9 Videogame Characters Who Were Punished Far Too Severely

Half-Life 2- Freeman Cover Videogames tend to take place in a world of absolutes €“ good versus evil, the bad guys versus the good guys. After all, it needs to be this way so we know what we're fighting against. If our enemies are quite nice chaps really, then it kind of takes the fun out of proceedings. I know some games like to upset the apple-cart with this rule but by and large, the goalposts remain the same. However, when we transfer this black-and-white thinking into more open-world or inventive games, we can occasionally see things go ever-so-slightly wrong, with groups of characters grabbing their torch and pitchforks for minor crimes or trivial actions. Such consequences can either be hilarious or ridiculous depending on where you find themselves €“ in some sandboxes, accidentally stealing a butter knife might inadvertently put you on the other end of a vigilante boomstick, and in others (GTA IV, for one) rear-ending a police car at no speed at all can result in a trip to the slammer. The point is that sometimes games have no idea of proper retribution, and anyone who's ended up in a firefight over spilled milk can attest to this truth. So with this in mind, I've decided to take a look at certain videogame characters where the punishment almost certainly did not fit the crime. In fact, the subjects of these punishments might've just been in the wrong place at the wrong time. Either way up, they fought the law, and the law hit them with a sack of bricks and then burnt down their house. Before we begin, I must point out that a SPOILER WARNING is in effect.

9. Fallout: New Vegas €“ The Courier Mildly Annoying A Faction Will Result In Hit-Squads

Fallout New Vegas - Caesar's Legion Fallout: New Vegas was lauded for implementing a system whereby you know where you stood with the various clans operating in the Mojave, upgrading the simple karma incarnation from the previous instalment. You could tell if the Followers treated you as a friend, and what side you were on in the NCR-Caesar€™s Legion ding-dong. However, there was absolutely no subtlety to the system, meaning people were more than happy to mow you down if you were in the €˜shunned€™ category. Now, I€™ve been shunned before, but that tends to just involve people not speaking to you for a while because you€™ve done something wrong. That€™s cool, I can get that. However, in post-apocalyptic Nevada, €˜shunned€™ and €˜heavily armed attack squads€™ seem to go hand in hand. I€™m serious €“ if you€™re treated with something below indifference, Caesar€™s Legion will send well-armed hit squads after you. While later on in the game you can probably swat them like annoying flies with your laser weaponry, this can even happen right at the start when you€™re armed with nothing but a pool queue, a broken pistol and a winning smile. It€™s frankly insane, although it does make clear why Caesar is so feared. Of course, this does happen in a society where a faction will hunt you with bullet-soaked fury for stealing a tin of beans inside their settlement, so swings and roundabouts really.

8. Skyrim €“ Shopkeepers Send Assassins After The Dragonborn For Stealing Pastries

Skyrim - The Dark Brotherhood We€™re staying with Bethesda now, because there€™s clearly going to be a morass of moral quandaries when you€™re able to steal absolutely anything that isn€™t nailed down. Yet as we all know, there€™s a way around doing this properly €“ you wait until that person€™s back is turned, and you pilfer to your heart€™s content. Some of the more inventive types will even put a bucket on the head of the vendor and just pillage everything. Yet occasionally, you will get rumbled, and bad things occur, usually involving fines. But occasionally, you get a retribution glorious in its perversity. Apparently, the shopkeeper saw you nick a sweetroll before gaily cantering outside, but they choose not to do anything about it at the most logical and effective time. Instead, they snap up the Dark Brotherhood, who will ambush you at some point because why the hell not. The first time it happens, you€™re actively confused €“ then you realise why it happened, and you start to take it as a necessary risk whenever you choose to pilfer in a shop. Apparently, a five gold penalty isn€™t enough €“ the people of Skyrim really like their trinkets, and are willing to send medieval ninjas after you to prove this.

