10 Video Games That Were Great At First (But We Quickly Lost Interest)

The games that were awesome for a day or two, but then starting collecting dust on your shelf.

The term 'pile of shame' is used to describe the list of games you've bought and started but never finished. For some people who are conservative with their money and time, it might just be a couple of titles they haven't got round to completing yet. For others who are a bit more frivolous with their cash, it could be hundreds and hundreds of games left unfinished, or even, despicably, left in their shrink wrap. Part of that pile of shame could be a game that you anticipated for months on end; a game you watched every trailer for and read every scrap of information you could find, just to make the wait more bearable. Then, when it finally arrived, you played for two days solid before throwing it back on the shelf and never looking at it again. Don't worry, we've all done it. It might be a fundamental problem with that particular game (or maybe we were just expecting too much?) that stopped our full enjoyment, but it happens more often than you might think. Here is a list of games that we played and initially thought were great, before we eventually lost interest and hardly returned to. We keep promising ourselves we'll come back to it eventually, but we really, really lack the motivation to return.

10. Minecraft

Is there a single person in this world that hasn't played Minecraft in some form by now? Mojang's indie smash-hit is becoming available on more and more platforms, making millions and millions wherever it goes. You've no doubt seen the impressive worlds created by users €“ replicating everything from Skyrim to Game of Thrones €“ and wanted to try your hand at it. Then you'll realise how much work and dedication it takes to create something that expansive and give up pretty quickly. Sound familiar? Yeah, thought so. The great thing about Minecraft is that it inspires creativity, but it really does take patience and dedication to create something worth bragging about, especially if you aren't using Creative Mode to build your visions. The frequent updates to the game offer a whole range of new content to explore and use but nothing will match that initial spark of discovery from the early days of Minecraft; in fact, gameplay updates like hunger have made the game more tedious to play, especially if you want to just drop in and have a crack at Survival Mode. Minecraft is still massively popular and will no doubt continue to grow but we wish our ambitions and determination matched its creative potential.

9. The Latest Street Fighter Title

Competition is one of the reasons that video games are so successful, and nothing inspires that competitive nature in us more than a fighting game. Of course, the most successful fighting series is Street Fighter; an Arcade classic which is now over twenty-five years old. Impressive. Equally as impressive though is how Capcom have managed to turn the series into a major cash cow with very few updates or changes. Take Street Fighter IV for example, the latest instalment in the franchise. Capcom are currently preparing the fourth version of the title, with each different edition adding more characters and various gameplay balances. The fact tStreet Fighter IV was released in 2008 and is still being improved is impressive; without the fighting game community, it probably wouldn't happen. Let's be honest though, all these updates and 'Ultra' editions are for that core community €“ the added bells and whistles gives them hundreds of hours' worth of content to learn and play with. But for the average gamer, the lifespan of a new Street Fighter title is considerably shorter. You'll pick up the new edition (it'll be priced pretty reasonably, at least until you the price of every version you've brought together), go through the Arcade Mode a couple of times with your favourite characters (Ryu and Ken, let's face it) and then you'll venture online. You'll suffer a perfect loss to some randomer from Korea and you'll swear never to touch the series again, aghast at the level you'll have to reach to even land a punch. Then the next update will be announced and you'll be suckered in all over again €“ it's a cycle and you're a part of it now. Sorry.

8. Grand Theft Auto V (Online)

Grand Theft Auto V was rightly acclaimed as one of the best games of 2013 €“ it's a non-stop thrill ride. As good as the single player story was though, a lot of the game's hype was built around Rockstar's latest venture into the online world. While games like GTAIV and Red Dead Redemption offered the chance to roam Rockstar's virtual worlds with friends, GTAV promised so much more, like the opportunity to own property and influence a living, breathing Los Santos. People were undeniably excited for GTA Online's launch; so much so that an overwhelming number of people tried to access it when it finally went live, crashing the game and bringing it to a standstill for millions. These connection issues lasted for ages with people unable to connect to their friends for weeks after the initial launch, causing Rockstar to issue apology after apology and issue in-game cash to appease the fanbase. Launch issues aside, there's a lot of fun to be had in GTA Online. However, it's also highly repetitive. There's a variety of game modes to play with but they don't feel like a unique experience anymore €“ it's fairly standard multiplayer fare. Rockstar overpromised with this one massively and many won't return to the game until user-created content is featured more heavily or developer ideas like heists are implemented as promised pre-launch. It's a shame because Los Santos is a place we love to spend time in €“ Rockstar just needs to give us the incentive to return to its sunny shores.

