20 Video Game Sequels NOBODY Defends
Don't even think about wasting your money on these terrible franchise games.
If you're a gamer, which you likely are given you're here, then you've no doubt felt that crushing feeling of franchise disappointment. Everyone has been there, grabbing the latest copy of one of their absolute favourite game series, only to be slapped in the face by a mediocre letdown.
The thing is, even some bad franchise entries have their fans, as faith in beloved IPs is often strong enough to help players overlook flaws. For example, Dark Souls 2 still has excellent PvP and atmosphere, Fable III took some big creative swings, and Fallout 76 got really fun after it was patched. You see these kinds of defences everywhere in gaming.
But what happens when a gaming sequel is so bad, so diabolical, so awful that it becomes unforgivable? Well, you can ask any of the entries on this list, as they hit that mark.
The following games were so maligned that even the biggest defenders of the series' couldn't save them. They're the games no one fights for, and are often pointed to as the absolute worst instalments in their respective franchises.
20. WWE 2K20 (2019)
Wrestling video games are a childhood staple of many. You don't even need to be a big fan of WWE or WCW to enjoy a good digital in-ring scrap. But the sad truth is that not every game is a winner, and the dreaded WWE 2K20 was definitely looking up at the lights when it rolled around.
WWE had already been delivering yearly releases for well over a decade by the time this game hit the shelves. Still, this title - the seventh instalment under the 2K Sports banner - made it clear that this unbelievable workload was taking its toll.
So, what was wrong with the game? Well, it's easier to list the things that were right with it, as it failed on almost every level. The gameplay was sluggish, the character models looked awful, and it had more bugs than an ant hill. On top of that, it was barren and lacked content, so even if it did work well, it'd still be disappointing.
There are many crappy wrestling games people forgive due to nostalgia, but this isn't one of them.
19. Zelda's Adventure (1993)
There are a fair few Legend of Zelda games that received less-than-stellar reviews from audiences and critics, but it's hard to think of any that don't have at least some supporters. The likes of Skyward Sword, Phantom Hourglass, Spirit Tracks, and more have die-hard fans who will defend them, even if they're not the most popular in Hyrule's roster. That said, there is a game that's even worse than what is often considered the lowest point in the LoZ series, and that's Zelda's Adventure.
This diabolical title was a sequel to the equally reviled Phillips CD-i games, Link: The Faces of Evil and Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon. But it earned even more ridicule, as those games were at least so bad they were good, whereas this one just sucked.
Zelda's Adventure's first notable problem was its visuals, made with live-action actors. It looked horrendously ugly, with acting that was worse than an amateur dramatics production. On top of that, its technical limitations made it troublesome to control, and meant it could barely play music. Oh, well, thank Hylia the series isn't known for its gorgeous scores then.
It's the one Zelda game that no one seems to like.
18. Shenmue III (2019)
The tale of Yue Suzuki's Shenmue III is one of tragedy, pain, and horror - and that's not a reference to the story, it's everything the players felt when booting it up. Damn, this game is dreadful.
This long-awaited sequel felt like the Holy Grail that all video games trapped in development hell hope for, finally continuing the series seventeen years after Shenmue II. Sadly, despite being gifted a golden opportunity to conclude the story, the director, Yu Suzuki, decided to use this title to set up another sequel, ending on a heart-shattering cliff hanger. Yeah, after waiting nearly two decades, that was nowhere near good enough.
Fans might have been able to overlook this if the game itself had been decent, but it wasn't. Shenmue III absolutely failed because it refused to adapt to the times. Its reliance on tedious gameplay made it crawl at a snail's pace, with the terrible writing and voice acting making the whole production feel incompetent.
The thought of what Shenmue III could/should have been was ultimately sweeter than the final product.
17. Postal III (2011)
Look, no one is going to claim that the Postal franchise is some holy relic of gaming. It's not. It's a simple, chaotic sandbox series that lets you engage with dark humour and violence, if you so choose. The games aren't even that good, but they're fun enough to have their fans.
