Assassin's Creed: 10 Times The Templars Were Right

Are we SURE these are the bad guys?

Assassin's Creed 3
Ubisoft

Ever since its debut title, Assassin's Creed has become known for its war between the Assassins and the Templars. Throughout the history of humanity, these two groups have clashed over ideologies and squared off on literally every continent in the pursuit of their goals. Numerous and significant blows have been exchanged by both sides over the years however, at their cores, they pretty much share the same hope for the world: peace.

Whilst the Assassins believe in peace through freedom and liberty, the Templars are a bit more grey when it comes to pursuing an end to tyranny and injustice. Often a lot more brutal in their methods and, more often than not, prone to a fair amount of corruption, The Templar Order believes in peace through order, control and direction from above.

Nevertheless, with so many games, characters and history behind them, it's inevitable that sometimes the good guy/bad guy roles get changed up a bit. Just because players mostly see things from an Assassin point of view, doesn't necessarily mean that is view they should take as gospel.

There are many examples of Templars with nobler goals, more ambitious and logical plans, or those a bit more clued up than their Assassin counterparts.

10. George Monro's Genuine Longing For Better Livelihoods - Assassin's Creed Rogue

Assassin's Creed rogue
Ubisoft

Assassin's Creed Rogue's General George Monro was a Templar unlike any other players had encountered before. A gifted general and close friend of Haytham Kenway, Monro was responsible for saving Shay Cormac when he was discovered adrift and unconscious, despite the fact that his fellow Templars urged him to leave him be.

Munro would also prove to be the guiding hand behind Shay's rise to the Templar's attention, updating Haytham with the young man's skills and informing him of his hopes that he might be turned to the Order.

There have been plenty of generals in the Assassin's Creed series that have been made out to either be ruthless cowards or brutal careerists, however Monro was portrayed as being the exact opposite to both of these. He's somewhat timid and silver-tongued, but remains a genuinely caring and empathetic individual towards his troops.

As a Templar, he believed himself to be a protector of the common man against an Assassin Order who didn't seem to care about the innocent lives they took in their pursuit of freedom.

Unlike the Assassins, he was able to look past someone's prior faults or choices, and went out of his way to ensure his troops with 'full bellies and warm clothing'.


9. Ahmet Wanting To Rid The World Of Blood Feuding - Assassin's Creed Revelations

The eldest son of Bayezid III and the heir to the Ottoman throne, as well as being the head of the Byzantine Rite of Templars, Ahmet's whole world view came from an unshakable belief in wanting to rid his lands of the constant blood feuding that was running rife across his lands at the time.

Suffering from that age-old Templar issue of thinking that his position was set in stone, his expedition to find the Masayf Keys and unlock the power of the mysterious Grand Temple eventually brought him into conflict with Ezio Auditore.

Though things would begin to unravel pretty quickly for Ahmet however, and he certainly showed off his wild side from time to time, it can't be denied that he was definitely onto something in believing public image and fairer distribution of wealth would be the secret to ridding the Ottoman Empire of its all its feuding.

Even some of his rivals in Assassin's Creed Revelations would remark that Ahmet, if nothing else, was genuinely sincere in his beliefs. Though the Assassins and Ottomans did indeed brings his plans to an end, they couldn't point to anything that suggested their way of doing things was any better than Ahmet's by the time the game's finale rolled on by.


8. Ben Hornigold's Nassau Assessment - Assassin's Creed Black Flag

Betraying the undeniably loveable Edward Kenway is not the best way of convincing anyone that you're a man in the right of things, but Ben Hornigold probably had more going for his rationale than most others in Assassin's Creed Black Flag.

One of the founding fathers of the free and equal city of Nassau, Hornigold's attitude actually remains fairly consistent throughout the entire game. His loathing of the imperialist empires and their oppressive regimes matched the Templars perfectly, and he found himself being driven into their arms after a visit by Woodes Rodgers.

His final standoff with Edward is where Hornigold really lets his mentality be known. Hornigold points out that they had all been living as free men on their supposed utopia of Nassau for years and asked where it had gotten any of them.

