8 Controversies That Have ALREADY Hurt Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk has been in the headlines a lot, but not always for the right reasons...

Cyberpunk Transgender Ad
CD Projekt RED

Right off the bat, it’s important to state that Cyberpunk 2077 is shaping up to have one of the biggest releases ever. Developers CD Projekt RED have massive goodwill after mega hit The Witcher III, while the intriguing genre, themes and visuals have generated massive buzz.

Also, they have Keanu Reeves.

However, it hasn’t all been smooth sailing as far as their momentum has gone. Various trailers and demos have already given us a few reasons to (at the very least) temper our expectations.

These scandals tend to run the gamut from those who might see them as deal-breakers, to others who question why anyone even cares.

You could even argue these aren’t all legitimate criticisms, but then they aren’t supposed to be criticisms at all. Instead, these are merely the biggest scandals to have hit the game so far.

All the times Cyberpunk 2077 has ended up in the headlines with negative press, to reasons not connected to hands-on gameplay. Whether you care about these are not is entirely up to you, but it’s obvious that at least some people out there do, and in one way or another, they’ve damaged Cyberpunk 2077’s momentum.

8. Twitter Scandals

Cyberpunk 2077 Twitter
Twitter

Anybody who’s anybody has some Twitter skeletons in their closet these days, and CDPR (and GOG, in their conglomerate) have three doozies.

Sean Halliday ran the social media for both companies, and first got into trouble after tweeting a picture of someone urinating on a gravestone marked ‘Games Journalism - Committed Suicide’ in reference to the GamerGate controversy.

The other two Tweets were labelled transphobic, with one using the hashtag #WontBeErased (used to discuss trans experiences in America) to promote GOG’s PC games.

The other replied to an innocent Tweet about guys gaming with unoriginal gag ‘Did you just assume their gender?!’.

There’s some things to say in CD Projekt Red’s defence though, even if the Twitter mobs tend to completely ignore grey areas.

The first is that Halliday wasn’t a dev. There’s nothing to suggest his attitude reflects Cyberpunk 2077’s overall, but that hasn’t stopped the outcry.

This is all about the biggest scandals, after all, not the most sensible reactions.

The second caveat is that Halliday was fired after these tweets, seeing CDPR & GOG distance themselves from him. Interestingly, Halliday claims he’d drafted an apology but that GOG refused to run it, instead just putting out a statement that he had been dismissed.


7. Enemies Just Seem Compelled By Addiction

Cyberpunk 2077 Animals
CDPR

Onto the actual game itself. While there are some more legitimate grievances later in the list, this complaint does feel like a bit of a stretch, especially in isolation.

However, when coupled with some of the other contentious issues, it has garnered some negative press. It probably won’t affect too many peoples’ decisions on whether or not to actually buy the games, but it might diminish their enjoyment.

Or not; we’ve only see a tiny morsel of what CD Projekt Red have to offer, when all’s said and done.

However, the ‘Animals’ were probably the low point of the demo. They’re very generic, bulky antagonists who are only interested in ‘juice’; no real explanation for this is given.

The other villains, the Voodoo Boys, at least had some narrative. V has to work with them initially, and learns they’re obsessed with transcendence: the idea of uploading themselves to cyberspace.

They can give it all the fancy lingo they want, but right now it just feels like two groups compelled by addiction. If that’s the case, it’s way short of The Witcher’s nuance.

The depiction of the Animals and the Haitians have stirred up some controversy on its own too...


6. Lack Of Diverse Enemies

Cyberpunk 2077
CD Projekt RED

The ‘Animals’ shown were all people of colour, and a few who got their hands on the demo reported feeling uncomfortable. After all, you spend the early exchanges of the game killing faceless, nameless black men only referred to as ‘Animals’.

If you squint a little, you can kind of see what they’re going for.

Taking race off the table, juice-addicted criminals are faceless monsters, dehumanised to make them easier to kill. It’s dystopian propaganda messaging 101.

Taking race off the table is easier said than done in 2019, especially for a game with a title which is inherently political.

Now, CD Projekt Red have insisted that the ‘Animals’ are a variety of races, and it was just the starting district which caused them to all be of colour. If that’s the case, fine. It’s arguably more realistic than even the multi-racial gangs often shown in media.

They surely should’ve twigged that if they were only going to show a snapshot, they were going to draw some ire from their (as it stands) heavy handed depictions of morality along race lines. As well as the Animals, the Voodoo Boys have been caught in the blowback too.


5. Racial Caribbean Stereotypes

Cyberpunk 2077 Voodoo Boys
CDPR

In order to get to grips with the wicked nature of the city, most of the characters you meet early are baddies, and with V starting in Pacifica (the Caribbean district), most of them are Caribbean; more specifically Haitian.

Having been told not to trust the people of Pacifica by a white man, one of your earliest experiences to be robbed by Pacificans. It feels like that’s supposed to be a double bluff gotcha, where the game has apparently subverted expectations by doing exactly what it said it would.

