21 Most Replayable Video Games Of The 2000s

12. Guitar Hero/Rock Band

Now that all the fake-instrument dust has settled, it's still pretty much a toss-up between the two heavyweights of the rhythm game genre as to which deserves your time in 2014. What Guitar Hero lacked in innovation after the first three titles, it tended to make up for with incredible song choices and a slightly better interface (even though as you can see above, by the end they were so close it bordering on a lawsuit coming in). However with Rock Band the catalogue of tracks on offer is unmatched. Whereas original developer Harmonix would jump-ship to create a full band experience in that title, takeover-team Neversoft drove the Guitar Hero name into the ground with multiple titles within extremely short release windows. You'll have to fork out some extra cash to obtain the likes of a Metallica Pack for Rock Band, but it has to be said that the song-selections on-disc are still incredible, and provoke a sense of communal sing-a-longs that Guitar Hero would never truly emulate, despite ripping off the idea of multiple instruments wholesale with Band Hero. Replay it specifically for: The sheer unmatched fun of grabbing the guitar-controller and wailing your way through something as iconic as Livin' On A Prayer. If you can grab a bunch of friends for an old school Rock Band session, it remains one of the finest experiences of multiplayer gaming known to man.

11. Gears Of War 2

The definitive Gears' experience, and the one that had just the right amount of story and epic levels to play through. Introducing new Fatality-style mechanics that upped the gore-ante and allowed you to lacerate fallen foes with weapons as fun to use as the explosive-arrow-firing Torque Bow, it marks the high-point for the series that Gears 3 accompanies only slightly underneath. The revolutionary Horde Mode also remains something that draws fans new and old back in - a mode where you must face increasingly-hard waves of enemies who spawn in, with you recouping your losses and scavenging for ammo in the seconds between assaults. Tackled with friends this was a huge amount of fun, and although Gears 3 would reprise the mode with some tacked-on additions to the arena-management idea of fortifying sections, it's this original mode that has the most appeal, with the best levels too. Replay it specifically for: The unmatched level of gunplay and fun, exemplified by the comically violent altercations between your under-mounted chainsaw-machine gun and many an opponent's chest.

10. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

Is it possible to pick just one Metal Gear title? If you were one of those people who coughed up your hard-earned to obtain a copy of Zone of the Enders just for the MGS2 demo, chances are that initial Tanker section has been replayed more times than all the other games combined. However if we're to go for gameplay to cutscene ratio (goodbye MGS 4), as well as hidden ways to play, with thoroughly memorable boss-battles that require more than just holding down the fire button, it just has to be Snake Eater. From the opening gag that gives you a rubber mask of then-hated protagonist Raiden should you have chosen the option 'I like MGS2' from the opening menu, through to the genuinely heart-wrenching tale of mentor-turned-enemy The Boss, Snake Eater remains a game that gave you bucketloads of satisfaction first time through yet remains endlessly replayable for the sake of an almost never-ending list of secrets and things to see. Replay it specifically for: The completely unique tone that's yet to be replicated anywhere else. You'll go from nail-biting in-game tension as you pray you're concealed enough to let a wandering patrol pass, to marvelling at some truly beautiful graphics and enemies that look like they fell out of some crazy Bond villian-generator on overdrive in the cutscenes.

9. Super Meat Boy

They blast incredibly heavy music at eardrum-bursting levels as a form of torture in some prisons and camps, yet give someone a controller and ask they get through a few consecutive levels of SMB with the threat of physical pain as an alternative, and they'll easily take the hits. Super Meat Boy's pixel-perfect levels are an exercise in ripping your own hair out, custom-programmed by Edmund McMillen and Tommy Refenes (also known as Team Meat) to be as relentlessly unforgiving as possible, pushing you to the limit of your hand-eye coordinated abilities, before nudging you over the edge and offering an outstretched hand in the form of an instant-restart screen. "Just one more shot" you say, which is also the last thing you remember saying as another four hours fly by and the neighbours are calling the police due to smattering of curse words emitting from your living room in the vein of some demonically-possessed hobo. Just one more shot though, yeah? Replay it specifically for: Experiencing 2D-platforming perfected, and for every curse word you'll scream or say through gritted teeth, as it won't matter when you finally nail the perfect run through a level.

8. Burnout 3: Takedown

What do you get when you take one of the most eyeball-searingly-fast racing franchises going, and add in the ability to ram other opponents off the road? Absolute euphoric carnage that's what. The previous Burnout titles managed to build a reputation on throwing the game's circuits at you at a stupidly fast pace, the challenge being of course to race against a handful of opponents but also to dodge a myriad of pedestrian vehicles. Takedown changed all of that, giving you a sense of invulnerability that throughout the preview coverage fans thought would surely break the game; what was the incentive and where was the challenge in dodging traffic at lightspeed to steal victory at the last second, if you could barrel straight through a blockade and win anyway? Therein lay the rub though, as developers Criterion handled the distribution of this ability perfectly, meaning you could only enter such a state if your boost meter was suitably filled up. This lead to so many instances where - thanks to the many hidden shortcuts and multiple levels within a given track - if you timed it right you could barrel straight into the side of your opponent and use the resultant momentum to fly away ahead of the pack...only to be taken out by someone who had been targeting you all along too. Replay it specifically for: One of the most perfect racing game experiences - Amultiplayer or otherwise - put to consoles since Mario Kart.

