20 Video Game NPCs You CAN'T Afford To Lose
Anyone who has lost Isobel in Baldur's Gate 3 knows how much one NPC can change the game.
There are two main ways in which players treat video game NPCs. They either love them and would give up anything for them, or they consider them to be disposable background props to do with as they please.
In a lot of games harming or even killing random NPCs is not a big deal. They're made to be your source of entertainment, no matter how questionable that entertainment might be.
However, this isn't always the case. Sometimes a random NPC's disappearance isn't as inconsequential as you might think. Their loss may not just end with a gentle slap on the wrist but a complete and utter destruction of your playthrough.
Some games include side characters that are secretly more relevant than they might seem at first glance. It can be easy to ignore their fate, but if you let them die or otherwise disappear from your game, their loss might cost you a valuable reward, or in some cases, it can even permanently ruin the main story.
If you don't want your game to change for the worse, you best keep an eye on the following NPCs. Losing them is a disaster you can't afford.
20. Survivors - No, I Am Not A Human
No, I Am Not Human is an indie horror game that takes place in a post-apocalyptic reality where sunlight has become deadly and the world is filled with mysterious “visitors” who pretend to be people.
The gameplay consists of receiving guests at your safehouse and either letting them stay at your place or turning them away. Considering that they all could turn out to be visitors and secretly kill you when they’re inside, you might wonder if there is any benefit in keeping them around.
The short answer is yes, although it’s not really because they provide any bonuses or special service. You can’t afford to turn them away because of the Pale Visitor.
The Pale Visitor is a creepy malformed man who appears at your doorstep every few nights. He always insists on making you follow him, and if you refuse, he threatens to enter your house and take you by force, but only if you live alone.
Unless you want to be snatched by the Pale Visitor and get a rather gruesome game over, you want to keep as many human survivors as possible.
They may not be useful, and some of them might turn out to be visitors in disguise, but they’re your only key to survival.
19. White Mask Varre - Elden Ring
White Mask Varre is one of the first friendly NPCs that you meet in Elden Ring, although the term “friendly” is used very liberally here.
The man does not attack you physically per se, but he does try to get you with words, calling you maidenless and being all around annoying.
Some players might feel the urge to drive their sword right through Varre the moment he opens his mouth. However, losing him will also cost you a pretty useful perk—an early entrance to Mohgwyn's Palace.
If Varre is alive, he reappears at a later point in the game and gives you a quest that grants early access to Mohgwyn's Palace, giving you an opportunity to fight Mohg, Lord of Blood, as well as giving you an excellent spot for farming lots of Runes on local mobs.
The alternative way to get to Mohgwyn's Palace is by a hidden teleporter that appears much later in the game, so doing Varre’s quest is definitely preferable.
It saves you time and nerves that you would’ve otherwise lost searching for the alternate path, plus getting to the palace early can really help you level up faster.
18. Shopkeeper - Spelunky 2
Spelunky 2, like its predecessor, is a roguelike dungeon crawler about exploring underground ruins filled with beasts, traps, and deadly monsters.
Also, shopkeepers, which, as weird as it sounds, are the most dangerous enemies in the game.
Shopkeepers appear in most levels in the game, offering a variety of useful items for sale. They are normally friendly to the player, but if you get the bright idea to kill one to get their goodies for free, their aggression goes from zero to a hundred.
After you cross your first shopkeeper, every subsequent shopkeeper will be out to get you. The clerks will start shooting you with shotguns on sight, moving erratically across the screen and stunning you with every bullet that hits you (if the bullets don't insta-kill you, that is).
Some of the shopkeepers will even set up ambushes on you at the exit doors, and if you kill more than five shopkeepers while trying to fend them off, their association will start building outposts with three to four angry merchants out to get you.
Whatever item you get for taking out a shopkeeper is just not worth the gauntlet that follows right after.
17. Buried Woman - Grand Theft Auto V
Grand Theft Auto V's open world hides dozens of unique random encounters with NPCs for the player to discover.
Most of these encounters are more about the experience than the reward, as they don't really offer anything besides a small chunk of change for completing them. This said, there is one random NPC that can secretly give you $60,000 for rescuing her.
The catch is that it can be very easy to miss her, and if you don't help her in time, your chance at earning the big bucks is gone with her, too.
