Casting The Perfect Red Dead Redemption Film

One of the greatest games of all time could become one of the greatest westerns of all time...

Ian McShane Red Dead Redemption
Rockstar

Film adaptations of video games have a rather poor reputation. Whether it was because of a lack of respect for the source material, a storyline that made no sense or characters that were nothing like their gaming counterparts, there are many reasons why fans are more worried than optimistic about a film version of their favourite games.

But things have gotten better over the years. Detective Pikachu and Sonic the Hedgehog performed well at the box office, and the Castlevania animated series on Netflix has won universal praise. If these franchises can be successfully adapted into films and tv shows, then there is still hope that the same success could be achieved with other games.

There are many incredible games fans would love to see get their chance on the big screen, and one such game is Rockstars iconic western, Red Dead Redemption. John Marston’s hunt for his former gang members would make for a thrilling cinematic experience, if done correctly.

Such a film would require a star-studded cast of actors capable of bringing all of the games key characters to life. So without further ado, here is, for your consideration, the perfect cast for a Red Dead Redemption film...

11. Josh Brolin As John Marston

No Country For Old Men Josh Brolin Moss
Miramax Films/Paramount Vantage

After becoming an orphan at 8 years old and killing his first man aged 11, John Marston was adopted into the Dutch Van Der Linde Gang when he was just 12.

This upbringing led to John developing into a seasoned outlaw of the American frontier whom Dutch often referred to as his “golden boy”, much to the envy of his fellow gang members. Now he must hunt down the surviving members of his old gang in order to earn his family's freedom from Edgar Ross.

Whom so ever should play the role of Marston must be able to portray his ruthless and aggressive manner, but is also able to make the audience like him enough that they want to see him succeed.

Josh Brolin seems to tick all the boxes for this role. He is an experienced actor with an impressive résumé of films under his belt. His roles in films like Deadpool 2, Sicario and No Country For Old Men should be evidence enough that he can play a ruthless and experienced killer with ease.

His performance in the remake of True Grit is also a testament to how well he can fit into a western setting.


10. Bryan Cranston As Edgar Ross

Bryan Cranston
AMC

If John Marston was one side of a coin, Edgar Ross would most certainly be on the other. He is a well dressed, intelligent and self-righteous individual who believes that everything he does is in the best interests of America and its people. He is also the mastermind who took Martson’s family into custody so that he could strong-arm him into hunting down his former gang members.

Despite leaving Marston to work alone for the most part, Ross accompanies him in his pursuit of Dutch Van Der Linde, leading to a rough exchange of words between the two. Where John points out the hypocrisy of Ross’ work and the means to which he achieves his goals, Ross constantly talks down to Marston in his self-righteous, condescending way.

It’s a role that requires an actor who can demand the same level of fear and respect that the character does, and for this, there are few better suited than Bryan Cranston.

Cranston’s many incredible monologues in Breaking Bad demonstrate how good he is at capturing the audience's attention and conveying what his character's true feelings are, which makes him the perfect to play Edgar Ross.


9. Ian McShane As Dutch Van Der Linde

Ian Mcshane Hercules
Paramount Pictures

Dutch would describe himself as the American equivalent of Robin Hood, the personification of the Wild West and a champion for true freedom and liberty in the face of government oppression. But the actions of Dutch and his gang would prove that they were no better than any common outlaw.

Throughout Marstons hunt for Dutch, we hear him reminisce about what kind of man he really was and how important he was to Marston and other members of the gang. In some instances, Dutch sounds like an honourable and kind man. But when Marston finally tracks him down, we see him at his most dangerous and most savage.

The years had not been kind to him, but he still has the same silver tongued bandit leader that was able to entice the downtrodden and vulnerable into working for him.

Ian McShane seems like the ideal actor to turn to in order to bring this anarchistic-spouting gang leader to life.

Like a few others on this list, McShane has a wealth of experience with characters like Dutch and could steal the show if he was ever given the part.


