5 Times Gamers Fought The Developer And Won
See, you can demand that developers deliver the goods!
For a long time, gamers had virtually no power in determining how video games were made. Instead, they generally played whatever they got and could only decide if they loved or hated it after they’d already invested in the experience.
Over the past 20 years, however, there’s been a drastic paradigm shift within the industry, with the growth of social media, gaming journalism, and other components of the gaming sphere allowing consumers to educate themselves about upcoming titles and share their thoughts ASAP.
Plus, it’s become increasingly easy and expected for video game developers to preview their latest projects months – if not years – before they arrive and make changes as needed shortly before or after they come out.
It’s no surprise, then, that there have been countless cases of people refusing to accept something about a future or recently released title. Whether it’s due to an issue with graphics, storytelling, characterization, mechanics or any number of other transgressions, modern players are more than happy to tell creators what they want and don’t want from them.
Sure, their demands aren’t always met, but there’s usually some sort of compromise between both parties when all’s said and done.
Case in point: the following list, which encapsulates some of the best examples of gamers who fought developers and won!
5. Doing Away With “Poop” Visuals - Bloodstained: Ritual Of The Night
Ever since video games started advancing visually and mechanically several decades ago, there’s been an ongoing debate regarding which is more important: graphics or gameplay. Of course, every player has their own opinion on the topic – so there’s no obvious answer – and it’s safe to say that most of them want titles that are pleasing to play and look at.
Someone should’ve told developer ArtPlay that before they started working on their spiritual successor to Castlevania, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night, as people really didn’t like what they were seeing when they got a good glimpse at it in 2018.
Specifically, myriad complaints were made across social media about its 2.5D aesthetic looking “bland” and “cheap,” with many pejorative comparisons to mobile games as viewers voiced their issues with character models, the lighting engine, environmental details and overall art design. Most famously, at least one person outright said that the game “looks like poop.”
However justified, the negative reactions Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night received from the public were surely disheartening for everyone involved.
After all, it’s the first game developed by ArtPlay, which was co-founded by beloved Castlevania producer Koji “Iga” Igarashi after he left Konami in 2014. Therefore, hopes were high that he’d prove himself as a master of his own destiny after cutting ties with the maligned publisher.
In fact, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night became the most successful video game software Kickstarter campaign ever in 2017, having raised about $5.5 million from nearly 65,000 backers. Even though it’s subsequently been beaten by properties such as Shenmue III and Shroud of the Avatar: Forsaken Virtues, that’s still impressive and telling!
Beyond that, the game had already been delayed numerous times.
Primarily, it was postponed in 2016 to sometime in 2018, with Igarashi – who had a major hand in the title’s writing and creative direction – telling IGN at the time that the decision was fueled by his need to sustain the “very high quality” regarding the “good” graphics that were “better than a traditional Iga-vania game.”
“It was either drop the quality bar one notch in order to get it out sooner, or it was to be satisfied with the quality and continue to make sure it was going to be maintained throughout the project. At the end of the day, I want to go with the quality. This is important to me,” he also explained.
In 2017, he told IGN that the team “decided to make some changes to the way the visuals worked,” including “implement[ing] procedural generation to . . . backgrounds” to ensure that “the world feel[s] more believable, or more real.”
Unfortunately, he released a developer update video in August of 2018 to say that Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night would be delayed again until 2019 to “raise the quality level” following “the very valuable feedback from the Beta Backer Demo.” Whether or not he’s referring to the aforementioned complaints about the graphics, said complaints arose around the same time.
In mid-2019, and soon after the game’s release date announcement trailer arrived, Igarashi told PC Gamer: “It was obviously pretty disappointing to see those sorts of comments, but that was what made me make the big decision to go okay, we need to do some research and make this better. And it turned out pretty well.”
He also specified that “there was a big difference in how the Japanese fans reacted and US fans reacted,” with many people in Japan saying that they preferred “the old version.”
Luckily, he had a sense of humor about the backlash as well since the trailer – which showcased a reworked lighting engine and additional assets – focused on Igarashi directly confronting what naysayers said. In particular, it featured images of various social media criticisms before showing Igarashi drinking wine and vowing to “prove them wrong!”
The trailer even called the old art style “poop”!
Clearly, Igarashi and his team’s willingness to revise the project’s visuals paid off, as Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night released in June of 2019 to rave reviews and multiple award nominations/wins. It’s since sold millions of copies, too.
4. That’s Not the Same Cole – inFamous 2
This one is similar to what happened with Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night, except that the problem wasn’t the game’s overarching appearance. Rather, it was the significant and – by many accounts – inferior character design changes made to snarky protagonist Cole MacGrath for 2011’s inFamous 2.