Near North Point next to the Paleto Bay area, you can find two gangsters trying to bury a woman alive. Once you encounter them, you have a small amount of time to stop them (by shooting them in the face, of course) and then interact with their victim before she is killed. If you manage to make your heroic rescue in time, the girl will thank you and ask you to drive her home.
Fulfilling the request doesn't seem to do anything at first, but after a short while, the victim's family will actually send you $60,000 for stopping her captors.
Sometimes, even the hardened criminals can benefit from helping people.
16. Terry Hintz - LISA: The Painful
LISA: The Painful features thirty unique companions, but in the game's brutal fashion, all of them can permanently die if you’re not careful or make bad decisions.
Even then, some players would willingly get rid of the game’s most annoying companion given the chance—Terry Hintz, the self-proclaimed Lord of the Tutorial.
Terry is the annoying tutorial character who explains how the game works with his incredibly poor fighting skills and utterly useless hints.
After finishing the intro, you and Terry get surrounded by a group of bandits that forces you to either give them Terry as tribute or lose everything in your inventory.
Given that Terry is absolutely useless in combat and never shuts up about his “hints,” the decision might look like a no-brainer. However, if you keep Terry around, he can secretly turn from the weakest to the strongest ally in your party.
Not only does Terry eventually learn skills that regenerate his HP, but at level 25, he also obtains “The Hottest Dance,” a fire attack that deals the most amount of damage out of all companion skills in the game.
If you let go of him at his worst, you don’t deserve him at his best.
15. Ashley - Until Dawn
Until Dawn is a story-based horror game, where your choices matter a lot. Every single character in the game can die, and you obviously don’t want to lose any of them, but what the game doesn’t tell you is that some of the lives under your protection are more important than others.
Because if you deliberately lose them, like Ashley, you’ll trigger a domino effect of death.
Ashley is the timid part of the survivor group that is the secret crush of the group’s comic relief, Chris. Early in the game, Ashley and Chris are put inside a Saw-inspired trap where Chris is forced to shoot either himself or Ashley to appease their mysterious captor.
The plot twist is that the entire decision is fake, and the killer who makes Chris choose is actually his friend Josh pulling a mean and quite frankly insane prank on the couple.
Now, you’d think this is a good thing since nobody dies. However, if you decided to let go of Ashley during this scene, you lose the girl’s trust forever, and later in the game, when Chris is escaping from a Wendigo, Ashley will not open the door to safety for him, letting him get devoured.
Your selfish decision to lose one person ends up killing the one you cared about to begin with.
14. Gaius - Fire Emblem: Awakening
Fire Emblem: Awakening is a turn-based strategy game that mixes warfare with romance. Your soldier can develop relationships on the battlefield and then even end up having children together.
In most battles, you focus on keeping your teammates alive while completely decimating the enemy soldiers at every turn you get.
However, there are exceptions, one of which is Gaius.
Gaius is an enemy in the mission “Foreseer” that can be secretly turned into a companion. Although the game treats him like one of the enemy thieves who attempt to break into Emmeryn’s chamber, the man can be secretly spoken with when you approach him and interact with him.
After a quick discussion, it turns out that Gaius wants little to do with the enemy soldiers trying to kill Emmeryn, and he gladly decides to switch sides, permanently joining you as a companion (provided he survives until the end of the mission).
Given that Gaius can be the father of the possible future children that you can recruit into your army in the second half of the game, it’s best to keep your impulses in check and not immediately go for the attack button the moment you see the red outlines around his character.
13. Dwayne Forge - Grand Theft Auto IV
Dwayne Forge is a supporting character from Grand Theft Auto IV that is one of Niko's potential friends and hangout partners.
"Potential," because depending on your choices, Dwayne can meet an untimely and rather depressing demise.
Dwayne plays a central role in the mission "The Holland Play." After getting recently released from prison, Dwayne becomes the target of his old protege in the drug business, Playboy X, who tasks Niko with assassinating the man for a huge pile of money.
The cash reward is tempting, and considering that Dwayne is already kind of done with his life, having to spend a lot of it in prison after being set up by his old partners, some players will naturally take Playboy X up on his offer.
However, losing Dwayne is secretly the less profitable option.
