10 Famous Books You've Been Reading Wrong This Whole Time
Sometimes hobbits are just hobbits.
Allegory, symbolism, critical analysis... sometimes we just overdo it. Books have been used to propel ideas through subtle references and metaphor, and often the reader easily gets the point: Narnia is about Christianity for instance, but no one would really describe this as subtle.
Sometimes a classic book becomes divorced from its historical context over the years. Or the intent of the author is ignored in favour of some other unintentional message, or sometimes the public as a whole just doesn't really 'do' nuance. And of course occasionally the movie is just a bad adaptation.
It raises an interesting question of who decides what the meaning of a work truly is: is it the person who planned and executed the storytelling or is it the person who in the end will pay for and consume the work? It can be argued that as the consumer and members of the court of public opinion that we decide what the true meaning is. But when a person takes the time to write the damn thing we should at least assume they get a pretty big say in the matter.
But sometimes a work is created to carry a specific meaning and instead of attributing some outside truth, we instead suggest it's about ghosts or some other nonsense.
10. The Prince Is Not Actually Machiavellian
Because of this book any act of social of political subterfuge in the name of personal advancement is characterised as 'Machiavellian'. The Prince acts as a guide on removing empathy and kindness from political practices, and discusses the best means of consolidating power and fooling the population. Even in the modern era it is relevant in its instruction, except it's all a pisstake.
Similar to Johnathan Swift's 'A Modest Proposal' (which isn't actually about eating children) the book is a satire, pointing out the flaws with the contemporary regime of 1500s Italy by posing as an educational text. Unlike Swift's guide on the preparation and eating of the poor, however, many people have tended to take the book at face value and see it as an actual guide on gaining power.
At this point in European history the upper class were given education on some themes that Machiavelli discusses, just without the sarcasm.
Rarely for its time and genre, it was written in vernacular Italian rather than Latin, leading some theorists to suggest Machiavelli may also have aimed to show the proletarian class the injustices present in the regime. It doesn't help when everyone misses the joke and just takes you seriously though.
9. Don Quixote Is Not About How Great Knights Are
Don Quixote is the story of Alonso Quixano, an old nobleman obsessed with romantic tales of chivalry, a very popular genre of literature at the time. So obsessed with tales of knights and quests in fact he decides to dub himself 'Don Quixote' and embark on a quest to... he never really plans that far ahead.
He employs a squire/carer, fights giants/windmills, and attacks some wizards/friars. It' s a pretty light-hearted affair but with hidden, or at least ignored, depths.
In truth, it's another pisstake, but this time instead of focusing his barbs towards the upper crust of society the author attempted to poke fun at a certain kind of literary fan. No one seemed to get the joke because Don Quixote, when analysed, is looked on as a love letter to tales of chivalry; when in actuality the point is to try an bring an end to a genre which Cervantes believed was deficient.
When Don Quixote was first published it was viewed almost universally as a riotous comedy. It was only later on that between poor translations and lost context that the book came to be considered the great novel of chivalry most believe it to be.
8. Gulliver's Travels Was Not A Children's Classic
Gulliver's Travels is a lovely adventure tale for children, or at least that's the way it's presented. If you check any bookshop (online or the other kind) you will find numerous retellings of the story as a picture book. In a way this makes sense: the book is a pretty silly tale of a man visiting a number of fictional countries and encountering their weird inhabitants, whether they be foreign, small or horses.
The problem is as time has gone on the book has lost its historical/cultural context. When it was first published in the early 1700s, it was considered a biting satire on nobility, xenophobia, weird science, and petty political feuding.
The tiny Lilliputians, for example, represent regal conflict and the ways in which the average citizen is drawn into the squabbles of nobility. For the Lilliputians the pointless debate was which end to open a boiled egg, a conflict about which the common man doesn't often worry.
