11 Creepy Paranormal Phenomena Debunked By Science

If you get too spooked this halloween, tell yourself it's just science...

Tulip Stairs Ghost
Public Domain

There are more things in heaven and earth, than are dreamt of in our philosophy, for sure. We live in a mysterious world and all sorts of unexplained things happen every day… or do they?

There are a few things these days that science has managed to partially, if not entirely, lift the veil on. Seeing as the basic job description of a scientist is to unravel the mysteries of the universe (a pretty cool job description in anyone’s book), it is unsurprising that they have so far managed to de-mystify a fair few tales of the strange and the unexpected.

Perhaps there’s a little less magic in the world now, but there are also fewer evil demons that want to wear you like a pretty frock – which is possibly a good thing.

Despite what the likes of Derek Acorah and Uri Geller might tell you, there are some pretty mundane explanations behind their seemingly extraordinary abilities. Obviously, it’s great to keep an open mind, but it’s always worth remembering that there are people out there who can make a lot of money out of the monsters under your bed.

Stay curious, informed and fair-minded – but always, always be aware that if you open your mind too much, your brain may indeed fall out.


11. Hauntings

Paranormal Activity 4 A L
Paramount

What’s Really Going On: Infrasound

In the early 80s, a British researcher by the name of Vic Tandy, was working in his laboratory when he began to feel that something wasn’t quite right. He reported that he was “sweating but cold, and the feeling of depression was noticeable – but there was also something else. It was as though something was in the room”. It was about then that he began to see a shadowy figure out of the corner of his eye, only to have it disappear when he tried to get a better look.

Then, one day, after a bracing fencing match, Tandy placed his sword in a vice in the lab for safekeeping and noticed that it was moving all on its own. Far from taking this as a sign that he was about to be run through by a ghost, Tandy immediately understood what had been going on.

The human ear can detect sounds within a range of 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz, and anything outside of that range is “silent” to humans. Anything with a frequency below 20 Hz is known as “infrasound” and, although they cannot be heard, their effects can still be felt.

The sound waves can agitate the stomach, creating a sensation similar to a release of adrenaline and a feeling of awe, panic or threat depending on the context. They can also vibrate the eyeballs, creating blurry images that aren’t there.

All sorts of natural and man-made objects can emit infrasound and, in the context of a creepy “haunted” environment, the effects can easily be interpreted as a ghoulish presence. Tandy soon discovered that a new fan had been installed in his lab that was emitting a sound at around 19 Hz. He turned the fan off and, voila, no more ghosties.


10. Psychic Reading

Derren Brown Sweary Gif
Channel 4

What’s Really Going On: Cold Reading

Cold reading is a technique used by psychics, fortune tellers, mind readers and astrologers to gain seemingly personal information from a sitter, creating the illusion of psychic abilities. Cold readers will gain their information using the body language, age, gender, verbal and non-verbal responses of their sitter in order to build up their insight into the life of the individual.

Take, for example, a psychic show in which the psychic will appear to contact the dead loved ones of audience members. Common techniques will usually consist of high-probability guesses such as “I’m looking for a lady who has lost someone” – as the majority of the audience will be there in the hope of contacting loved ones and at least half of them are likely to be female, this one is a pretty sure shot.

They might then throw out some Barnum statements – these are statements that will seem very specific but can actually be made to apply to most people. These could be a double header such as “You’re very sociable, but sometimes you prefer your own company”; a double negative to which the answer can correctly be both yes and no such as “You don’t have a cat do you?”; or even simple flattery like “You’re a very kind person and this isn’t always fully recognised”, which is something that most people would want to believe about themselves.

In some cases, even the psychic doesn’t know that they are doing this and will genuinely think that the ideas that are popping into their head are being delivered from the spirit world. In other cases, they know full well what they are doing.

A psychic medium will more often use the presence of your dead mum/auntie/milkman/cat to make personal statements about the living sitter, rather than passing on any message more meaningful than “she is very proud of you”, as “proof” that they have been contacted. Oddly, the spirits rarely offer any insight into what it’s like to be dead, surely a pretty big talking point for the recently deceased, no?


9. Ouija Boards

ouija board
Giphy

What’s Really Going On: The Ideomotor Response

Ouija boards – most often used by misguided teenagers in horror movies, these “talking boards” have been used to contact the spirits of the netherworld for many years. A ouija board consists of a polished wooden board with the letters of the alphabet, numbers 0-9 and the words yes, no, hello and goodbye. A pointer or a glass is placed on the board and everybody will gently place their finger on it to “channel” a spirit. If successful, the spirit will move the glass/pointer and answer questions from the group.

Anyone who has ever tried it will attest to the fact that it is pretty spooky when the glass begins to move, seemingly unaided, more often than not spelling out increasingly threatening responses – it’s enough to convince anyone of the presence of malevolent spirits. Fortunately, there is a very simple explanation: You’re pushing the glass.

