive Club and Little Big Planet 3 have all been plagued with wretched problems, calling on Day One patches to get them in more acceptable states.

Bugs are inevitable - particularly in massive open-world games - but for the basic mechanics and selling-points of these titles to be outright broken is inexcusable. Broken games leads to people not trusting developers, which in turns leads to a significant drop in sales - and that, which as we've already seen, is incredibly damaging when sales expectations are set way too high in the first place.


6. Innovation Is Either Non-Existent, Or Terrible

Kinect 360
Microsoft

This goes for both software and hardware. Yes, doing something new is hard, but Microsoft has only just accepted that no one wants a Kinect, after five years of trying to justify it. The big innovations this generation - like Twitch and voice commands - don’t really do much for the average gamer, and even less for anyone who's followed the industry for years. 

When it comes to games, Activision has been releasing the same FPS for over ten years. The Halo, Uncharted and Assassin’s Creed franchises have been doing the same thing as well. And when they do innovate, most people hate it (AC: Revelations' tower-defence, anyone?). 

However, when something truly new like Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning comes along - with none of the PR clout necessary to make it stand out - they expect it to have the same kind of sales that established series' have, and use that lack of follow-through as justification to fall back on what's dependably bankable and formulaic.

The lack of innovation means there is little to choose between consoles or games. Why buy the next Call of Duty when it is the same as the last, or why buy an Xbox and PlayStation when there's no difference between them? Without innovation and the competition it brings, across a long enough timeline, sales can only drop.

Worse still, when it comes to established single-player franchises, the height of innovation seems to be adding a multiplayer mode. Which brings us to...


5. There Is Too Much Of An Emphasis On Multiplayer Gaming

Call Of Duty Ghosts
Infinity Ward

To a lot of gamers, multiplayer is all there is. But crucially, that's not for everyone. 

Games that are predominantly sold on their online component - mainly the FPS genre - have been testing for years how little single-player content can be put into a game and still legitimately be called a “campaign”.

Call of Duty: Ghosts was so derided for its insulting single-player offering that the next game went completely the other way and gave the world a Kevin Spacey film masquerading as an FPS. Other big AAA titles like Titanfall, Evolve and Destiny didn’t even bother with little things like plot or a single-player mode - and they suffered for it.

But much worse than this are the games from franchises that built their fanbase on a strong single-player experience, only to now do their best to alienate them. I’m talking about franchises like Fable and, yes, Assassin’s Creed. Many introduce multiplayer modes that don't always negatively affect the single-player experience, before then going all-in with online-only multiplayer games. For example, despite the recent failure of countless MMOs, Bethesda followed up the phenomenal success of the single-player Skyrim with... an MMO. 

Who could have predicted that it wouldn’t be the monster hit the follow-up to Skyrim should have been?

This pushes casual players towards mobile and indy titles, spelling big trouble for the AAA studios who rely on sales from a smaller and smaller, more disenfranchised group.


4. Too Many Re-Releases

Tomb Raider
Square Enix

It started with Tomb Raider and her hair. Then no-one was surprised when Grand Theft Auto V and The Last of Us - widely regarded as two of the greatest games of the last generation - were updated and brought to Xbox One and PS4, despite both being less than two years old. 

Next came Halo: The Master Chief Collection, which despite its bug-filled rollout, was exactly the sort of thing that should get re-released.

But then, the deluge started. What followed was a whole list of games that weren’t that popular on the Xbox 360 and PS3, so why bring them to the new consoles? It has gotten so absurd that The Game Awards have introduced a “Best Remaster” category.

It’s about time the games industry called this trend for what it actually is: monetised backwards compatibility. A big deal was made about the lack of this feature for the new generation, but here it is - so long as you are willing to pay £50 for each game you already own. Once again this poor output leads to lower than expected sales, because who in their right mind wants to pay close to full retail price for a game they either already own and have experienced, or could go purchase on an old console for a tenth of the cost?

