Mega Man Games: Ranked Worst to Best

This December marks the 25th anniversary for Capcom's beloved Blue Bomber, Mega Man. Through countless iterations and re-imaginings, this little robot hero has stood tall next to industry icons such as Mario, Link and Sonic the Hedgehog. At their core, the Mega Man games offer challenges based on pattern recognition and razor-sharp reflexes. Not to mention, the Mega Man games are home to some of the most energetic and catchy pieces of game music ever composed. In honor of my personal gaming hero (some of my first memories are playing Mega Man games on my Nintendo Entertainment System), I've decided to rank his games from worst to best, according to my own personal feelings. For the sake of size, I'll only be covering the 10 numbered games in the regular Mega Man series (excluding the Game Boy Advance's Mega Man & Bass) and not the countless spin-offs (a number of which are quite good) or else this would be an amazingly unwieldy list. NOTE: If you care about SPOILERS, this article could very well be rife with them. Also, all years are based on the North American release dates.

10. Mega Man 7 (1995)

Mega Man's transition from the classic Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) to the highly evolved Super Nintendo was unfortunately not as favorable as his other gaming counterparts. The art direction felt bulbous and weighty instead of the airy simplicity of the 8-bit era, the music was tedious, the robot masters were almost uniformly dull (with the exception of Shade Man a.k.a. We Can't Call Him Bat-Man), and the story did little else than frame itself around introducing a new character, Bass. While Bass has become a fan favorite, I'll always prefer Proto-Man's mysterious and often tenuous ally status to Bass' forced antagonism. Its key contribution to the franchise is introducing an upgrade system which involved collecting screws from enemy drops that you could spend at an upgrade store. Otherwise, Mega Man 7 is the obvious contender for weakest in the series, and it doesn't help that it's overshadowed by its far superior spin-off Mega Man X. However, I'd take the worst Mega Man game over the best Call of Duty game any day. That's right. Feed me your hate in the comments.


9. Mega Man 10 (2010)

Mega Man 10's greatest failing could probably be having to follow the alarmingly astounding Mega Man 9, but that's something that feels present in the game itself. It feels like a rushed endeavor in order to capitalize on the previous game's runaway success (critically and financially), and the game suffers for it. The level design is lazy (Nitro Man's in particular stands out) and for maybe the first time in a Mega Man game, the story feels over-stuffed and unimportant. There are a couple choice music tracks, but the overall impression is pretty underwhelming. Same with the robot masters: a few inspired choices (Solar Man being my favorite) but mostly derivative and uninteresting (Sheep Man? And his stage is inside a computer? And he's an electric boss? This has to be some bizarre Phillip K. Dick reference, right?). Even though Mega Man 10 gives the option to play as Proto-Man (and Bass, available through DLC. *snarl*), the game doesn't have anything else that elevates it above its predecessor or even some of the easier games in the series. A missed opportunity, and a serious disappointment for the tenth entry in a such a storied series.

8. Mega Man 4 (1993)

After the frustrating (but enjoyable) challenge of Mega Man 3, Capcom seems to have realized that the main demographic for the series (especially in North America) were younger players who couldn't cope with the higher difficulty present in the first three games. This led to Mega Man 4 feeling like the start of a more "kid-friendly" approach to the series. This game introduces the New Mega Buster which allows you to charge up a more powerful shot, making it simple to kill most enemies with one blow. Also, the item drops from enemies becomes far too giving. If you have the patience, you can farm enemies for extra lives. This makes veteran players, who grew up with the difficulty of the original games, pretty hesitant towards this game and the consecutive two entries. The colors in this game look strangely washed out and bland, but the level design is pretty solid. The robot masters for this one are decent, with the exception of two: Skull Man and Pharaoh Man. These two would be worthy of any "Top Ten Robot Masters" list. The music is fine, but it's the story that helps this game out. The first game to introduce a "fake" villain and a castle you have defeat before fighting Doctor Wily would become a staple for the next two games. Mega Man 4 is an acceptable entry, but not incredibly memorable.

7. Mega Man 8 (1997)

With Mega Man's transfer to the Sony PlayStation comes a Mega Man game that is incredibly divisive in the fan community. The art style is either "love it or hate it" and I seem to be in the minority when it comes to loving it. The anime cut-scenes (featuring awfulsome voice-acting where some of the actors even stumble over their lines!) are fun and the story is the most in-depth of any Mega Man game up to that point. The robot masters are mostly inventive and all have very unique level design, sometimes to the point of confusion (Astro Man's level, anyone?). The music is probably the weakest aspect of the game, trading in the familiar 8-bit style for a more traditional scoring, although familiar themes do pop up. Strangely, it downgrades the "collecting screws" system introduced in Mega Man 7 by having a limited number of screws hidden throughout the levels instead of making the screws available by enemy drops. This is the weirdest change going forward in a series, and it's no surprise that it was replaced with the system from Mega Man 7 when the following game was released. Mega Man 8 is a mixed bag, but it's worth the time put into it.

