10 True Crime Documentaries That Got Cases Reopened
More than just morbid entertainment, these documentaries actually impacted the cases they covered.
True crime documentaries have been circulated through media for decades now, and yet they seemingly never stop increasing in popularity. Whether these be through film, television, radio, podcasts or streaming, we just cannot consume enough of these morbid and atrocious tales.
It seems we as humans are just wired to want to delve into the minds and lives of the depraved, seeking out the worst of our villains to try and gain an understanding of why and how someone could commit a serious crime. Sometimes we follow the case, sometimes the accounts of witnesses and survivors, but either way, we’ll always be both educated and entertained.
On occasion, especially when the documentary is following an unsolved or suspiciously resolved case, the world ends up with more than just an entertaining show. It’s not uncommon for true crime documentaries to pick up some serious buzz and popularity, which can then lead to public interest in a case. This can even go as far as to influence investigators to re-open their cases, or for courts to grant appeals for those who were potentially wrongly convicted.
This article will list ten occasions in which a true crime documentary has done more than just cover a case, but has actually impacted the case as well.
10. The Staircase
The Staircase is a documentary which was initially released in 2004 on French television, before being picked up by Netflix, with follow-ups being filmed between 2012 and 2013, and three more episodes again in 2018. All 13 episodes across the show’s lifespan are available to watch on Netflix.
The series covers the case of Michael Peterson who was accused of murdering his wife, Kathleen, and then trying to cover up the crime by claiming that she fell down the stairs. What’s interesting in this particular case is that Peterson actually hired the film crew himself to cover his trial (which was the focus of the original 2004 episodes.) He did this as he did not believe he would receive a fair trial and he was ultimately convicted of the murder at the end of this case.
Information obtained in the documentary was used to launch one of numerous appeals by Peterson, in which he claimed that a blood-splatter analyst had given a misleading testimony. However, the appeal was unsuccessful in overturning his conviction as it was deemed that Peterson would have been found guilty regardless. Peterson ultimately plead guilty to Manslaughter in 2017, which resulted in his release due to time served.
9. The Teacher's Pet
The Teacher’s Pet is an Australian podcast from 2018, hosted by journalist Hedley Thomas. The podcast covered the 1982 disappearance of an Australian homemaker and mother named Lynette Dawson. Lynette’s whereabouts have never been discovered and there is therefore no physical confirmation as to whether she is alive or dead.
The podcast focussed a lot of attention on Lynette’s husband, Chris Dawson. Chris was a former Rugby League player and teacher. Thomas covers not just the disappearance in his 17-episode documentary, but also an affair that Chris has with a sixteen-year-old girl, and further allegations of sexual misconduct that took place in the school where Chris worked.
Most importantly, Thomas suggests that there were flaws in the initial police investigation and goes on to uncover new evidence and potential sources for enquiry. The information provided in The Teacher’s Pet resulted in Chris Dawson being arrested in 2020 and charged with the murder of Lynette.
Chris is currently on bail with his trial scheduled to take place on the 9th of May 2022. It is expected for the trial to last for eight days, although it’s possible this could be extended for longer, given the complexities involved in prosecuting a murder without a body or confirmation of death.
8. Up And Vanished
2016 podcast Up and Vanished covers the missing person case of Tara Grinstead, a high school history teacher from Ocilla, Georgia. Grinstead was first reported missing in October of 2005 when she failed to turn up for work and to this day, she has never been found.
A 2008 48 Hours special covering the case advised that a latex glove was found at the scene and, whilst the police considered a number of suspects, fingerprint analysis was unable to find a match. In 2010 Grinstead was declared legally dead by a judge.
Filmmaker Payne Lindsay recorded Up and Vanished in 2016, visiting Ocilla and working alongside a private investigator to gather evidence and speak to locals about the case. Around 6 months after the podcast aired, police arrested two of Grinstead’s former students, Ryan Duke and Bo Dukes (no familial relation.)
Bo Dukes received a 25 year sentence for helping to cover up the murder after his trial in 2019. Ryan Duke was initially meant to go on trial for murder, concealing a death, burglary and assault in 2019 as well, but due to legal issues and COVID interruptions, the trial is yet to take place, with jury selection set to commence in May 2022.
7. Accused
Accused is a podcast series which aired its first episode in 2016. Season One covered the death of Elizabeth Andes whose boyfriend, Bob Young, discovered her having been stabbed to death in 1978 at her home in Ohio. Young was arrested immediately and after around 15 hours of interrogation and a polygraph failure, he gave a false confession.
Young was ultimately acquitted when his case went to trial, as his lawyer was able to point out inconsistencies between his statement and the facts of the case. However, although both legal and civil courts found Young not guilty, authorities were still convinced that they had the right man and refused to continue their investigation.
Thankfully a reporter for the Cincinnati Enquirer, Amber Hunt, caught wind of this case and decided to produce an investigative podcast covering the events of Andes’ murder and the trial of Bob Young. Her podcast found that to this day, the only evidence the police had against Young was his forced confession.
With Young’s permission, Hunt has convinced police to reopen the investigation and, although no new suspects have yet been considered, Hunt continues to send tips and new evidence to the police regularly, in hopes that one day some closure can be reached.
6. Death In Ice Valley
Death In Ice Valley is a podcast authored by Marit Higraff, a Norwegian investigative journalist, which was published by NRK and BBC Worldwide in 2018. It covers the mysterious case of a badly burned female body discovered in 1970 by a group of hikers in Norway’s Isdalen Valley. Due to the nature of the burns, the woman could not be identified and was simply referred to as the ‘Isdal Woman.’
