10 Bands That Stole Another Band's Sound

Unintentional plagiarism.

my chemical romance
Reprise

A band’s goal is typically to find a sound that no one has ever heard before. While it’s easy to follow along with genre trends, it’s always more fun to find a sound that you can really identify with. These bands certainly have their sound down to a science... it’s just that it belongs to someone else.

For as much as some people try to distance themselves from their influences, a lot of bands have come to the forefront who aren’t even shy about where they got their sound from. Whether it’s playing in the same style of music or actively lifting the chord progressions of famous songs, these bands have all worn those influences a little too much on their sleeves.

Even though some of these bands have had to live in the shadow of their influences, some have been able to successfully distance themselves from their heroes by switching up a style or improving on the sound they stole.

From having a one-off song tribute to making a full-blown career out of plagiarism, these are just a handful of bands who could have benefited from being just a touch more original in their heyday.

10. Madonna To Lady Gaga

Lady Gaga was a breath of fresh air for the entire pop scene at the end of the ‘00s. With so many divas crowding the charts, here was a bonafide superstar that was ripped straight out of the golden age of pop music. A lot of Gaga’s talent came from years of hard work, but the style and aesthetic was a bit too on the nose.

Ever since her debut with “Just Dance,” Gaga has always gotten dozens of haters claiming that everything she is doing is based on Madonna. It might seem like a cheap shot comparing the ‘80s superstar to a new pop star, but using the same chord structure between songs like “Express Yourself” and “Born This Way” are a bit too close to just be a coincidence.

While it may have been easy to put Gaga in the realm of throwback act, she has actually done plenty of other musical ventures to distance herself from the genre as of late, from the country tinged Joanne to the duets album with Tony Bennett.

Also, Gaga has one-upped her competition by giving a much greater acting performance in A Star is Born than Madonna has given in her entire filmography. It was a long road to acclaim, but Lady Gaga shook off the naysayers and has turned into one of the most interesting pop stars of the past 20 years.


9. Mr. Bungle To Red Hot Chili Peppers

Whenever you take too much influence from a band’s sound, the artist in question might take in a different way. While many will take it in stride, others may be a little skeptical as to why a new band would try to take ownership over their style.

Other times though, those artistic similarities can lead to outright hatred between two acts.

Such is the case when Mr. Bungle came to fruition in the ‘90s. Formed by Faith No More frontman Mike Patton, this act combined rock aggression and funky rhythms with a punky attitude, alongside a vocal delivery that fit comfortably between singing and rapping. It was a unique shakeup for alternative rock, but the fact the Red Hot Chili Peppers were already huge at the time led to a bit of a dustup.

Wanting to stir the pot a little bit, Patton took to the stage one night with Mr. Bungle, performing some of the Chili Peppers’ tunes with the words changed, as well as pretending to shoot heroin in reference to the band’s drug problems.

Absolutely disgusted by his behaviour, Chili Peppers frontman Anthony Kiedis asked that Mr. Bungle be removed from a major festival that the Chilis were supposed to appear on. Sometimes people are able to make amends with their copycats, but this feud ended up getting ugly really fast.


8. Metallica To Megadeth

Dave Mustaine deserves a lot of credit for pioneering the sound that has become known as thrash. Ever since he started playing in the California area, the riffs he wrote ended up becoming some of the most legendary musical pieces in the metal genre. It’s a pretty big accolade for any rockstar to achieve that, but Mustaine never really got to celebrate his accomplishments.

Originally destined to dominate the planet with Metallica, Mustaine was woken up and kicked out of the band after they had travelled across the country in search of a record deal. Even more insulting was the fact that Dave ended up hearing his riffs used in some of Metallica’s greatest songs like “Ride the Lightning” and “The Four Horsemen.”

Not wanting to go back to being a burnout, Mustaine assembled a ragtag team of metal musicians and formed Megadeth, where he performed his songs to try to equal his former band’s might.

Attempting to improve upon his old band’s attempts at writing songs, Mustaine ended up rewriting songs with the same riffs he had written for Metallica, with “Mechanix” copying “The Four Horsemen” and “Hangar 18” borrowing the chord progression from “The Call of Ktulu.”