6. Mega Man 6 (1994)

I like to look at the last three Mega Man games released on the NES as a sort of trilogy, incorporating their own rules and style that differ from the original three games. In that way, Mega Man 6 feels like the third entry in a trilogy: flawed but ultimately satisfactory. The backdrop of a robot tournament orchestrated by the mysterious Dr. X (who is most definitely not Dr. Wily in disguise) is a neat concept, and the selection of robot masters feels cool and mostly original (except the awfully familiar Wind Man. Paging Mega Man 2...). The levels are nicely constructed and there are a good number of worthwhile music tracks. Even though it's a laughably easy experience, Mega Man 6 delivers on what you want from a Mega Man game if nothing else. Not great, but not bad either.

5. Mega Man 5 (1992)

If the trilogy analogy holds up, Mega Man 5 fulfills the necessary duty of being the best of the bunch. Though it still carries over the simplified difficulty of the previous game, there are a lot of improvements made. Mega Man's charged shot has a much better animation, the colors in this game are eye-popping and all the robot masters feel fresh and new. There's a good number of catchy music tracks and some of the levels are the most inventive in the series up to that point. The gimmicky fun of Gravity Man's level and the gravity-less jumping in Star Man's level add a new dimension to clearing the stage. Plus, the story in this is easily the highlight of the game. Has Proto-Man turned evil? It's a great hook right from the intro screen. And his castle stages include the criminally underutilized Darkman, one of my favorite Mega Man baddies. If you're going to play one of the "easier" Mega Man games from the NES era, this is the one I'd recommend.

4. Mega Man (1987)

The one that started it all. It's hard to write a lot about this entry since so much of it has been said in a modified form, due to most of the sequels being improved remakes of this old school classic. The robot masters, stage design, music and everything are all here in top-notch form. My only minor complaint is that this has to be one of the most difficult games in the entire series. While certainly not impossible, the later games learned how to funnel the difficulty in different areas instead of making every aspect of the game feel like a grand frustration. Still, this is an important game in the medium's history and a classic by any standard. If you haven't played through Mega Man, you're missing out on one of the most definitive games ever made.

3. Mega Man 3 (1990)

Expanding on the form and function of its preceding entry, Mega Man 3 is one of the most challenging and rewarding gaming adventures you can have on the NES. Filled with awesome enemies (Snake Man could very well be my number one robot master), level design that is inventive and themed well for each robot master, and feverishly fun music, this is a hallmark of the entire series. But, it's most important contribution comes in its implementation of a canon-defining story. This is the game that presents us with Break Man, a mysterious red robot that pops up from time to time to battle with Mega Man. However, after the end boss fight, Break Man saves an unconscious Mega Man from certain destruction and drops him off with Dr. Light. It's then that Dr. Light reveals Break Man to be Proto-Man, his first creation and Mega-Man's brother. This ending shapes the Mega Man world into just that: a fully realized world with characters and emotions that may not be as prevalent in the preceding games. If just for that reason, Mega Man 3 is one of the most crucial entries in the franchise.

2. Mega Man 9 (2008)

When Capcom announced the first true Mega Man sequel in almost a decade, the interest of the gaming community was piqued. But, it was the news that the series would return to its 8-bit style that sent fans into a frenzy. This return to form ended up creating the second best game in the whole series. This game had no right being this incredibly well-crafted. The level designs were both gorgeous and challenging, the robot masters were an eclectic mix that felt wholly original (including the first female robot master! Progressive!) and the story was a wonderful twist: Dr. Light being portrayed as the villain was a great backdrop, and seeing the big "Dr. L" logos before each boss room was a cool take on a familiar image. But among all things, Mega Man 9 does one thing so perfectly: the music. The tracks in this game are among some of the best ever composed for the entire series. Knowing that the music was one of the most beloved things about the franchise, Capcom really gave 110% in this arena and it shines. I could listen to these tracks all day and never get bored. Mega Man 9 is one of the best games released in the past few years, and it shows that old school gaming can still be done in new and inventive ways without kowtowing to most modern conventions. A true gem in the series and maybe even the last truly great Mega Man game.

1. Mega Man 2 (1989)

Mega Man 2 is easily one of the top five most important games in the entire NES library. Taking everything from the original game and tweaking it to perfection, Mega Man 2 also established some of the tenets of the series. The number of robot masters, the sprites used for health and weapon energy, the ridiculously catchy music and more. The game also features a wonderfully diverse set of robot masters that feel fresh and varied, with levels that are just as unique and well thought out. Along with super tight controls and an art style that would define every Mega Man game following it, Mega Man 2 deserves to be mentioned in the same breath as other trail-blazers like Super Mario Bros and The Legend of Zelda. A well-deserved classic of the NES era and the best Mega Man game hands down. Do you have a different ranking? A compelling argument for Mega Man 7? Do you think Mega Man 10 is actually a better game than its predecessor? Please discuss in the comments below and thanks for reading!

In this post: 
mega man
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Drew Dietsch is an Entertainment Editor at Fandom.com. He's written for CHUD.com, the News-Press, WhatCulture, and releases a weekly podcast about his media consumption called The Drew Reviews Podcast.