10 Recent Video Games Sent Out To Die
Suicide Squad is living up to its name.
For better or worse (let's face it, mostly worse), video games live or die by their marketing. You can have the best piece of art ever created, construct oscar-worthy cinematics, fabricate new worlds full of rich characters or craft the finest, most satisfying mechanics ever put to code but if you can't convince anybody to check the game out, all that work goes to waste.
At the same time though, it's perhaps worse if you do have that gem of a game and the marketing department fails to sell players on it, creating cringeworthy trailers and boring gameplay videos that wrongly send people away from the title, rather than to it.
Conversely, sometimes a publisher knows they've got a stinker on their hands and will try to quietly release it without anyone realising.
With all this in mind, over the past year there have been a whole bunch of releases that have been sent out to certain doom.
Some were so terrible anyway that they probably didn't deserve better, but others were genuinely overlooked gems worthy of your time that, for one reason or another, weren't given a fighting chance at the market.
11. Honorable Mentions
Okay, so before we get into the already-released games that we can say, in hindsight, were definitely sent out to die, it's worth talking about the upcoming titles that inspired this list.
There weren't enough to justify their own article (despite my best efforts), but the most obvious upcoming game being sent out to the (killer) sharks is Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League. Skepticism has lingered over this superhero spin-off since its initial announcement as a four-player co-op shooter, and that turned into outright hostility following more extensive looks at gameplay via trailers that only highlighted uninspired missions and repetitive gameplay.
This backlash resulted in the title getting hit with a last-minute delay that pushed it back by nearly a whole year. Unfortunately, recent early impressions and previews haven't done much to win players back either. It's too soon to say whether Suicide Squad deserves to be rejected off the bat (its cinematics and story do look tantalising), but it feels obvious that it's gearing up for a thorny reception.
Other 2024 releases seemingly set to suffer the same fate at the time of writing also include the just-released Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown which has enjoyed exceptional reviews but has been let down by Ubisoft's lack of marketing, as well as Skull and Bones which, according to Kotaku (via The Gamer), only remains alive after a decade in development hell due to a deal that was made with the Singapore government.
Who said you can't balance art and commerce, eh?
10. Redfall
Though it seems like a lifetime ago now, Redfall set the standard for bad games and botched launches in 2023 when it released last May.
Pre-release, it felt like everyone except Microsoft knew that asking a developer best known for its singleplayer immersive sims to create an open-world multiplayer live-service shooter would lead to dodgy results, and as such players weren't exactly convinced by Redfall's early trailers. Though the art direction and world building looked as top-tier as you'd expect from an Arkane release, everything else looked, well, a little ropey.
Despite initially being pitched as a major Xbox exclusive for 2023, Redfall was ultimately dumped onto store shelves and Game Pass with little fanfare, but that didn't stop it receiving a huge wave of post-launch press for being a buggy, empty, half-baked experience.
Full of performance issues and quest-breaking bugs, even if the game worked as intended it wouldn't have been received well, as a lack of interesting missions and enemy encounters made for an experience that didn't play to the developer's strengths.
Explanations for the game's state came shortly after launch from a damning report by Bloomberg's Jason Schreier (via VGC), whose sources within the studio claimed that they hoped Microsoft would cancel Redfall rather than release it, and that the pivot to multiplayer caused a mass exodus of talent.
Whatever happened, don't expect to see a Redfall 2 anytime soon.
9. Avatar: Frontiers Of Pandora
It wouldn't be a list about games that were sent out by their publisher to die without an Ubisoft title, and from the studio that brought you dumped gems like Immortals: Fenyx Rising comes Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora.
Coming at the tail-end of 2023 after players had gorged on the holiday season's deluge of must-play titles and the Game of the Year winners had already been announced, Frontiers of Pandora was treated as a footnote, an afterthought that many wrote off as 'just another missable Ubisoft game'.
Vacating its initial 2022 launch window which would have no doubt bolstered interest thanks to the close proximity of box-office smash Avatar: The Way of Water, the title quietly released with virtually zero marketing behind it a year later. It was no surprise then when Frontiers of Pandora debuted at only no.5 in the UK charts despite no other competition that week, and had its price slashed in a sale later that month.
And unlike Redfall, this is one that's a shame. Ubisoft should have had more confidence in the project, as Frontiers, while not coming close to the quality of 2023's biggest hitters, is still a damn good time, and far better than the publisher's recent output. In fact this was reflected by a report from Forbes, which pointed out that Avatar boasted a better user score on Metacritic than any AAA Ubisoft game in nearly a decade.
Even when Ubisoft has a good thing on its hands, it still manages to fumble the bag.
8. The Lords Of The Fallen
In the head-to-head race between the two major Soulslikes set to release in 2023 - those of course being Lies of P and The Lords of the Fallen - I had my money on the latter being the better of the two.
