10 Scariest Movies That Aren't Horror

These non-horror movies will leave you SHOOK.

Threads man with fire background
BBC

The beauty of the horror genre is that it's a big, wide spectrum that can encompass a near-limitless number of styles and tones, ensuring the definition really comes down to whatever a filmmaker would prefer. While the following ten movies would certainly not be traditionally deemed horror films, they do offer up such soul-shaking, nerve-rattling terror that they basically feel like horror movies regardless.

So, inspired by this recent Reddit thread on the very subject, here are the ten scariest movies ever made that actually aren't horror movies. From stomach-knottingly tense thrillers to brutally disturbing war films, existential dramas, and even a certain Steven Spielberg-directed blockbuster, these non-horror movies gave us all nightmares regardless of their label.

It's a tough thread to needle, and in a few cases some might even argue that the filmmakers went too far in hammering the horror home, but there's a blunt effectiveness to each of these movies and their no-nonsense approach to provocative subject matter.

Again, they're not horror movies in any official capacity, but considering how they left us all feeling when the end credits finally, mercifully rolled, they might as well have been...

10. We Need to Talk About Kevin

Ezra Miller We Need To Talk About Kevin
Artificial Eye

Tonally and stylistically, Lynne Ramsay's masterful We Need to Talk About Kevin tap-dances on the fringes of horror throughout, even if it's officially a psychological thriller-slash-drama.

Ramsay's movie is basically every parent's worst nightmare, as Tilda Swinton's Eva struggles to reckon with her inability to bond with her son Kevin (Ezra Miller), and come to terms with the subsequent heinous act he commits as a teenager.

Tripwire-tense, awash in the colour red, and leaving enough ambiguity hanging in the air to haunt viewers long after the credits roll, We Need to Talk About Kevin broaches an extremely difficult subject with both tact and honesty.

A young Miller is remarkably chilling as the title character, and, in an era where explosive acts of violence are commonplace across America, its messaging feels only more vital than it did back in 2011. It's not an easy sit, but it is a refreshingly confronting piece of work about a subject many simply don't want to discuss - how psychopaths are made.


9. Come And See

Come And See
Sovexportfilm

War movies can either serve to glorify combat or demonise the human cost, and in the latter case there's simply no better or more impactful example than Elem Klimov's incredible 1985 film Come and See.

Klimov's dramatisation of the Nazi German occupation of Belarus can't ever be accused of making warfare "cool" or "sexy" - this is a profoundly upsetting, even nightmarish look at how war destroys youthful hope and innocence.

Topped by a mesmerising performance from Aleksei Kravchenko - in what might be the greatest work ever done by a child actor - Come and See is unflinching in its brutality and yet never feels exploitative or without purpose.

You'll certainly want to have something frothy and harmless cued up to watch afterwards, but the film so expertly details war's grand toll that it should probably be mandatory viewing for politicians the world over.


8. Contagion

Contagion Kate Winslet
Warner Bros.

When Steven Soderbergh's pandemic thriller Contagion was released back in 2011, many opined that while it was entertaining, it also felt a touch too ridiculous at times.

And then COVID happened.

Needless to say, Contagion's account of what humanity would be reduced to by a pandemic was pretty much spot-on, with Scott Z. Burns' expertly researched script conveying the fear, the paranoia, the selfishness, and yes, the grifters trying to profit off it all.

Thankfully COVID wasn't nearly as deadly as the virus in Contagion, which sweeps the world and unexpectedly wipes out major cast members totally out of nowhere. Soderbergh's detached directorial style only further highlights the staid eeriness with which the virus takes lives, obliterates social order, and shows us all who we really are.

As awful as COVID has been, Contagion posits a considerably bleaker situation for humanity, and one we should probably be glad we didn't end up with.


7. Threads

Threads man with fire background
BBC

Quite probably the most terrifying British film ever made, Threads is a docudrama depicting the fallout both literal and figurative of nuclear war between the United States and Soviet Union.

With its grounded setting of Sheffield, deeply immersive docu-style camerawork, and utterly relentless account of the physical, mental, economic, and overall societal impact of a nuclear strike, Threads makes almost all other post-apocalyptic films feel like cartoonish fantasies by comparison.

The down-to-Earth matter-of-factness of the filmmaking makes its many horrific sights feel cruelly believable even four decades later, while serving as perhaps cinema's greatest argument about any nation ever dropping another bomb.

Even going into Threads with an awareness of its reputation as one of the most terrifying films ever made, you're probably not ready for how anxious it's primed to make you feel.

There aren't any supernatural monsters or mask-wielding serial killers, but there is a basically never-ending parade of unforgettably harrowing imagery. And yet, it still never loses sight of the human factor nor devolves into pure misery porn.


6. The Father

The Father Anthony Hopkins
Sony Pictures Classics

It's incredibly difficult to convey the interior experience of an individual living with dementia cinematically, but director Florian Zeller did a devastatingly effective job in The Father.

Anthony Hopkins gives an arguably career-best - and unarguably Oscar-winning - performance as an elderly man suffering from dementia, which combines with the film's ingenious non-linear editing style to capture the emotional destruction caused by an individual losing grasp of their own identity.

