10 Mysterious Disappearances You've Never Heard Of

Read about the most fascinating unsolved disappearances throughout history.

Frank Morris Anglin Brothers
FBI

According to the National Missing and Unidentified Persons (NamUS) database (U.S. Department of Justice), more than 500,000 people go missing every year in the United States alone. There are all sorts of reasons behind these disappearances - some nefarious, others not so - but a select few cases throughout history have proved so intriguing and mystifying that they remain a focus of speculation.

Everyone likes a good conspiracy theory, and many of the cases on the list below lend themselves to such conjecture. From advanced scientific designs and infidelities to prison breaks, lost colonies and the Masons, the stories below make for fascinating reading. Many of them are still being investigated by historians and amateur sleuths to this day. One even involves an active case, the hearing for which is due later this year.

Your writer has tried hard to eschew the more obvious and well-known cases here, with the focus instead more on unearthing some of lesser-known, but no less compelling narratives that you've likely never heard of.

Whatever your tastes, you are sure to find something here that will capture your imagination.

10. Owen Parfitt

For this entry, we go back in time 250 years to the provincial town of Shepton Mallet, England in the year 1763. Not too much is known about Owen Parfitt. His background is sketchy. What we do know is that he lived with his sister, Susannah, who also served as his carer. At this point in his life, Owen was completely paralyzed, unable to move by himself but able to talk. It seems as though he had not always been this way, for Owen habitually told wild tales of his earlier life.

These stories included terrible battles, piracy and women a-plenty. Although locals took Owen's tales with a hefty pinch of salt, there may be some truths around with his narratives were woven. On the day which concerns us here, the 60-year-old Owen had been taken outside to sit on his sister's porch. It was a warm evening. Owen was dressed only in his nightshirt. Directly across from him were a group of farm-workers, going about their business.

At around 7pm, mindful of an approaching storm, Susannah and a neighbour went to carry Owen back inside, and were shocked to discover that he was no longer there. In fact, no sign remained save for the folded greatcoat upon which Owen had been seated. The nearby farm-workers were adamant that they had seen no one come or go. Despite many subsequent investigations, no trace of Owen was ever found.


9. Louis Le Prince

One of the great forgotten pioneers of motion picture technology, Frenchman Louis Le Prince was an artist and inventor of admirable genius. Born in 1841, Le Prince worked in his native country, and also in the United States and England. He is arguably the first person ever to capture a moving picture sequence using a single-lens camera and film-strip.

By 1888, Le Prince was working in the city of Leeds, in the North of England, and much secrecy surrounded his experiments.

It seems certain that the inventor was in-step or slightly ahead of contemporaries such as William Frese-Greene and Wordsworth Donisthorpe, and far in advance of the Lumière brothers and Thomas Edison. Sadly, planned public demonstrations were never held, due to Le Prince's sudden and unexplained disappearance.

He was last observed boarding a train, in September, 1890, and never seen again. Rumours of heavy debts or secret homosexuality circulated, but it seems we will never know for sure. You can read a fuller account of this fascinating story here.


8. Al-Hakim

Abū ʿAlī Manṣū, commonly referred to as Al-Hakim, was the sixth caliph (ruler) of the Fatimid Empire, and a man whose legacy is sharply debated. A dynasty of Arab origin, the Fatimid Caliphate existed from the 10th to the 12th centuries, and covered a vast area of North Africa from the Atlantic Ocean to the Red Sea.

Similar to England's Richard III, Al-Hakim, who lived from 985 to 1021, was a ruler who has quite possibly suffered from negative propaganda. As historian Paul Walker observes in his book, Caliph of Cairo: "Ultimately, both views of him, the mad and despotic tyrant, irrationally given to killing those around him on a whim, and the ideal supreme ruler, whose every action was just and righteous, were to persist, the one among his enemies and those who rebelled against him, and the other in the hearts of true believers.”

What is known for certain is that on the night of 12 February 1021, aged 35, Al-Hakim left for a solitary night-time journey to the hills outside of Cairo. This was apparently not unusual, though on this occasion the caliph did not return, and was never seen again.


7. The Colony Of Roanoke

This entry concerns an important piece of American history. Roanoke colony was established by Sir Walter Raleigh, under governor Ralph Lane, in 1585, on Roanoke Island, which now forms part of Dare County, North Carolina. It was intended to be the first permanent English settlement on the continent. Hampered by a lack of supplies and apparent poor relations with the local Native Americans, Lane abandoned the colony a year later.

A second expedition, led by John White, returned to the same island in 1587. Approximately 100 colonists formed this new settlement, and their fate is unknown to this day. White himself returned to England that same year, intending to bring back further supplies. Delayed by the Anglo-Spanish War, White did not reach Roanoke until three years later, in 1590.

He found the settlement entirely intact, but abandoned. Carved into the wooden palisade was a single word: 'CROATOAN' – the name of a nearby island. White never made it to Croatoan to check, but others subsequently have, and yet no trace of the missing colonists has ever been uncovered.


6. Ambrose Bierce

Writer, journalist and poet, Ambrose Bierce (1842-1914) remains one of the great, lesser-known American writers. A veteran of the American Civil War, Bierce was renowned for his short fiction, including the acknowledged classic, An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge. He is also the author of the satirical work, The Devil's Dictionary – an 'alternate' dictionary which contains such epithets as: “Admiration - Our polite recognition of another’s resemblance to ourselves.”

Bierce's horror fiction has been ranked alongside notables such as Edgar Allan Poe and H. P. Lovecraft. As a literary critic, Bierce's opinions were highly influential. In 1913, aged 71, the writer declared his intent to travel to Mexico to experience first-hand the ongoing Mexican Revolution, and to tour some of his old civil war battlefields on the way.

