Silent Hill: Ranking 9 Games From Best To Worst

Silent Hill Logo In this article we will dig into what I consider to be my favorite franchise in all of gaming; the psychologically terror-inducing Silent Hill. It€™s a mysterious and demonic town where tortured souls unwillingly come to face and accept their darkest secrets. Aside from two games, no entry is connected to another, leaving the mythos and history of the town itself the recurrring main attraction along with the personal past of each protagonist. Admittedly, the franchise isn€™t heralded for its gameplay, which still to this day clunkily forces the player to fight the controls just as much as the enemies. Instead, articles like this are compiled to express the varying opinions from story to story. It could be the downright freaky enemy designs that often symbolize something relevant to the protagonist€™s disturbing past, Akira Yamoaka€™s hallucinogenic and dreamlike musical compositions (sometimes coupled with vocals from the amazing Mary Elizabeth McGlynn), or the thematically driven narrative itself that creates these divergent opinions among the fanbase. The current fanbase is unfortunately in a state of shambles, constantly bickering with one another about the turn the series has taken. It€™s no secret that ever since Team Silent disbanded the quality of the franchise has diminished, with mainstream appeal nearly dead. Also, while the latest installment was definitely a return to form in terms of narrative, the gameplay still hasn€™t evolved. Another new studio tasked with whipping up another story closed earlier this year, and with that I fear came the silent death of the once acclaimed series that spanned three console generations. As someone who€™s played them all without bias towards even the American developed games €“ who some still refuse to touch €“ I feel now is an appropriate time to crank out what is a personal passion project; a complete ranking of Silent Hill. This does include handheld games but not arcade/phone related content, just the main canon entries. There are also no story spoilers.

9. Silent Hill: Book Of Memories

Silent Hill This is probably the furthest from traditional Silent Hill you can get and an unabashed spinoff featuring character customization and Diabo inspired combat. It was supposed to be a selling point for Sony€™s PS Vita but€ yeah., this game is awful and I honestly never finished it. I like to pretend that this song is the only trace of its existence. I don€™t hate the game for trying something completely different because the franchise does need some spinning to inject life back into it, but making Silent Hill a dungeon crawler is about as absurd as making Resident Evil a fighter. Book of Memories is terrible and I only recommend trying it out if you€™re a hardcore Silent Hill fan that€™s curious what the fuss is about.

8. Silent Hill: Origins

Silent Hill Origins Logo Acting as a prequel to the game that started it all, Silent Hill: Origins ties up loose ends surrounding the events in the groundbreaking classic. It€™s low on the list but not nearly as bad as Book of Memories so we€™re gradually climbing that ladder into better games. Outside of serving as a vessel for plot exposition surrounding the persistent cult that is obsessed with birthing a God, the game follows a trucker named Travis who definitely has his own baggage, but his personal story is ultimately second fiddle to everything else going on and is underdeveloped as a result. Weak gameplay, boring locales, and unsatisfactory puzzles didn€™t help.

7. Silent Hill: Homecoming

The first American developed Silent Hill is also one of the most vehemently despised and while it€™s understandable why, I also applaud the game for its attempt to modernize the combat in some way. They just went a bit too far down the action route with unnecessary quick time events, overblown boss battles, and lost that sense of vulnerability and horror for its protagonist. Its worst offense though is the near plagiarism of Silent Hill 2 to the extent where it coined in the same exact twist. The story also is a disjointed mess that shoehorns in more exposition on the infamous cult. Also, if Pyramid Head is in a game that isn€™t Silent Hill 2, it€™s nothing more than shameless whoring out of the character considering the metallic and triangular headed executioner€™s existence is directly related to the plot of that game. Despite all of that it€™s probably the most fun Silent Hill game to actually play, complete with refined shooting and evasive maneuvers. Everything else is just a disappointing mess but we did get another amazing end credits song.

6. Silent Hill 4: The Room

Silent Hill The Room In a very peculiar move Silent Hill 4 decided to include gameplay segments in a first person viewpoint when exploring the apartment complex housing the titular possessed room. It wasn€™t executed very well and thankfully didn€™t catch on but The Room is far from a bad egg in the franchise. I€™d actually wager from here on out in this list, each installment is a storytelling masterpiece. The game€™s psychopathic child-murdering serial killer villain Walter Sullivan was actually referenced to in a newspaper found within Silent Hill 2. He€™s on a murderous quest to kill 21 victims in an act of cleansing the apartment while players assume the role of Henry and must protect Eileen, the 21st victim at all costs. Narratively it follows a different structure than earlier iterations stemming from the fact that the game originally was not planned as a Silent Hill title until mid-production. The end results are an unforgettable experience with twisted villain motives. The game also ends with one of the greatest pieces of music to ever grace any medium, perfectly capturing the essence of the story in tone and lyrics.

5. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories

Shsm Lrg This engaging experience for the Nintendo Wii is another stark departure from series roots. For starters, it contains almost no physical combat, forcing you to escape-artist past danger. The unorthodox gameplay received major flak but I found the game exhilarating. Its puzzles were admittedly really stupid though and nothing more than making dumb motion gestures. Shattered Memories is most known for its story €“ a drastic reimagining of the original game which takes all of the familiar characters and molds them into something else entirely. Harry is still looking for his daughter, but the twist will shatter your mind. The credits also roll yet another brilliant song from the duo of Akira Yamoaka and Mary Elizabeth McGlynn.

4. Silent Hill: Downpour

Silent Hill Downpour 1 600x300 Last year when Silent Hill: Downpour released it finally seemed like the series had found redemption. I fully admit the game is a technical mess with framerate issues galore, but the story and level design encapsulated everything a modern day Silent Hill game should. Unfortunately, the game got unfairly panned by critics and received poor sales which led to the development studio being laid off. The themes and morals explored however were incredibly gutsy and taboo, a staple of the series that did admittedly go away after the disbanding of Team Silent. Downpour begins with you mercilessly stabbing the hell out of a fat guy in a prison shower, and leaves you glad you did by the end. Downpour also introduced side missions to do around the haunted city which were also eerily disturbing with premises that could make for their own intriguing nightmarish experience. Traditional series composer Akira Yamoaka was also replaced by Daniel Licht of TV show Dexter fame but I liked what he brought to the table too.

3. Silent Hill: 3

00127 Outside of being a gapped follow up to the original classic, Silent Hill 3 also boasts the best gameplay the franchise has ever seen. Antiquated complexity is the only real way to explain it but overall, you had more dangerous and agile enemies with more speed yourself playing as Heather. The game€™s strongest asset is its undeniably disturbing story that involves birthing a demon God complete with a scene where Heather throws up the fetus, only for antagonist Claudia to then eat the aforementioned fetus. Heather may not have been the most identifiable protagonist considering she€™s usually whining like your typical teenage girl, but this game is too mad not to love. It€™s also a perfectly executed sequel with one of the saddest and most tragic deaths in gaming history. The game also marked the introduction to Mary Elizabeth McGlynn providing awesome vocal work for select tracks composed by Akira Yamoaka.

2. Silent Hill

Silent Hill This is the foundation of it all and while graphically it has aged excruciatingly badly with cringe-worthy voice dialogue delivery, it can still horrify like no other game. Harry Mason is looking for his daughter and must battle demonic school children, grotesquely erotic nurses, and traverse hell itself to find her and solve the mystery of who she is. It€™s psychologically brilliant and will most likely leave you confused but when it clicks, it€™s poetic. Every character serves a purpose into tying the intelligent narrative together. While Resident Evil had everyone pissing themselves from jump scares, Silent Hill was psychologically toying with our mind in outstanding ways.

1. Silent Hill 2

36246 Was there really any doubt? James Sunderland receives a letter from his dead wife, insisting that she€™s alive and waiting for him in their special place. James traverses the town meeting more yet equally distressed characters, but it€™s how the writers weave all of their unsettling and downright disgusting past into a story intricately and subtlety based on sex, rape, and murder. The game€™s central executioner antagonist Pyramid Head stalks James every step of the way as the narrative builds towards mind-bending twists laced with unnerving themes. Taboo doesn€™t even begin to describe some of the scenarios found in this iconic masterpiece where every character, enemy, scene, and item is stuffed with symbolism. The original score by Akira Yamoaka is also the greatest soundtrack in all of gaming. If you haven€™t played Silent Hill 2 but consider yourself an aficionado of narrative driven games, than do so immediately. So, there you have it, the rankings of Silent Hill from one of the most dedicated and passionate fans around. Let us know below if you agree or disagree.

Contributor
Contributor

I write for WhatCulture (duh) and MammothCinema. Born with Muscular Dystrophy Type 2; lover of film, games, wrestling, and TV.