Game of Thrones: 5 Ways to Make a Great Video Game Adaptation
George R. R. Martins A Song of Ice and Fire is a world practically tailor made for a video game. It is immense, vast, dark, violent, and full of richly realized characters all in alliance and/or conflict with each other. With the success of the HBO series Game of Thrones, it should come as no surprise that a few games have been made to capitalize on this recent rise in popularity. Unfortunately, all efforts so far have lead to subpar results. As of this writing, two major titles have been released, both by French based developer Cyanide. Game of Thrones: Genesis is a real-time strategy game taking place over 1,000 years of the history of Westeros, and allows you to take control of various major houses for control of the iron throne. Earlier this year, Cyanide released an RPG simply titled Game of Thrones, which is actually a prequel to the book series, and tells the story of Nights Watchman Mors Westford and fire priest Alester Sarwyck as the both get tangled in a royal conspiracy. On paper, both of these titles had great potential, which only makes the disappointment all the more painful. I must confess, I have not actually played Genesis, but from what Ive seen and heard, the general consensus is that it has a solid foundation dampened by poor gameplay and storytelling mechanics. This is too bad, as the prospect of a Game of Thrones RTS that takes into account both the battles and the political machinations that fuels them is exciting. Same goes for the RPG released this year. While telling a genuinely compelling story that sheds some light on the events leading up to the first book, it too is dampened by boring gameplay, outdated graphics, linear level design, and inconsistent voice acting. These design flaws negatively affect any enjoyment one gets from the story, so much to the point that I have yet to actually finish it, despite my love of the world and characters. Upon further reflection on these disappointments, my mind eventually turned to the future. There will be more video games based on this franchise; there is no doubt about it. The popularity and potential are there, and it would be foolish for publishers and developers to miss the opportunities available. In fact, a browser-based MMORPG titled Game of Thrones: Seven Kingdoms is currently being developed by Bigpoint Games and Artpant, and should be released next year. While this again has potential, I can safely say that this is not the A Song of Ice and Fire (from this point ASoIaF for brevitys sake) video game that I want. When looking at the attempts made so far, it becomes ever so clear why a great video game adaptation hasnt been made yet. The blueprint to a perfect ASoIaF game is there; it just has to get made. Here are five ways how to do that.
5. Don't Base It On The Television Show
When playing the Game of Thrones RPG, I couldnt help but feel that the potential for greatness was squandered by its faithfulness to the look and feel of the television series. The developers claim that the game was being developed before the series was released, and I believe them, as it only further validates my belief that the series success negatively affected the final product. They had their own designs and look for Castle Black, the Red Keep, Kings Landing, and other notable locations from the books. However, at some point, they were informed that they should make the game more like the tv series, and this had to have taken up time better used to further polish the game. Characters now had to look like the actors portraying them on the show, and locations had to look like the sets. Not only was the look of the show reused, but even the music was. No original music was composed, and familiar tracks from the show make up the entirety of the score. I adore Ramin Djawadis score, but I expect to hear new stuff from a video game, not recycled stuff, as great as it is. The final product comes off as rushed in every aspect. Martins universe deserves better than rushed, and it deserves to take on a life of its own outside of HBOs adaptation. I understand why publishers and developers, as well as HBO, feel safer adhering to the look and feel of the show, as that is what catapulted the franchise into popularity, but doing so limits creativity and imagination. Instead of letting numerous artists create new interpretations of characters, settings, and locations, they instead have to simply render what already exists. This may be faster and more efficient, but these components do not make for a polished, well conceived video game. Passion does not sprout from strict adherence to the work of others, nor from efficiency-based development, and for a video game to be good, passion must fuel it. In order to generate passion, reference and adherence to the HBO series must be thrown out. However, even forgetting all that, I just want to see another version of this universe. I dont want to see the tv series translated to video game form. If I want to see that version of the universe, Ill watch the show. When playing ASoIaF video game, I want to experience a new and different version of this familiar world. I want to see a different Tyrion, a different Eddard, a different Jaime, etc. As good as the actors of the tv series do at portraying them, they are the cinematic interpretations, and should stay that way. For the video game to truly stay faithful to the feel of the series as a whole, it should put its own creative stamp on it. Basically, the game should be based on George R.R. Martins A Song of Ice and Fire, not HBOs Game of Thrones.It would make for a more exciting and enriching game.
