12 Ways Bethesda Should Have Made Fallout 4

Many months later, does it still hold up?

fallout 4
Bethesda

Some games split rooms by their very mention, yet up until Fallout 4, Bethesda's post-apocalyptic series wasn't one of them. Both Fallout 3 and Obsidian's New Vegas went down very well indeed, and despite being processor-straining affairs with more than a fewbugs and glitches, still amassed audiencesinthe tens of thousands.

It proved that Bethesda's signature brand of RPG game design - formerly seen in their landmark Elder Scrolls titles - can hop across genres and breathe life into something else entirely, yet seven years later when they tried to do it again... we sawa bit of a mixed reaction.

Not from critics, mind you. Critically, Fallout 4 was Game of the Year across the board - aside from here, where I appointed The Witcher 3 the top spot - as instead, it was only the outlier who pointed at things like its antiquated presentation, lack of new features outside base-building and the overwhelmingly 'last-gen' feel of it all.

Now, Fallout 4 is still one hell of an achievement in pure game design, but there are a number of issues I think will always prevent it from being remembered as fondly as its predecessors. Many, that should've been done far better...

12. Fix The Prologue Pacing And Introduction To The World

fallout 4
Bethesda

There are a few instances with Fallout's narrative presentationthat right from the get go, put me on the back foot. The entire prologue from before the blast feels rushed, going from hanging out with your partner to answering the door mentioning a new Vault-tec shelter, to the bombs dropping just as it's been discussed and walking out into the post-apocalypse a few moments later.

The scene where your partner is killed gets an appropriately passionate reaction, but following that, it's a very quick "I'll avenge you and find our son" line, before you're blasting radroaches and toddling off to do side-missions. Being that your infant son is somewhere in the world, all alone (or so you think), there's a distinct lack of drive behind your actions - especially in how little you're freaked out by, or worried about.

Super Mutants? Not a problem. Radroaches, humanity being decimated, your own house being a pile of bricks? Nope, not a thing.

As a way for Bethesda to fast-track everything in service of 'getting on with the game', all dialogue is very lighthearted and immediately forthright when it comes to embarking on missions. You can choose to be a bit more emotional when telling a handful of characters the details of your family - and you'll suddenly trigger a slow... very... serious... delivery... - but then you're back to being chipper again! Wahey!

It doesn't add up.

Where were the options to scream, Jack Bauer-style, "WHAT'S GOING ON?!"? Even if you had to do necessary tasks to gain peoples' trust, at no point could you grab someone by the collar and get some real answers.


11. Give Us A Visual Knockout

FALLOUT 4
Bethesda Studios

'Good graphics' are inherently subjective. You might think something like Okami looks sublime, whereas I might not care for cel-shading. Shovel Knight's pixel art aesthetic is absolutely delightful and charming by me, but to others, it's completely off-putting.

Too often we only look to the shiniest and most lifelike character models as an indicator of what graphics 'should be', and although Fallout 4 can knock you out thanks to some sublime lighting effects and world design, overall it looks decidedly last-gen.

Which is weird, because going back to Skyrim now, is an eye-opening experience. Villages are intricately crafted places that mix a creative designer's touch with a lived-in feel, showing that people have made their mark in various ways. Enemies are all distinguishable and identified through unique animations and attacks - the world itself looks hand-crafted, bespoke and inviting - it's absolutely stunning from river to mountaintop.

Granted, Fallout 4 is a post-apocalyptic wasteland (not that genre tropes should matter, impressive is impressive) but you can tell Bethesda did try to spruce up the colour palette throughout. However, in trying to present what could be a nice visual 'style' (what with its rounded faces, iconography and item aesthetics) feels like a step back.

You need only look to Metal Gear Solid V or The Witcher 3 for an indication of where the bar is on a purely graphical level, as Fallout 4 was very far from its contemporaries in this regard.


10. Less Repetitive Faction Quests

fallout 4 brotherhood of steel
Bethesda

It was a bad idea starting the game out by having you immediately meet the Minutemen, as from the second you leave the vault you're being asked to take over as leader for only the barest of reasons, catapulting you into a never-ending loop of "Go here, kill this, come back" missions, that pretty much go on forever, if you let them.

Disregarding how out of place it all feels when you're trying to fulfil the story and get your kid back (more on that later), none of the factions were especially well designed mechanically, or felt worthwhile to pursue.

The close of the game forces them together for the big finish, but when you remember just how memorable and incredibly distinct the likes of the Dark Brotherhood or College of Winterhold questlines were in past Elder Scrolls titles, there's nothing quite so impactful or worth seeking out here.