That said, even the low standard established by the previous games was blown out of the water by the trash fire that was Postal III.
To put it plainly, this game barely worked. That's saying a lot, given the previous titles were hardly known for their technical prowess. This threequel was janky as hell and hardly even playable at times, with the threat of sudden crashes following you the whole way through. A lot of this could be attributed to the devs, Running with Scissors, outsourcing the game to a dodgy Russian company, Trashmasters (how fitting).
Even when the game wasn't broken, it was just boring. It was a generic third-person shooter with an overabundance of terrible escort missions and edgelord humour that didn't land. Most fans, and even the devs, like to pretend this one never happened.
16. Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League (2024)
There was genuinely a time when the most controversial and divisive entry in the Rocksteady Arkham series was Batman: Arkham Knight. Oh, how naïve a time that was, because this follow-up did everything it could to tarnish that legacy. The sad thing is that it pretty much did.
Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League puts you in the shoes of the titular group of villains, as they're tasked with, well, killing the Justice League. The promising premise had people excited, until they heard those dreaded words: "live-service."
Suicide Squad focused on repetitive gameplay loops, forcing you to fight enemies, grind for better gear, and do precious little else, making it a repetitive slog. To make matters worse, it made the controversial decision to (spoiler warning) have the protagonists seemingly kill off Rocksteady's Batman in shocking fashion. It is later revealed that this is a clone and not the actual Bruce, but the scene went viral for all the wrong reasons.
The best defence this game had was that it was fun to play for a little bit before the repetition kicked in. As such, it's no surprise it earned itself a spot on this list.
15. Fable: The Journey (2012)
You can say what you will about this fantasy comedy action-RPG series, but the Fable franchise really is a bright spot in gaming for many. While Fable III really didn't do well with critics or audiences, there are still plenty of gamers who enjoyed their time with it and stand up for the flawed game. However, that well of good faith definitely dried up with Fable: The Journey.
This game, the last title produced by Lionhead Studios, made the bold choice to turn the beloved RPG series into an on-rails shooter, controlled via the Xbox Kinect. Naturally, it was a clear attempt to sell the Kinect by connecting it with one of Xbox's flagship franchises, something that wasn't lost on fans.
The game was mostly fine, if a little repetitive and uninspired. But, as a Fable game, it's embarrassing to think this was the final title produced by this legendary studio. At least Fable III felt like a Fable game; this one just felt like a cheap attempt to get eyes on Microsoft's motion-control device.
14. Mortal Kombat: Special Forces (2000)
The Mortal Kombat franchise inherently invites debate. Which game is the best? Who has the coolest fatality? Who is better, Sub-Zero or Scorpion? The beauty of this gruesome fighting franchise is that everyone has different views on these questions. That said, one thing most fans can agree on is that Mortal Kombat: Special Forces is the absolute worst in the line-up.
Special Forces, which was released in 2000, moved away from the series' one-on-one fighting mechanics, instead offering up a 3D action adventure where you battle Kano and his gang as Jax. It's not a bad idea on paper, but in execution, this dish came out very underbaked.
What do you do in the game? Well, you walk around poorly designed levels, beating up enemies. That's pretty much it. It's broken, unpolished, and ultimately boring. Sadly, it's been well documented that this game suffered in development, especially after series co-creator John Tobias left the project. This goes a long way to explain why the game is so terrible, but it doesn't save it from being the worst MK game ever made.
13. Duke Nukem Forever (2011)
Duke Nukem 3D, the third game in the franchise, was released in 1996 and landed like a bombshell. It was funny, bold, brash, and bombastic, leaving many to wonder what would come next for the bubble-gum chewing, badass action star. Sadly, when Duke Nukem Forever was released in 2011, the world had moved on, but Duke Nukem himself hadn't learned that lesson.