After all, while not being much of a fan of the first game in the series, the pre-release trailers showed off a visual marvel of a hack-and-slasher, while the new developers had the opportunity to take the IP to new heights. And even if it didn't look amazing, surely it would still be better than the Soulslike starring freaking Pinocchio, right?
Well...
Lies of P turned out to not only be a great entry into the sub-genre, but one of the best surprises of the entire year. The Lords of the Fallen, however, couldn't live up to the potential teased in the marketing, releasing with major performance issues that overshadowed the genuinely good elements in there.
Had they been ironed out, and had Lies of P not stolen its thunder just a few weeks prior, perhaps this reboot could have landed with a bigger splash.
7. Immortals Of Aveum
EA's Immortals of Aveum had a rough ride in 2023. It garnered a lot of good will for being a rare original big game from the publisher, but it was sadly fighting an uphill battle from the get go.
The next-gen exclusive never quite caught the attention of players, with trailers looking promising, but not exactly proving why Immortals should be considered the next big thing. Sold on its colourful magic-based first-person combat system and enthusiastically championed in trailers by actors said to be bringing to life a compelling story within the game, nothing particularly looked bad, but there was nothing that grabbed your attention either.
Its $70 price point no doubt played a large role in players choosing to not gamble on a lukewarmly-reviewed debut project from an unproven studio, especially in a release window which saw the likes of Baldur's Gate 3, Starfield, Mortal Kombat 1, Lies of P and Armoured Core VI vying for the audience's attention. All these factors resulted in a pretty disastrous launch, and were acknowledged by the studio when it announced that 45% of its staff were being laid off shortly afterwards.
It's another sad story without a happy ending. Immortals of Aveum might not have ever been destined to do Elden Ring numbers, but it's hard to shake that it could have found its audience if it had been dealt a different hand, kind of like Dead Island 2 managed earlier in the year.
6. The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
I was surprised by how much I loved the Texas Chain Saw Massacre game. Despite not being a huge fan of other asymmetrical horror releases, Texas Chain Saw's twist on the formula, pitting four villains against four survivors rather than having just one killer, turned out to be the secret sauce for delivering a fresh cat-and-mouse experience.
It helped that it was a horror fan's dream come true in terms of presentation as well, with the characters and iconography of the classic original movie being lovingly translated to video game form. For die-hards, it was as much of a kick to simply walk around the Sawyer family abode as it was to chainsaw the head off someone's shoulders.
Despite its promise though, it was annoyingly clear from launch that Texas Chain Saw might not have the legs to see it succeed for years to come. For one, this is a notoriously difficult sub-genre to garner popularity in, as other attempts like Evil Dead: The Game ultimately failed to attract enough attention to justify long-term support (despite also being a quality offering).
Another issue stemmed from a fundamental problem with the game itself though. See, Texas Chain Saw Massacre, despite being a longstanding franchise boasting nine movies, is mired in a licensing cobweb. As such, the developers of the game only had the license to the original movie, meaning that locations, characters and story beats from the other eight instalments couldn't be leveraged for a DLC roadmap.
That severely limited the game's potential in terms of future maps, playable heroes and villains, and even cosmetic unlocks. That's why the title in its current form features newly created characters to fill out the roster, rather than any recognisable faces pulled from other movies.
That decision, plus market factors, would knee-cap the potential longevity of any release, and as such the average Steam playerbase for Texas Chain Saw dropped from 10,000 at launch, to just over 900 as of December.
5. Firewall Ultra
The writing was on the wall with Firewall Ultra all year.
Though the original game was a signature staple of the PSVR's library, serving as a tense, innovative Rainbow Six-like for virtual reality fans, this semi-sequel, semi-remake had red flags from the start. Not only did early trailers look choppy and unconvincing, but the world of VR had changed massively since the launch of the first Firewall.
Other multiplatform PSVR2 titles like Pavlov had since established the bar for shooting in the medium, featuring jaw-dropping visuals with the jump to Unreal Engine 5, as well as immersive weapon mechanics, including manual firing, moving and reloading. Firewall, with its aged visuals and more input-based controls, felt a generation behind from the get go.
It wasn't just fans that weren't convinced either. Sony itself seemingly tried to bury the game following its announcement, releasing little footage from the title across 2023 and, most damningly, omitting it altogether from a segment of a Playstation business presentation that highlighted the strength of the PSVR 2's upcoming portfolio of games.
Without a release date until a month before it released in August, the title dropped with no marketing push to mid review scores and even worse fan reception. Tragically, the studio behind the franchise, First Contact Entertainment, announced it was closing its doors a few months later.
4. Alan Wake II
Sometimes, a game comes along that proves why we can't have nice things in this industry.