7. The Darkness €“ Paulie Blows Up Orphans For Being In An Orphanage

The Darkness - Paulie As befitting a game called €˜The Darkness,€™ this wasn€™t exactly a cheery game. It€™s infamous for creating one of the most convincing relationships and emotionally intimate moments in gaming €“ when protagonist Jackie and his girlfriend Jenny watch TV just because €“ before snatching it away from you by having Paulie Franchetti slit her throat in front of you. Yet everyone seems to forget that the game committed its own undeserved fate moments before this trauma. That moment came when Paulie blew up Jackie€™s goddamned orphanage for no other reason than spite. Of course, as corresponding to Paulie€™s status as a villain, the orphans are all still inside, and suffer a brutal incineration entirely because they just so happened to dwell in the same building as a man who annoyed the mob. Seems unfair, really. I know Paulie didn€™t really like Jackie, but there had to be a better way to make that apparent than blowing up a load of innocent children. Maybe he could€™ve just sent him a strongly-worded letter, or something.

6. Half Life 2 €“ Gordon€™s Pro-Littering Stance Means A Deathly Beating

Half-Life - Rubbish The Half Life series (well, two games) are renowned for their excellent opening sequences, and Half Life 2€™s Welcome To City 17 was just as effective as Welcome To Black Mesa (yeah, you heard). The whole thing existed to make it clear that you lived under an inter-dimensional jackboot where individuals are rounded up and shot for colluding against the Combine. Yet according to this opener, the Combine classes refusing to pick up litter with the same sort of punishment they keep for enemies of the state. The moment comes when you€™re midway through your tutorial, and a truncheon-wielding guard demands you pick up a can and throw it away. If you don€™t do this, he will beat you to death, and believe me, a lot of people know this. Yes, I was one of the people who tried to get past him, but there€™s just no way you get round the environmentally-sound beating meant for you. This man just really loves the environment, and he€™s more than willing to turn you into compost if you don€™t share the same enthusiasm. As deaths go, it€™s heroically embarrassing.

5. Bioshock €“ Jack Will Die For Smashing Windows

Bioshock - Shops Glass breaks all the time €“ you can blast a football through it, objects can fall into it and if you€™re really unlucky (or living in a martial arts movie) you can go tumbling through it yourself. Either way up, accidents happen, and a situation involving broken glass can usually be resolved with an apology and a monetary sum. Yet in Rapture things don€™t quite work like that, apparently because Andrew Ryan just could not be bothered to hire any security or police force. I get that it might not be the most objectivist thing in the world, but there€™s such a thing as private security and sheriffs (no, not the cowboy kind), the people who give you a clip round the head for smashing a lovely shop window and then chase you for the bill, and if that's not ultra-capitalist, I don;t know what is. But instead of creating this arm to stave off unemployment (which, let€™s remember, Fontaine was able to use as a tool to beat Fontaine round the head with) he decides to subcontract the issue to robots, who will come and gun you down if you accidentally swing your wrench too near an Arcadia shop front. It€™s just so wildly ridiculous that it stands out even among the murder and mayhem of Bioshock. I€™ve never seen anti-vandalism enforced with such reckless retribution. Think about that next time you break something €“ at least you won€™t have flying machine-guns coming after you.

4. Fable 2 €“ The Assassination Targets Clearly Don€™t Deserve Their Fate

Fable - Assassintion As identified in the Skyrim slide, assassins aren€™t exactly a work-shy bunch. They€™ll take up arms for any reason at all if you give them enough coin, and that provides ample opportunities for abuse, Ridiculous, insane abuse, but abuse nonetheless. Possibly the most notorious example of this comes in Fable 2, where as befitting the sandbox-game situation, you€™re free to go around and do whatever you want, even if the concept €˜whatever you want€™ seems to differ between the players and Peter Molyneux. But anyway, enough sniping €“ Fable 2 does let you join an Assassins Guild and carry out duties as befitting an assassin. Of course, with assassinations comes a mark, and usually, you€™d believe that people have done some pretty terrible things to deserve a fate on the pointy end of a paid blade. Well, not in Fable 2 they don€™t €“ people are executed for all sorts of strange reasons, including an overdue library book, selling a half-eaten box of chocolates, believing they€™re funny, or even if they €˜win€™ the draw of the week. With such low standards, I€™m surprised there€™s anyone left in Fable€™s world.