Her death was extremely suspicious and shrouded in mystery given that, shortly after the discovery, two unclaimed suitcases were picked up by police from a nearby train station, containing wigs, money in various different currencies and glasses with fingerprints that matched those on the body. It was also noteworthy that the tags had been cut from the Isdal Woman’s clothing, presumably to make identification more difficult.
There’s no doubt that she was murdered, but who by, and how did she end up in such an awful situation? This is what Death In Ice Valley set out to discover, firstly by identifying the Isdal Woman. Higraff discovered that a dentist had saved the woman’s jaw which was distinctive enough for investigators to agree to reopen the case. Sadly however, to this day, the Isdal Woman’s identity remains a mystery.
5. The Thin Blue Line
1988’s The Thin Blue Line is a film documenting the life of Randall Dale Adams who was convicted of the 1976 murder of a police officer named Robert Wood. Adams was sentenced to death for this crime, but always professed his innocence in the matter.
It was widely believed that the murder had actually been committed by another man, David Ray Harris, who had given Adams a lift in his car shortly after the murder had occurred. The documentary speculates that Adams was only convicted because he could be tried as an adult at the time. Harris was also known to regularly brag about having shot a police officer and during an interview, the film’s writer-director Erol Morris managed to get a recording of him confessing to the murder.
This footage was used to exonerate Adams and he was released from death row after having spent 12 years behind bars for a crime he did not commit. He was never compensated for his wrongful conviction and Harris was subsequently executed for an unrelated murder. Whilst Adams never really got justice for his ordeal, if it weren’t for The Thin Blue Line, he would likely have been wrongly executed for the murder.
4. The Jinx: The Life And Deaths Of Robert Durst
Arguably the most impactful documentary on this list, The Jinx was released in 2015 and covered a wealthy real-estate heir named Robert Durst and the deaths of three women closely connected to him; Kathleen McCormack Durst, who was his first wife, Susan Berman and Morris Black. Durst had used the documentary as a platform to deny the murders.
However, Durst made a fatal error when he excused himself to go to the bathroom, not knowing that his microphone was still on. The microphone picked up Durst talking to himself and essentially confessing to the murder. The transcript of the recording is as follows:
"There it is. You're caught! .... You're right, of course. But you can't imagine. ... Arrest him ... I don't know what's in the house ... Oh, I want this ... What a disaster ... He was right. I was wrong. And the burping ... I'm having difficulty with the question ... What the hell did I do? Killed them all, of course."
Durst was arrested two months after the documentary was released and was convicted of the murders following his trial in 2020.
In 2021, Durst contracted COVID and he died at the age of 78 on 10 January 2022 whilst in custody.
3. Minds Of Madness
Minds of Madness is a podcast that was started by Bek and Tyler Allen in 2017. One of the podcast's most popular stories covered the mysterious death of a 19-year-old man named Tanner Barton, who seemingly died in his sleep whilst staying overnight at a friend’s house.
When Barton’s body was originally examined, police found no signs of trauma or hints of foul play. A toxicology report showed a small amount of cannabis in his system, but nothing that could be considered out-of-the-ordinary or lethal. They ended up ruling that his death had been caused by asphyxia, brought on by his obesity and the position that he was sleeping in.
Barton’s mother, Michele, refused to believe this was the case and was sure that something else must have happened. She got in contact with the Allens, who took up her case on their podcast, investigating the mysterious death over a four-month period. The podcast brought the story into the public eye and forced police to rereview the case. New witnesses were interviewed, and data was taken from Barton’s phone.
Texts revealed that Barton has been using Adderall and hadn’t slept for over 30 hours, however the case was officially closed in 2018, with the cause of death remaining the same. This is still disputed by Michele, who continues to investigate her son’s tragic death.
2. Serial
Sarah Koenig’s Serial is a now legendary podcast series, which released its first season back in 2014. This season covered the controversial case of Adnan Syed, who was convicted of the murder of his classmate, Hae Min Lee, in 2000. The murder occurred in 1997 when Adnan was just 17 and, through vigorous interrogation and difficulty remembering certain details, he ultimately received a life sentence for Lee’s murder.
Koenig got in contact with Syed, as well as a number of his friends and classmates to discuss what had happened with the case. She conducted a lengthy investigation and found that some details just didn’t add up. Over the season, Koenig found that cell phone tracing evidence presented by the prosecution had been unreliable, that Syed had been subject to hours of forceful interrogation, and even found an alibi for him on the day that the murder took place.
As a result of Serial, a judge reviewed Syed’s case and granted him a retrial in 2016, on the grounds that he had received ineffective counsel. However, the state appealed against the retrial and so far, their appeal has been upheld. In 2019 the Supreme Court rejected a counter-appeal from Syed to have his retrial go ahead and, for now, Syed remains behind bars.
1. Making A Murderer
Quite simply the Godfather of true crime documentaries, Netflix’s 2015 powerhouse, Making a Murderer, covered the arrest, trial and eventual conviction of Wisconsin man Steven Avery and his nephew, Brendan Dassey. The pair were convicted of the murder of Theresa Halbach in 2007 and the circumstances around this fate were iffy to say the least.
The documentary suggests a plethora of poor practices on the side of the police when it came to securing a conviction for Avery and Dassey. These included, but are not limited to, tampering with evidence, planting evidence, false testimony and coercing a confession from Dassey, who had learning difficulties.
Viewers were led to believe there was just NO WAY Avery and Dassey could have committed this crime, with mountains of evidence supporting their pleas of innocence. However, accusations were made post-release that the documentary had been biased and ignored strong evidence in favour of the prosecution.
Regardless, the public outcry was deafening after the first season aired and both Avery and Dassey have been on a rollercoaster of legal appeals since. Dassey was the closest to being released, with a federal judge overturning his conviction due to his questionable confession, but this decision was appealed successfully by the state and both men remain in prison, fighting for their freedom and continuing to protest their innocence.