8 Video Game Protagonists Who Would Be Better Villains

These protagonists would make for TERRIFYING antagonists.

hitman 3
IO Interactive

Creating an iconic video game protagonist sure isn't easy, and typically requires developers to workshop the hell out of their design, write a great script, and then find a killer voice actor to help bring them to life.

And that's without even getting into the moment-to-moment gameplay - they also need to feel fun to control for potentially dozens of gaming hours. No easy feat.

But at the end of the day, sometimes it's tough not to think that some video game protagonists, for all of their apparent heroism, might actually be better-suited to being the villain.

While these characters all kicked a ton of ass in their respective games, their design, their personality, and their power-set all feel just one crappy day away from taking a turn to the dark side.

And so, it's easy to see how these gaming protagonists might actually be a better fit for the Bad Guy role, because who among us would want to get on their bad side and in turn experience their wrath?

If circumstances were just slightly different in these games, these characters would've surely been antagonists rather than protagonists...

8. Isaac Clarke - Dead Space

Dead Space
EA

Let's be real here - if any one of us saw Dead Space's Isaac Clarke walking towards us, we'd surely run a bloody mile.

With his armoured engineering suit complete with a creepy face helmet, Isaac straight-up looks like a slasher movie villain, to say nothing of the fact that he rocks some seriously hefty weaponry like his trusty Plasma Cutter, while also harbouring a penchant for stomping living things into a bloody paste.

And then there's Isaac's well-noted psychological issues, from the trauma of losing his girlfriend Nicole to effectively developing space dementia from his contact with the Marker.

Despite being the ass-kicking hero of Dead Space and a character millions love playing as, Isaac ticks so many damn villain boxes, and considering what he's been through, who could even blame him?

Honestly, a survival horror game where a crazy masked guy in a spacesuit is trying to rip us limb from limb sounds pretty damn awesome. 

With the Dead Space franchise basically being on ice for the foreseeable future, why the hell not?


7. Kratos - God of War

God of War Kratos
Sony Santa Monica

Kratos is unquestionably one of the most badass video game protagonists in history, but much like Dead Space's Isaac, you definitely wouldn't wanna meet him down a dark alley.

But even beyond his pant-pissingly intimidating visage - defined by his ape-like frame and piercing gaze - Kratos is one hell of a morally dubious protagonist.

In the original Greek-era trilogy of games, Kratos' quest for vengeance against the Gods left an ungodly amount of mortal bloodshed in his wake - sometimes entirely innocent folk whose only crime was standing in his way.

Consequences, schmonsequences.

And while Kratos absolutely cleans up his act by the time he enters his dad era, he's still a literal god capable of wielding the sort of power that nobody, anywhere, ever, should have to themselves.

In another game it'd be easy to picture Kratos as the final boss - the mythic villain the plucky Chosen One has to topple at the end against the odds, rather than a literal god-slaying goliath in his own right.

Honestly, the fact that many newer players find the original Greek games tough to play because Kratos is such a relentlessly blood-thirsty, nasty piece of work really says it all.


6. Max Caulfield - Life Is Strange

Life Is Strange Max
Dontnod Entertainment

Max Caulfield is of course the heroine of the Life Is Strange franchise, who manifests the ability to rewind time and endeavours to use it to resurrect her murdered friend Chloe - a decision which is ultimately left up to the player.

Yet as likeable as Max is throughout the franchise, it goes without saying that few people who develop the power to manipulate time would use it in a truly responsible way.

And more to the point, the series' own rules frequently demonstrate that messing with time has unintended, almost always negative consequences, such that the very act of tampering with time is, well, less than ideal.

And so, Max could so easily slip into the role of a time-tinkering supervillain - a possibility which was teased in last year's divisive sequel Life Is Strange: Double Exposure, where Max crosses paths with her own dubious future self.

There comes a point where screwing with the space-time continuum isn't just reckless or misguided, and in the wake of another sufficiently traumatic event, it'd be so easy for Max to become a temporal terrorist, forever trying to bend the universe to her will, no matter the mass-casualty calamities it causes.


5. Corvo Attano - Dishonored

Dishonored 2
Arkane Studios

Dishonored's protagonist Corvo Attano is freakin' awesome, because the game gives players so many potential abilities to make him an absolute menace.