4. Open World
One of the most important aspects of any ASoIaF video game should be the setting and atmosphere, and the recent Game of Thrones RPG fails in this regard because of how linear and closed off it is. For an RPG, it is incredibly small scale, only allowing the player to travel between a few major locations, such as Castle Black or Kings Landing. However, even these areas are small, closed off arenas that offer nothing outside of the main objective. There is nothing to see or explore in these areas, and at no point does the world of Westeros ever feel fully realized or properly represented. The result is a world that feels boring and empty when it should be full of exciting possibilities. It is of my opinion that the best means of achieving a true representation of Westeros is to make it open world, à la Skyrim. This would be a daunting task for any developer, to be sure, but well worth the effort in the end. Just imagine being able to travel a world only imagined from the books; to see it fully realized before our eyes. Of course, all the major locations, from Winterfell to Dragonstone, should be available to travel to and fro at your leisure. Such areas should be heavily populated with NPCs to make it feel alive and lived in. Westeros isnt lacking beasts to tangle with either, as areas such as the Godswood and Kingswood should also be populated with all sorts of creatures, like shadowcats, direwolves, bears, and boars. And much like Elder Scrolls, the continent should have tons of missions and side quests to flesh out the world and give it life. Westeros is a big place, and for any game to accurately represent the atmosphere of the fiction, it must allow the player to explore and immerse themselves in it. Anything less feels like a copout and a disappointment. An open world in the style and scope of Skyrim is the perfect way to do this.3. Character/House Creation
A big temptation is making ASoIaF video game is to simply place the player in control of one or more of the various characters that populate the novels. I understand why this temptation exists. Who wouldnt want to play as Tyrion Lannister or Eddard Stark? The problem with this approach is that their paths are set in stone, and playing as them would mean that all you would get to do is replay sequences you already experienced from the books or show (unless they were to take the prequel approach). This has a certain novelty, but beyond that there really is no point. For me, excitement for ASoIaF video game doesnt come from taking control of an already established character, but from the prospect of creating my own identity and interacting with them. This is why the best approach is to allow the player to not only create and customize their own character, but their own house as well. Such an approach would give the game a much more personal feel, and as games like Mass Effect and Skyrim have shown, personalization positively adds to an already great experience. And since in Martins world status and power are everything, youd also be able to create the house attached to your character. Name, sigil, words, and allegiance to one of the great houses would all be a part of this process. Giving the player the ability to create their own house and character adds all sorts of possibilities for the player, while also greatly expanding the personal investment. This raises the stakes considerably, which has the potential to make the events of the campaign a more exhilarating/exhausting experience. Character and house customization would be a fantastic way of personalizing each player's experience while keeping the aspects unique to the ASoIaF series.
2. Playing Politics
Of all the various elements comprising ASoIaF, none feels more unique to the genre than its emphasis on politics. Martin always placed as much importance on the battles behind the curtains as those on the battlefield, if not more so. Therefore, in order to make a video game true to the material, politics must be incorporated and heavily emphasized as well. As the leader of your own house, you must play the game of thrones to your advantage. The most obvious way of doing this is to include an intricate and subtle dialogue system. The Game of Thrones RPG incorporated such a feature, and it turned out to be one of the better aspects of the game. A dialogue system would allow conversations to diverge down different paths depending on the choices you make, and these divergent paths would determine who is ally and who is foe. However, you wouldnt be able to get everyone on your side, as aligning with one house would make you the enemy of another. Politics wouldnt just involve dialogue though. It would also include accumulating territory and holding its allegiance through lobbying and bartering. Allegiances could be made with individuals or entire houses, and it all would contribute to just how politically powerful you are. All this would have to be managed by you on a consistent basis. This, of course, has a risk of being boring, but anyone who is a fan of the books or show knows that this isnt the case. If the system were designed to emphasize the intricacy and intrigue, it would make for quite a unique and memorable gaming experience.1. Narrative Freedom
I mentioned earlier that passion does not sprout from adherence to the work of others. I bring this up again because anyone familiar with Martins world knows that there is a lot of information to keep in mind at all times. Westeros has a long and intricate history, and so a video game that attempts to tell a story in continuity has the arduous task of doing so without contradicting what has already been laid out. Therefore, the only way out of this conundrum is to forget about adherence and focus on telling a great story. Now, before you grab your torches and pitchforks, let me clarify myself by saying that I am not saying a video game should just disregard all the elaborate back story and do whatever it wants. What I am saying is that the game should not strictly follow the events of the books. The perfect starting point for the video game would be just after Robert Baratheon dies, and the War of Five Kings begins. From this point on, the player is allowed to diverge and change events through the gameplay elements I previously outlined. By creating an original character and forming your own house, you have already changed the way events will play out. From that point, you are free to traverse the world of Westeros, making enemies, forging alliances, and playing the game of thrones to your desire. Want to ally with the Starks of Winterfell? You would be free to do so, but at the cost of a potential alliance with the Lannisters. However, at any point, you can betray them if the opportunity presents itself. As the leader of your house, youd have to manage all the various challenges that come with such a role, including collecting territory, sending messenger raves and orders to troops deployed, dealing with any would be betrayers, forming alliances, and participating in battles yourself. The appeal of a video game based on ASoIaF is the chance to live in that world and experience all that comes with it. The best way to do this is to allow the player to create their own character, throw them into a vast open world that feels real and lived in, and let them forge their own path, all while utilizing the components unique to Martins mythology. All of these various gameplay elements would come together to create a true ASoIaF experience, which unfortunately will probably never see the light of day. But hey, a fan can dream, cant he?