If that’s what they’re going for, it’s somewhat understandable, and paints a dog eat dog picture of Night City. Still though, it’s just a white guy telling you not to trust the black people, then the black people rob you.

As you play more, apparently, you’ll meet some less stereotypical characters who depict Caribbean culture in a more positive light. It does seem like there’s been some second hand offence here, similar to people upset at Mexican stereotypes in Super Mario Odyssey’s Tostarena.

Several actual Haitians (like actual Mexicans) have responded with excitement that their people will be in the game, with many of the detractors players offended on the Haitians’ behalf.


4. Hypersexualised Trans Billboard

Cyberpunk Transgender Ad
CD Projekt RED

Leading into that comes another thorny issue.

It’s one of those things where if potential racial insensitivity is a non issue for you, this probably will be as well. That’s fine and all, but arguments to keep politics out of video games ring hollow when the game is called "Cyberpunk".

The genre has a rich history of transhumanism, anti-corporate, anti-objectivism, pro-proletariat and counter-culture themes. It was built on politics.

If CD Projekt Red is going to wade into that conversation, it’s going to attract attention.

It was reported recently that Cyberpunk will (possibly) allow you to play as a transgender or non-binary character; more on that later. This was set against a backdrop of a highly sexualised poster featuring a transwoman with a huge cybernetic bulge and the tagline ‘mix it up’.

The in your face sexual imagery would be eye grabbing in any case, but on a feminine body, that’s amplified ten times over. No publicity is bad publicity though, and the billboard itself isn’t inherently negative.

CD Projekt Red’s response has been pretty good so far, but they’ve yet to really back it up. This is where the scandal gets a little deeper...


3. The Billboard Is Supposed To Be Part Of A Wider World... But We’ve Not Seen It

Cyberpunk 2077 Poster
CDPR

CD Projekt Red’s response to the billboard was actually pretty measured, and has given some people confidence that Cyberpunk 2077 will be able to pull off such boundary pushing social commentary.

CDPR’s artist Kasia Redesiuk claimed ‘hypersexualisation is everywhere’ in the game, and the billboard model is deliberately ‘displayed there as a thing’; an apparent symbol for corporations abusing people’s desires and dressing up their practices in rainbow capitalism.

Transwomen, and to an extent queer people in general, have frequently been fetishised in media, so if this focus is actually the game making a self-aware commentary, that’s great.

However, this is a hard message to sell. There needs to be some NPCs to balance things out.

If we see real gender non-conforming characters displayed as more than their body parts, or can even ‘mix it up’ with V ourselves, Cyberpunk will be pushing the boundaries in the best possible way.

Remember, this isn’t about documenting what Cyberpunk has done wrong or reasons not to buy. While some won’t have cared at all, the clunky focus on gender nonconformity has gotten people heated on both sides of the debate.

With that in mind, it’s been one of the biggest powder kegs of the marketing so far.


2. You Might Be Able To Play As A Trans Or Non-Binary Character

Cyberpunk 2077
CD Projekt RED

On the opposite end to the social/political spectrum to those up in arms about the fetishistic portrayal of a transwoman comes the revelation you might be able to make your V transgender or non-binary.

Though, again, the majority don’t particularly care, some have described the move as pandering, causing said controversy. You do have to say though if any given player would rather play as cisgender, they’ll definitely be able to; it’s extremely likely the vast majority of players will do that, too.

Whether this means male voices on ostensibly female Vs (or vice versa), or something more complex like mixing up sex characteristics or giving a feminine V a cybernetic bulge of our own remains to be seen.

Though gaming continues to be dominated by straight white male characters, there’s definitely more diversity around these days. With that does come controversy, though most in and around the industry would argue it’s worth it; more demographics means more enjoyment for all and, cynically, more customers.

Celeste’s creator Matt Thorson recently came out as non-binary, and they’ve become an overnight trailblazer. The future looks set to be more inclusive, but there’ll certainly be people upset/angry/offended (check those which apply) on the way.


1. Crunch Time

CD Projekt RED
CD Projekt RED

This is a controversy which is by no means unique to CD Projekt Red, but more of an overarching issue in the games industry overall. In fact, alongside microtransactions and loot boxes, it’s arguably the biggest controversy facing gaming today.

Crunch is the name given to the mandatory overtime at the end of a game’s development cycle as the pressure of release deadlines increase. CDPR are far from the only company to use such a practise (Rockstar have come under fire for it before most notably), but they were heavily criticised in the wake of crunch for The Witcher III.

Naturally then, they’ve been asked about crunch in regards to Cyberpunk 2077, and their response has been a little sketchy.

CDPR’s co-founder Marcin Iwinski and studio head Adam Badowski have admitted in a joint statement that a crunch time approach is ‘not for everyone’, but believe it is worth it, and ‘just require[s] a lot of faith, commitment and spirit’.

It sounds like typical industry speak where developers are expected to forgo sane working hours and their own mental health for the good of the game. There will apparently be a ‘more humane’ approach to crunch time on Cyberpunk, but some remain unconvinced.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)