7. Dead Rising 3

After all the pre-launch fury over the Xbox One's various policies (later ditched in damage control measures for Microsoft), the launch of the console went by pretty smoothly. Every console lacks must-play titles at launch but the Xbox One could boast the return of a genuine classic from the Xbox 360 days - Dead Rising. Back as an exclusive to Microsoft's console, Dead Rising 3 is one of the better games released on next-gen consoles so far. However, it's also very formulaic when compared to the previous titles in the series (the story and scenario is almost identical in every Dead Rising game, despite the differing settings) and while having thousands of zombies on screen at once makes for a great spectacle, it also makes getting around a chore, especially with vehicles now being slowed when moving through the hordes. Every time we load up Dead Rising 3, we seem to follow a short routine €“ load up with weapons and food; head to the next mission objective; get bored while finishing that mission (which usually involves driving all over the place); finish the mission and quit the game. It's a shame because it's a genuinely fun game €“ you just have to be prepared for a lot of tedious running around.

6. Payday 2

The influence of Left 4 Dead on Payday 2 is clear. To up the replay value, both games use artificial intelligence to spawn items and enemies at random, as well as changing the placement and availability of some key objectives to make a more dynamic experience. This means you could play the same map several times in a row and have a different experience each time, even though the map itself doesn't physically change or alter. Left 4 Dead rode this to big success €“ with the random enemy spawns being much more surprising, there was a sense of dread in not knowing what was round the corner. With Payday 2, it's a lot less successful. The game lacks unique enemies like Left 4 Dead and so replaying a map feels very similar with next to no changes made. A vault door may have moved to a different wall or there may be another security feature added which you need to take note of, but that's about it. To begin with, and especially with the longer campaigns like Rats where you're tasked to create crystal meth for sale, the game feels fresh and exciting. Gradually though, you'll become more aware of the grind necessary to progress through the levels and the tedium will start to set in. A little more variety in maps or enemies (or a wider selection of longer campaigns) might have drawn our attention more. Sadly, it's just going to sit there on our shelves as a game that didn't quite live up to its potential.

5. Any American Sports Game

American football, baseball, basketball... you've no doubt tried to become interested in at least one of these sports in the past. Watching on TV can be great fun, but they say there's no better way to learn a sport than to play it. Of course, nobody goes outside anymore, so we turn to virtual sports in order to help us enjoy the same pastimes as our American friends. Basketball is a great example of this; you've no doubt seen LeBron do his thing on the court and felt you could replicate that (well, in video games anyway). As the premier basketball video game, 2K's NBA series would be your go-to game but you'll quickly realise you're actually no good at it. Any attempt to take the ball off the opponent will result in a 'reach-in foul' and you'll watch in horror as they score slam dunks like they're going out of style. Playing Madden will see you run offside constantly while wondering what the hell a 'QB Read' is, before your computer opponent scores an 80 yard touchdown because you were setup in a Field Goal Block formation. We're not even going to discuss the complexities of the sport of baseball €“ it could take years. So your brand new American sports game will be banished to the shelf in frustration. That's what you get for trying to broaden your horizons €“ it seemed like such a great idea at the time.

4. Pokemon X & Y

You old-timers out there might not understand the appeal of Pokemon (and probably never will) but for those of us who grew up with characters like Ash and Pikachu, it will always hold a massive place in our nostalgic hearts. Pokemon X & Y are the first games in the series to be released on the Nintendo 3DS and feature massively updated graphics with an overhaul in the gameplay, such as the ability to walk diagonally (revolutionary, I know). You'll blast through your first couple of hours, enjoying the nice new visuals, before a horrifying realisation €“ you've outgrown Pokemon. In the past, Gotta Catch 'Em All was your tribal cry but now it feels like an unbelievable chore. Perhaps the games are easier now or perhaps we're just far better gamers now (yeah, right) but the challenge is sorely missing. People practically hand you the Pokemon you need to defeat the local Gym Leader and your rivals are too busy making cute faces to be a real threat to your dominance. With a Ruby and Sapphire remake no doubt arriving soon, we're still refusing to let Pokemon leave our lives completely. Whether we'll be able to give it the attention it deserves though is another question entirely.