9. Make Settlements Matter

fallout 4 settlement
Bethesda

The entire idea of settlement building still feels incredibly strange, the more you look back on it. It pointed to an ideology at Bethesda HQ that the series could tap into a Minecraft-esque mentality, or one that revelled in PC modding entirely, giving you the tools to build and craft all sorts of items, weapons and biggest of all, home bases.

The issue was... well, you didn't need to. Many have argued that such an approach is entirely the point, and the reward you get from doing so is gratifying in itself, but I don't think that holds water, especially when it could've been so much more integral.

Firstly, the only 'tutorial' around, requires you repeatedly talk to Sturges to get the most basic information. The UI is terrible, and for the finer points on how to build anything impressive, we all had to go looking online.

In terms of integration, if you really dig through the menus you can find out how to set up a nice little economy of traders stockpiling items and caps for every time you return, but it's never integral to your progression, nor is it encouraged or even pointed out.


8. Story (Part 1) - Why The Focus On Kellogg?

fallout 4 kellogg
Bethesda

Why was so much time spent literally getting into the mind of Kellogg and understanding his motivations? I can't tell you, because it never matters in the long run. We find out the guy who took our son had a tough upbringing on the way to discovering where he's hiding out and... that's it.

Seriously, think about the structure of Fallout 4's narrative. You come out the vault, track down Kellogg, learn where your son is through memories, meet up with him and choose a faction. Fin. He makes up about a quarter of what you 'do' in the entire game.

Kellogg kills your partner, steals your kid and is then revealed to be this potentially sympathetic figure drawn into a life of crime because of how detached he was from society itself. Were we supposed to do something with this information? It doesn't change how your son relates to you, there's no Stockholm Syndrome-esque implication that all the time spent with Kellogg actually made the latter something of a father figure - nothing.

The most useful thing from Kellogg is his pistol, and although that could be a brilliant commentary on his arc as a character, I think that would be giving too much credit for what's actually here.


7. Story (Part 2) - Pacing & The Son Reveal

Fallout 4 Institute Spoiler
Bethesda

I've covered the intro pacing, but even if you accept that your infant son is just going to fend for themselves, you'll then dart off and indulge in other missions and exploration. Fine. But come the point where you track him down and discover he's been an old man this entire time, there are even morehours where the story changes altogether, trying to get you invested in choosing between the four factions.

Narratively, it doesn't feel right. Your goal up to this point has been to find your son, but the reveal he's the head of the Institute comes with only the barest explanation. Re-evaluating what you thought you knew about your purpose in this world - which was already poorly portrayed by your character just going along with everything - you now have to start siding with pivotal characters for the sake of an unknown, encroaching event.

The extended chunk of time after this reveal makes it feel like one elongated epilogue, but within that, multiple prompts rush to warn you of the dangers of siding with one person over the other.

You're repeatedly told "Doing this will negate this and this", but the rationale or reasoning inherent to these decisions isn't there, being the preceding tens of hours were spent finding your son. There's not even an option to unite the factions, despite you being best buds with all their leaders, culminating in a forced decision that triggers a final battle and - for some factions - another catastrophic explosion.

Your main character then has the gall to chime in with "War... war never changes". It feels crowbarred in, like Bethesda thought "Hey, if we just put this at the end, the fans will love it!" Sorry, but you need to earn that phrase if you're ultimately going to fall back on the idea of everything being a loop.

This isn't Bioshock, after all.


6. Story (Part 3) - Do Something Impactful With The Slavery Allegories

fallout 4 synth
Bethesda

What does it mean to create life? How much sentience and anthropomorphic features does a given 'thing' have to have, before we can attribute human qualities to it? And does any of that matter, if said creation isn't flesh and blood?

Such questions are bandied about in Fallout 4, as it attempts to weave in what should've been a Blade Runner-meets-slavery theme, but wraps things up a little too conveniently in the end. See, back in 1857, a truly disgusting ruling from a retrospectively despised court case (that was later overturned 11 years later) ruled that "A free negro of the African race [...] is not a "citizen" within the meaning of the Constitution of the United States."

This fundamentally wrong way of thinking is at the heart of all racial disputes, and is connoted throughout Fallout, as various characters talk about the indistinguishably humanoid synths not having the same rights as the rest of us, or generally talking in a xenophobic manner.

Whilst it would be disrespectful to compare a race to an A.I. construct, the idea of "foreign entities living among us" is a fear tactic you'll see on a nightly Fox News report. Now, for a game to even tackle these themes so subtly should be applauded, but it's all handled with the detached, Fallout-style sense of humour.

You can choose from a menu at the close of the game where you stand on the matter, no matter what, as oppose to facilitating something that only comes about based on many integral decisions or dialogue choices along the way.

The fact that segregation could be a primal/human response and not necessarily a political or social one is massive, yet only comes to the surface if you scoop it out yourself.


