10 Video Games That Punish You For Making The Ethical Choice

Friend crying out for help? RUN AWAY.

Not too long ago you might have spotted a list on WhatCulture hosted by the lovely Jules that focused on video games that punished you for being a bad dude. Well, sometimes video games punish you for being a good guy, too. They sure do keep us guessing.

In this list we’re tucking into the video games that let you choose what seemed to be a no-brainer good moral choice only to pull the rug out from under you and punish you for it.

Whether the game offered you a choice and it turned out the unethical option was less damaging, or you were pushed into a corner where the ethical choice was clear but would cause you a crazy amount of trauma, there was nothing easy about these dilemmas.

--

Note: Spoilers for A Plague Tale: Requiem in final entry.

--

10. Vampyr

Vampyr game
Dontnod Entertainment

Don’t Nod released action role-playing game Vampyr in 2018 where, and this should come as no surprise, you play as a vampire.

Of course, being a vampire, you’re met with an ethical conundrum right off the bat, and Vampyr lets you choose if you want to be a bad guy or a good guy. You don’t have to kill innocents but not doing so leaves you pretty much incapable of levelling up.

If you aren’t consuming human blood and killing civilians you’ll miss out on vital experience points, vampiric powers, and both active and passive skills, making combat much more difficult. It’s also a hell of a lot of fun to become an uber-powerful vampire via the means of being unethical, so that’s another punishment in and of itself.

On the upside, you’ll have an easier time maintaining Reid’s cover as a doctor if you aren’t running around town doing murders, but on the downside... pretty much everything else.


9. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

witcher 3 finding ciri
CD Projekt RED

There are a lot of choices you can make in The Witcher 3 which seem like the right thing to do and then end up being the super wrong thing to do. This happens over and over again but surely the most brutal of these situations concerns the ultimate fate of your ward, Ciri. You spend a huge portion of the game looking for her and then when you do the game is running a set of checks in the background to see how you treat her which actually has life or death consequences.

The kicker here is that in order to keep Ciri alive you actually need to let her go off and do her own thing and not be overprotective by keeping her under Geralt’s wing. Which is pretty hard because you will feel very protective of her.

If you try to solve all her problems for her, protect her from The Emperor by encouraging her not to go, or treating her too much like a child by insisting you’ll accompany her wherever she goes, she actually won’t feel capable during the final battle. These are little decisions you’d be making the whole game, which might feel like the right thing to do because she’s been through so much and you can finally help, but they will actually lead to her death.

And there’s nothing quite like a 150 hour game ending in the death of a beloved character as a punishment for being too nice.


8. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic II

star wars knights of the old republic
Obsidian

Often when we talk about being a good guy or a bad guy in video games the obvious references are Mass Effect’s paragon and renegade options, and Star Wars’ light side and dark side. It stands to reason, then, that being an ethical goodie-two-shoes in Star Wars is just a matter of aiding the downtrodden, being nice to everybody, and giving to the poor.

Not so in the case of Knights of the Old Republic II where murder granny Kreia gives you a talking to on the dangers of blind altruism.

A refugee in Nar Shadaa asks for a few credits and you do so because it’s only five credits, after all.

Immediately Kreia tells you giving him what he’s not earned is like pouring sand into his hands and a scene plays out where the very same refugee is beaten and robbed due to having the money you just gave him. She concludes with, “Be careful of charity and kindness, lest you do more harm with open hands than with a clenched fist.”

Kreia also spends the whole game having a go at you and you’ll lose influence with her for undue charity so if you want to be a good guy, I hope you like lectures.


7. Until Dawn

until dawn ashley death
Supermassive Games

Until Dawn is a game where you can get everybody killed so it’s fair enough you’d want to stay on your toes and perhaps question whether the ethical choice is the right one. Now, it might not be the right choice to follow the voice of your friend crying out for help down a creepy dark tunnel but she is doing a lot of crying out for you so it’s certainly the ethical thing to do.

If you’ve already read the passage saying the game’s evil Wendigo monsters can imitate voices and seen the Loss totem that clearly shows Ashley getting her head ripped off, this would be an extra silly thing to do, but there’s a chance your friend needs you so, off you go.

Being the ethical bastion of good I know you are, you’ll venture down that sinister hallway just in case it turns out your friend is in fact, in danger. She isn’t, and you’re now dead, but I respect you for trying.


6. Frostpunk

frostpunk game
11 Bit Studios

These next two games are actually both made by the same developer, 11 Bit Studios, so when it comes to ensuring you have to stay in the ethical grey realm to succeed lest you be punished, they’re kind of the experts.

Frostpunk is a 2018 survival game where you’ll need to make some brutal choices to ensure you keep your city functioning and keep your people alive.

Given this is a cutthroat strategy game where climate change has pushed humanity to its limits, trying to make all of the ethical choices will run your city into the ground very quickly. The stakes and challenges are incredibly high and keeping your citizens fed, warm, and content is a constant battle. On top of that, you’re called on to establish laws as the leader of the city and some of these really go places.

For example, you can build a cemetery which is a good and ethical thing to do, but burials will take time away from your workers' already limited daytime work hours. You can also make a law that signs off on child labour, adding to the number of people working in the city, but obviously not being an ethical choice at all. If that wasn’t hard enough, you’re met with personal requests where meeting someone’s individual needs might hurt everyone else.