At that point in the story, it's a pretty damning thing for Edward to think about.

The Assassins had been on the verge of collapse for pretty much the entirety of the game, all of Edward's friends were either dead or growing sick of the sight of him, and his free, selfish thinking had left him with no legacy and no real identity.


7. Elisé's New Templar Order - Assassin's Creed Unity

Though Assassin's Creed has occasionally shown Assassins and Templars being aware of one another, very few games have tried to have one member from each faction grow up and remain as close as Arno and Elise were in Assassin's Creed Unity.

Growing up as a Templar, Elise's world view came from understanding what was expected of woman of her time; subsequently going against most of these norms. A free spirit and exceptionally steadfast in her own beliefs, Elise's stubbornness was what separated her most from Arno, and kept her in line with the Order.

Elise would soon become embroiled in a bitter series of in-fights with Francois-Thomas Germain over the role of the Templar Order and its beliefs over the French Revolution. Germain believed that the Order had become corrupted by its continued association with the aristocracy and needed to be purged and restarted from the ground up.

Elise, on the other hand, followed a much more Haytham Kenway-inspired view on the Templar Order, believing that the conflict between themselves and the Assassins was pretty futile by the time Assassin's Creed Unity kicked off and worth bringing to an end.

It might have been a belief that proved to be instrumental in bringing about her death, but it was certainly proven right over the course of the game.


6. Crawford Starrick's Disdain Towards The Monarchy - Assassin's Creed Syndicate

It's fair to say that Crawford Starrick is a pretty bad dude. Assassin's Creed Syndicate's main baddie, Crawford Starrick is in many ways the ultimate Victorian industrialist. Thanks to a combination of shrewd business and a collection of powerful Templar connections, he owned businesses and influences right across the city of London and saw his profits sky rocket with the rise of British imperialism.

He also possessed that famous Templar greed, wanting to keep powerful artefacts such as the Shroud of Eden all to himself, even if individuals like Lucy Thorne had been instrumental in him finding it. Conservative, arrogant and with an unhealthy obsession for control, every move he made in the game was in the pursuit of better business and a stronger position for himself within the city.

However, underneath Starrick's nasty demeanour lay some pretty undeniable beliefs. For one, he was one of the most vocal voices on the inequality present in Victorian London, believing that the Monarchy, Church and upper classes were the biggest problem and a source of tyranny in the city.

Going out of his way to assassinate Queen Victoria might have been a bit too extreme, but points should go for wanting to move past social inequality.


5. The Pazzi Pointing Out The Medici Hypocrisy - Assassin's Creed II

Arguably the questline that really helped launch the popularity of the best Assassin's Creed game in the franchise, everything about The Pazzi Conspiracy is iconic at this point. The real-world historical accuracy and tie-ins to Ezio's origins made for a great combination, and the original trio of Vieri, Francesco and Jacopo were all so delightfully killable to players of the game.

What helped as well as the whole storyline being so relatively simple to understand. No mysterious artefacts (yet), no long-lost hidden temples or obscure prophecies, just a nice and simple plot to overthrow a powerful ruling family and take over a city for their nefarious goals.

However, there's undeniably something unsettling about the way in which the Medici family flaunted their wealth around the poor in the city, and certainly something deeply unsettling about what Lucrezia Borgia claims happened to the remaining innocent Pazzi family members following the failed conspiracy in Assassin's Creed Brotherhood.

Contemporary historians have also began to challenge how much of a 'Golden Age' the Medici reign of Florence really was, and some even go so far as to say that The Pazzi Conspiracy was far more of a pushing back against a ultra-powerful family than just a resentful group of traitors striking out.


4. Torres And The Hunt For The Observatory - Assassin's Creed Black Flag

Assassin's Creed Black Flag's Governor Torres is perhaps one of the best examples of the goals and ideologies of the Templar Order coming together properly. Smooth talking, devout and unnervingly fixated on his goals, Torres was also in vocal opposition to things such as slavery and, on more than one occasion, spared some of his staunchest enemies from unnecessary violence.