In both look and voice, the Cole from 2009’s inFamous was like modern-day Jason Statham, with his extremely short hair, muscular build, and raspy matter-of-fact speech making him a cool and relatable badass. Couple that with his iconic courier clothing, charismatic personality, and heroic quest to save Empire City from further destruction and it’s no shock that innumerable players adored him.
Before long, he even became an easily recognizable mascot for the PS3 and the PlayStation brand as a whole.
Why, then, did Sucker Punch Productions choose to radically revamp their depiction of Cole’s when they started work on inFamous 2? They must’ve known how much blowback they’d get, right?
Indeed, that’s what they got following the game’s gameplay reveal at E3 2010, when plenty of people scolded the developer for making Cole nearly unrecognizable.
Among the major modifications were replacing his buzz cut with a lengthier stack of dark hair; adding tattoos; and giving him a uniform black color scheme and more generic facial structure. Plus, original actor Jason Cottle was swapped for Eric Ladin, which understandably rubbed certain fans the wrong way on principle if nothing else.
Granted, Cole was never an especially unique character, but he stood out more than the artless create-a-character Sucker Punch Productions turned him into between the original inFamous and its direct sequel. Apparently, the changes were driven by the developers wanting to do more with motion capture, as well as the switch in setting from the chilly New York-inspired Empire City to the hotter New Orleans-inspired New Marais.
In an August 2010 interview with Engadget (via Yahoo! News), art director Mathias Lorenz affirmed that they altered Cole’s outfit because there was “no way he [could] keep his leather jacket on” in such “humid” weather. In addition, they replaced Cottle with Ladin because he “could do both the voice acting and . . . the motion capture, and we tried to imbue some of his likeness into Cole.”
In their June 2010 preview of inFamous 2, Engadget joked that Cole "acquired . . . the ability to grow a soft, voluminous head of hair. He's also been put on a regimen of Ricolas and piping-hot peppermint tea, curing his perpetually gruff voice from the first game." They continued: "[H]e's clearly taken a few lessons from the Nathan Drake Institute of Grooming, Speaking and Generally Being an Edgy Dude."
The next month, multiple reports emerged of Sucker Punch Productions going back to the drawing board because of the vitriolic responses they’d received earlier that summer. Although they kept Ladin – who, to be fair, ended up doing a fine job in the finished product – they modified Cole once again to strike a finer compromise between old and new styles.
“[W]hen we revealed Cole at E3 2010, we were taken aback by the uproar of fan support for the original Cole,” Lorenz added in the Engadget interview. “We were positively surprised and we didn’t expect it, so of course we listened . . . and went back and took the best of everything to end up with the design we have settled on now.”
Ironically, Sucker Punch Productions co-founder Bruce Oberg similarly told Eurogamer in September 2010 that despite “the media reaction to the original Cole [being] lukewarm,” they knew they had to return to it after seeing “16 pages of [new] Cole complaints” on fan forums.
Said compromise, which essentially put inFamous 1 Cole in a short sleeve T-shirt, was widely welcomed by gamers. Furthermore, it even became the character's signature look in the 2011 expansion – inFamous: Festival of Blood – and when Cole guested in 2012’s PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale and Street Fighter X Tekken.
3. The Controversial Ending – Mass Effect 3
It’s not uncommon for a movie trilogy to start out great but drop the ball at the finish line due to disappointing resolutions, subpar quality, and/or other shortcomings. Despite not being discussed as often, the same can be said for the third chapters of video game trios, as showcased by Dead Space 3, Watch Dogs: Legion and Fable III among several other culprits.
Upon its release in March of 2012, the highly anticipated Mass Effect 3 was added to that list for a handful of reasons, including claims of it having an overstuffed roster; a lack of meaningful and varied dialogue choices; repetitious missions and gameplay; and a general lack of polish. Easily its biggest and most notable indiscretion, though, was its incredibly unfulfilling ending.
Basically, Mass Effect 3 completed the series’ operatic story by having protagonist Commander Shepard activate the Crucible to destroy the villainous Reapers. Before doing so, he’s confronted by the Reapers’ hive mind – presented as the Star Child – who justifies the Reapers’ actions. Shepard then chooses from three color-coded decisions, all of which result in the Crucible destroying the galaxy’s mass relay network and Shepard's Normandy ship hitting a distant planet.
BioWare’s first two mainline entries were revered for their rich storytelling, deep characters, and dense player agency; therefore, it’s reasonable that fans were upset about Mass Effect 3 rendering a ton of prior decisions and plot threads irrelevant in favor of streamlining things with three barely different – but universally depressing – outcomes that avoided the series’ penchant for moral complexity.
To that end, the “Retake Mass Effect” movement soon arose, with representative Krista Hauser telling Forbes in April of 2012: “This isn’t a vocal minority but a sizeable collection of fans who have found themselves disappointed, confused and upset by the unusually poor quality of what everyone expected to be an epic conclusion to a groundbreaking trilogy. . . . We want an ending . . . that stays true to what has made the series so amazing.”
