Star Wars Battlefront 2 Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
Probably not the sequel you're looking for.
EA's anxiously-anticipated Star Wars Battlefront 2 has finally arrived, and unless you've been living under a rock the last few days, you'll no doubt be aware that the game has come under immense scrutiny for its microtransaction and loot box systems, and rightly so.
At present, Battlefront 2 has the exact same critical score as its predecessor, a disappointing result considering how aggressively EA promised fans that the sequel would be an apology for everything the original got wrong.
Instead, the new game is an incredibly mixed bag indeed, a frequently gorgeous and intermittently fun but poorly-conceived mess, full of elements designed to frustrate players and even put them off entirely.
In light of all the launch controversy, nobody could blame you for giving the game a miss completely, especially with how many quality games are available on all platforms right now, but if you do decide to give Battlefront 2 a go, you absolutely must be aware of the game's severe drawbacks...
Downs...
5. The Campaign Is Extremely Disappointing
After fans complained that 2015's Battlefront lacked a single-player campaign, EA promised that Battlefront 2 would feature a rich, substantial story mode, but sadly, that's not the case at all.
Clocking in at just four hours in length, much of which consists of cut-scenes and walking sections, the campaign is a disappointingly piecemeal offering that's largely comprised of generic A.I. skirmishes with cut-scenes wrapped around the edges.
Janina Gavankar gives a compelling performance as protagonist Iden Versio, though players ultimately get little sense of her as the game frequently cuts away for fan-servicey sections in which you play as one of several Star Wars legends.
Versio's arc is predictable throughout and the core plot itself proves resoundingly dull, a few crowd-pleasing moments notwithstanding.
Simply, it's just not what fans were sold, and is distressingly basic considering how much EA talked it up pre-release.
4. Progression Is An Insulting Mess
Battlefront 2's progression system is by far the game's worst and most controversial aspect, as the multiplayer suite is effectively built around a loot box system intended to convince players to part with real-life cash for a better chance at getting that sweet, sweet loot.
While at present EA has actually switched off microtransactions (though will surely be turning them back on in revised form in the near-future), the multiplayer infrastructure is still defined by a hyper-convoluted loop of acquiring credits at a sluggish rate through gameplay, using them to open loot boxes, and hoping you unlock a performance-enhancing Star Card that's actually worth a damn.
There are too many types of in-game currency, it seems to be made intentionally confusing for players both new and old, and overall it can't shake a predatory stink that wants to get players in the mindset of handing over their credit card details, even if at present EA has unplugged the potential pay-to-win aspect after panicking at the furious online response.
Considering how stingy the game is with doling out credits, the progression system just isn't fun at all, and makes the multiplayer feel rather hollow and soulless at times.
3. The PS4 Version Runs Horribly
Since launch, original PS4 owners have been reporting horrendous technical issues. During the campaign, cut-scenes may lag and judder, and multiplayer gameplay is full of stuttering, which is especially infuriating considering the precision required while playing online.
Given that this wasn't a problem at all in the beta, it's particularly frustrating, and EA desperately needs to get a patch released to remedy it, because at present, it's hard to recommend playing the PS4 version unless you're prepared to put up with frequently dying when you probably didn't deserve to.
That a purportedly "AAA" game can release in such shoddy form should be considered an embarrassment for all involved.
2. Stat Tracking Is Shockingly Minimal
What's something everyone loves about modern online shooters? Stat tracking, of course. Most gamers will take it as a given that an online shooter in 2017 will allow them to tirelessly and obsessively track their online progress, but Battlefront 2 goes almost the total opposite way by including little in the way of comprehensive stats.
Ask any multiplayer shooter community whether they need stat tracking and there will be a decisive answer in the affirmative, but in Battlefront 2 there's currently no way to check your kill-death ratio or any of the other stats players typically expect.
EA has stated that they will be adding stats in the future, but seriously, how the hell can this not be ready for launch day? Again, embarrassing.
