Fallout 4: 12 Early Reactions You Need To Know

The truth is finally revealed...

Fallout 4's worldwide release is imminent, but the gaming press have been lucky enough to have their hands on it for about a week prior to that, and are now dropping their impressions with the lifting of the embargo. Well, fans can breathe a sigh of relief that the game is scoring well with critics, sitting at around the 90 mark on Metacritic so far, making it easily one of the year's best-reviewed games. Yes, the game is a success by the sounds of it, but it's worth considering that most reviewers were thorough enough to delve into the aspects of the game that it works in spite of, those less-polished elements that prevent the game from perhaps being a true masterpiece in the eyes of some. From what's great, to what's bad, what's familiar and what's just really weird, the dozens of reviews flooding the net now give a pretty strong picture about what sort of game Fallout 4 is, and if you've not quite got your mits on it yet, it seems like you're largely in for a treat (with a few qualifications, of course). Here are 12 early Fallout 4 reactions you need to know...

12. It's Very Similar To What Came Before (And That's Mostly OK)

One common thread that has come up among critics is that Fallout 4 isn't much of a departure at all from what came before: "Bethesda plays it surprisingly safe with the formula" (USGamer) and "this is more of the same, even if that 'same' has been pushed to new heights" (Videogamer). Sure, nobody should've expected a radical overhauling of the game, but even so, it's been earmarked as clinging closely to Fallout 3's mostly successful schematic. This caused a few to refer to it as "over-familiar "(Rock, Paper, Shotgun) and "archaic" (Forbes), but on the whole most conceded that the familiarity was acceptable considering the game's scope in other areas and the overall heft of the massive adventure. But yes, if you're anticipating a game-changer for the franchise, you might want to brace yourself...

11. Combat Has Been Vastly Improved

Here's one aspect of Fallout that's been majorly tweaked and for the better, no less. Polygon even said "it was jarring to actually enjoy the gunplay in Fallout 4 after trudging through the controls in literally every other game Bethesda has made", and though they had problems with the melee combat, IGN commended the gunplay as feeling "more like a typical good-quality first-person shooter than the series ever has before." This sentiment was reflected in almost every major review, praising Bethesda for honing the combat beyond the clunkiness of previous games in the series, making it "an accomplished and enjoyable shooter" (PC Gamer) and by far the "most improved element" (Game Informer). Many also noted the refined V.A.T.S. system, which introduces an added urgency as it no longer stops time completely (merely reducing it to a slow crawl), but of course, still comes with the requisite gory explosions that everyone loves. Several critics stated, though, that the pure combat was so surprisingly good that they abandoned using V.A.T.S. altogether after a while.

10. The User Interface Is A Clunky Mess

As enjoyable as the game is overall, an overwhelming majority of critics had complaints about how the game lays out options to the player via its user interface. Gamespot said that "surveying the world map can be a chore" due to limited functionality, and that cycling through weapons and items can be far more time-consuming than it needs to be. Polygon called the interface "too opaque", and PC Gamer complained about the crafting workship being "a bit fiddly to use...At one point, I had to fast-travel between multiple different settlements just to remember where I'd left the pocket watch that contained the gear I needed to build a water pump." Granted, with a world this large, coming up with navigation menus that encompass everything intuitive and succinctly is incredibly difficult: you need look no further than the recent Metal Gear Solid V, which also received some measure of flak for its cumbersome array of menus.

9. Settlements Are Fun But Unnecessary

One of the major additions to FO4 is settlements, that players can now help establish small communities out in the wasteland, using their resources to help the locals set up lines of communication and, of course, build defenses to chase off any would-be attackers. On the whole reviewers praised the mechanics, though agreed that it ultimately felt unnecessary and disconnected from the whole: "The main quest only asks you to construct an object or two, and never incentivises you to build a proper settlement" (Gamespot), "my network of towns almost never contributed meaningfully to my adventures other than somewhere to hang my vast collection of looted hats" (IGN). Many stated that building settlements is more demanding on the player than it should be because "building tools are not clearly communicated" (Game Informer), and that you may find yourself stuck as to how to connect everything together, perhaps relying on the online community to re-iterate things for you rather than the game itself.

8. The Story Is The Best Of The Series

Fallout's story has inarguably always taken a backseat to the thrill of adventure and discovery, to the point that it often feels like the player is writing their own experiential journey in the wasteland. That said, the consensus appears to be that Fallout 4's story is tops as far as the series is concerned, mustering up "the strongest writing it's ever managed" (Polygon) and "the best main story Bethesda has created" (PC Gamer). Though it seems to be agreed that the game rushes the player through the prologue sequence in order to get them out into the wasteland, many stated that the game's dramatic choices left them genuinely unsure of what to do, and without going into spoilers, found them more drawn into the narrative than ever before.

7. Companion Mechanics Are Highly Flawed

Ever since we all first saw the dog known as Dogmeat, we've been looking forward to chilling with him in the wasteland...but going by the early reviews, the mechanics are something of a mixed bag, which given their track record in this series, isn't at all surprising. Most of the criticism is leveled around the bad ally AI, such that your companion will "frequently run blindly into chaos" (Game Informer), and they're always quick to go down during an epic battle. Amusingly, Eurogamer said, "as in previous games, they're more useful as walking backpacks than as actual companions, while Gamespot criticised the "lack of streamlined companion controls". Sure, companions are never the be-all and end-all of these games, but given how much effort has been put into marketing the bond between man and his best friend, it's undeniably disappointing that this aspect of the game is still assailed by bargain basement intelligence routines.