Hauser also specified that unhappy fans “want an ending that reflects the choices made by the player throughout all 3 games but also respects the lore of the series.” Beyond that, grievances were filed with the Federal Trade Commission and Better Business Bureau because of BioWare’s alleged false advertising and false promises.
Of course, industry opinions were divided regarding whether the outrage and demands came from a place of love and justification or immaturity and entitlement.
Meanwhile, BioWare Director Casey Hudson defended the ending and BioWare promised single-player DLC that would reflect player feedback about the conclusion. Before long, the free Extended Cut DLC of Mass Effect 3 was announced with the purpose of “answer[ing] some questions” to “give closure to this chapter of the Mass Effect story.” Even so, BioWare clarified that it would “expand on the existing endings” with “additional cinematics and epilogue scenes” but wouldn’t offer new endings.
The DLC came out in June of 2012 and included fixes to several plot holes alongside embellishments to the Star Child’s reasoning and extra context for the aftermath of Shepard’s ultimate decision. There was also a new option for Shepard to refuse the Reapers’ offers – leading to the Reapers winning because the Crucible wasn’t used – and in March of 2013, the Citadel DLC brought more closure to Mass Effect 3’s story and character relationships.
Unsurprisingly, those DLCs – in addition to others, all of which were included in 2021’s Mass Effect Legendary Edition compilation – was embraced by some and rejected by others. In fact, some people still created their own mods, such as the Happy Ending, Priority: Earth Overhaul, and Starchild-Be-Gone mods, to transform the entire experience into whatever they wanted Mass Effect 3 to be.
In hindsight, and with the initial pangs of disappointment gone, many people have argued that Mass Effect 3 was unfairly criticized and deserves to be as celebrated as its two predecessors. Journalists acknowledged the importance of Mass Effect 3’s ending controversy, too, in shaping the power gamers now have to influence developers.
2. Rebuilding and Rebranding - Final Fantasy XIV
The Final Fantasy franchise – which turns 40 years old in 2027 – is arguably the most popular RPG series of all time. Because there have been over three dozen games under the umbrella when considering primary entries, sequels, spin-offs, remakes and the like, there have obviously been some that haven’t been up to snuff.
For instance, a quick glance at Metacritic reveals that Final Fantasy: All the Bravest, Final Fantasy VII: The First Solider, Final Fantasy IV: The After Years, and A King’s Tale: Final Fantasy XV are rated extremely low. As for mainline titles, fans understandably have a plethora of gripes with the second, thirteenth, and fifteenth entries.
That said, few – if any – of them were ever met with as much contempt as Final Fantasy XIV was when it premiered in 2010.
Given the critical and commercial victories of SquareSoft’s first attempt at a Final Fantasy MMORPG – 2002’s Final Fantasy XI – before returning to the series’ single-player roots for the next two titles, it made sense for them to aim for a second success with Final Fantasy XIV. Yet, developer Square Enix instead received absolute vitriol when the vanilla version of the game arrived on Windows platforms.
It’s hard to fault fans for being so upset when they had to deal with problems inside and outside of the gameworld.
In particular, server crashes were rampant; the user interface hindered the gameplay and graphics; user accounts were inexplicably deleted; and the misguided Fatigue System penalized devoted players by reducing EXP and skill points if they played for too long.
Honestly, that’s just scratching the surface of what was wrong, and the overall consensus from critics and consumers alike was that Final Fantasy XIV was only half-baked when it came out of the oven.
Naturally, its failure affected Square Enix in astronomical ways.
Chiefly, some project staff were swapped – namely, original director/designer Nobuaki Komoto and producer Hiromichi Tanaka were replaced by Naoki Yoshida – as fiscal expectations dropped by 90% and the planned PlayStation 3 version being delayed.
Perhaps most damaging, however, was the fact that countless players canceled their subscriptions – and lost faith in the franchise as a whole – prior to the serves being shut down in late 2012.
At the 2011 Tokyo Game Show, then-CEO Yoichi Wada admitted that “the Final Fantasy brand has been greatly damaged” by the situation. He then vowed: “We'll continue with our reform work, which basically amounts to fully redoing the game, and hope to revive the FFXIV that should have been released.”
To his credit, the development team tried mending the existing version of Final Fantasy XIV throughout 2011, but various factors – including a devastating earthquake and subsequent tsunami in the Tōhoku region of Japan – made it difficult.
So, they decided to officially say goodbye to version 1.0 via an epic CG cutscene and rebuild the game from scratch, with a new engine and reworked interfaces, mechanics, combat, and storylines implemented at the prospect of regaining people’s trust and restoring the company’s reputation.
