8 Terrible Games That Didn't DESERVE Sequels

When dreadful games get sequels anyway... for some reason.

Dead island 2
Dambuster

As the world of video game development becomes ever-more perilous, of course publishers want to keep building their war chests of mainstay franchises that can reliably crank out sequels every few years. 

But sometimes a game is so mind-bogglingly bad you have to wonder how it possibly sold well enough for a sequel to ever be commercially viable. And yet, in the case of all these games, it still happened regardless.

These are the kind of "why-did-they-make-this" sequels that make you sob at all the unrealised sequels you'll never get to play because somebody wouldn't roll the dice on them - because the original didn't sell quite well enough.

Now in fairness, some of these sequels were actually marked, even massive improvements over the previous game and ultimately earned their keep, yet what came before was so flabbergastingly dire that it's baffling a sequel ever crossed anyone's mind.

Sure, the original game might've sold well, but that doesn't mean a game deserves to get a sequel - at least not artistically-speaking. Publisher shareholders might have a different opinion on the matter, though...

8. Hello Neighbor

hello neighbor
TinyBuild

Hello Neighbor is proof perfect that a quality end product is no match for a game's viral potential.

This stealth horror game, in which players attempt to sneak into their strange neighbour's basement, was widely panned on release for basically everything that wasn't the story and characters.

For all its promises of intelligent, dynamic AI, Hello Neighbor was a pure slog to play, its unremarkable puzzles and generic stealth gameplay conspiring with an abundance of bugs to sabotage any lingering promise.

Yet the viral marketing propelled it to massive sales success regardless, leading to a number of spin-off titles before Hello Neighbor 2 was finally released in 2022.

While the sequel received better reviews for its somewhat more robust gameplay, it was still an agonisingly mid experience to behold. 

And yet, continually boosted by its popularity with streamers, the franchise continues to flourish commercially, with Hello Neighbor 3 currently in the works.


7. Red Steel

Red Steel
Ubisoft Paris

Red Steel was one of the launch titles for the Nintendo Wii - a first-person shooter intended to showcase the console's innovative motion controls.

But like so many launch games, Red Steel feels less fully-formed than an awkward proof-of-concept, and one that categorically fails to make a compelling argument for its focal feature.

Even if you can forgive the thunderously generic crime story and characters, Red Steel's motion controls were woefully clunky and unresponsive, ensuring that both gunplay and swordfights failed to rouse the advertised excitement.

Yet the game was still a commercial success on the apparent strength of its gimmick, enough that Red Steel 2 arrived four years later in 2010.

And fair's fair - Ubisoft Paris took most of the vocal complaints about the original onboard, with the Wii's MotionPlus accessory ensuring the motion control combat was decidedly more intuitive this time around.

Basically, Red Steel 2 is what Red Steel 1 should've been.

The irony, however, is that many players were seemingly burned by the original game, as Red Steel 2 proved a sales disappointment, causing Ubisoft to cancel tentative plans for a third title.


6. Bubsy 3D

Bubsy 3d
Eidetic

There are few video game franchises more bafflingly enduring than Bubsy, because while the earlier installments were basically passable Sonic knock-offs, Bubsy 3D was a failure of such catastrophic proportions that it would've sunk most other IP for good.

Even with the novelty of Bubsy 3D being one of the first fully 3D platformers, its controls, garish environments, and grating voice acting were swiftly panned.

It certainly didn't help that publisher Accolade dared to release it mere months after Super Mario 64 sucked all the oxygen out of the room.

Two poorly received spin-offs were released in 2017 and 2019, but the world was left shook when, last year, Atari announced that Bubsy 4D was in development.

There was a loud echo of "Who asked for this?" throughout the gaming sphere, even as some couldn't help but respect the audacity to produce a sequel to a widely loathed, commercially unsuccessful platformer from 30 years ago.

And in the biggest plot twist of all, early gameplay impressions have been shockingly positive, suggesting this just might be the series' best game yet. A low bar for sure, but great to see it cleared regardless.


5. Rise of the Robots

Rise Of The Robots
Mirage

There are many, many young gamers who saw the box art for Rise of the Robots and thought that it looked like the coolest game of all time. 

After all, this 1994 cyborg brawler touted some extremely cool character designs and 3D visuals that, at the time, were mouth-wateringly impressive.