3. Various Zelda Games €“ Attack A Cucco And Receive Death By Poultry

Legend of Zelda - Cuccos Now, I don€™t condone attacking animals, but if that animal is usually edible and delicious, then perhaps I€™ll make an exception. Well apparently, a lot of other people did as well, choosing to terrifying the Cuccos that litter the Zelda universe whenever they can, maybe out of cruelty or maybe because they earnestly believed they could turn that chicken into food. However, they didn€™t count on the fact the Cuccos appear to be even more powerful than Ganon, for they are Cuccos , and they are legion. Honestly, if you swing a blade at the walking poultry, they will summon all their friends and swarm you like the coward you are until you drown in invincible hen-feathers. Occasionally €“ and increasingly less often €“ you€™ve just got to tip your cap to Nintendo. I€™m willing to bet that their ridiculous decision to create some sort of Cucco guerrilla army inspired at least one vegetarian, and almost certainly had young gamers refusing to go anywhere near chickens out of fear that if they touch it, the rest will blitzkrieg them into submission. If PETA could make people believe this will happen, there€™d be no need for all the trolling publicity.

2. Max Payne 3 €“ Marcelo Gets Necklaced For A Cover-Up

Max Payne - Marcelo If you don€™t know what necklacing is, congratulations €“ you€™ve gone far enough without reading about something truly horrific. If you still don€™t wish to know, click on the next slide €“ it€™s not very nice at all. Go on, I don€™t mind. Still here? Ok then. Well, necklacing is an execution practice either originating in Brazil or South Africa where the subject has a tyre stuck around their neck €“ hence, €˜necklacing€™ €“ filled with petrol and then lit, causing the unfortunate soul wearing the tyre to die via a combination of fire and molten rubber. People have been known to live for anywhere between 15 and 30 minutes after the tyre is lit, so it€™s really not a good way to go at all. So spare a thought for Marcelo in Max Payne 3. The bloke€™s hardly evil €“ his main fault appears to be his jealousy for his older brother, yet even when Max kills him he€™s utterly distraught. So when this man gets necklaced by vigilantes/corrupt cops to shift the blame for the Max Payne-related carnage onto the Favela€™s local gangs, you€™ve got to feel for him. He was just a nice idiot, and he dies in the most painful way imaginable, when they could€™ve killed him quickly. It€™s just unremittingly brutal, and utterly undeserved, even if you didn€™t like the bloke.

1. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas €“ CJ Buries A Foreman Alive For Wolf-Whistling

CJ - Grand Theft Auto San Andreas Carl Johnson is not the most stable man. He€™s got a bodycount larger than most dictators, knows his way around a tank, a harrier jump-jet, most weaponry and combines all of this with a thoroughly amoral outlook on life. So when you get on his or his family€™s bad side, expect Los Santos€™ resident bullet sponge to turn up on your doorstep, furious. Of course, the problem seems to be that CJ thinks violence is the answer to everything €“ there€™s no option to sit down and talk to your victims, or even to fire your gun into the air True Crime-style, so if you wish to make your point, you€™re going to need a trip to Ammu-nation and/or a baseball bat, even in the most ridiculous circumstances. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the San Fierro construction yard mission, where CJ€™s sister Kendra takes umbrage with some builders from the yard behind their property wolf-whistling her. Now, I am not a woman (at least not since the operation) so I can€™t really tell you how demeaning having a pack of builders yell obscene things at you is, but I'm sure it's not a good thing. Kendra€™s right to get her brother involved to stop them doing it, yet what CJ does is just insane €“ he goes to a bulldozer, bundles a Foreman-housing portaloo into a hole and pours concrete on it, burying the poor chap alive. Strangely, Kendra seems happy with this act of pitch-perfect insanity, meaning they take sexual harassment damn seriously in San Andreas €“ except with the prostitutes of course, apparently they don€™t seem to count. Agree or disagree? Can you think of any more? Fee free to comment!

Contributor
Contributor

Durham University graduate and qualified sports journalist. Very good at sitting down and watching things. Can multi-task this with playing computer games. Football Manager addict who has taken Shrewsbury Town to the summit of the Premier League. You can follow me at @Ed_OwenUK, if you like ramblings about Newcastle United and A Place in the Sun. If you don't, I don't know what I can do for you.