5. Expand The Dialogue System ("Sarcasm"?!)

fallout 4 sarcasm
Bethesda

After that weighty point, let's delve into something far more noticably divisive; the dialogue system.

Going into Fallout 4, I had no issue with voicing every response in theory (it certainly didn't harm Mass Effect), but in reality, resigning you to four options represented by the barest of words just didn't work. The most shouted-about negative is the omnipresent 'Sarcasm' response; an adjective that could be positive, negative, humorous or anything in between.

I never reliably hit this option, as there was NO way of telling what would happen.

Immediately, a fan-made PC mod was released that showed what your full sentences would be before you triggered them. A simple change, that really should've been in since the beginning.


4. Some Method Of Travel Other Than Fast Travel

fallout 4 cars vehicles
Bethesda

Bethesda have always been the king of giving you a reason not to fast-travel, instead ensuring tons of interesting things are on your way from checkpoint to checkpoint, if you'd just take the time to wander on foot.

However, the vast majority of players will see the option to get to their destination immediately and take it, every time. To meet in the middle, a method of travel that's faster than walking, but not as instant as fast-travel, would've been ideal.

Vehicles were rumoured for quite some time pre-release, and as we're seeing robots get the fleshed out DLC treatment, why are there no cobbled-together, Mad Max-style machines we can use to get across the wasteland?

Cars in many open-world games are ostensibly the norm, which is perhaps why they weren't on the table, but there's nothing saying we couldn't have some cool mech-bike or other crafted bit of kit to get around in.


3. Armour Layers & More Base Options

fallout 4 armour
Bethesda

A truly strange oversight, this. Despite the fact that armour pieces are segmented into head, chest and all four limbs, you can only place them on top of your basic Vault-tec suit, as oppose to applying them to the many other pieces of equipment you'll find.

It results in your character barely looking any different for the duration - unless you want to prioritise a cool-looking jacket over not getting mauled by a Deathclaw.

Maybe this is just a decision Bethesda wanted you to consciously make, but being that many shoulder pieces and leg braces hang 'off' your character's skin anyway, they'd clearly sit nicely over the majority of what you pick up.

Again, a mod on PC addressed this immediately, but it's something almost every other player has pondered since day one.


2. A Need To Explore

fallout 4 antibiotics
Bethesda

I'll refer to this as 'Mass Effect 3 syndrome' i.e. a narrative imperative so strong, it prevents you from exploring the rest of the game. In Bioware's trilogy-capper it was amassing a galaxy-wide army to thwart the Earth-enslaving Reapers (not exactly something that could wait), and here, the fact your own infant son was anywhere other than in plain sight.

As such, you could employ the age-old open-world rationale of "See that? You can go there" as reason to do so, but you never needed to. Crafting components could be found in everything from kettles to destroyed androids, but there was no indication that specific areas would have richer rewards, or why you'd even want to seek them out.

My entire time with Fallout 4, there was always a story-driven reason to pursue my lost son, and then, to explore his motivations and finally, to stop a faction war. Unlike The Witcher 3, where Geralt being a supernatural bounty hunter means its always worth finding new villages and monsters, your place in the world here, is not one befitting exploration.

Fallout 4 had a far more dense map than ever, with some of the most detailed settlements and outposts in Bethesda's history - they just didn't give you any reason to seek it out.


1. It Needed To Be Built From The Ground Up

fallout 4 bug glitch
Bethesda

Here's the crux of the matter. Whenever any game developer releases something buggy or broken, we jump on it. "This should've been fixed", "I can't believe they released it like this", "This has ruined the game for me", etc.

But Bethesda release a buggy game, and the fallback is "Well, they couldn't make it without these rough edges", "They're trying their best", "For Fallout to be this big and this intricate, it has to be like this."

I'm sorry, but it doesn't - or if it does, maybe the overall experience should be trimmed back until it's manageable. For one, Skyrim held together better, and that was back in 2011, then GTA V showcased a humungous world in 2013, still on the same hardware. Third, The Witcher 3 has just as many interlocking components and elements moving in unison, and its map is 10 square miles bigger.

The idea of placing faith in this nebulous, unknown assumption of what Bethesda can or can't do, reinforces the fact they could make a better game, just as much as the opposite.

It comes to something when you can use Fallout 3's hacking cheats to get through the exact same minigames in the sequel, as for me, that went on to personify Fallout 4 entirely. It felt like 'Fallout 3.5', a mostly cobbled-together execution of cool elements that completely lack cohesion as a whole, not the marked jump across generations that it should have been.

There was nothing here you could sell Fallout 4 on, than Fallout 3 or New Vegas didn't already nail, and that's the real issue.

Let us know in the comments what you'd change about Fallout 4 if you could!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.