8 Video Game Monsters That Were Absolutely Terrifying (Until You Saw Them)
How do you mess up a horror game? Let you see the horror.

I'm putting it out there - horror as a genre is just plain better when you're controlling the action on screen. Think about it: As a passive viewer of any given film, be it in the cinema or at home, you're relegated to merely reacting to everything.
Volume-spiking jump-scares are the most common (and the most cheap) but after that, many directors fall back on a particularly 'horrifying' monster design or tension-building cinematography to bring out the chills. In gaming though, you are ostensibly in that role, piloting your camera and characters through the world, opening each door, seeing what's round every corner and contemplating how much you want to hang back and assess your options, before pushing forward regardless.
When the lights go out and something's inevitably "in there with you", they're REALLY in there with you. However, not all games stick the landing. As was the case in Stranger Things and its weird, plant-headed zombie... thing, some talked-about, amped-up uber bosses can actually look a bit naff.
Let me know in the comments which video game monsters were absolutely terrifying... until you actually saw them.
--
8. Nemesis - Resident Evil 3: Nemesis

Yup, this big ol' stack of pork products. Nemesis was front and centre for the entire rollout of Resident Evil 3. His intimidating stature translated into a menacing presence in-game too, as gameplay revolved around staying out of his way, learning where best to evade and how to get the hell out of Dodge whenever he randomly appeared.
Such a spontaneous approach was more than effective, as Nemesis became the digital embodiment of some unforeseen powerful force that haunted your nightmares.
Then you saw him up-close, and... not so much.
It wasn't that Nemesis just looked like an overgrown slab of meat in some overalls, but that his attacks did jack-all damage. It's one thing to feel the pressure of having some unstoppable force close in on you, but if that's quickly followed up by said force wailing on you and barely making a dent, it completely ruins the moment.
Good on paper and terrible in game? That's Resi 3's Nemesis to a tee.
7. The Manpigs - Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs

Harbouring what's easily one of the most effective and outright terrifying atmospheres of all time, the beginning hours of A Machine for Pigs are Victorian goth-horror done exquisitely well.
Travelling through dank, cobbled streets and continually hearing bumps in the distance or behind you, you'll uncover notes and documentation about the horrors that other individuals have seen (or been killed by). Talks of a 'half-man, half-pig' hybrid paint all sorts of pictures in your mind, and the squeals that echo from the other side of many doorways or from around corners do the rest.
This is petrifying, and it's a testament to how much your imagination runs wild with expectation, that any developer (in this case, The Chinese Room) can just never match.
When you finally get eyes on any of the Manpigs, sadly, they look and animate terribly. It feels as though the entire game's budget went into the environments and sound effects, leaving nothing for the character models that were so essential to the full package.
Less Piggsy from Manhunt and more Porky Pig after being homeless for a month, these creatures ended up tanking the entire experience.
6. The Xenomorph - Alien: Isolation

The Alien may just be the single most iconic sci-fi character design in the history of cinema, and provided you're already scared by its appearance in any medium, the Isolation version does its job too.
However, in service of giving you some breathing room when going place to place, the way the Xeno animates tends to be more human than it's ever been on the silver screen. Whilst you see its vibrations in ventilation shafts above and all around you, hear it hissing as you slowly make your way around the Nostromo, the second you see it moving... yeah, it's not the best.
Considering the serpentine, slithering nature of its cinematic counterpart, I expected the game version to be sitting, waiting for me on ceilings, to literally come around the inside wall of a corner right when I was about to get a full view into the next room - anything that replicated its sporadic motions in the films.
Instead - and in gameplay terms, this was totally fine - we got what looked like a man in an Xenomorph costume, awkwardly prancing around before occasionally getting a gallop on and chasing you down. A far cry from the "perfect killing machine" you may have expected.
5. Carl Stucky - Alan Wake

