10 Greatest Unfinished Novels

Just because they aren't finished doesn't mean they aren't worth reading.

The Last Tycoon
Simon & Schuster

It takes true talent and genius to write a masterpiece even though you haven't finished it yet.

Whether due to perfectionism, other projects, illness, or even death, some authors never managed to finish books which, when eventually published posthumously, were recognised as tantalising works of literary excellence, even if there are endings missing and plot points unexplored.

The unfinished novel is something of an interesting phenomenon, similar in kind to deleted scenes or early abandoned drafts. Their incompleteness affords them an extra, mysterious quality; there is space to imagine, to daydream possibilities. That feeling attracts a certain type of reader, one who doesn't mind the ambiguity of ideas half-fleshed out or plots sharply incomplete.

But for all the many examples of unfinished works, few are of such quality as to be of anything more than of academic interest or 'what if' curios. There are, however, some volumes which shine, despite not having received that final coat of polish, and some of these vary wildly from the opening acts of stories to novels approaching their final moments.

Of this rare bunch of unfinished great books, these are the ten finest novels that continue to make us wonder 'what if', whilst satisfying every book-lover who opens their pages.

10. The Ivory Tower by Henry James

Henry James, Author
National Portrait Gallery, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Towards the end of his life, James - or The Master, as some referred to him - set about a series of highly ambitious and deftly woven novels, some of which were considered the finest writing he ever produced. Had he lived to finish The Ivory Tower, it no doubt would have automatically joined The Ambassadors and The Golden Bowl in superlative estimation.

A dark and brooding critique of money, The Ivory Tower concerns two ageing financiers looking back on their lives and wondering whether they have corrupted themselves and the next generation. The novel, as we have it, is about halfway finished; James died at this juncture, leaving copious notes and half a manuscript.

Whenever James let his imagination turn towards the darker and more sinister aspects of society, the resultant works were always amongst his best: from 'The Turn of the Screw' to 'The Figure in the Carpet.' Eschewing the supernatural aspects of those stories yet retaining the powerful, claustrophobic, and subtle prose of his late period, what we have of The Ivory Tower is magisterial, and was set to be the Master's final exquisite farewell.


9. Between The Acts By Virginia Woolf

Virginia Woolf, Author
George Charles Beresford, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In her last novel, Virginia Woolf wrote a piece that exemplifies the modernist spirit in Literature: experimental, engaged, and balanced between symbolic playfulness and sharp social critique.

Between the Acts is an intricately written story about a pageant being performed in an English country house just before the Second World War, with the play itself charting different periods of English history. The play and the audience itself serve as objects for the prose to examine and absorb in an experimental piece indicative of some of Woolf's other modernist masterpieces, particularly To the Lighthouse.

Woolf had written and submitted the manuscript but did not live to correct and make the final revisions to the novel prior to her death by her own hand. Due to this, numerous critics consider this to be an unfinished work, and it is certainly one of the finest examples as such. As the culmination of one of literature's most well-regarded careers, what we are left with is an exquisite swan song - as moving and as stylistically daring as her best works.


8. Three Days Before The Shooting… By Ralph Ellison

Ralph Ellison, Author
United States Information Agency staff photographer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Ellison's first novel, Invisible Man, was recognised as a masterpiece immediately upon publication, and some theorise that the worry about living up to it stalled progress on his second novel. And yet, when eventually the manuscript was published, it was duly recognised as the major work it is.

Edited from over 2000 manuscript pages into a novel in 2010, Three Days Before the Shooting... concerns the life of Bliss, born of indeterminate race, who is raised by a black Baptist minister, yet in adulthood, assumes the identity of a white man and becomes a race-baiting politician.

There is still debate over quite why Ellison never managed to complete the novel over the course of the 42 years he spent working on it. He claimed to have lost parts in a fire early on, though evidence from letters he wrote to friends seems to contradict that. Some blame his perfectionism. Whatever the reason, when eventually published in its longest form in 2010, the imperfect novel was still recognised as a sublime piece of work with stand out passages and sections of true power.


7. The Good Soldier Švejk by Jaroslav Hašek

The Good Solder Svejk
Wikipedia Commons

This darkly satirical novel is considered by some to be the defining work of modern Czech literature, despite having been published unfinished. The eponymous character has entered the Czech language and zeitgeist and throughout numerous translations has become world-famous, despite the book abruptly having been cut short by Hašek's death by heart attack.

Throughout the book, the mishaps and misadventures of the eponymous Svejk are charted, as he confronts authority in all its guises during the First World War. No one, whether the audience or the characters, can quite figure out if Svejk is as incompetent and daft as he seems or if this is ironic subversiveness. The result is a picaresque masterpiece and one of the first anti-war novels.

Quickly, upon publication in the early 1920s, the novel was recognised as a work of considerable merit, and quickly its influence began stretching far and wide over Europe and beyond, especially as a favourite book amongst anti-fascists in the thirties.

Today, The Good Soldier Svejk remains as fresh as it did 100 years ago and, arguably, is funnier than that other classic anti-war novel, Catch-22.


6. The Buccaneers By Edith Wharton

Edith Wharton, Author
E. F. Cooper, Newport, Rhode Island, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Death cheated us of the concluding chapters of the last of Edith Wharton's works, to which numerous critics would award the crown of the best of her writings had she managed to complete it. And yet, even still, what we have is a glittering piece of prose.

The novel revolves around the fortunes of five American women, wealthy and ambitious, and the titled yet penurious gentry they marry from England. In particular, the book focuses on the marriage of Nan to the Duke of Tintagel. This is a return to similar material as her earlier masterpiece, The Age of Innocence, and has her working in a genre she is most comfortable with.