His various supernatural powers include the ability to see foes through walls, perform short-distance teleportation, possess other characters, slow or freeze time entirely, summon swarms of rats, and turn dead enemies to ash. 

This is without even getting to Corvo's actual arsenal of tangible weapons, too.

That is to say, Corvo is basically a terrifying wraith of a human being, capable of liberating folk of their lives with stealthy precision, all while rocking a terrifying-ass mask that'd look more at home in a horror movie.

While Corvo's fear factor is dictated by each player's play-style, those who embrace a high chaos run will basically be playing Corvo as a merchant of death to be feared by folk both good and bad.

Imagine having to take him on as the end boss in a horror game, of needing to find a way to answer his stealth attacks and put him down.


4. Kirby - Kirby

Kirby
Nintendo

Don't let his adorable exterior and mere 20 inches of height fool you - Kirby is an abomination the sort of which Lovecraftian nightmares are made.

Kirby's suite of offensive and defensive abilities are as terrifying as they are mind-boggling - he can change the shape of his body to fend off a foe, inflate himself with air and fly, and even open his mouth to swallow enemies whole in an attempt to satisfy his apparently insatiable appetite.

More to the point, Kirby can adopt the characteristics of anyone he devours, and if this all somehow wasn't quite terrifying yet, he's also proven himself powerful enough to kill actual gods.

If you read this description sight-unseen, you'd more likely assume Kirby to be the big bad from a sci-fi horror film, not one of Nintendo's all-time most cute and popular mascot characters.

For as fun as Kirby is to play as, the experience of battling something so malleable and protean must be utterly oppressive.


3. Doomguy - Doom

Doom Eternal Doomguy
iD Software

In the grand pantheon of first-person shooter protagonists, there are precious few who can hold a candle to Doomguy. 

The ultra-buff, demon-hunting space marine may be a man of few words, but you can sure as hell hear him coming any time he enters a room and liquidates the assembled hellspawn.

And the current rebooted era of Doom games absolutely lean into the idea that Doomguy is such a fearsome legend at this point that many of the demons are straight-up scared of him, perceiving him as a demon himself.

And why the hell not? The man is basically a walking tank, can somehow carry an entire armory's worth of weapons on his person, and is able to effortlessly rip demons in half with his bare hands.

Everyone, no matter which "side" they're on, should absolutely be scared of Doomguy, because just imagine how utterly terrifying it'd be to have him on your tail.

The likes of B.J. Blazkowicz, Samus Aran, and Master Chief will ruin your day, but Doomguy will end you with extreme prejudice.


2. Agent 47 - Hitman

Hitman 3
IO Interactive

Few would profess Hitman's assassin protagonist Agent 47 to be a card-carrying hero - the man kills people for money, for heaven's sake, and even though many of his marks are ultimately awful human beings, it's a stretch to call him anything more than an anti-hero.

And 47 is so damn good at his job that it's easy to appreciate just how terrifying it'd be to have him assigned to your dirt nap.

With his basically preternatural ability to blend into just about any scenario - even with a barcode tattooed on his noggin, logic be-damned - and the endlessly creative means with which he can shuffle someone off their mortal coil, 47 is basically a force of nature unto himself.

He's tremendously fun to play as, then, but he'd also make for an absolutely terrifying stalker antagonist - a basically Terminator-like killing machine whose ability to infiltrate and eliminate without showing a flicker of emotion is virtually unrivaled.

Once 47 accepts a contract on you, you'll never rest easy ever again, but you also probably won't have too long to fret about it either.


1. Link - The Legend of Zelda

The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom Link
Nintendo

And finally we have The Legend of Zelda's Link, who is undeniably one of the most iconic video game heroes of all time. 

But oh, how things could be so different.

Link is silent and indomitable - he won't ever stop until the day is won, while being aided by a vast array of weapons and abilities, with new powers typically being introduced in each successive game.

Link's most notable abilities from past titles include time, matter, and weather manipulation, the power to transform into a wolf, and superhuman strength.

It's great for players, but just imagine if the shoe was on the other foot and all of this was coming at you - you probably wouldn't be making cracks about his goofy green tunic now, would you?

As a wordless warrior who is seemingly unstoppable despite his small stature, Link has as much in common with Kevin from Sin City as he does a typical hero. Just with less cannibalism, obviously.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.