It's kind of forgivable that Gulliver's Travels is so widely misread today, as its targets were rooted in a very particular cultural climate which really doesn't exist anymore. Also it was a parody of the (at the time very popular) 'travel diary' genre, though it did very little to stop its success, as you will see at your local bookshop.
7. Jane Austen's Pride And Prejudice Is Not All That Romantic
Most people believe Pride And Prejudice to be the greatest piece of chick lit ever written, harking back to a more genteel time when ladies were ladies, men were square-jawed and stories ended with a nice wedding. They also believe it involves Colin Firth in some capacity.
Pride And Prejudice, at its heart, is not some grand love story. Love plays a part, as does prejudice and indeed pride, but the nub and crux of the book is its subtle critique of the social norm of treating women, specifically daughters, as a means of moving up the social ladder.
This message criticising what essentially amounts to arranged marriage has been lost over the years. This happens a lot with older books with romantic plotlines: Wuthering Heights, for example, is often considered a great romance, but it's more of a revenge story than anything else.
To truly understand Austen's writing, you need some insight into the woman herself. Jane Austen, who never married and didn't really like people, had no patience with either romance or the restrictions placed upon her by her class and gender. She was very smart and she was very bored, as anyone might be if their primary roles in life consisted of 'embroidery' and 'being charming'.
6. Frankenstein Is Not About Playing God
Before any discussion of the importance of Frankenstein can occur, it should be pointed out that Shelley wrote the book on a bet. She was trying to win a scary story competition between her, her husband Percy Shelley, and Lord Byron.
Also the concept came to her in a dream (or so she claimed). With all this in mind it would be perfectly valid to elide any discussion of the book's deeper themes and just read it as a nice creepy Gothic tale.
What the book most definitely is not about, contrary to its common interpretation, is playing God. You can in some small way read that to be a critical theme, but the major motif of the book is about taking responsibility for your own actions. (Ironic, as it was initially published anonymously.)
Dr Frankenstein didn't create a monster when he moulded a man-shape from fleshy playdough. He created the monster when he rejected his creature. What was he expecting, some kind of delightful Adonis-esque tennis buddy? On his first go?
Frankenstein opens with a quote from Milton that makes this point very clear: “Did I request thee, Maker, from my clay / to mould me man? Did I solicit thee / From Darkness to promote me?”
5. Friedrich Nietzsche's Thus Spake Zarathustra Is Not Really For Nazis
Another chapter in the very long saga of 'Nazis ruining everything'. Much like his contemporary Wagner, Nietzsche is credited with inspiring and reinforcing the Nazis' ultra-nationalistic, wildly racist ideologies. Unlike Wagner, a raging antisemite, Nietzsche was actually violently opposed to nationalism and theories of racial superiority.
The misunderstanding is in large part down to Nietzsche's sister Elisabeth Förster Nietzsche. After Nietzsche died she became the owner of his intellectual property and ordered edits on his work, this included giving Zarathustra a far more nationalist spin and presenting Nietzsche, for future readers, in a believer of nationalism.
The edits were because Elisabeth was super nationalistic and seeing her brother's ability to present philosophy and convince an audience, decided that his works were a bit too liberal for her taste.
The most enduring concept from Zarathustra is that of the Ubermensch: a sort of John Cena of the soul, if you will. The Nazis, through a combination of malicious editing from Elisabeth and their own poor reading comprehension, took the Ubermensch to represent an ideal of Aryan perfection.
Nietzsche had meant the concept as a kind of unattainable goal, something all of humanity could strive towards, rather than any kind of pseudo-scientific inevitability.
4. Upton Sinclair's The Jungle Is Not About Meat
If you like eating meat, don't read The Jungle.
When Upton Sinclair's The Jungle was published in 1906 it contained an authentic look at the meat industry in 1900s America. These practices are what you would consider now to be barbaric and akin to having Oscar the Grouch as your butcher.
The book had a massive effect: it grossed out the entire nation and lead to new legislation on health practices on the meat industry. It's a pretty amazing look at how literature can effect real change, it just wasn't the change Sinclair was aiming for.