Alan Wake II was a decade in the making. The follow up to a cult classic that didn't sell as well as it deserved, it took developers Remedy years before they got a chance to revisit Alan's story and the strange, charming town of Bright Falls. Naturally there was a huge amount of expectation surrounding the long-sought-after project, but that only seemed to galvanise the studio, which arguably delivered its best game to date when the sequel launched at the end of October.
A genuinely unique survival horror experience that threw everything at the wall, including live-action musical sequences, a heady story-within-a-story-within-a-story narrative structure and fascinating crossovers with other Remedy titles, it was a bona-fide critical darling, a dominant Game of the Year contender, and a beacon of originality in a sea of safe-bet releases.
But... well, you know where this is going. Despite the lavish critical praise and word-of-mouth hype from fans, Alan Wake II repeated the fate of its predecessor, reportedly selling poorly across its first few weeks on storefronts. Annoyingly though, the major issue had nothing to do with the quality or appeal of the game itself, but rather the decision to sell the title exclusively as a digital release, which many fans suspect severely limited the reach and visibility of the AAA game.
Hopefully there's a glimmer of hope with this one though. Despite suffering that major handicap, the response to Alan Wake II could see it become a slow-burner sales-wise, with the console numbers reportedly rising to nearly 900,000 by the end of December. Here's hoping it can remain steady into 2024.
3. The Walking Dead: Destinies
It's saying something that in a year which brought us stinkers like Lord of the Rings: Gollum, The Day Before and Redfall, The Walking Dead: Destinies still stands out as being one of the smelliest in recent memory. Granted, it's impossible to name a Walking Dead game based on the TV show that you'd generously give even a 6/10 (unlike the games based on its comic counterpart, which are nearly universally incredible), but Destinies is a special kind of bad because it's built around the nugget of a good idea.
Though the gameplay looks and feels budget, it might not have mattered if the central conceit - that being giving the player the ability to alter events from the first four seasons of the show and create interesting 'what if' storylines based around the show's major beats - was handled well.
Of course, this central mechanic amounts to little more than a gimmick in the title itself, with the majority of time being spent in bland levels grappling with atrocious controls and stealth that'll make you think you've gone back in time to the PS2 era.
Some games don't deserve to be sent out to die, but others? Well... no comment.
2. The Day Before
While many players will remember 2023 for stunning titles like Baldur's Gate 3, Alan Wake II and Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, just as many will associate it with one game and one game only: The Day Before.
The mecca of everything wrong with misleading pre-release trailers, dodgy promises and unwieldily hype, Fntastic's survival game (or is it an extraction shooter? a live service?) had an unprecedented release-to-killed turnaround, with the studio behind it shutting down just five days after the The Day Before's launch.
So, what happened? Well, what initially was Steam's most wishlisted game following a tantalising reveal trailer soon came under constant scrutiny from burned fans who wondered whether it even existed at all. With constant delays, zero communication, and ever changing goalposts in regards to what the game was even going to be, that early hype quickly evaporated as The Day Before was hit with claims that it was nothing more than a scam.
Finally releasing at the end of 2023, fans got to play the game they had such high hopes for - and it was even worse than they could have imagined. A barebones extraction shooter with glitches that would make Assassin's Creed: Unity blush, the last minute Early Access release saw a huge chunk of players jump in to sate their curiosity... only for literally 90% of them to call it quits when they saw how rubbish the release was.
It was nothing compared to the quality promised by that first trailer, and will no doubt be remembered as one of the most disappointing games of all time.
Seriously, I can't do the travesty justice in this list, but SkillUp has an excellent, exhaustive breakdown of everything that went wrong with this garbage fire that you should definitely check out.
1. Crash Team Rumble
You shouldn't judge a book by its cover, but sometimes all you need to see is a single trailer or hear a one-line premise to know a game is gonna go down in flames. And, I hate to say it, but that was always the case with Crash Team Rumble.
Following an all-timer set of remakes in Crash N. Sane Trilogy and Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fuelled, alongside a new original game in the form of Crash Bandicoot 4: It's About Time which rivalled the quality of the original trilogy, it seemed as though Crash was back and, more importantly, that Activision had a vision for the franchise's future.
And then the company revealed Crash Team Rumble, a live-service multiplayer spin-off.
You'd be forgiven for forgetting this thing even came out, as it seemed like such a soulless attempt from the Activision brass to turn one of the most beloved franchises of all time into a monetisable cash cow. It actually reviewed decently (it was developed by Toys For Bob, a genuinely great studio), but the interest wasn't there for a live-service Crash, and few were enticed to pony up the $30 to see if it was more than a quick cash-in.
In fact, according to reporting by TrueTrophies.com, Crash Team Ruble's PS5 player count was nearly 70% lower than another game that hit the console in June 2023 No, not Final Fantasy XVI, but rather... My Friend Peppa Pig. Tragic.
This is probably another case of Activision being too greedy for its own good; Crash Team Rumble might have won players over if it was free-to-play, but the publisher's hubris got in the way yet again.