This sequel is notorious for how much it tarnished the legacy of this boomer shooter franchise. The tedious level design and lacklustre shooting mechanics, combined with the poor graphics, shone a light on just how troubled this game's development had been. It was a poorly polished product, despite the 15-year waiting period.
On top of the generally terrible gameplay and aesthetics, Duke's signature attitude was pretty outdated in 2011 as well. His crude humour and rampant sexism felt entirely forced and like a product of a previous time. As such, the game felt old fashioned in every way imaginable, culturally and mechanically, which is why no one stands up for it.
12. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 (2015)
The legacy of Tony Hawk, the legendary skateboarder, is one that only a few can dream of achieving. His celebrity status has allowed him to plaster his name on many projects, with perhaps the most influential being the series of video games he is associated with.
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater and Tony Hawk's Underground games are an absolute nostalgic treat for many. But, as is often the case, there's got to be a stinker in the line-up. For this franchise, that is no doubt Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5.
This game landed with the grace of an amateur skater falling flat on their face after a failed rail grind. It arrived utterly unfinished, full of bugs and glitches, and with gameplay that felt unresponsive and clunky, especially when compared to the smoothness of its predecessors. It also felt barren, with dull level design, a scarce Career Mode, and a general sense of emptiness.
It was a real fall from grace, especially given that it had been over a decade since Pro Skater 4.
11. Alone In The Dark: Illumination (2015)
Alone in the Dark was once a groundbreaking series that helped pioneer the survival horror genre. Without it, the likes of Resident Evil, Silent Hill, and more might never have come to fruition. So, what was such an influential franchise, known for its Lovecraftian haunted-house settings, doing in 2015? Oh, well, it was attempting to create an online-only four-person co-op shooter.
Yes, it was as bad as it sounds.
Illumination, the sixth instalment of the franchise, was a woeful gaming experience. The mere concept, taking survival-horror exploration and action and turning it into a mindless co-op shooter, was bad enough, but the game added salt to the wound by not even doing it right. It was a dire title plagued by mindless AI, awful levels, a boatload of technical issues, and generally uninteresting gameplay.
The clear attempt to emulate the likes of Left 4 Dead showed how desperate Atari were to breathe new life into the series, which only further ruined its status. Sadly, the 2024 reboot hasn't really brought any glory back either.
10. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III (2023)
Call of Duty, the absolute monolith of the first-person shooter genre, is no stranger to hate. The long-running series has featured many entries that have grinded gamers' gears, with the likes of Ghosts, Infinite Warfare, Black Ops 4 and more garnering divisive reputations.
Still, some will defend the previously mentioned games. However, the same cannot be said for the dreadful Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III remake, because even die-hard CoD fanatics hate this one.
This game was received with genuine disdain, as its incredibly short campaign, filled with recycled Warzone assets, showed a clear lack of care from Activision. That point was made clear by the fact that the game began as an expansion pack for the previous entry, only to be expanded into a lacklustre full game.
MWIII 2023 also took one of its source material's most popular plus points (the story) and butchered it, leaving old players disappointed and failing to impress new ones. Overall, it's a franchise entry that sank right to the bottom of the CoD sea.
9. Metal Gear Survive (2018)
A multi-million dollar corporation takes a beloved IP and pumps out a crappy game, assuming name-brand recognition will take them all the way to the bank. It really is a tale as old as time, and one that usually doesn't pay off. Case in point - Metal Gear Survive.
This was the first MGS game developed without the architect of the series, Hideo Kojima, after his infamous split with Konami. So, no one can say they were surprised when this game was such a dumpster fire.
Survive took the famous story-led stealth franchise and turned it into a forgettable base-building zombie survival title, clearly hoping to capitalise on the trending genre at that time. It was boring, poorly made, and featured a nonsensical story. On top of this, it was also plagued by predatory microtransactions that showed how little Konami actually cared about making the game over the money they'd rake in for it. That made it doubly awkward when the game sold terribly. Oopsie.
This game was an absolute insult to long-term fans, and the MGS community have still not forgiven it.