Throughout Black Flag's story, he is constantly trying to steer Edward away from a course that will his force his hand, and is one of the few Templars in the game to never really look down on anyone beneath his social status.

Torres' fixation on finding and making use of the Observatory is also fairly admirable. The heart of his plan revolved around capturing Bartholomew Roberts and using the power of the Observatory to control the British, Spanish and other imperialist empires around the world from the shadows. Though this might be closer to 'slavery-ish' than it is to world peace, there's no denying that Torres and the Templars plan certainly carried more potential for good than the Assassins plan of simply doing nothing at all.


3. Shay Cormac Turns Against The Assassins - Assassin's Creed Rogue

Assassin's Creed Rogue is, besides a glorified DLC for Black Flag, a game that really goes out of its way to try and flip things on their heads and change everyone's perspectives on the Templar/Assassin debate. Instrumental to this is main character Shay Cormac, an Assassin-turned-Templar who players see the entire game through the eyes of.

Shay's loyalties to the Assassin way of life changed when he was tasked with recovering two Pieces of Eden that the Templars had stolen from Achilles Davenport and his Colonial Brotherhood. Though he had been musing over their methods prior to his arrival at the First Civilization Temple, the earthquake he triggered in pursuit of the artefacts brought about a whole new awareness for the innocent lives the Assassins were claiming in the pursuit of freedom.

His Brotherhood's inability and eventual refusal to deviate away from their methods really left Shay no choice but to turn rogue and eventually join up with the Templars. Constantly in search of a way of sparing innocents and helping others (even going as far as stopping the mighty Haytham Kenway from killing Achilles), the only place for someone like Shay was with the one group at the time committed to preserving peace: the Templars.


2. Robert De Sable Calling Out Al Mualim - Assassin's Creed

Right from the opening memory of the original Assassin's Creed, Robert de Sable, 11th Grand Master of the Knights Templar, is shown to be public enemy number one to any self-respecting Assassin.

A brutal, formidable enemy to Altair and co., Robert is one of King Richard I's chief generals in the Third Crusade, but has been hard at work throughout the game trying to lure leading Crusaders and Saracens to his Templar Order. Genuinely believing he was on the road to securing peace for the Holy Land, albeit with any freedom for the people living within it, Robert was finally brought to justice by Altair on the eve of the Battle of Arsuf where the two clashed.

However, Robert had one final revelation for the Assassin to digest. The Templar Grand Master revealed that Assassin head honcho, Al Mualim, had been the evil mastermind behind the entire game's events and had only instructed Altair to kill all of his targets so that he could steal away the Piece of Eden and its powers for himself.

Robert was absolutely right of course, and his revelation to Altair undoubtedly remains one of the best moments in the entire Assassin's Creed franchise to this day.


1. Stopping The Revolution - Assassin's Creed III

When disillusionment towards the monarchy began to grow in the North American colonies on the eve of the American Revolution, Haytham Kenway and his Templar Order saw their opportunity. Throwing a whole load of fuel onto a keg ready to explode, Haytham and co. were instrumental in kickstarting the revolution with the end goal in mind of creating a nation where their Templar principles would eventually become law.

Throughout the entirety of Assassin's Creed III, Haytham is almost reduced to pleading with Connor to understand that his Order wanted to bring an end to the fighting between Colonials, Natives, Assassins and Templars alike.

Haytham pointed out that it was actually Washington that had ordered the burning of Connor's village and that it had been the Templars, not the Assassins, that had been instrumental in freeing his people from slavery in the past.

Haytham again points out that both he and Connor oppose the same things: tyranny, injustice and suppression of the people. Where the two diverge is with Haytham's example of Washington's flawed reasoning and the imperfections of giving people the freedom to make errors, something which Connor reluctantly agrees is present, but hopes improves in the future.

In many ways, Haytham's dreams of a peaceful world in which people are given control and direction isn't so sinister after all.


Contributor
Contributor

Horror fan, gamer, all round subpar content creator. Strongly believes that Toad is the real hero of the Mario universe, and that we've probably had enough Batman origin stories.