10 Video Game Collector's Editions That Were Total Rip-Offs

CDPR are beloved, but Collector's Edition Geralt looked like chewing gum.

The Witcher 3
CD Projekt RED

There is no better way to say "I love this game" than buying the most expensive version; filling your shelves with statues, artbooks and trinkets. Truly, we've all at least considered buying one of these luxurious testaments to gaming.

Usually, a collector's edition will have a small fee attached, but will then offer a variety of different goods alongside the base game, such as a statue of the main character, a steelbook, artbook etc.

Although this may seem a little generic, these collector's editions are the ones that people tend to enjoy, as they give the customer exactly what they want: Something to collect. In fact, some of the best collector's editions follow these rules to a T, upping the ante in regards to overall quality.

But we're not here to talk about those ones.

Despite generally being known for consistency, there are some cases where the whole concept of value was thrown out the window, leaving customers feeling ripped off.

Whether it be missing content, badly painted statues or just being completely lied to in advertising, sometimes collector's editions are more hassle than they're worth.

10. Metal Gear Solid V - Collectors Edition

MGS V Premium Package
Konami

The thing that really enticed people about this was the replica of Venom Snake's arm. The final product though, was nothing to cheer about.

In the initial advertising for this collectors edition it said that the Venom Snake replica arm would be a 'half-scale' replica. Venom Snake must have tiny hands then, because what we got was miniscule.

Look, no-one was expecting the replica to be full-size, but it ends up looking like a cheap McDonald's toy and that's a real shame. Rather than being a bad collectors edition, this one is just disappointing because it could have been so much more.

For $100, this is probably one of the least expensive collectors editions on the list, but the pure disappointment of the size and feel of that arm is a feeling that money can't really measure.

Combine all of this with the fact that many people had problems with the DLC and you've got a pretty disappointing package overall.


9. Wolfenstein: The New Order - Panzerhund Edition

Wolfenstein Panzerhund
Bethesda

This was one of the first notable examples of a collectors edition that didn't include the game, but even overlooking that this is a pretty poor showing.

For $100 you get a metal box, a steelbook, a journal and a tiny statue of one of the game's enemies - the titular Panzerhund. Notably, the Panzerhund edition of Wolfenstein: The New Order doesn't include a copy of the actual game, which means you'd also have to pay an additional $50.

The biggest sin this collectors edition commits is that it started a trend of publishers offering them as a separate product, in an effort to suck as much money out of fans as possible.

It could be made a little less painful if the main Panzerhund statue was worth the cash, but it's absolutely laughable. The 'statue' looks like a Kinder egg toy, and is about the same size.

At least Bethesda really stepped their game up with Wolfenstein 2's collector's edition.


8. Batman Arkham Asylum - Batarang Edition

Batman Arkham Asylum Collectors Edition
Rocksteady

The Batman Arkham games have had some pretty interesting collectors editions, but this was a pretty poor start.

As is the case with a lot of these collectors editions, the idea for this one is actually pretty great. This collectors edition advertised that you could own your very own Batarang, as well as a bunch of the usual limited edition stuff.

So what was the big problem then? As it turns out, the Batarang was attached to a cheap plastic stand that meant it couldn't be moved at all. The only reason anyone would really want to own a Batarang is to be able to mess around with it, or even to just be able to hold it.

Even for those few that just wanted to keep the Batarang on display, the thing itself looked pretty cheap and nothing like it was advertised to be.

Consider that this whole package was $100 and holy rip-off Batman!


7. Halo 3 - Legendary Edition

Halo 3 Collectors Edition
Microsoft

If you were told that the Legendary Edition of Halo 3 would include a replica of Master Chief's helmet, you'd assume it was wearable, right? About that...

This is the big problem with the Legendary Edition. As cool as having a replica of the famous helmet is, the fact that it can't be worn is just a massive disappointment. All you have to do is look online, and you'll see plenty of people who were burned by this one.

The Legendary Edition also had a much bigger problem because it also offered a metal steelbook that inadvertently wrecked many customer's game disks. The thing was so loose that disks often just fell out and scratched against the metal case, which is ridiculously bad planning on Microsoft's part.

When you consider that this was back in 2007, charging $130 for this is actually pretty expensive, especially when compared to other collectors editions of the time.

Halo fans would probably argue against this one, but there's just no excuse for broken disks and a useless helmet.


6. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Collector's Box

Red Dead 2 Collectors Box
Rockstar Games

Considering Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't even out yet, this is a preemptive entry but it's been made pretty clear that this won't be worth it.

This one retails for $100, which doesn't sound too bad, but it doesn't actually include the game. This is a rather annoying trend in collectors editions at the moment, as it requires you to make separate purchases if you want to get everything.

Besides that, this collector's box seems to be made up of absolute tat. Unless you really want a hat, a coin, some playing cards and a useless steel box then you can absolutely avoid this one.

Rockstar's collectors editions are never too great in the first place (more on that later), but this is really taking the cake.