8. Silent Hill: Book of Memories (2012)
Choosing the worst Silent Hill game is, sadly, something you won't be starved of options for. The beloved horror franchise has had its fair share of stinkers over the years, including Downpour, Homecoming, and The Short Message, among others. Still, while those games are generally disliked, those who really love the spooky IP can at least find some of the franchise's signature survival horror charm in them. The same, however, cannot be said for Silent Hill: Book of Memories.
2012's Book of Memories was a major outlier in the SH franchise, as this PS Vita title was a lacklustre dungeon-crawler, which is about as far from the Silent Hill formula as you can get. Now, in fairness, a shake-up can sometimes be a blessing, but it worked no wonders for this game, as BoM was cursed with mediocrity. The levels were painstakingly repetitive, the horror was minimal, and the combat was threadbare. Most people can forgive bad combat in an SH game, but not when combat is basically the whole thing.
For the record, Silent Hill: Ascension absolutely would have been on this list if it were technically a video game. It's more of an interactive TV show, really, but consider this a dishonourable mention.
7. Afro Samurai 2: Revenge Of Kuma (2015)
Afro Samurai is a franchise that's about as wild and bombastic as it sounds. Beginning with the original manga, written by Takashi Okazaki, it has wowed audiences with its eye-catching visual style, unique blend of cultures, and surprising amount of substance in almost every format. It's no surprise then that the video game adaptation was also great, giving players the chance to kick ass as the titular hero.
Sadly, that magic didn't make its way to the sequel, which was so bad it was removed from storefronts and disowned by its devs. Yikes.
Afro Samurai 2: Revenge of Kuma suffered from monstrous launch issues, including freezing, crashes, slow frame rates, glitches, and more. It also didn't impress when it ran decently, as the gameplay fell flat and the story was confusing and disjointed, thanks partly to its reliance on jarring flashbacks. It was a flop on every level, something that publisher Versus Evil's general manager, Steve Escalante, refused to sugarcoat.
He openly apologised for the game, pulled it from sale, refunded players, and cancelled the planned volumes 2 and 3. It doesn't get worse than that.
6. Bubsy 3D (1996)
Mascots are a central part of the gaming pie, with the 90s really thriving off of these lovable characters. It's hard to even imagine a world without the likes of Mario, Crash Bandicoot, Sonic, Banjo-Kazooie, Spyro, and more. That said, it's much easier to imagine a world without characters like Bubsy, because it's one most people probably want to live in.
Bubsy the bobcat is a character that never fully clicked with players. That said, his first two games weren't terrible, and some out there might look back fondly on the little guy, even if it's through nostalgia-tinted glasses. However, it's hard to think of anyone who holds a place in their hearts for the maligned, dreaded, horrendous Bubsy 3D.
This game is often touted as one of the worst games ever made, and it's hard to argue. The barren levels, ugly graphics (even for the time), terribly annoying lead character, and clunky controls all came together to produce a game that was near impossible to sit through. While there are some minor Bubsy fans out there, you won't hear them dying on this polygonal, 3D hill.
5. Hotel Mario (1994)
The dreaded relationship between Nintendo and the Phillips CD-i has already reared its ugly head on this list, thanks to its crossover with the Legend of Zelda series. But, while plenty of gamers remember Phillips' dreadful take on Hyrule, many often forget that they got their mitts on everyone's favourite Italian Plumber too. The result was, unsurprisingly, one of the worst Mario games ever made.
Hotel Mario was a puzzle game that tasked the titular hero with venturing around a unique version of the Mushroom Kingdom, which had been converted into a series of hotels by Bowser, yes, really. You had to solve a series of puzzles based on opening and closing doors, which grew boring almost immediately thanks to the lack of challenge, repetition, and mundane design. That's three things Mario has never been known for.
It also, of course, featured the CD-i's signature terrible cutscenes, looking like they'd been scraped together in MS Paint, complete with awful voice acting, writing, and animation. It's no surprise Mario fans hate this stain on this franchise's otherwise near-perfect overalls.