6. Full Voice Acting Is Decent But Unnecessary

One of the more divisive additions to Fallout 4 is the fact that the entire game has a full voice cast, which some feared could result in a more trimmed-down narrative, or that it might rob the player of the opportunity to impose their own personality on their protagonist. Critics seem similarly divided on it, in that while most praise the acting itself and its function (PC Gamer said, "Having a voiced protagonist gave me a greater sense of attachment to the world, and particularly to the companions"), there's also the feeling among many that it didn't really add enough to the experience to be worth the clear effort invested in it. IGN commented, "I frankly don€™t feel like it added much beyond the convenience of not having to read as much text when playing from the couch." So, no, full voice acting is not an Earth-shattering refinement, in case you were wondering, but given how the game falls down in a number of key areas, it's a shame more time wasn't devoted to that rather than this. Speaking of which...

5. It's Full Of Glitches

Yes, yes, a thousand times yes, Fallout 4 is absolutely riddled with bugs, glitches, hitches or whatever you want to call them. This was by far the most pervasive complaint in the reviews, with Polygon warning players that if they've been worn down and infuriated by Bethesda's bug-ridden titles in the past, they may want to "exercise caution" with this one. IGN reviewed the game on all platforms and saw "occasional crashes" across the board, while Eurogamer did a brilliant job summarising the problem with this terrific rant, "If you despair of Bethesda's creaking game engine, with its frequent glitches, stutters and occasional fatal crashes, then you'll also find everything you feared...often falling apart at the seams and pushing its game engine far beyond its comfortable limits. If you were expecting the move to powerful new generation console hardware to smooth out the kinks that endured in Bethesda's RPGs for the decade-long lifespan of the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3, you'll be disappointed...It's impossible to miss the glitches, bugs and downright broken bits in Fallout 4...appalling frame rate that plummets to what appear to be single figures during moments of intense action, and lengthy pauses while the game hangs and decides if it wants to continue or not." After the last two Fallout games suffered immensely from bugs, especially on consoles, it's a shame that once again consoles seem to get the worst of it. You ultimately need to decide whether you can forgive them enough or if they're just too infuriating. As such, it's frankly a surprise that it hasn't dented the reviews more.

4. The Graphics Are Disappointingly Rough

When Fallout 4 was finally revealed earlier this year, one of the major criticisms was that the graphics just didn't look that good. Sure, they weren't as bad as the negative Nancies made them out to be ("they look like a PS3 game!"), but yes, they felt incredibly dated and the game wasn't even out yet, though of course, many defenders took a "wait and see" approach, as there was still months of dev time to polish things, right? Well, behind the glitches, the most common issue is that the game doesn't look great. Sure, the addition of more colour to the wasteland is incredibly welcome, but FO4 has been taken to task for its "plainly framed scenes and basic animations" (Gamespot), human characters that "still look a little terrifying" (Polygon), "frequent frame rate slowdowns well below the target of 30 when simply walking around the world" (IGN) and that "framerate stutters and dips are fairly common in larger firefights and within densely populated city areas" (Game Informer). Eurogamer added that the graphics, "look far better than previous Bethesda games while still falling short of what most people will expect from "next-gen" systems", and PC Gamer succinctly concluded that "the age and limitations of Bethesda's engine are well apparent". Sure, no-one should expect a game that looks like MGS V when the world is so much larger comparatively and there are so many more moving parts, but even accepting that gameplay trumps graphics every time, the game just looks OK, and the frame-rate issues don't help. At the time of review, even just using the scope on the PS4 version of the game was reported to cause substantial FPS drops.

3. The Ending Is Underwhelming

There's not much to be said here for fear of going into spoiler territory, but thankfully critics were respectful and made almost no references to how the game ends other than a general, vague response to it. Several noted a disappointment with how things wrapped up: "the resulting cutscene wasn€™t as tailored an epilogue to my adventure as previous" (IGN) and "as world shifting as the events you enact potentially are, they're dampened by the abruptness of the conclusion" (PC Gamer). The end was still commended for not being closed-off like in Fallout 3, allowing the player to continue to explore the world long after the core story wraps up, but it sounds like the conclusion is set to be divisive with fans. We'll just have to wait and see...

2. It's Brilliant Despite Its Many Flaws...

The bottom line to take away from the reviews is that Fallout 4 is for the most part an excellent game, albeit one with an uncommon amount of issues attached to it for something so acclaimed. Eurogamer possibly put it best, saying, "fans...will likely shrug and accept that this is simply how things are in a Bethesda RPG, and it's true that the highs do outweigh the lows", and Gamespot agreed that the game's "minor issues pale in comparison to its successes." Even with its niggling issues, Digital Trends called it "the best, most polished Bethesda RPG to date." Again, it's worth considering how prepared you are to put up with Bethesda's usual design and presentation problems, because they're pretty much equally abundant here as usual, but those who persevere will be rewarded with one of the year's best games without question. There is one more thing to consider, though...

1. ...But Hardcore Fans Should Probably Lower Your Expectations

Arts Technica summarised it beautifully by saying this: "series fanatics probably shouldn't cancel their pre-orders, but they should definitely check their expectations about ambition and next-gen series boosts at the radioactive vault's doors." Fallout 4 arrives on such a massive tidal wave of hype and positive buzz that it would be very easy to be disappointed, in much the same way that MGS V looked like it was going to be the second coming of Christ but suffered under a wildly underwhelming story (even if it was magnificent in most other areas). Fallout 4 may be a fantastic game and one of the best of the year, but it's worth considering that the game just might be great rather than "GOAT". It's always thrilling when your expectations are superseded, but if you pitch them at the sky and hope for the stars, you're probably letting yourself in for a letdown. What do you make of the Fallout 4 reviews? Shout them out in the comments!

In this post: 
Fallout 4
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.