At least the independent companies are still releasing original games. Except that...


3. Successful Independent Publishers Either Sell Up Or Go Bust

Minecraft Steve
MoJang

Look at the big indie success stories in gaming over the last few years:

In 2009 Zynga launched Farmville, the game that would take Facebook by storm with 16 million daily users at its height. But by 2013, Zynga was laying off staff and closing three offices across the world and in 2014 they laid off another 300-plus staff. Angry Birds is a genuine media franchise, but 2014 saw an announcement that net profits were down 50% on the previous year, with 130 out of the 800 people working for the company losing their jobs as a result.

The only thing that can compare to the success of Angry Birds in recent memory is Minecraft. The sandbox game has made the same giant leap from game to entertainment phenomenon, and as a result the creators sold the company to Microsoft for $2.5 billion. But after looking at Rovio and Zynga, who can blame them?

The success of the indie market has pulled casual gamers away from consoles to some extent. But because the success isn't sustainable, more indies will sell to AAA developers, leaving a vacuum for new studios who will either go bust or sell-up. It will go round in circles until the indies have taken so much of the market away from the AAAs that they can't afford to buy them anymore, and the previous system will collapse.


2. Publisher's Disregard For The User Experience

Battlefield companion app
EA

If there is a gaming apocalypse, historians will look back and brand AC: Unity the first horseman. Or maybe the E.T. of the 21st century.

Ubisoft's 2014 release already appeared on this list due to its ludicrous amount of glitches and bugs, but Ubi are just as guilty of introducing terrible 'innovations' like forced interaction with smartphone apps - manifesting itself in Unity by gating content behind a registration wall.

What really pushes AC: Unity into E.T. territory was Ubisoft’s response to all this. Reviews of the game were embargoed until 12 hours after release, ensuring unless journalists wanted to be threatened with lawsuits, they couldn't do their job effectively and inform the public of what they were going to buy. It felt entirely like Ubisoft knew they were peddling a broken game, and intentionally prevent reviews from being read.

When consumers did get hands on and the list of bugs became a mile long, which feature did they choose to concentrate on fixing first? Their number one priority was the “Helix Credits issue”, meaning after having asked you to spend $/£60 on their game, the first thing they are going to fix is the ability to spend even more money. 

Gee, thanks a lot there, Ubisoft. It's not like Arno was falling through the floor or struggling to maintain his facial muscles or anything.

Which brings us to the saddest fact of all...


1. It’s All The Consumer's Fault

Call of Duty Black ops 3 III
Activision

Yes, it’s gamers and consumers that have allowed this situation to develop.

Every year Call of Duty and FIFA outsell everything else, because people buy them regardless, giving license to developers not to innovate. But here's the thing: CoD sales have dropped the last two years. A blip, or a sign of things to come? And some games get piles of pre-orders no matter what, meaning publishers can afford to push release on buggy titles and fix them later.

The high sales of certain titles leads companies to believe that a similar game will do well, so trying to push something completely new out the gate gets knocked back as everything is bet on 'what works' - an ethos consumers are more than happy to prove right. 

It's a vicious cycle, as the success of Call of Duty leads to 101 military-themed games like Red Faction and Homefront; games that later cost THQ their existence. And when they don't sell, the surviving teams go back to releasing the same stuff all over again, risky game budgets and market research reinforcing the lack of necessity for forward momentum.

It feels like gamers are getting increasingly fed up, and one day there'll be enough of us who simply stop buying whatever buggy and unoriginal offerings the industry puts out - but maybe that's the only way they'll listen.


How do you feel about the game industry's treatment of its fans right now? Agree? Disagree? Let us know in the comments below!


Contributor
Contributor

Having failed at being an actor and failed at having a job Dan decided to return to education and is now studying for a PhD in Classics. In his spare time he enjoys analysing every area of popular culture: from film to television to video games to theatre to literature. Find him on twitter @dangoad