1. No VR Mode
This might seem like a nitpick to some, but for VR owners, it feels like a hugely missed opportunity that Battlefront 2 doesn't even have a basic VR version of Starfighter Assault.
After EA released a Star Wars X-Wing VR experience last December to commemorate the release of Rogue One, which remains one of the best VR experiences to date, many expected Battlefront 2 to feature some sort of VR support, but sadly not.
While it's entirely possible such a mode could be patched in at some point, it's probably best not to expect anything, even if last year's experience proved just how well-suited VR is to the Star Wars universe.
As disappointing as the game is, it's not all bad, and hell, some of it is actually genuinely fun...
Ups...
5. It Looks Fantastic
Make no mistake that if you forget about all the crap surrounding the game's loot box nonsense and even the unfortunate stuttering issues on PS4, from moment to moment, it is an absolutely gorgeous game regardless of what platform you play it on.
Like the previous game, it perfectly captures the epic visual scope of the Star Wars universe, with a crowd-pleasing attention to detail, while the texture quality itself is again excellent, even if not a huge leap from 2015's game.
Locales ripped straight from the movies typically look incredible, and in terms of immersing fans in a living, breathing slice of Star Wars, this is easily the game's biggest success.
4. The Core Multiplayer Is Fun...To A Point
It would be absurd to claim that Battlefront 2's multiplayer isn't enjoyable...for a time. The large-scale center-piece that is Galactic Assault will scratch the Star Wars itch for most players, and the numerous other on-the-ground modes such as Heroes vs. Villains and Strike bring just enough diversity to the table.
It's easy to sink hours into the multiplayer suite, and though it's troubled by the aforementioned progression system, overlong loading times and a lack of weight to the shooting, for those craving some casual gunplay, it does the job just fine.
If you can't having fun playing a game where you can become Yoda and mercilessly slice your way through the enemy team, what's the point even playing games?
Fans are likely to be divided on the map selection and whether the game truly improves upon its predecessor, but yes, for the most part the online mayhem is enjoyable, with heavy qualifiers.
3. The Sound Is (Mostly) Terrific
As with the visuals, Battlefront 2's aural department is second-to-none in terms of replicating the sound of the Star Wars universe, and as low-effort as much of the game seems, that certainly doesn't apply to the stellar audio work.
From the iconic blaster sound effects to the unforgettable orchestral score and even the incidental dialogue during multiplayer, it all sounds incredibly faithful to this world, and played with a great set of headphones, the feeling of immersion is absolutely incredible.
Sure, some of the soundalikes in the campaign mode are pretty suspect (especially the hilariously unconvincing Luke Skywalker), but for the majority, it sounds magnificent.
2. Starfighter Assault Is An Excellent Addition
One of the 2015 game's most underwhelming aspects was its piecemeal Fighter Squadron mode, which felt hurriedly slapped together for release, but one of Battlefront 2's undeniable improvements is its replacement mode, Starfighter Assault.
Far from the disappointing restraint of Fighter Squadron's generic battles, Starfighter Assault gives every Star Wars fan an opportunity to realise their childhood dream, to dive headlong into epic space dogfights against an army of 12 enemy players, plus AI of course.
It's an easy mode to jump into and have fun with, and though not particularly complex, this is one area of the game where EA and DICE clearly listened to player complaints from the previous game and delivered accordingly.
1. There's A Ton Of Content
All its issues considered, the final question to ponder is this: is Battlefront 2 good value for money? Yes and no. The potentially predatory progression system is a major strike against it, but at the same time, if you're a Star Wars fan who just wants to take part in some fun gunfights, there is a lot of content here to that end.
With the campaign and various multiplayer suites, you'll easily get tens of hours for your money, though it ultimately just comes down to how forgiving you can be of the game's lackluster elements, and the overall feeling that EA tried to take gamers for a ride before being called out on it.
If you can accept the game's issues, there's plenty here to keep you busy over the holiday period.
Have you played Battlefront 2 yet? What do you think so far? Shout it out in the comments!