A masterclass in paranoia and the cultivation of that quintessential, "Just what the F**K is going on?!" feeling, Alan Wake may not have beaten Max Payne as a followup to that game's film noir brilliance, but it did excel at putting you slap-bang in the centre of a Twin Peaks-style town, before drip-feeding a sensation of unease throughout.
By the time you'd lost your wife and been rendered helpless other than a revolver and flashlight, nothing beat those next few furtive steps. What would you find, how would you fight it, and y'know, what the hell was going o- you know how it goes.
The forest feels like it comes to life, a shadowy figure darts across the foreground, you'll even dispatch a number of inky underling enemies along the way, too - then you come across Stucky's Gas Station, only to find this figure is the owner, who's become possessed (or whatever) too.
After such a brilliant buildup, the fight against Stucky amounted to him saying bizarre phrases in a sped-up or slowed down fashion ("Caaaarl STUCKY!") as you awkwardly tried to fire off a few rounds to end the madness. Terrible.
4. Slender Man - Slender Man

Ever since Freddy Krueger brought the surrealist idea to the mainstream, certain people have found horror in the idea of elongated fingers or other protruding digits (calm down at the back).
Thus, Slender Man was born, a perfect horror character for any developer on a budget. And why? Because his whole 'thing' is, you can't look at him. The character only advances when you're not aware of him, you see, meaning the game excelled with fright-fans as the second they happened upon him, the game would flick to static and bam, they're satiated.
For the rest of us that didn't sprint out the room though, Slender Man has always looked just that wee bit too daft. He never actually does... anything really, and providing you're always looking at him, nothing happens. He's obviously done very well with Youtube streamers, but as an up-close character model, Slender Man poses about as much of a threat as a sentient packet of noodles.
Although, maybe that is quite scary...
3. Big Daddys - Bioshock

I wish, I WISH fighting or interacting with the Bioshock's Big Daddys (how weird is that to spell? Big Daddys, Big Daddies?) actually lived up to both the box art and their first appearance in the game.
Remember the first time you saw the thing in motion? A huge, hefting half-man, half-machine force of will, lumbering its way around the underwater city of Rapture, obliterating a threatening NPC and saving one of the Little Sisters.
How in the blue hell were we going to contend with that?!
The drill, the stature, the fact its mind didn't seem to have too much of a conscience outside of preternatural protection, when an in-game one came round the corner you braced for impact... only for it to butt into you repeatedly, until you killed it.
Like some overgrown moth in a helmet, there remains no real strategy to taking these things down. Instead you fire, get hit, heal, move a little, get hit, fire, repeat - it's truly testament to how awesome their character design is, that it overshadowed such terrible implementation.
2. The Regenerator - Resident Evil 4

Resi 4 remains a turning point for the franchise overall; the one where creative designer Shinji Mikami introduced way more action elements than ever before, and the one that haters of how Resi 5 and 6 turned out, point to as where it all went wrong.
To that end, the threats within Resi 4 are more routed in coming at you head-on, like the bag-wearing chainsaw villagers or the gigantic monster that lives in a mist-caked lake. One enemy that does play on the old-school fear of 'being in the room with you' though, is the Regenerator.
At least, it does, until you have to engage in combat.
Having first discovered these guys inside a cryogenics lab, your mind runs wild with the idea of what can happen to a frozen human body after it's exposed to the Las Plagas infection. The result is a giant bullet sponge, one that admittedly, makes some pretty freaky, breathless noises, but that you can put down either by dumping ammo into its chest, or taking out a couple of parasites located on its chest.
Considering the super-cool buildup and "I wonder how this thing is going to fight!" assumption that comes alongside, the fact it's an instant death-bringing, walking tank, was a bit of a letdown.
1. Pyramid Head - Silent Hill 2

Talk about him as one of 'the greatest horror characters in gaming', I've NEVER been able to take Pyramid Head seriously. I mean, just look at him.
Perhaps if we go down the route of 'things that should not be are inherently a bit scary', maybe, but for me, well... he's got a bathtub on his head.
Not to get too informal, but considering in Silent Hill 2 you first see this thing raping some mannequins (a horrific allusion to more mind-games and disturbing imagery that may follow), it's the subsequent boss encounters where you get to see his character model up close and personal that ruined everything for me.
From the first scene to the last - and especially if you've revisited Silent Hill after years of people telling you Pyramid Head was The Scariest Thing Ever - I'm putting this thing up there as a design that just falls way more into comedic territory than anything remotely horrifying.
--
What video game enemy had you on the edge of your seat... until you saw them? Let us know in the comments!