Sinclair wanted to highlight the harsh treatment and conditions on the mostly immigrant work force. He worked in a meat packing plant to get an idea of the working life of most of the working poor's lives, which is why the book contains so much information on the industry.
In a darkly ironic twist new legislation brought in as a result, focusing on hygiene rather than employment rights, led to workers being forced to work harder and longer in dangerous conditions.
Sinclair described his regret on the misunderstanding with his now famous quote: “I aimed at the public's heart and accidentally hit it in the stomach.”
3. Nineteen Eighty-Four And Animal Farm Aren't About How Bad Communism Is
Orwellian, Big Brother-esque, thoughtcrime: these are all terms that will get thrown around as examples of how society is going to hell and becoming more like George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four. It's downright impossible to get a real idea of what Orwell was going for, unless of course you read about what Orwell was going for, then it's easy.
Nineteen Eighty-Four and Animal Farm get pushed together here, as both are seen as a dystopic view of communism and totalitarian rule, with Nineteen Eighty-Four specifically going into the details on government surveillance and control.
Big Brother isn't the real problem though, the fine print is the problem.
A life long socialist, Orwell saw no real issue with socialism on the whole (both books are pretty anti Stalin and single-party control, however) Orwell's big bugaboo was complacency and the public allowing these totalitarian groups to take control.
He was still trying to highlight why Stalinism was bad, but the fact he wanted to show that the public's willingness to allow it to happen seems to have become ignored over the decades.
In one letter Orwell explained that had the animals put their collective foot (paw? Hoof?) down when the pigs started hoarding all the apples they would have had no problems, but they didn't, and so Boxer the lovable horse gets turned into glue. (Spoilers.)
2. Fahrenheit 451 Is Not About Censorship
To highlight how widely misunderstood this book is: Ray Bradbury once stormed out of a university lecture he was giving on Fahrenheit 451 because the students in attendance insisted he didn't understand what the book was about. His book. That he wrote.
People tend to pick up on the book-burning as a theme in Fahrenheit 451, probably because it's such a dramatic, viscerally upsetting image; and in that context we can draw on history (once again, the Nazis ruining everything).
Because the burning of books is the part of the book that sticks with you, we assume that's the point and that it relates to censorship.
Bradbury's major intent was to direct attention to what he perceived as the collective dumbing down of people, largely exacerbated by television. He felt television allowed people to be spoon-fed information at the discretion of those who create programming, and at the expense of individual thought.
Bradbury did change his mind several times on key issues, including what the point of Fahrenheit 451 actually was, so those students at that lecture may have had a point.
1. The Lord Of The Rings Is Not Intentionally Metaphorical At All, Actually
It's a common assumption LOTR is about World War 2, with its unambiguous villain, its coalition of loosely-assembled good guys, and the eagles rushing in to save the day at the last minute, probably singing The Star-Spangled Banner. Eagles! It's not exactly a subtle metaphor.
Except it's not a metaphor at all. The eagles aren't the Americans; the camp, conflict-averse elves aren't the French; and Tom Bombadil is just... whatever the hell Tom Bombadil was supposed to be.
If the races in the book represent anything at all, it's the various regions of the UK. The amicable, food-loving hobbits and their idyllic rural homesteads represent the wilds of rural Warwickshire, for instance.
In fact Tolkien was personally offended by claims Lord Of the Rings was based on the war. In the foreword to the second edition to The Fellowship Of The Ring, he wrote: “The real war does not represent the legendary war in its process or its conclusion... I cordially dislike allegory and all its manifestations.”
Tolkien did however state that a writer can never entirely escape their own experiences and the resulting inspiration – by all accounts he was influenced by his own experiences on the Front in World War 1 – but that he had no intent of imbuing the book with any hidden meaning or symbolism. It's just a book about hobbits and a ring.