8. Rachel McAdams As Abigail Marston

Rachel McAdams True Detective
HBO

Rachel McAdams has played a wide variety of characters in both film and television. From her breakout role as the manipulative teenager Regina George in Mean Girls, McAdams has become a well known and successful actress whose career shows little signs of slowing down.

In the last few years, McAdams has gained praise for her performances in films such as Southpaw and Doctor Strange and the second season of True Detective, with the latter having her play the more stern and determined Antigone "Ani" Bezzerides.

It’s because of these performances, and others, that make McAdams a good fit to play Abigail Marston.

An orphan who grew up scraping off a living from bars and brothels across Western America, Abigail is a no-nonsense, straight-talking woman who will do whatever it takes to protect her son Jack and survive in an unforgiving world. After joining the Van Der Linde Gang as a prostitute, she eventually fell in love with John and gave birth to Jack, but he would often doubt that he was his real father.

It would be entertaining to see McAdams evoke the same fire and tenacity fans had come to expect and love from Abigail.


7. Jeff Bridges As Uncle

Jeff Bridges The Big Lebowski
Working Title Films

Uncle was certainly a very different character compared to most people in Red Dead Redemption. Where most people were either resourceful, intelligent, ruthless or all of these things at once, Uncle was always the good for nothing slouch who was just there for comedy relief.

Always asleep or unwell when work needs done, but wide awake when there is whiskey on the go, it was always a mystery why Uncle was allowed to be a part of the Van Der Linde Gang in the first place. But despite his lack of enthusiasm to do any form of manual labour, Uncle was still an unforgettable character of the Red Dead series.

After living a life of petty crime, Uncle was able to redeem himself by demonstrating his strong sense of loyalty to Marston and his family when he gave his life to defend them from the surprise attack by Ross and the US Army.

He would not have to do much, but Jeff Bridges would certainly be able to nail the characters mannerism and personality, much like he did in The Big Lebowski when he played The Dude.


6. Noah Schnapp As Jack Marston

Stranger Things 3 Will Byers Noah Schnapp
Netflix

Although Jack would not play a major role in the films overall story, you may as well make sure you get one of the best child actors around.

Born and raised amongst the Van Der Linde Gang for almost all of his childhood, Jack had to adjust to life on the road and developed a love for the outdoors and nature as a result. However, Jack's relationship with his father would always be a rocky one. He resents his father for getting the family into more trouble and not being around to raise him or look after the family ranch.

It is this conflict between Jack and John Marston where Noah Schnapp could be allowed to shine. After John has finished his business with Ross and the government, he tries to rekindle his relationship with Jack, leading to a few harsh words between the two, but also a few moments of endearment and bonding.

Schnapp has proven in both the film IT and the television series Stranger Things that he is able to talk about mature subject matter with a believable performance and would be able to handle the role of Jack Marston with ease.


5. Jessica Chastain As Bonnie MacFarlane

Miss Sloane Jessica Chastain
EuropaCorp

Marston’s hunt for his old gang members could not have gotten off to a worse start, as he is left for dead at the hands of Bill Williamson. But when it looks like our hero's journey was going to end before it even began, in comes Bonnie MacFarlane. She takes Marston in, pays a doctor to tend to his wounds and offers him a place to stay in exchange for his help around her ranch.

Her life story is a prime example of what kind of hardship people who settled on the American Frontier had to go through, but also what they were able to achieve because of their hard work.

Bonnie proves to be a valuable ally to Marston in his pursuit of Bill Williamson, and Jessica Chastain would prove to be a perfect choice to play her in any film adaptation.

Her roles in some of the most recent blockbuster successes such as The Martian, Interstellar and Zero Dark Thirty are evidence enough of her acting talents and how she would be able to deliver a strong performance as the determined and steadfast Bonnie.


4. Paul Giamatti As Nigel West Dickens

Paul Giamatti Mean Gene
WC

The Wild West was certainly the land of opportunity for all kinds of people. This was especially the case for one lying and cheating degenerate known as Nigel West Dickens.