3. Final Fantasy XIII

Final Fantasy was probably an introduction to the role-playing genre for a lot of people; that's why FF6 and FF7 are held in such high esteem by fans. It's not a series that has aged well though (Final Fantasy XI being an MMO really killed the momentum of the series for me) with recent instalments dividing the fanbase more than ever before. Some people really enjoyed FFXIII while others despised everything about it; the gameplay, the characters and the story. The game itself is beautiful and starts off exciting enough but quickly becomes a linear trial of a game; testing you to see whether you're worthy of getting to the 'good' part of the game with a series of corridors and long cut-scenes. The 'good' part of the game comes several hours in when you arrive on the world of Gran Pulse; this is where it finally opens up and allows for some exploration. The slog to get to that point is demoralising though, with no option to change your party due to everyone being split up for story purposes. Even the Battle system in this game has an 'Auto-Battle' feature if you're feeling particularly lazy, automatically making your characters use abilities and attacks that best suit the weakness of the enemies. It seems bizarre that Square Enix would choose this title as the basis for the series' first trilogy but perhaps its best they don't tamper with the classics. Final Fantasy XV looks set to experiment with gameplay elements even more, so don't be expecting a 'classic' Final Fantasy experience for quite some time yet.

2. Resident Evil 6

As we've already seen with Street Fighter, Capcom knows how to cash in on a series' nostalgic value. Resident Evil 6 is a great example of this. Resi 5 made dramatic changes to the series' foundation (adding a notoriously stupid co-op partner for example) but was still an enjoyable game, even if it wasn't particularly scary anymore. Resident Evil 6 is just an abomination though. It starts off so well. Leon's campaign (protagonist of Resident Evil 2 and 4, widely renowned as the best in the series and featuring a terrific, immovable haircut) retains the survival horror elements of the franchise well, with actual zombies, little ammo and atmospheric locations. It does eventually end with you fighting a giant zombie dinosaur but that's almost acceptable when compared to the other campaigns on offer. Chris' campaign is a bad Gears of War knock-off and newbie Jake's campaign isn't much better (you just care a lot less because you don't really know who he is). Both see you sprinting from boring gun-fight to boring gun-fight with little interest in the story or what's happening. You probably won't even make it far enough to unlock the secret fourth campaign (starring the mysterious Ada Wong), so perhaps that's why Capcom made it available from the start with a post-launch patch. Definitely a series in need of a major rethink.

1. Call of Duty: Ghosts

It's one of the biggest franchises in entertainment history, so why are we getting so bored of Call of Duty? We see a new Call of Duty title release every single year, bringing a new campaign and a new set of multiplayer maps but very little advancement. Call of Duty: Ghosts is a great example of this €“ blasting through the campaign may only take a few hours but it's an entertaining experience (though not a particularly deep one). It offers very little replay value though and the once daunting Veteran mode seems to get easier and easier every year. Extinction is Infinity Ward's answer to the success of Treyarch's Zombies mode and it'll keep you busy for a couple of hours but again, it's not a lengthy experience. Then there's the multiplayer; the jewel in Call of Duty's crown. It's undeniably fun, especially with friends, but it lacks that addictive quality that kept us coming back for more with earlier games. Maybe the novelty has worn off and we're just looking for something fresher, and gameplay 'innovations' like peering around a wall just won't do it. Call of Duty still makes a ton of money though, so we're unlikely to see any groundbreaking changes anytime soon €“ and hey, Ghosts may just be a blip on the series' record. Without changes to future titles though, more and more people may turn their backs on a franchise that revolutionised online shooters. Some people might revel in that but we want to see a Call of Duty that's earned its place at the top of the online charts. So let's have a bit of a name and shame session - what games have you started but never got around to finishing? Was it because they were disappointingly bad or did something else grab your attention instead? Share your Pile of Shame with the world below.

Contributor
Contributor

I have an addiction to achievements, a craving for new bands and a dream to become Captain America. I once finished second in a Mario Kart 7 tournament so I'm kind of a big deal.