But within minutes of loading Rise of the Robots up, it became clear that the game was a pig with lipstick on. 

Even the basic moment-to-moment controls feel horrible and the move sets are brutally lacking, ensuring there's absolutely nothing going on beyond the visuals and Brian May's awesome soundtrack.

Yet despite the game's commercial failure, a sequel was swiftly developed anyway, with Rise 2: Resurrection launching just 18 months after the first.

But if you thought that developer Mirage might've learned any harsh lessons after the pummelling the first game took, think not. Unsurprisingly it flopped at retail just like its predecessor, killing this most puzzling franchise dead.


4. Killzone

Killzone
Guerrilla Games

The original Killzone is nothing if not a cautionary tale of what hype can do to a game's reputation. 

Widely touted as a potential "Halo killer," Guerrilla Games' FPS was ultimately a hollow shell - visually and sonically impressive to a point, but an absolute chore to get through due to the sluggish, wading-through-treacle control scheme, generic shooter gunplay, atrocious AI, and excess of bugs.

It's the dull colour greige in video game form, making all the foaming pre-release hype seem that much more ridiculous.

But Killzone nevertheless sold enough for Sony to greenlight a sequel - a sequel which turned a lot of heads with its jaw-dropping reveal trailer at E3 2005, a trailer so mind-bogglingly impressive many (rightly) believed it was pre-rendered.

Yet when Killzone 2 finally landed in 2009, it received near-universal acclaim for its technical achievements and tight gunplay, proving itself a colossal improvement over its utterly lifeless predecessor.

Its commercial success led to two additional sequels, before Guerrilla effectively retired the IP to focus on the Horizon franchise.


3. Two Worlds

Two worlds game
Reality Pump

Two Worlds is a 2007 action-RPG infamous for several reasons - its dated graphics, infuriating interface, and most of all its utterly shambolic voice acting, which was largely performed by staff at developer Reality Pump in place of professional performers.

There's Eurojank and then there's... whatever the fresh hell Two Worlds is. A Hall of Fame-tier example of a developer biting off more than they can chew.

Yet folk sure do love their RPGs, and so Two Worlds was a solid seller regardless, resulting in the release of the comically monikered Two Worlds II in 2010.

But credit where it's due - this sequel was a marked improvement over its predecessor, from its more polished gameplay to its professional voice acting.

It certainly still had its rough edges and didn't fully escape the Eurojank label, but there was a much clearer alignment between the ambition of the dev team and the final game they released.

Two Worlds III was announced more than a decade ago, though considering how little we've heard about it lately, it doesn't seem terribly likely to ever see the light of day.


2. Dead Island

Dead Island
Deep Silver

Is there a game more categorically set up to fail by its amazing reveal trailer than Dead Island?

The cinematic teaser trailer, which depicts a young girl transforming into a zombie and being thrown out of a window in reverse, suggested an emotional resonance and artfulness that just wasn't present in the final game.

In reality, Dead Island was an incredibly schlocky open world action-RPG without much of a story to speak of. 

Furthermore, the gameplay was packed to the brim with jank, it launched with an obscene amount of bugs, and the visuals were repellent even for 2011.

It was a passable slice of zombie-killin' junk for short play sessions, but ultimately so piecemeal in basically every aspect that it failed to hold the attention long. Not great for a game with a 20-hour critical path.

But Dead Island still sold well enough for a DLC, a spin-off, and eventually a bonafide sequel in 2023.

In the very least, Dead Island 2 boasted more personality and polish than its predecessor, which is a basically miraculous result after a near-decade-long development period.


1. Shaq Fu

shaq fu
EA

And finally we have Shaq Fu, which not merely content to be terrible, just might be one of the worst video games of all time.

As amusing as the prospect of a fighting game starring Shaquille O'Neal might be, Shaq Fu undermines any sense of fun with its maddeningly unresponsive controls, limited move sets, and thoroughly naff animations.

It was so clearly a game created as a cynical branding exercise for its star and nothing more - a title designed to take up shelf space in stores for a few months and then never be heard from again.

But some 24 years later, Shaq Fu returned from the dead with the belated sequel nobody asked for - Shaq Fu: A Legend Reborn.

And while this follow-up received a little more praise for its self-aware tone and improved gameplay, it was still dire by any regular metric. In the very least its apparently lukewarm sales should keep us safe from Shaq Fu 3. 


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.