If you spare Dwayne and instead kill Playboy X, you not only get to befriend Dwayne and be able to hang out with him, but you also get to take Playboy X's penthouse from him at the end of the mission.
Killing Dwayne, on the other hand, only nets you $25,000, so the deal really pales in comparison.
You can't put a price on friendship.
12. Kent Connolly - Fallout 4
The Silver Shroud is one of the most fun quests in the base game Fallout 4. The whole mission revolves around donning the costume of the in-universe comic book hero called the Silver Shroud and then pretending to be the masked vigilante to help a pre-war ghoul comic book nerd named Kent Connolly rid his neighborhood of crime.
Throughout the mission, your helpful but shy sidekick Kent stays inside the safety of his radio booth to help you coordinate attacks on Goodneighbor’s gangs. However, towards the end of the mission, Kent gets kidnapped by a raider leader called Sinjin, and this is where you need to make extra sure the ghoul makes it out alive.
While rescuing Kent from Sinjin’s men is incredibly difficult due to him having low health and being surrounded by hostile people that are programmed to prioritize him as the target, you want to do everything you can to keep Kent alive. This is because Kent is the only NPC in the game who can provide upgrades to the Silver Shroud’s gear.
The buffs Kent offers if he stays alive can turn the superhero costume into one of the best armors in the game, offering incredible damage resistance with relatively low weight, so you definitely don’t want to miss out on it.
11. Mercurio - Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines
Unlike its flop sequel, the original Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines is a fully fledged RPG that allows the player to make genuinely impactful choices at every stage of the game.
Sometimes, however, the full consequences of your actions don’t appear right away. In fact, one of the earliest choices you can make, saving Mercurio from death, awards you for it at the end of the game.
Mercurio is the Camarilla Prince's servant who helps you get the explosives for your first-ever mission as the newly embraced vampire fledgling. When you visit him in his apartment, the man is on the brink of death, bleeding out on a sofa after being assaulted by the gangsters who offered him the bomb.
At this point you can either ignore Mercurio and go get the bomb yourself, or you can try to help him first by giving him some painkillers.
Your act of mercy doesn’t seem to have any effects at first, but if Mercurio survives up until the end of the game, in the epilogue he will give you access to his special stock of weapons, allowing you to buy the best gear in Bloodlines.
The painkillers you give Mercurio are both for him and for the boss fights in the final act.
10. Syanna - The Witcher 3
With the new Witcher 3 remaster just around the corner and the next DLC coming out next year, some people may feel tempted to go back to the previous expansions.
If you are one of those people and want to get the most out of the story of Blood and Wine, make sure to keep an eye out for Syanna.
Syanna is the lost sister of Toussaint’s duchess, Anna Henrietta, who acts as the secret antagonist of the DLC, manipulating the vampire Detlaff to get revenge on her family.
When Detlaff discovers Syanna is using him, he demands that you send her to him so he can personally punish her. Given her crimes against Toussaint and Detlaff’s somewhat sympathetic backstory, some players might be tempted to do just that.
However, letting Detlaff kill Syanna leads to the worst possible ending to the DLC.
After Syanna is murdered, Anna Henrietta blames her death on Geralt. Despite the lost sister trying to take the duchess’ life, her death enrages her so much that Henrietta sends Geralt to prison.
To prevent this absolutely humiliating and depressing ending, make sure to give Syanna her ribbon from the fairytale land so that she can escape Detlaff’s punishment.
Otherwise, it’s off to jail with you.
9. Sandayu Oda - Cyberpunk 2077
Death is perhaps as important of a theme in Cyberpunk 2077 as its dystopian future aesthetic. Characters die tragic deaths all the time, and even the protagonist, V, has their inevitable demise looming over their head like those creepy commercials for body mods that you see on every elevator and street in Night City.
Still, some of the deaths in the game are preventable, and if you’re going for one specific ending, then you might want to be especially careful when deciding the fate of Arasaka’s cyberninja bodyguard, Sandayu Oda.
Oda appears in the mission “Play It Safe” as a boss fight at the end of V’s infiltration of Arasaka’s parade in Night City.
Although the cyberninja is ruthless, upon defeating him your partner Goro gives you the option to spare Oda, and while you might be tempted to take him out anyway, incapacitating Oda comes with a secret reward.