7. Bioshock

While other games on this illicit that inbuilt 'I gotta do that again!' repetition of some particular gameplay mechanic, Bioshock provides one of the most detailed and fun-to-explore environments ever conceived. Although previous 'Shock title System Shock 2 instigated the now in vogue trend of relaying story elements through collectable audio diaries, it was journeying through the underwater utopia-gone-sour world of Rapture that really brought it to the mainstream and made it an extremely integral part of the overall environment itself. The combat in the Bioshock titles has never been as refined as mastermind Ken Levine would hope, with the best moments of the game instead coming from simply exploring the world and drinking in the fantastically dank and macabre art design that accompanies every nook and cranny. Replay it specifically for: That endgame plot twist, which if you've managed to survive on Earth this long and not know you should probably fake an illness or something and marathon through it before someone else ruins it. For everyone else, just play and remember the first time you found out...it's still unmatched.

6. Dark Souls

Lord Of Smashed Controllers and Arbiter Of Frustration, Dark Souls is a PHENOMENAL franchise, and one that has spurred some really old school gaming vitriol from both sides of the love/hate divide. It's truly a wondrous experience through and through, as although the game literally forces you to unlearn everything you think you know about 3rd-person action-adventure games, if you let it's ridiculously minimalist approach envelop you, a beautiful system of give and take emerges. Think you can just go up to a creature and attack them? Wrong. You need to study their animations and wait for your perfect time to strike. The game will nearly always kill you in one attack if you mess up and are wailing on the attack button hoping for a kill, as not only will you run out of stamina and be left shield-down, but damage is enhanced significantly if you deliberately go against the rules of combat. Dark Souls' reputation precedes it though, as there is a difference between incredibly hard and just plain unforgiving. Aside from a couple times in the game where developers FromSoftware seem to want to remind you of the bleakness of the world you're playing in and others where character models may get stuck or glitch through surfaces, 99% of the time you'll only die in Dark Souls of your own accord. Therein lies the rub, as there has barely been a game in years that handles the exquisite sense of progression and achievement as Dark Souls. As if the cumulative little victories weren't enough along the way, when you finally topple the last flame sword-wielding enemy and watch the credits roll, you'll dive straight back in and do it all again, picking a different class or weapon just to poke and prod the world some more, knowing that this time around you've gained a little bit more of the precious knowledge to survive, and that's the unique beauty of it. Replay it specifically for: The heart-attack-imminent, sweaty-palmed feeling of snatching victory from the jaws of defeat just as you're teetering on the edge of a full mental breakdown. Beating a boss in Dark Souls is like nothing else, and is a sensation that you'll chase through the game and its sequel.

5. Final Fantasy IX

Just making it into the 2000's bracket by a couple of months, aside from a graphical downgrade IX has barely aged a day. Although FFX remains a pretty strong contender for this article headline's crown, too many people were put off by the flat voice acting and convoluted story for it to rank above this masterpiece of RPG game design. The last of what are essentially referred to as The Big Three of Final Fantasy's alongside the world-changing VII and the polarising VIII, IX corralled everyone back under a banner of fantastic characters, perfect motivations and one hell of a gorgeous art style throughout. Speaking of art-style, the appeal of main hero Zidane's tale lies in every pixel of the scenery you explore, and every modicum of the bouncy anime-esque animation that powers the combat and exploration segments. Tie the entire package together with a sense of humour that makes the whole thing !*$% loveable, and you've got a title perfect for any newcomers who may not have seen it all the way through just as much as the rest of us who may have forgotten just how joyous this title still is. Replay it specifically for: The sheer love you can have for a character with no face - small Mage Vivi remains one of the best RPG characters ever created, and his story of nervous self-discovery when faced with certain death-inducing odds is one that many fans still regard as an unmatched franchise high-point.

4. Wii Sports

The game that changed the world. Just let it sink in a bit, how many people do you know that have tried - or to cast a wider net, know of - Wii Sports? For many it's their ENTIRE family. Everyone from the barely-educated tween that exists on a heady diet of abdomen-baring poptarts all the way up the generational ladder to granny who remembers when it was frowned upon to have a bit of ankle on show, every single one can get stuck into Wii Sports, and they still do in their droves. Now we live in a world where mentioning you spent an afternoon on Call of Duty or FIFA is no longer met with looks of disgust or comments about how 'games are for kids', instead that person is more likely to join in with you and have a couple of games next time they're round. And the very reason for this potent paradigm shift? Wii Sports. No longer is gaming the vestige of the soap-deprived and scraggly-haired (well, it is that too), but thanks to the proliferation of Nintendo's initially laughable console idea, games became a staple of the living room, and we've been thrashing granny at tennis ever since. Replay it specifically for: Having an entire family showdown at the virtual bowling range.

3. World Of Warcraft

115 million players can't be wrong. Even though The King Of MMORPGs has been going for a decade strong, the numbers have grown in strength to strength alongside, thanks in no part to a full mainstream embrace of Blizzard's momentous achievement that includes Big Bang Theory references, celebrity ad campaigns, and that oh-so fantastic episode of South Park: Make Love, Not Warcraft. A total game-changer in it's day, there have been many MMOs since, with the most recent that was touted to at least make a dint in the crown being The Elder Scrolls Online. Sadly a world where hundreds of people are instanced into potentially meaningful situations and dialogue-exchanges by way of first-person combat and a plethora of glitches does not an enjoyable experience make, leaving the millions to remain in the ever-expanding world of Azeroth where they can continue to live a virtual life of questing and companionship to their heart's content. Replay it specifically for: The occasional need to do something away from taxes and the drudgery of dragging your barely-moving husk into work the next day, as going for a stroll down the Elwynn Forest with a posse of friends ready to do battle is a much more pleasing concept. 'Team-building' they say? We got this.

 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.