Better than any other film on the tough subject, The Father explores both the gut-wrenching personal impact and havoc it wreaks on an afflicted individual's family. And so, Zeller would've only needed to add a few genre flourishes to make his movie a true out-and-out horror flick - though if he had, the horror-averse Academy likely would've ignored The Father completely rather than shower Hopkins with awards.

You'll probably only ever want to watch The Father once, yet considering how deeply it mines the well of existential horror, once will probably be enough.


5. Zodiac

Zodiac Robert Downey Jr. Jake Gyllenhaal
Warner Bros.

Though some might well consider it a card-carrying horror movie, David Fincher's Zodiac is better categorised as a crime thriller/police procedural - and an exquisitely well-crafted one at that.

From start to finish, this dramatisation of the Zodiac Killer's rampage across the San Francisco Bay Area is utterly soaked with dread, Fincher building an atmosphere of deep unease that's all the more unsettling because - spoilers! - Zodiac remains at large to this very day.

Fincher does his level-best to erode the facade of safety that most movies put up, instead acutely reminding audiences that they never know who they're going to encounter out on the street on any given day.

No fantastical monsters are necessary here - with a mere flesh-and-blood antagonist, Zodiac delivers one of the most chilling cat-and-mouse games in cinema history, underlining the cold brutality with which serial killers operate.

While many serial killer movies love to play fast and loose with the facts for dramatic effect, Fincher's fastidiously researched and meticulously detailed approach finds true terror in the distressingly everyday.


4. The Zone Of Interest

The Zone of Interest
A24

Like basically every movie ever made about the Holocaust, Jonathan Glazer's Oscar-winning masterpiece The Zone of Interest can't help but be deeply horrifying, yet also approaches its subject matter in a wildly unconventional way.

Rather than relentlessly document the terrors of what occurred in the Auschwitz concentration camp in up-close detail, Glazer keeps us on the periphery, only able to observe from afar in a house next to the camp. And so, instead of showing emaciated prisoners and gas chambers as one might expect, we're left only to watch billowing smoke from trains pulling into a nearby station, and smokestacks belching human remnants into the sky.

The film also relies heavily on its Oscar-winning sound design, with much of the off-screen horror implied through bone-chilling screams, gunshots, barking dogs, and so on. By framing the film around one of the camp's commandants and his family living next door to Auschwitz, The Zone of Interest captures the banality of evil in uniquely nauseating terms.


3. Indiana Jones And The Temple of Doom

Temple Of Doom Black Sleep
Paramount Pictures

Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom well and truly tested the bounds of what Hollywood could pass off as "family-friendly" blockbuster entertainment, because this is quite possibly the single most deranged four-quadrant tentpole ever made.

While Indiana Jones has always flirted with grotesquery - Raiders' traumatising face-melt sequence, for instance - Temple of Doom basically bathes in it. This is, after all, a film centered around a Thuggee cult that enslaves children, practises black magic, and rips out the hearts of human sacrifices for the goddess Kali. 

There's little goofy or light about these prolonged sequences, which frequently lurch into genuinely disturbing territory. Hell, Steven Spielberg himself even called it "too horrific," and went so far as to say that it "out-poltered Poltergeist."

George Lucas meanwhile suggested that Temple ultimately became a much darker beast than either he or Spielberg intended because they were both going through relationship breakdowns at the time, putting them in a headspace not remotely conducive to producing rip-roaring, breezy action-adventure entertainment.

While Temple is certainly among the series' more divisive entries, its bold edginess nevertheless won it many loyal defenders, who respect Spielberg for delivering such a ballsy horrorshow of a blockbuster.


2. Requiem For A Dream

Jared Leto Requiem For A Dream
Artisan Entertainment

Darren Aronofsky's Requiem for a Dream demonstrates the soul-destroying perils of drug addiction in deeply disturbing yet utterly hypnotic fashion.

Luring audiences in with its stylish filmmaking and especially its razor-sharp editing, Aronofsky's movie nevertheless offers no fun times or easy respite for its beleaguered central characters, each of whom is on an unavoidable path towards annihilation in one form or another.

Perhaps more than any other film ever made, Requiem for a Dream forensically details how drug abuse can erode a person's sense of self and boil them down to the all-consuming pursuit of another fix.

Jared Leto, Jennifer Connelly, Marlon Wayans, and especially Ellen Burstyn - who received a Best Actress Oscar nomination for her work - turn in sublimely heartbreaking performances, teasing out the existential horror of dependence. And by the time it's all over, you'll feel more shook than by 99.9% of actual horror movies.


1. Mulholland Drive

Mulholland Drive Naomi Watts
Universal

And finally, while many might consider David Lynch's Mulholland Drive a straight-up horror movie - and honestly, who can blame them? - Lynch himself insists that it isn't. So, Word of God and all that.

All the same, this delirious mystery-thriller offers up one of the most terrifying depictions of identity crisis ever committed to film, complete with perfectly executed jump scares, deeply disturbing imagery, and an overcurrent of pervasive dread.

While the particulars of Mulholland Drive's narrative remain up for debate almost 25 years on, it so acutely feels like the experience of someone losing their mind in cinematic form, aided by superb performances from Naomi Watts and Laura Elena Harring.

Like much of Lynch's output, the overall tone is so uncomfortable throughout that it can certainly be deemed horror-adjacent. All the same, nobody would blame you for calling it a pure horror movie - just don't say it to Lynch's face.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Threads
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.