A lot of bands like to borrow from their predecessors, but in this case, Mustaine ended up aping himself and crafting a completely different metal beast.


7. The Rolling Stones To Aerosmith

The impact of the British Invasion on the American rock scene cannot be understated.

For as much as Little Richard and Chuck Berry set the standard for what rock would be going forward, acts like the Beatles and the Rolling Stones laid the blueprint for every other band to follow. Anyone would kill for that kind of rock chemistry, but one band from Boston had that British swagger down a little too well.

Nowadays, people tend to know Aerosmith for their mix of boogie rock and soulful vocals from Steven Tyler, but it was a totally different story when they started out.

As the band were coming out with their first few records, they often came under fire for sounding a bit too much like the Rolling Stones. With the Stones already going down a more blues-influenced road, the amount of swagger Aerosmith had at the time seemed secondhand by comparison.

It also didn’t help that the band’s main songwriters Steven Tyler and Joe Perry had a chemistry that seemed like a caricature version of Mick Jagger and Keith Richards. Though the band may have been going down the same path as the Stones, later albums like Toys in the Attic and Rocks showed them opening up their influence to more eclectic ballads and hard-edged rock and roll.

Aerosmith may be synonymous with rock right now, but their connection to one of Britain’s greatest rock acts started out as a real sore spot.


6. Queen To My Chemical Romance

My Chemical Romance got a lot of hate thrown at them in their early years based on their looks. Regardless of the musical talent these guys possessed, many people thought they were just prettyboys who threw on some eyeliner and tried to appeal to the emo crowd. Even when people started taking them seriously with the Black Parade, the band still couldn’t shake off the cries of plagiarism.

While the band’s influences in the early days were very much indebted to the heavier side of rock like hardcore and punk, The Black Parade was a sprawling rock epic of mammoth proportions, with orchestral guitar parts and stratospheric vocals. The goth opera idea ended up being just ridiculous enough to actually work, but the band ended up being criticized for just pulling from Queen. The members had no shame in citing Freddie Mercury and co. as an influence, but the crux of the record pulls from all kinds of rock and roll, from metallic gloom to Southern rock to blues to theatrical balladry.

If anything, the band’s costumes of military men owe themselves more to the Beatles in the Sgt. Pepper’s era than to the ones who brought you “Bohemian Rhapsody.” Sure, some of the tunes may have looked similar on the surface, but the Black Parade ended up being a completely different beast whose musical power could even equal some of Freddie Mercury’s finest moments.


5. Mushroomhead To Slipknot

When Slipknot first arrived on the scene, they seemed like something ripped straight out of your nightmares.

From the dark themes they explored in their songs to the terrifying masks that they donned while performing, these guys have won the hearts of many metalheads and terrified many little siblings in their day. It could take any other band years to find an aesthetic this perfect, but Slipknot may have had some collateral inspiration along the way.

As the band’s debut started gaining traction throughout the metal community, the band ended up being criticized by fellow metal act Mushroomhead.

For as much as Corey Taylor’s shout defined the band, Mushroomhead’s mix of harsher influences as well as bits of nu metal in their presentation gave them a decent argument for calling Slipknot copycats. Lifting a sound is one thing, but the fact that Mushroomhead also wore masks when performing led many to believe that their argument did actually hold some water.

Though the bands have sparred back and forth ever since the late ‘90s, things finally seem to be water under the bridge nowadays, with even some of the Mushroomhead band members performing with Slipknot DJ Sid Wilson. It may seem important to call out someone who has ripped you off, but these bands have shown the ability to take the high road and move on from a petty feud.


4. Pearl Jam To Stone Temple Pilots

At the dawn of the ‘90s grunge movement, you couldn’t escape bands like Pearl Jam and Nirvana from tearing up the charts.

No matter which radio station you were on, chances are something from the rainy city of Seattle would find its way across your dial. Just when it seemed like the next new Pearl Jam album would be great, fans were up in arms when they found out someone else had tried to pull from Eddie Vedder’s songbook.