When you reach the end of the game and side with Hanako Arasaka, Oda will actually reappear and join you and Goro in your assault on Arasaka’s headquarters.
The extra blade can come in handy during this rather tough fight, plus having an extra ally is certainly better than making Goro sad for slaying one of his old friends.
8. Wrex - Mass Effect
Mass Effect is well known for its vibrant cast of companions, featuring aliens and humans from all walks of life. Some of these companions are more likable than others, but this doesn’t mean that you’d necessarily want to give the less charming crew members up.
Even if the game gives you the option, as it does with Wrex.
Wrex is the Krogan bounty hunter that is simultaneously one of the grumpiest and the most beloved companions in the series. He has one of the best character arcs in the whole series, turning from a solider of fortune into a battle master commanding his whole species, but the thing is, to experience this amazing development, you first need to make sure Wrex stays alive.
In Mass Effect 1, there are several ways in which you can get Wrex killed, including separate instances of Shepard or Shepard’s teammates betraying the Krogan.
Of course, it’s nice that the game gives you more choices to make, but given how important Wrex is to the Mass Effect’s lore and how he can reappear in Mass Effect 2 and 3 as a companion, one anticlimactic death isn’t really worth the hours of interactions and developing storylines you’re going to lose.
7. Little Sisters - Bioshock
Bioshock sets itself apart from other first-person shooters thanks to its unique Plasmid mechanic that allows you to unlock supernatural abilities, letting you switch between regular guns and fun bioengineered powers.
The way you obtain new Plasmid powers in-game is by finding them or purchasing them with ADAM. The way you get more ADAM is by harvesting them from Little Sisters—the creepy girls that accompany Big Daddies scattered throughout the game.
Each of the twenty-one Little Sisters in the game can be either killed and harvested or rescued. Depending on your choice, you get different rewards from them. Rescuing Little Sisters gives 80 ADAM plus a small gift for every three Little Sisters spared, while killing them is much more profitable, giving you twice as much ADAM to use however you want.
From a pure gameplay perspective, harvesting the Little Sisters is the best way to get powerful fast, but it does come with some serious consequences.
Aside from missing the unique powers you get for rescuing several Little Sisters, the ending of the game is dependent on whether or not you spared them.
If you rescued Little Sisters, they come in the epilogue to save you, and you get the good ending. If you let them die, you get the bad ending and the deep, overwhelming sense of shame.
6. The Merchant - Resident Evil 4
Resident Evil 4 is filled with psychotic mutants and freaks of all shapes and sizes. After playing for long enough, you begin to develop a habit of shooting first and wondering what you were shooting at later.
However, no matter how trigger-happy you are, make sure not to pull your gun out around the Merchant.
The Merchant is one of the few non-hostile NPCs in the game and provides the crucial service of selling ammo and buying your junk. Without the Merchant, you are forced to survive off of whatever Leon is able to scavenge in the world, probably lacking enough ammo to defeat certain bosses, so you’d think the masked stranger would be too valuable to be killable.
Well, the game does actually let you shoot him, and if you do it on Professional mode, the Merchant will permanently disappear. He will not offer his services to you anymore, meaning that just one stray bullet can potentially cost you one of the most useful mechanics in the entire game.
The Merchant might have a sinister voice and look like someone who’d stab you in the back, but he’s really the best ally you have, so don’t betray his trust.
5. Chloe - Detroit: Become Human
Detroit: Become Human is all about moral choices. As your three main characters try to find their role in the android revolution, it is up to you to guide them towards the correct path.
This may sometimes mean making sacrifices. However, if the sacrifice is killing Chloe, you’re better off completely ignoring it.
Chloe, the android who appears in the game’s main menu and acts as Kamski’s personal assistant in-game, is a character that you meet as Connor in the latter half of his storyline.
Kamski will ask you to shoot Chloe in exchange for providing the location of Jericho, the secret headquarters of the deviant resistance group that Connor is tasked with destroying.
The price may seem appropriate to the reward, especially since Chloe doesn’t really resist Kamski’s orders, but if you get tempted to shoot her, the decision will seriously damage Connor’s relationship with his partner Hank.
The penalty for killing Chloe is so severe that unless you have somehow managed to keep a perfect relationship score with Hank up until this point, the man will be guaranteed to betray later on, forcing you to either kill him or die by his hand.