In one of the most impressive and heartwarming turnarounds in video games history, the second iteration of Final Fantasy XIV – known as A Realm Reborn – released in August of 2013 on Windows platforms and, poetically enough, on PlayStation 3.
Fortunately, it soon brought back many franchise followers and allowed 2014 to be a profitable year for Square Enix. Despite still having some reservations and criticisms, publications such as GameSpot, GamesRadar+, IGN, Polygon, and Famitsu praised its beneficial changes and Square Enix’s commitment to doing right by their fans.
Since then, Final Fantasy XIV has gotten numerous patches and expansions to keep the expanded playerbase – now with Xbox and macOS users among them – active and satisfied. In total, it’s been showered with accolades, too, and appeared on several Game of the Year lists.
Tens of thousands of players still jump in daily, so it remains incredibly popular, and it’s even been called one of the greatest MMORPGs ever made and one of the best Final Fantasy games of all time.
1. Story, Progression & Craig - Halo Infinite
The initial Halo trilogy was so beloved that it almost single-handedly put Xbox on the map while turning protagonist Master Chief into the console’s flagship mascot. Therefore, 343 Industries had a lot to live up to when they took over franchise developmental duties from Bungie in the early 2010s. Sadly, and despite being positively received overall, 2012’s Halo 4 and especially 2015’s Halo 5: Guardians failed to deliver what fans wanted.
That’s why the sixth mainline entry – which was meant to be a November 2020 launch title for Xbox Series X/S – was met with hope and hesitancy when its announcement trailer premiered at E3 2018. Over the subsequent years, numerous flaws both pre-release and post-release continued hurting Halo Infinite’s reputation, with some of the biggest issues temporarily derailing the game’s chances at finally restoring the series to its former glory.
Probably the most infamous and humorous transgression came during the summer of 2020, when the first gameplay trailer was lambasted for its disappointing graphics.
In particular, the openly work-in-progress footage depicted Master Chief fighting some Brutes, including one – forever known as Craig – whose blank expression quickly birthed a thousand memes. Although Craig was fun to mock – even by 343 Industries’ Community Director, Brian Jarrard – franchise loyalists still demanded that Halo Infinite’s outdated graphics be improved by launch.
Famously, Eurogamer encapsulated the negative feedback by writing: “[It] looks like the fake plastic trees version of Halo, like a video game designed with Mega Bloks in mind. It pops in all the wrong places. The Brutes and their silly faces seem almost plonked down onto the battlefield like a child would arrange toys to bash about in their bedroom. It doesn't feel grounded. It doesn't feel like it has depth. It feels, well, surface level, smooth and uninteresting.”
The backlash against Halo Infinite’s graphics was so strong that in August of 2020, the title was postponed to sometime in 2021.
Responding to the hostile responses, the game’s Narrative Experience Director – Dan Chosich – told critical gamers: “I've been in your shoes. I know what it's like to have expectations built + feel let down. I want you to know your voice matters + is heard. You're not falling on deaf ears. I always want to live up to the legacy that Bungie pioneered. I personally care a lot about honoring that.”
As Studio Head Chris Lee explained at the time, the delay was made to “ensure the team has adequate time to deliver a Halo game experience that meets our vision.” Similarly, Character & Combat Director Steve Dyck disclosed in October of 2021 that the “positive outcome” of the Craig debacle was that it exemplified “343 working with and aligning with the Halo community around expectations.”
Eventually, news broke that the August 2020 delay was also the result of the team deciding to bring back veteran writer Joseph Staten to revise Halo Infinite’s story direction. Initially, 343 Industries intended to pick up where Halo 5: Guardians’ story left off; yet, that campaign was so divisive that they chose to significantly downsize the Guardians’ role in the sequel and change Staten’s role to Head of Creative to safeguard against narrative shortcomings in Halo Infinite.
Then, in August of 2021, Halo Infinite’s multiplayer beta arrived, and while players commended 343 Industries’ advanced gameplay, they also criticized the beta’s slow Battle Pass progression system.
Consequently, the studio updated things so that players earned more XP for various daily goals and challenges, with community manager John Junyszek tweeting in late November of 2021: “We know many of you want even larger changes and we're committed to doing so, but those will take time. We made this update based on data and player feedback, and we'll monitor its impact after we push it live tomorrow morning.”
Those are but three chief components of Halo Infinite that drew ire and were subsequently fixed thanks to the relationship between 343 Industries and Halo’s diehard devotees. True, other issues have cropped up – and Halo Infinite remains imperfect – but its December 2021 launch was far more successful critically and commercially than it might’ve been if the developer never listened to the fans.
Of course, Halo Infinite has only gotten better from there, and 343 Industries even threw in a Craig Easter egg to further poke fun at themselves and let bygones be bygones.