10 Times Video Game Critics Got It Wrong

Don't trust the reviews.

Zelda Skyward Sword Metacritic
Nintendo

A good game is a completely subjective thing. What one player likes and another doesn't can be completely different, and it makes reviewing them a pretty hard thing to do.

How do you score a product when there's always going to be some people out there who just don't like it? Critics have struggled with this problem for a long time, and it's something that doesn't seem like it'll ever be fixed.

Understandably, there are going to be a few times when - through the eyes of the wider populace - they get it completely wrong.

Whether it be snubbing a good game and not giving it the attention it deserves, or giving a mediocre game a good review, the amorphous collective voice we tend to give critics doesn't always result in the "right" score.

Whilst some would argue that it doesn't matter as long as the player enjoys the game, the review scores that a game gets can massively impact how well that title does, so it's a pretty big deal.

With that in mind, let's hope that the critics avoid making the same mistakes twice.

10. Destiny 2

Destiny 2
Bungie

Metacritic Score: 8.5

User Score: 4.9

Nobody likes Destiny 2 more than the critics.

Upon launch (and even now to some extent), Destiny 2 was considered to be one of the emptiest experiences this generation, with no massive improvements over the original game, and nothing really placing it above any game out at the time.

Unlike the first Destiny, which still managed to have a large and devoted fanbase, Destiny 2 was mostly rejected by those same people. Destiny 2 was labled as boring, unfulfilling and a grind. That's not even mentioning how bad the randomised loot had gotten.

Yet, despite all of this, Destiny 2 still managed to get some pretty great reviews from critics all over. Eights and nines all over, with only a few critics giving it mediocre scores.

For a game that's generally regarded as Destiny 1.5, how the critics gave it better reviews is a mystery. It seems like many were blinded by it's production values.


9. Deadly Premonition

deadly premonition
Access Games

Metacritic Score: 6.8

User Score: 8.3

There's just no game out there like Deadly Premonition.

When it first released, Deadly Premonition was slammed by critics, but its cult status with players has managed to elevate it beyond what the critics said.

The weirdest part is that a lot of complaints about Deadly Premonition are actually pretty correct. The game is a mess in many regards, and its graphics and gameplay do leave a lot to be desired. Despite all of this, Deadly Premonition is pretty much a masterpiece in what it tries to do.

Deadly Premonition is a passion project through and through, and is so oddly charming that it literally can't be explained without playing it. Many aspects of it are so unique and self-aware that reviewing it is, perhaps, impossible. You can't really blame the critics on this one, even if they did miss the point.

Even if critics were right in many ways, Deadly Premonition is absolutely essential as a gaming experience, and that's something only a few people caught onto.


8. Dragon Age 2

Dragon Age 2
BioWare

Metacritic Score: 8.2

User Score: 4.3

Oh boy were people mad about this one.

Dragon Age 2 was one of the most anticipated games of its time, so for fans to find out that it was a massively stripped down and boring experience when compared to Origins was a pretty big shock. It was an even bigger shock when you see that critics had absolutely raved about the game.

The reviews just don't match up to the product at all. Similarly to Fallout 4, Dragon Age 2 was hated so much because it stripped down the RPG mechanics so much and delivered a meaningless story.

Dragon Age 2 also has it's lovers, but the majority of those who played it were shocked at the lack of quality, which probably hurt the series in a massive way.

Despite all this, Dragon Age 2 was pretty greatly reviewed by almost every critic. None of them seemed to notice how lacklustre the game really was, especially as a Dragon Age game, and it still remains as one of the biggest disagreements in review history.


7. Mass Effect: Andromeda

Mass Effect Andromeda
Bioware

Metacritic Score: 7.1

User Score: 4.8

This one is still as much of a surprise now as it was when it happened.

After reading some pretty good reviews of Mass Effect: Andromeda, fans were all ready to finally experience another great game in one of BioWare's best franchises.

What they got was a complete mess of a game that could barely be played, let alone be given a good score.

Andromeda launched with so many glitches and problems that it was completely unacceptable. Gameplay was pretty standard Mass Effect fare, but the lack of an interesting story and all of the production issues made it a really poor experience.

Reviews for Andromeda didn't light the world on fire, but still spoke of a pretty good game that would keep long-time fans of the series happy whilst taking Mass Effect in a new direction. That certainly didn't happen.

Mass Effect: Andromeda basically killed off the Mass Effect series, which is crazy when you consider that the first three games are remembered as one of gaming's best trilogies.


6. No Man's Sky

Nms Toxic
Hello Games

Metacritic Score: 7.1

User Score: 4.5

Even if No Man's Sky has picked up since release, there's just no forgetting a first impression, and the one that Hello Games gave us was filled with deceit and dull gameplay.

So why on earth did it get good reviews?

No Man's Sky is perhaps one of the most controversial and upsetting games of this generation, with so many people putting their faith in at as the game to end all games. When it ended up being mediocre, it shocked the world, yet most critics out there weren't phased by it at all.