You’ll have a far easier path through the game being a tyrant, but sleeping at night might be tricky.


5. This War Of Mine

This War of Mine old couple
11 Bit Studios

There’s a Papers Please sort of game genre that seems to want to make you sad, and This War of Mine absolutely belongs in the same bucket.

This War of Mine is a strategy survival game where you’ll have to make difficult choices for a group of civilians hiding out in a fictional city under siege. You’ll need to maintain the group’s health, hunger, and mood and deal with encounters with other NPC survivors. This is where things get tricky. Well, trickier. Outsiders will ask for food and medicine and it’s up to you to help them if you want, or you can rob or kill them. Of course, the ethical thing would be to help your fellow man but giving away your extremely scarce supplies is going to make things incredibly difficult for you in game and for the survivability of your group.

If for some reason this doesn’t sound like a painful ethical nightmare already, you can always grab The Little Ones DLC.

This expansion adds a child survivor who can’t help the shelter initially or defend themselves but needs constant attention, is prone to depression, and needs to be taught to help out with various chores over time. It’s a losing battle trying to keep everyone safe and happy the entire time, but making the ethical choices in this instance will often make things far more dire.


4. Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey

assassins creed odyssey plague family
Ubisoft

When Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey was set up as the first game in the series to allow you to make meaningful decisions, Ubisoft didn’t do things by half measures.

They also seemed to have a pretty fun time trolling you as one of the earliest decisions where a no-brainer good guy move seems to be the right call actually results in devastating consequences. The Blood Fever quest kicks off very early when you’re still on Kephalonia.

You encounter a plague ridden family including small children and you either defend them from those intent on killing them to stop the spread or allow them to be executed. Now, to be fair, this is an ethical conundrum. Leaving the family alive could put others at risk of catching the virus, but murdering them in cold blood seems inexcusably wrong.

If you make the kinder choice in the interim and spare the family their violent fate, you actually end up dooming the entire island.

If you do make the trip back later you’ll find the entire place has been ravaged by the plague, so, that’s a bit of an oops on your part.


3. Tyranny

tyranny game
Obsidian

Tyranny is an RPG from Obsidian Entertainment that came out in 2016 and it makes a very strong case for the Game Most Likely To Screw You Over For Trying To Be Nice.

Or for the purposes of our list, punish you for making the ethical choice. As the name implies, this is not a game about being nice. You’re literally working for an evil empire and trying to maintain control over the people you’ve conquered the best way you know how.

Your choices here range from Lawful Evil to Chaotic Neutral, but you’ll be erring closer to doing what's best for you and your superiors, rather than just going around handing out money and picking all the blue options. You can support your tyrannical leader, be a different kind of evil, or decide you only care about yourself, but not leaning into one of the more evil routes is going to be more difficult and, honestly, less fun.

If you start feeling too bad you can always pull the ‘Hey man, I just work here’ logic.

So what are you waiting for? Go on over to that dark side.


2. Bloodborne

bloodborne suspicious beggar
FromSoftware

It shouldn’t come as a great surprise that Bloodborne is a brutal game with a brutal game world that offers up brutal outcomes for any choice you make, including the ethical ones, but just in case it does, consider yourself warned.

If you try to save all of the friendly NPCs you meet out and about in the nasty game world, you’ll get them all killed. It doesn’t matter if you send them all to Ioesefka’s Clinic or to the Chapel, you’ll more than likely lead most of them to their untimely deaths. The caveat to this is if you send the Suspicious Beggar from the Forbidden Woods to Ioesefka’s Clinic.

Do this and you’ll still get the guy killed but since he’s a cannibal you won’t let him loose on the rest of your townies. Send anybody to the clinic and Ioesefka will experiment on them and kill them horribly, send the Beggar to the Chapel and he’ll systematically kill off everybody there. Also horribly.

To be fair, though, when you meet the guy he is munching on a kid’s corpse, so, this one is sort of on you.


1. A Plague Tale: Requiem

a plague tale requiem
Asobo Studio

ENORMOUS SPOILER WARNING.

I’m about to tell you what happens at the very end of A Plague Tale: Requiem, so if you haven’t reached the end of the sequel, leave now and I won’t be offended. Okay?

Alright let’s dig into this real crappy ethical choice.

--

A Plague Tale: Requiem is the hotly anticipated 2022 follow up to the critically acclaimed A Plague Tale: Innocence and it ends on a hell of a note. After spending two games doing your best to stave off the Macula infection from overwhelming Amicia’s little brother Hugo an extremely unexpected thing happens and it turns out you’re simply too late.

Believing his sister to be dead, tiny little Hugo gives himself over to the aggressive genetic condition, becoming entirely possessed by it. You’re left with a couple of options and both of them are bad. You can walk away from the shell of your little brother, now entirely merged with Macula, dooming the world to be destroyed by rats. Or you can kill him with your sling, which is the ethical choice. And one of the worst things a video game has asked me to do in 2022 and probably ever.

If that’s not a punishment, I don’t know what is.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Until Dawn
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.