Upon publication, many critics noted that The Buccaneers contains some of Wharton's finest prose: at turns ironic, witty, and always well measured and precise. Had she finished, it may have been her masterpiece. And yet, even unfinished, it was brought to a point in the story that leaves no frustration in the reader when they reach the end, and up until that point, you have page upon page of dazzling prose and astute social commentary.


5. Islands in the Stream by Ernest Hemingway

Ernest Hemingway, Author
Lloyd Arnold, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Islands in the Stream not only inspired the title of the song (not a facetious joke, that's actually true) but also managed to contain some of Hemingway's finest prose.

Left unfinished at the time of his suicide, Islands in the Stream is a tantalising glimmering piece of work which contains flashes of the young Hemingway brilliance, sadly lost in his later years through increasing mental strain and his trying to live up to his own legend.

Islands in the Stream tells the story of three stages in the life of Thomas Hudson, an American painter living in the Caribbean. The novel shows him and his relationships, particularly with his sons, through his time in Bimini before WWII, then in Cuba during the war, doing reconnaissance work for the Americans.

Edited after his death, Islands in the Stream was eventually posthumously published and recognised as something of a return to form for Papa Hemingway, as he was known to some. Particularly in the early fishing sequence and the final 'At Sea' act, the prose is some of the writer's most gracefully balanced.


4. Sanditon By Jane Austen

Jane Austen, Author
National Portrait Gallery, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

For her last novel, left as a partial fragment at the time of her death, Austen mustered all the wit, sharpness of detail, and exquisite prose that defined her other works for a charming examination of romance and life in a commercial seaside resort in England.

Set mostly in the fictional seaside village of Sanditon, the novel follows Charlotte Heywood as she goes to live with friends, the Parkers, who have designs to make the quiet town a fashionable seaside resort. Soon, they are all visited by relatives of the Parkers, all of whom claim to be 'invalids,' yet seem to be rather hypochondriacs.

This is typical Austen: a magnificently detailed, nuanced, and witty picture of a slice of Regency life.

Austen's bibliography is of astonishing quality and so it should hardly be surprising that, even in the truncated form in which it exists, Sanditon shares that excellence with its full-fleshed counterparts. It is the final piece of sharp observation and criticism from her pen, targeting here the fledging encroachment of commercialisation on traditional rural life.


3. The Mystery of Edwin Drood by Charles Dickens

Charles Dickens, Author
Jeremiah Gurney, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Dickens died whilst working on Edwin Drood, which has therefore left us tantalised with the unfinished mystery tale ever since, to the simultaneous delight and chagrin of generations of armchair sleuths. And unlike some of the other entries on this list, Dickens left no plan for the unwritten half of his novel, challenging writers ever since to have a go at writing a solution to this final mystery.

The Mystery of Edwin Drood focuses instead on the titular character's uncle, John Jasper: choirmaster, precentor, opium addict. To make matters more complicated, Jasper is in love with the same woman as his nephew Drood, Miss Rosa Bud, as is another man.

Amidst this romantic intrigue, Edwin Drood suddenly disappears, under the most mysterious of circumstances.

Edwin Drood is worth it alone for the magnificently glooming and foreboding opening scene set in an opium den. And yet, despite its unresolved mystery, there's enough meat on these bones to confirm Drood as Dickens at his finest; despite being half-finished, Edwin Drood is as excellent a novel for fans of the sinister and thrilling as any complete crime book today.


2. The Last Tycoon by F. Scott Fitzgerald

F. Scott Fitzgerald
Carl Van Vechten, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

After the publication of Tender is the Night in 1934, F. Scott Fitzgerald struggled with his worsening alcoholism, his wife's deteriorating mental health, and other issues which might have ended other creative ambitions in some lives. And yet, after a gruelling experience in Hollywood, Fitzgerald managed to write about half of some of his finest prose for what ended up being his final, unfinished novel.

The Last Tycoon is one of the finest of that sub-genre of Hollywood novels (despite only being half done). Set in the 1930s, the novel tells the story of Monroe Stahr, based on 'the Boy Wonder' film producer Irving Thalberg. All the glitz and glamour of Golden Age Hollywood, and its dark underbelly, are here: what truly makes it the best book about Hollywood is how it conveys the magic of La La Land whilst never underplaying its cruelty.

Fitzgerald managed to get about halfway through when a heart attack cut him short of finishing what probably would have been his best book. Yet what we have remains magnificent and the notes accompanying let us know how the tale would dramatically come to an end.


1. In Search Of Lost Time By Marcel Proust

Marcel Proust, Author
Otto Wegener (1849-1924) (source : Album Pleiade), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Proust's talent is absolutely undeniably, considering he penned what some consider to be one of the finest novels ever written even though it remained unfinished at the time of his death. To some, it is the definite novel of the 20th century.

The novel is a meditation on the transition from the 19th into the modern 20th century, as told through the recollections, often involuntary, of an unnamed narrator.

Particularly famous is a passage involving the eating of a Madeleine cake dipped in tea; the experience triggers vivid recollections of childhood, effectively setting the seven volume novel off. Indeed, apart from its stature critically speaking, Proust's novel is monumental - seven volumes coming in at somewhere in the region of 4,200 pages.

It is difficult to overestimate the influence of Proust's unfinished novel on subsequent literature; it is the last of the great 19th century prose works and one of the first truly modern novels. Writers from Virginia Woolf to Vladimir Nabokov and beyond have noted their esteem of the book and it regularly appears in writers' top ten lists. All this despite being unfinished.


In this post: 
Books
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A philosopher (no, actually) and sometime writer from Glasgow, with a worryingly extensive knowledge of Dawson's Creek.