The song in question was “Plush” by Stone Temple Pilots, which featured loud guitars with the right amount of distortion and Scott Weiland droning on in a nasally style way too reminiscent of Vedder’s yarl.

While most casual rock fans took it with a grain of salt, the Seattle grunge community were absolutely furious at this new band. Since they came from the beaches of San Diego, what the hell would they know about the tortured Seattle sound?

Even though things started pretty tense, STP ended up becoming one of the biggest names in the alternative movement, quickly moving on from the grunge sound to a more conventional hard rock approach and even glam rock stylings on albums like Tiny Music…

Stone Temple Pilots deserve to be in the conversation of the greatest bands of the ‘90s, but when getting the ball rolling, they were public enemy #1 for any grunge purist.


3. Bob Dylan To Bruce Springsteen

Bruce Springsteen has come to define everything great about the American Dream. Coming from nothing on the mean streets of New Jersey, his run of albums like Born to Run and Darkness on the Edge of Town have painted the most vivid stories that the rock world has ever seen. There’s no doubting Springsteen’s songwriting prowess, but the way in which he approached his tunes was a little close to another rock wordsmith.

Though Springsteen has his definitive sound down to a science at this stage, his early days saw him getting tagged as a more rootsy version of Bob Dylan.

From a critical standpoint, there are far worse songwriters to be compared to than Dylan, but the kind of praise seemed a little too apt for Springsteen to handle. Even though Springsteen had loved Dylan as a kid, he did not set out to be just another kid trying to write in his style.

After a few more albums of the Dylan tag, Springsteen broke through to the mainstream with Born to Run, where the power of his E Street Band finally gave his music the emotional gravitas it really needed. The fame may have gotten a little too close for comfort at times, but after his magnum opus, Springsteen went from the interim Dylan to the Boss.


2. Radiohead To Muse

Muse has remained one of the most interesting acts going in the rock world today. Standing at just three people, this power trio has mixed everything from alternative to classical music to electronica to arena rock to help fill out their gargantuan sound. Even with that many influences at their disposal, people still have found similarities to another rock giant.

Ever since the band’s debut with Showbiz, they have constantly been called a substitute Radiohead by fans around the world. Though Muse may have their sound in their own right, it’s not that hard to see where the naysayers are coming from.

The tenor register of Matt Bellamy has always been somewhat reminiscent of Thom Yorke’s spectral croon, but Muse has always been more than just their frontman. While both bands have also had songs related to space travel, the similarities seem less in practice and more in creative mindset.

From the start, both Radiohead and Muse have always refused to be tied down to one genre, but that’s where the comparisons should end. Whether you’re listening to Black Holes and Revelations or In Rainbows, both bands have done what they could to toy with their sound at every turn.

Muse may have put out some tunes that feel like leftovers from Ok Computer, but songs like “Knights of Cydonia” and “Uprising” have given them a sound all their own.


1. At the Altar of John Lennon - Oasis

By the mid ‘90s, it felt like the British Invasion was coming back around again. In a weird reversal of the ‘60s Revolution, the Britpop movement started to arrive in full force, with Oasis leading the charge as one of the most accomplished bands on the scene.

They may have had the same spirit of the British Invasion, but the Gallagher Brothers also had a lot in common with some of the bands of the time as well.

It’s almost become a running joke amongst music fans as to how much Oasis has pulled their ideas from the Beatles. From the way they sing to the way Noel Gallagher composed songs, these guys clearly worship the ground and Lennon and McCartney have walked on.

Across the band’s big hits, you can hear bits and pieces from the Fab Four, from Liam Gallagher’s nasal whine to the fact that the intro of “Don’t Look Back In Anger” basically lifts the entire melody of “Imagine.”

Even the Gallaghers seem to be in on the joke by cramming their lyrics with Beatles references, but what they did went beyond just worshipping their idols. As opposed to just being the ‘90s version of the Greatest Band in the World, the Gallagher Brothers took the Beatles’ melodic foundation and combined it with punk and psychedelia to create some of the most glorious anthems of the modern age.

Though people may still contest that Oasis should be held accountable for plagiarism, what they did was not so much stealing but rather re-contextualizing the pop rock of old for a new generation.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97