Even ignoring this collector's box, Rockstar have been taking the mick with Red Dead Redemption 2's special editions, as it costs $100 before you can get a bloody steelbook with the game.


5. Fallout 4 - Pip Boy Edition

Pip Boy Edition
Bethesda

When the Fallout 4- Pip Boy Edition was announced at E3, it was met with crowds of thunderous applause. If only they knew.

Having your own Pip-Boy is the dream of many a Fallout fan, and the fact that Bethesda would be releasing one alongside the next Fallout game made it all the sweeter. Packaging made it look like a pretty hefty collectible, perhaps made out of a sturdy material.

In addition to this, the Pip-Boy would even be compatible with the game itself through a phone app, meaning that it wasn't just something to display.

The real Pip-Boy edition though? Completely plastic, and completely pointless.

Fallout 4's Pip-Boy edition retailed for about $100, which meant you were paying half of that just for the replica itself. Why then, did it have the quality of a cheap plastic toy? Why doesn't it have any cool functionality?

This could have been a dream come true for Fallout fans but it ended up being a huge wasted opportunity. Maybe next time eh?


4. Grand Theft Auto V - Collectors Edition

GTA V Collectors Edition
Rockstar Games

Rockstar has a habit of getting away with making their collectors edition as expensive as possible whilst including nothing of note.

Grand Theft Auto V had a particularly egregious collectors edition which included a map, a baseball cap, a steelbook and a lock bag. All of this pretty meaningless stuff retailed for $150, which is absolutely nuts.

The most interesting thing out of the whole thing was the baseball cap, and even that was pretty plain in the grand scheme of things. The blueprint map was only cool with a blacklight, and the security deposit bag was just pretty pointless.

Considering Rockstar could very easily take all of this junk out and put in a cool character statue, it's a shame that people keep getting excited for this stuff.

The trick here is that the hype for each of Rockstar's releases mean that people will eat up whatever they put out without anyone batting an eyelid.

At least the game was good.


3. The Witcher 3 - Collectors Edition

Witcher 3 Statue
CD Projekt Red

Execution is everything.

By all accounts, the Witcher 3 Collectors Edition should have been one of the coolest of this generation, with an artbook, steelbook, Witcher medallion and an awesome statue to top it all off.

The statue is where things started to go wrong.

Despite being shown off as highly detailed and well painted, the final product showed a Geralt who more often than not looked like some sort of cheap Hollywood monster.

Geralt's mug is the main problem of this statue, as in most cases the paint job was completely messed up. The end result is pretty haunting, but it's not like the rest of the statue lived up to expectations either.

This wasn't a cheap collectors edition either, going for about $200 when The Witcher 3 released, with the size of the statue making this quite an expensive one.

Imagine putting down that much money to end up with a pretty ugly end product. What a shame.


2. Saints Row 4 - Wad Wad Edition

Saints Row Wad Wad
Deep Silver

Think $150 for a statue is a rip-off? Try $100,000.

The aptly named 'Wad Wad Edition' claims to have a million dollars worth of content, with some of the prizes being offered including a trip to space, a full size Dub-Step Gun replica and spy training.

Sounds good right? Certainly worth $100,000, and definitely not, say, $630,00?

Besides being an extravagant waste of money anyway, that was truly the big kicker for this collectors edition- you were basically throwing away $370,00 just for the sake of it. It's not like Saints Row 4 was a particularly outstanding game anyway, so why all this grandiose nature?

Deep Silver recently tried something like this again with Dying Light, but the 'My Apocalypse' edition was only £250,00 and wasn't nearly as much of a rip-off.

Obviously no-one ended up buying the 'Wad-Wad' edition of Saints Row 4, which does soften the blow a bit, but the idea that it was ever even considered for purchase really is just taking the mick.


1. Marvel Vs. Capcom: Infinite - Collector's Edition

Marvel Vs Capcom Infinite Collector S Edition
Capcom/Marvel

Marvel vs. Capcom Infinite was enough of a disappointment without having one of the worst collectors editions of all time.

This collectors edition retailed for $200 and was advertised as coming with four character statues and a neat box with the Infinity Stones inside. Throw in the season pass and you've got a good, if fairly standard, collectors edition.

The statues of Mega Man, Captain Marvel, Iron Man and Chun Li are actually pretty cool too, even if they aren't anything amazing. Definitely not worth $200, but they aren't the main problem with this collectors edition.

The real issue comes when you get to the Infinity Stones which, instead of looking like some of the most powerful artifacts in the universe, look like cheap plastic Easter eggs.

No, really.

How Capcom thought this was worth the money is beyond anyone, but the Infinity Stones are truly embarassing. Not that you would want to anyway, but you can't even take them out of their big plastic case.

This wouldn't even be worth it at $100.

--

Do you own any of these collectors editions? Let us know in the comments below!


In this post: 
Halo 3
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jumping through portals, swinging through cities, destroying beings made of darkness and occasionally shooting a gun or two. I also write about games.