Considering Connor can find Jericho without Kamski’s help, the risk is simply not worth it.
4. Mudcrab Merchant - The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind lets the player do virtually anything they want, which is a double-edged sword. On one hand, there are no restrictions to how you play, but on the other, you can often softlock yourself by killing important NPCs.
Even worse, you can accidentally kill the best merchant in the game—the talking Mudcrab.
The Mudcrab merchant is a unique NPC that looks identical to a regular mudcrab mob but can be secretly interacted with for trading.
The merchant is not only unique in that, well, he is a talking mudcrab, but also because he is the richest trader in the game, and unlike most merchants, he doesn't adjust his prices based on the items' disposition value, making him perfect for selling off all the excess junk you carry around.
Unfortunately, the Mudcrab is incredibly easy to mistake for a regular enemy, and since he isn't an essential NPC, if you accidentally kill him, he will be gone for good, along with all his massive capital for buying your loot.
It's just not worth killing him, and besides, the guy already has enough on his plate. He has a serious alcohol problem according to his dialogue, so just let him catch a break for once.
3. Three Dog - Fallout 3
Three Dog is the charismatic host of Fallout 3's Galaxy News Radio. He is one of the most beloved characters in the game thanks to his reports on the Lone Wanderer's deeds and his overall friendly personality.
Although most players know him as the incorporeal voice that plays out of their Pip-Boys, Three Dog is actually a proper NPC in the game, operating out of the GNR building plaza. This means that the player can physically visit him and have a chat in person, but it also means that, like other NPCs, Three Dog can die.
And if he does, the quality of radio broadcasts in the Capital Wasteland goes down with him.
Should the player kill Three Dog or should the host somehow die over the course of the story, his voice will disappear from the Galaxy News Radio station forever. His coworker Margaret replaces him as the new host, and the broadcast becomes significantly worse.
Unlike Three Dog, Margaret will not even try to do her job. Most of her reporting consists of complaining about Three Dog's murder, being annoyed at her job, and generally being as entertaining as drywall.
She will also not report on your current doings, so if you like your host fun and engaged with your story, make sure to keep Three Dog alive.
2. Krem - Dragon Age: Inquisition
Cremisius Aclassi, better known as Krem, is one of the most iconic characters from Dragons Age: Inquisition. He is one of the first transgender characters to ever appear in a BioWare game, serving in Iron Bull's band of mercenaries who consider him "Aqun-Athlok," which is a Qunari title for people "born as one gender but living as another."
Krem is a character most people want to protect simply due to how unique and fun he is to hang with, but if you ever needed another reason to keep him alive, the game actually gives you one.
Being second-in-command for the Iron Bull's Chargers, Krem is obviously heavily tied to Iron Bull's personal storyline. In fact, depending on your choices, Krem can die during Iron Bull's companion side quest, and this can bear serious consequences on your relationship with the Qunari warrior.
If you order the Bull's Chargers to sacrifice themselves during the assault on the Venatori, in the game's epilogue, Iron Bull will unexpectedly betray you and join forces with the hostile Ben-Hassrath, leaving your party and attacking you on the spot.
If you want to keep Iron Bull as your companion and spare yourself having to fight the epilogue with one less party member, make sure Krem doesn't die.
1. Isobel - Baldur's Gate 3
Act 2 of Baldur's Gate 3 is considered to be the best part of the story. It mixes the desperation of surviving the shadow curse with the intrigue of infiltrating two rival factions.
Or it can be just moments of desperation if you happen to lose Isobel.
Isobel is the cleric of Selune that shields the Harpers from the shadow curse inside the Last Light Inn. Isobel is important not only because she is secretly the daughter of Absolute's Chosen Ketheric Thorm, but also because her survival determines the survival of the entire Harpers faction.
If Isobel is ever killed or kidnapped by her father's forces, her protection over the Last Light Inn disappears, and all the people inside immediately turn into undead abominations, effectively cutting out huge chunks of the story and killing off dozens of important NPCs.
Even on an evil playthrough, you should try to keep Isobel alive for as long as you can, although it's easier said than done, considering the Absolute tries to kidnap her the moment you come to visit her, and if you play as the Dark Urge, you get a quest to take her life.
The girl has a death sentence on her head, even though an entire faction relies on her for survival.