Nigel was a con artist hiding under the disguise of a travelling salesman, who promised anyone unfortunate enough to be drawn in with his sales pitch that any ailment they had could be cured with his miracle elixir. Fortunately, Marston is able to see through Nigels lies, but does aid him with selling his elixir so long as Nigel helps him in return.

The dynamic between the two is fun to watch, as they are both experienced in getting money from people through dishonest means, but have very different styles and personalities.

Paul Giamatti is the perfect pick to play Nigel as he has a proven track record of strong supporting roles in films like Saving Mr Banks and The Illusionist. His recent success on tv show Billions further demonstrates his abilities.

Paul would be capable of bringing the showmanship side of Nigel to life while also being a great contrast to some of the more serious characters in the film.


3. Jason Clarke As Bill Williamson

Burt Young Jason Clarke Chinatown
Penthouse/20th Century Fox

Jason Clarke has had a decent run as an actor in television, but it’s his recent success in films that has seen his career reach new heights.

Clarke has appeared in both starring and supporting roles in Lawless, Zero Dark Thirty, The Great Gatsby, Dawn Of The Planet Of The Apes, Terminator Genisys, First Man and Pet Sematary, all while earning great praise from fans and critics. His rugged appearance and gritty appearance, combined with his exceptional acting, would make him the best choice to play the loud and proud Bill Williamson.

After his dishonourable discharge from the US Army, Bill ended up becoming an alcoholic and robbing people on the highways. He would eventually join the Van Der Linde Gang as a gunman and was especially loyal to Dutch, even while he was slowly descending into madness. But after the gang broke up, Bill was forced to fend for himself, which led to him developing a much darker personality.

Jason would be the ideal choice to play a broken and enraged Bill Williamson, who forms his own gang and terrorises the people of the American Frontier with arson, kidnapping and murder.


2. Michael Mando As Javier Escuela

Michael Mando
Ubisoft

Michael Mando has come a long way from starring as Vaas Montenegro, the main antagonist in Far Cry 3. He has since gone on to star as Mac Margan, a.k.a Scorpion, in Spider-Man Homecoming and as Nacho Varga in Better Call Saul. All of these performances and others highlight Mando’s ability to play a character that should be feared for their lethal intentions and intimidating demeanour.

Which is why it should be a foregone conclusion that he would do an exceptional job playing the role of Javier Escuella.

Javier was forced to flee to America after he became a wanted man for the murder of a former military leader and for spreading revolutionary ideas. This was how he came to meet Dutch and became a member of his gang, who he came to see as his true family and home. When the gang broke up and Javier returned to Mexico, he ironically became the private hitman of Colonel Allende and was under the protection of the Mexican Army.

Javier is as loyal and passionate as he is deadly and resourceful. Characteristics that Mando would have no problem showing off in his performance of Javier.


1. Quentin Tarantino As Director And Writer

Quentin Tarantino
filmbuffonline

Now just because you are able to put together a great cast and crew, does not mean you are guaranteed a successful film. There are plenty of examples of studios going out of their way to assemble some of the best talent, only to forget that a film is only as good as its script and director.

For a film adaptation of Red Dead Redemption, it would need someone who can juggle all the different storylines and characters while also delivering an entertaining and cinematic experience that remains true to the source material. Red Dead is, of course, a western, but also has many memorable moments of drama, action and dark humour.

So it should come as no surprise whatsoever that Quentin Tarantino would be the first name on this, and many other peoples list for the job.

Tarantino has a successful list of films under his belt, such as his crime drama Reservoir Dogs and his spaghetti western Django Unchained.

Were Tarantino allowed full creative control of the film, there is no doubt that he would be able to make a faithful adaptation that would please fans of the games and film audiences alike.


Watch Next


Contributor

I am an open minded guy who is always up for trying new things. I love playing video games, watching and critiquing the latest films and tv shows and a big fan of football. P.S, I hope you are all doing well during these challenging times and that you have a great day.