A glance at Metacritic will show you that whilst critics gave it favourable reviews, users absolutely slammed the game and leaved it with a bad unfavourable review score.

Although this sort of disagreement can be pretty common, the fact that No Man's Sky was a boring, empty mess was sort of unarguable. The fact is, No Man's Sky has only just started earning the review scores it initially got, and even then it's a pretty hard sell.


5. Uncharted 3

Uncharted 3 Drake's Deception
Naughty Dog

Metacritic Score: 9.2

User Score: 8.4

Uncharted 3 was lauded as the best game in the series when it first came out, but that's definitely an overstatement.

As great as Drake's Deception is, it's nowhere near as great as Uncharted 2, and especially no better than the last game in the series, A Thief's End.

With many critics giving Uncharted 3 perfect review scores, you might think it's much better or at least on par with Uncharted 2, which received similar levels of praise as the third game. That's not really the case.

Despite some improved gameplay, Uncharted 3 really let itself down with the story and overreliance of setpieces. With Naughty Dog considering the setpieces before the story, many of them actually don't make much sense at all and are simply there to show off.

When you compare this to Uncharted 2, which managed to have amazing moments and still have a coherent and passionate narrative, it really shows which is the better game.

Don't get me started on Uncharted 4's lower scores.


4. The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

legend of zelda Skyward sword
Nintendo

Metacritic Score: 9.3

User Score: 8.1

Did any of the critics actually play Skyward Sword again after finishing it before reviewing it?

Considering the perfect review scores, it's hard to imagine that they did. Even though Skyward Sword is actually a pretty good game, it's easily the least popular Zelda game in recent memory, and for pretty good reason.

Despite having some of the best characterisation in a Zelda game (particularly for Link and Zelda), Skyward Sword had some of the most repetitive and boring gameplay in the series. Focusing on having motion controls for every action probably didn't help matters much either.

With such significant complaints, it's surprising that Skyward Sword managed to be both a nominee and winner of Game of the Year. Skyward Sword isn't a bad game in any regard, but it's certainly nowhere near as good as other games in the series, let alone the best game that year.

The Nintendo bias is starting to show a little guys...


3. Kingdom Hearts II

kingdom hearts 2
Square Enix

Metacritic: 8.7

User Score: 9.0

Widely regarded by many as the best game in the series, Kingdom Hearts II didn't get anywhere near as much praise as it rightly deserved.

Despite there now being over eight different games in the Kingdom Hearts series, the second still stands as the best one out of the bunch. Kingdom Hearts II added to everything the original did, whilst having a much more satisfying combat system than the first.

Complaints about a confusing overarching story aside, Kingdom Hearts II doesn't deserve much of the criticism it got. Calling the game too easy, or 'mash triangle to win' are completely unfounded, especially if you choose to play the game on critical, where it becomes a true challenge.

By no means did Kingdom Hearts II get the worst reviews in the world, but when you consider how much it defined the series and how little credit it gets compared to the first it was definitely misjudged.

Let's hope they get it right when Kingdom Hearts III rolls around.


2. Star Wars Battlefront II

Goldeneye Rogue Agent
EA

Metacritic Score: 6.8

User Score: 1.0

Even the mention of Star Wars Battlefront II is sure to ruffle a few feathers, and rightly so.

Not only did Battlefront II screw up improving upon the game in any meaningful way, it also managed to cause a worldwide controversy that might have changed how microtransactions are done forever. Sales were massively down from the last game and it seemed like the game topped more "Worst Games Of 2017" lists than any other that year.

So how did one of the most hated games of our generation score with critics? Surprisingly well.

Battlefront II managed to get reviews that most games would only dream of. Although the game isn't as bad as it could be, the problems that it does have far overshadow any of the good that it does.

The fact that governments had to get involved over how egregious the lootboxes were should really say it all. Critics really got this one wrong.


1. Fallout 4

Fallout 4 5
Bethesda

Metacritic Score: 8.7

Critic Score: 6.6

Bethesda's latest game may have done pretty well with its review scores, but most fans unanimously agree that it's their most disappointing game.

Fallout 4 was actually pretty good in a lot of regards, but the one major thing it lacked in was RPG gameplay, which is what the series was founded upon and most loved for. Gone were perks and in was base-building.

Change isn't a bad thing in most games, but it went too far with Fallout 4. It didn't feel like a natural evolution of the formula, and instead felt like a different game altogether. Combat was arguably the only thing that was improved, and that wasn't what people were looking for in a Fallout game.

Critics didn't see it the same way. Fallout 4 was considered as one of the best games in that year, which is is a massive overstatement. Fallout 4 is a good game, but it's made nowhere near the impact it could, and should, have.

--

What game do you think the critics got wrong? Let us know in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Jumping through portals, swinging through cities, destroying beings made of darkness and occasionally shooting a gun or two. I also write about games.