Madden 16: 8 Most Shocking AFC Player Ratings

There's a new addition to the 99 club.

The Madden 16 hype is building, with the game set to launch later this month, and EA have been busy teasing fans with player ratings across the AFC. Tom Brady's Patriots, Peyton Manning's Broncos, and Andrew Luck's Colts have all had their star players shown off to the world with fans discussing ratings across forums and social media. Brady has been bumped up to a 97 but that's hardly a surprise considering another amazing season from the Patriots' main man, while Luck has sprung into the top five QBs with 94, but where does that leave Peyton Manning? There's also the matter of wide receivers, and where the sensational draft class of 2014 will slot into the Madden system this season, and whether or not they'll be rated supremely or cautiously based on their achievements so far. This article will pick out some of the most intriguing ratings to emerge so far, including players who are shockingly high, underwhelming low, and others that are based on knee-jerk seasons in 2014 as well as a new player to be handed a 99 overall. What do you make of the ratings you've seen, and how accurate do you think they really are?


8. Johnny Manziel - 71

Johnny Manziel took a slaughtering last season, surprising absolutely nobody. His big, bold, brash entry to the NFL caught the nation's attention following his college antics and subsequent draft by the Cleveland Browns. But when it came to football, his time was limited and largely unsuccessful. Manziel's rating for Madden 16 is a meagre 71, despite reports that the quarterback has been seriously impressing the coaches in Cleveland during this off-season. He'll more than likely be sitting on the bench come Week 1, but that still doesn't mean he should be rated 7 and 9 points lower than Marcus Mariota and Jameis Winston who're both completely unproven in the NFL.

7. LeSean McCoy - 88

LeSean McCoy's off-season move from the Eagles to the Bills is a nice fresh change for the star running back who has notched up four 1,000+ yard rushing seasons in his six NFL seasons, the other two being an injury-hit campaign and his rookie season. He's an exceptional talent, no matter how much controversy he has the potential to cause like his recent 'aged 21+ females-only party' that he advertised on social media. But 88 doesn't actually seem high enough. Could he have been nudged in to the 90s, quite possibly, with coach Rex Ryan touting him to tip 1000/1000 rushing/receiving yards in a season.

6. T.Y. Hilton - 89

T.Y. Hilton could fall into the McCoy category of 'is his rating high enough?' The Colts' star receiver has taken Reggie Wayne's mantle as Indy's Number 1 WR, with his numbers increasing rapidly year-on-year. He picked up 861 yds in his rookie season, before moving up to 1,083, then sparkled in 2014 with 1,345 as he moved in to fill the injured Wayne's cleats. Now going into his fourth NFL season, Hilton has signed a long contract extension, and with Andrew Luck always improving, he's set to grow and thrive as one of the league's most explosive receivers. 89 isn't high enough, but hopefully once he gets going EA will give him a boost.

5. Khalil Mack - 91

There's no denying Khalil Mack looks like a thoroughly immense talent after his debut season with the Oakland Raiders, and his impact on the team should grow each season, with Pro Football Focus research claiming that his stat grades were second only to J.J. Watt on defence last year in the whole league. He had a great season, but does that warrant a jump from 81 to 91, immediately into the upper-elite linebackers in the NFL? I'm not as convinced. He's only played one season and that's a big leap. Mack could well soar to those heights during the season as EA upgrade players, but for now it's steep.

4. Peyton Manning - 92

Peyton Manning's overall rating has tumbled. The time has come, he's fallen from 98 down to 92. It's not a surprise that he's taken a hit, but it is shocking to see a top five Madden quarterback list without Peyton on there. Instead, the top five is made up of Aaron Rodgers, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Ben Roethlisberger, and Manning's Indy successor Andrew Luck. Manning is still a phenomenal talent during the regular season, commanding the Broncos offence, though he suffered in last year's playoffs, and several playoff games before.

3. Antonio Brown - 97

Antonio Brown is a phenomenal player, there's no question. He's quick and productive, with the top receiving yards in the league last season with 1,698, edging out Demaryius Thomas. Brown is the eye-opening top WR on Madden 16 and comes with that mega 97 rating. He's toppled them all, including Dez Bryant and Megatron himself, Calvin Johnson. It'll take a mighty effort for Brown to repeat his heroics from 2014.

2. Marshal Yanda - 98

Marshall Yanda had an immense 2014, starring for the Baltimore Ravens throughout the season. The right-guard is seen by many as comfortably the greatest player in his position right now, though his rating is still huge to look at. Yanda has escalated to the very top of the pack, he's the best offensive lineman in the entire league according to EA, an opinion that is mirrored by many, but not all fans and players around the league. He ranked in at Number 79 in the NFL's Top 100 players, and while it's based on opinions, it still shows Yanda needs a monster season to justify such a huge rating.

1. Rob Gronkowski - 99

Rob Gronkowski is the top tight end in the NFL. Personally, I don't think there's much doubt about that, but is he really worthy of being one of just three 99-rated players? That's questionable. Gronk had a fantastic 2014, resulting in a Super Bowl win, but being placed above every other player in the league not called Aaron Rodgers or J.J. Watt is a huge statement. The NFL Top 100 had him down as Number 10 earlier this year, while he was ranked 41st before last season. Placing him in the Top 3 is likely to be a controversial decision by those who don't frequent Gillette Stadium during the football season.

Contributor
Contributor

What Culture contributor. NCTJ accredited Sports Journalist. Regret-filled Sunderland AFC season ticket holder. Optimism-filled NFL fan. Lover of all things Game Of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Walking Dead & more.