4. Street Fighter 2010: The Final Fight (1990)
The Street Fighter series is easily one of the most influential franchises in gaming, mostly thanks to the seminal sequel Street Fighter II, which (literally) changed the game and kick-started the popularity of the fighting genre. That's why it feels odd to talk about the other Street Fighter game that was released before that classic - Street Fighter 2010: The Final Fight.
Unsurprisingly, it was absolute trash.
The Final Fight was released for the NES in 1990, a year before Street Fighter II made its way to arcades. This game took some wild swings, portraying the beloved Ken Masters as a retired fighter turned cybernetic scientist, who travels across space trying to avenge his murdered lab partner and stop the creation of a superhuman army. It was also an action-platformer, not a fighting game.
Wild premise aside, the game was rough to play, as its intense difficulty and horrendous time limit mechanic left many broken controllers in its wake. Long-time fans of the series prefer to pretend that this bizarre offshoot never even existed.
3. Umbrella Corps (2016)
Even at it's worst, the Resident Evil franchise is at least worth a glance. This absolutely beloved zombie series usually pulls out the stops and makes some good choices, even when it doesn't stick the landing. However, there's one game so bad it doesn't even include the franchise's name in the title (outside of Japan), which is a pretty clear sign of its quality. Say hello to Umbrella Corps.
This 2016 game was Capcom's attempt to delve into the lucrative market of online tactical shooters, using one of their most notable IPs to get a head start. Sadly, they fumbled it about as badly as Netflix fumbled the Resident Evil TV show.
Umbrella Corps was a messy and poorly constructed game that failed on every mechanical level. The shooting handled terribly, thanks to the clumsy controls and the poor hit detection. It also had a dreadful cover system, jarring movement, and a distinct lack of scares.
On top of being a bad game, it was also simply too far removed from the franchise's unique selling points, missing out on the thrilling story and atmosphere that have always been Resi's bread and butter.
2. Sonic The Hedgehog (2006)
Being labelled as the lowest point in the Sonic franchise is worse than being called the ugly duckling's even uglier best friend, as this series is arguably known for its lows more than its highs. But, oh boy, there's no arguing for it when it comes to the universally despised Sonic The Hedgehog 2006, as this game is worse than trash and easily ranks as the SEGA mascot's biggest trainwreck.
Sonic '06 has developed a reputation for many things, none of which are good. First and foremost is the overly convoluted story, featuring time travel, a narrative-breaking ending, and a romance between the titular Sonic and a human princess. Who the hell is out there wishing for a romance between a human woman and a blue hedgehog?
On top of the ridiculous story choices, it's also a completely broken game, full of dragging loading times, a multitude of bugs, an atrocious camera that's impossible to control, and more. Sonic fans have been through a lot and have forgiven many disasters, but forgiving this game was too much to ask.
1. Bomberman: Act Zero (2006)
When looking through the line-up of games in the Bomberman series, most of them will blend in with one another. You'll see bright colours, cute visuals, a charming central mascot, and an overall sense of joyfulness. But, at one specific point in the series, you'll reach Bomberman: Act Zero and receive instant whiplash from the intense shift in tone.
What is Act Zero? Well, it was Bomberman's attempt at a gritty reboot, and, oh boy, it was an embarrassment.
This game took the cartoony character and turned him into a dark, sci-fi, post-apocalyptic hero, clearly attempting to reinvent the character for a new generation. Naturally, this went down like a lead balloon, as long-term fans were shocked by the shift.
Playing the game was also a nightmare, as the AI was entirely unbalanced, the level design was drab and repetitive, the loading times stretched on far too long, and plenty more. But the biggest fumble was the multiplayer, a staple of the Bomberman series, as Act Zero did away with local co-op in favour of online play. However, the game's First-Person Battle Mode was ruined by its terrible camera that made it hard to do anything, and wasn't even in first-person, meaning even its namesake was a joke.