Bierce passed through Louisiana and Texas into Mexico. It was reported that for some time he journeyed with the army of Mexican revolutionary Pancho Villa, but left them at the city of Chihuahua. There, he wrote a letter to an old friend, stating that he was leaving the next day for an 'unknown destination'. Bierce was never seen again.


5. Joseph Force Crater

The story of New York State Supreme Court Justice Joseph Force Crater was, for a time, the most famous missing person case in the country. Crater, who disappeared on 6 August 1930, was 41 years old at the time, and already infamous for his alleged corruption and frequent affairs with showgirls. He was last observed leaving a restaurant in Manhattan on West 45th Street and, despite being the subject of a large-scale investigation, was never seen again.

In the days leading up to his disappearance, Crater received a mysterious phone call at his summer home in Belgrade, Maine. Telling his wife that he had to hurriedly return to New York, Crater arrived at his Fifth Avenue apartment the next day, but then continued on to Atlantic City in the company of his mistress. He returned to Maine briefly on 3 August before once again leaving for New York, promising to be back by 9 August.

He spent some time in his office, cashed checks worth around $80,000, and went to dinner with his mistress and a friend, William Klein. At some point, Crater left. Klein's and the mistress' accounts differ, but Crater was never to return.


4. William Morgan

William Morgan, born 1774 in Culpeper, Virginia, worked as a bricklayer and stone cutter, and later owned his own store in Richmond. Morgan claimed to have served as a captain during the war of 1812, though this fact is contested. In 1819, aged 45, he married 19-year-old Lucinda Pendleton. The couple spent some time in Canada, where Morgan owned a brewery, before settling in Batavia, in New York State.

During his time in Canada, Morgan asserted that he had been a Master Mason in a lodge based in Rochester. He further claimed that his attempts to open lodges in Batavia had been stalled by fellow Masons who disapproved of his character. In retaliation, Morgan stated, he was going to publish a book exposing the secrets of the organisation in detail, with backing from a local newspaper publisher, David Cade Miller.

Soon after, Morgan was arrested for alleged non-payment of a loan. Miller swiftly visited the debtor's prison in Canandaigua where Morgan was being held, and paid off the debt. Morgan was then re-arrested on charges of allegedly failing to pay a tavern bill. With Morgan back in prison, a group of unknown men arrived and convinced the jailer's wife to release the captive into their charge.

Morgan was taken by these men to Fort Niagara, and there the trail goes cold. Miller posthumously published Morgan's book, which became a bestseller and sparked an anti-masonic movement.


3. Ettore Majorana

The second renowned scientist on our list of unexplained disappearances, Ettore Majorna was a theoretical physicist, born 1906 in Catania, Italy. He disappeared on 25 March 1938, while travelling by ship from Palermo to Naples. We know that Majorna purchased a ticket for the journey, and reports suggest that shortly beforehand he had withdrawn all of his money from his bank account, yet he never arrived at his destination.

What makes this account especially fascinating, is that it seems this is one case in which the disappearance was planned.

In a note sent from Palermo to Antonio Carrelli, director of the Naples Physics Institute, Majorna wrote: “I made a decision that has become unavoidable. There isn't a bit of selfishness in it, but I realize what trouble my sudden disappearance will cause you and the students. For this as well, I beg your forgiveness, but especially for betraying the trust, the sincere friendship, and the sympathy you gave me over the past months.”

Despite his family offering a reward of 30,000 lira, the mystery remains unsolved.


2. Renee MacRae

Currently standing as Britain's longest-running missing person's case, Renee MacRae and her three-year-old son, Andrew, disappeared in 1976 on a busy stretch of road in Scotland.

On Friday 12 November of that year, Renee left her home in Cradelhall and drove with Andrew and his elder brother, Gordon (9) to the house of her estranged husband. There, she dropped off Gordon and continued on, driving south on the A9, ostensibly to visit her sister in Kilmarnock. It was later revealed that she actually planned to see William MacDowell, a married man with whom she had been having a long-term affair.

Renee and Andrew never made it. A train driver spotted their burnt-out car in a lay-by. Police discovered the vehicle empty apart from a rug stained with blood which matched Renee's type. Despite extensive searches, both at the time and subsequently, no trace of Renee or Andrew has ever been found.

As recently as 2021, the now 80-year-old MacDowell was charged with their murders, with the trial set for later this year. This is one case on this list which might, at last, be solved.


1. Frank Morris & The Anglin Brothers

A three-in-one here.

In June 1962, convicted felons Frank Morris, Clarence Anglin and his brother John Anglin joined a select list of men who breached the walls of Alcatraz Jail. Built in the mid-19th century, situated on an small island 1.25 miles offshore from San Francisco, Alcatraz initially served as a lighthouse and military prison. From 1934 to 1963, the complex was used as a civilian prison, 'hosting' such notorious names as Al Capone and Machine Gun Kelly.

Over that span, 14 escape attempts were made, involving 36 inmates. Six of these were shot and killed, 23 caught, and a further four confirmed drowned. The bodies of Morris and the Anglin brothers, however, have never been located. To aid their escape, the trio built papier-mâché models of their heads, constructed from toothpaste, dust, soap, toilet paper and hair from the barbershop floor, which they used to fool guards into thinking that they were asleep in their bunks.

They then escaped through ventilation-ducts beneath their cell sinks and set off across the bay on a make-shift raft. Although remnants of the raft were eventually found, together with some personal belongings, speculation remains as to whether the fugitives made it ashore and, if so, where they went next.


Contributor

Chris Wheatley is a journalist and writer from Oxford, UK. He has too many records, too many guitars and not enough cats.