Surely you’d notice, right? Wrong. The ideomotor response is the result of the power of suggestion that makes our muscles contract, causing unconscious movements. If you expect the glass to move, you will make it move. This was put to the test in 1853, at the height of Victorian spiritualism, during an experimental séance put on by four doctors.

During a demonstration of “table tipping” – a similar concept to the ouija board but using hands placed on a table that will move about he room – the doctors told half of the participants that the table would move to the left, and half that it would move to the right and (surprise surprise) it didn’t budge. Once the participants were all told the same thing, the ideomotor effect returned and the tables began speeding around the room with renewed vigour.


8. UFO Sightings

Stealth Planes
Wikipedia

What’s Really Going On: Aircraft

Given that the aeroplane was invented well over 100 years ago, you’d think that we’d be pretty used to things flying about in our atmosphere by now. However, an astonishing number of UFO sightings can be put down to the misidentification of Earth aircraft.

Even a commercial airliner, perhaps viewed through a thick fog a night, can suddenly appear to be an unearthly ball of light hovering in the sky. If an aircraft makes any sharp turns, ascents or descents, the directional landing lights will point away from the observer, creating the impression of a sudden disappearance of the craft. Even the blinking wing lights can give the appearance of many smaller ships flying in formation.

And, if that’s just the planes that we’re used to, imagine the trouble caused when a civilian happens to spot a secret military craft. There have been countless sightings of experimental craft that really do look like visitors from another world. Flights by these aircraft are unlikely to be reported publicly and (if you really want to get your conspiracy theorist hat on) we suspect that governments would prefer you believe that they’re keeping the Men from Mars a secret from you, rather than divulging closely guarded military secrets.

With an estimated 22% of UFO sightings put down to misidentified aircraft, another 22% to celestial objects such as satellites and the planet Venus, and the rest made of weather balloons sightings, dust, clouds and even birds – there are actually very few Unidentified Flying Objects that have remained “unidentified”.


7. Daylight UFO Sightings

Lenticular Cloud Over Harold's Cross Dublin Ireland 30 6 15
Wikipedia

What’s Really Going On: Lenticular Clouds

Altocumulus lenticularis is a high-altitude cloud formation that usually chills out around mountain ranges, hanging in the sky and looking for all the world like an alien spacecraft.

It is thought that many reports of UFO sightings can be put down to the misidentification of lenticular clouds by those who are unfamiliar with them. The formations take on a seemingly unnatural saucer shape and will remain stationary despite wind direction, giving the impression of conscious control. The smooth surface can even take on the appearance of shiny metal in comparison to their fluffier brothers and sisters.

There are even some that are able to correctly identify lenticular clouds, but believe that they are simply cloaking devices for the alien ships within. An interesting theory, but so far, none of the gliders (who will actively seek them out due to the super-fun air currents) has gone smashing into the side of a poorly-disguised space ship on any of their encounters with the cloud formations.


6. 'Orb' UFO Sightings

Ball Lightning
Wikipedia

What’s Really Going On: Ball Lightning

Okay, so clouds are one thing, but what about those huge balls of light that so many people report from their encounters?

Only identified in the last 50 years or so, ball lightning seems to pretty well fit the bill. Essentially, ball lightning is a sphere of static electricity that can hang in the sky for minutes at a time and is so bright that it can even be seen in daylight. The surface can even take on a metallic appearance that will look very much like the surface of a spacecraft.

Due to the electrical charge of such objects, they can also be attracted to objects such as aircraft, creating the illusion that they are “following” them. They will speed up, slow down and change direction in line with the aircraft creating the illusion of control. When the lightning eventually dissipates, it can seem to be absorbed into other objects, or can even explode into many smaller spots of light before disappearing.

Given that scientists have only managed to identify the phenomenon in the last half a century, it’s unsurprising that this strange and unfamiliar phenomenon has been taken for something otherworldly in the past.


5. The Bermuda Triangle

Bermuda Triangle
AP

What’s Really Going On: A Media Storm

The Bermuda Triangle, also known as the Devil’s Triangle, is an infamous stretch of ocean in the North Atlantic, well known for claiming countless ships and aircraft and damning them to oblivion. There have been reports of electronics going haywire, compasses that don’t point north, whole ships being swallowed by the sea and many craft simply disappearing off the face of the Earth.

So what could possibly be the cause? Could it be a black hole, a deadly whirlpool, or even a vicious sea monster? Some have even posited the theory that the phenomenon is caused by the ancient technology of the lost city of Atlantis claiming passing ships for its own.

Why is this patch of ocean so deadly? Well, the short answer is: It Isn’t.

After an extensive amount of research, a librarian by the name of Larry Kusche came to the conclusion that, despite the hype, the area known as the Bermuda Triangle has claimed no more lives than any other similarly trafficked stretch of ocean. The story seemed to have arisen as a simple bit of sensationalism, which then began to perpetuate its own myth.

Many of the “unexplained” disappearances can be put down to unreported storms in the area or ships that have gone off course and had their disappearance publicised, but not their reappearance. Some of the stories can simply be found to be straight up lies with absolutely no evidence of them happening at all.

It would seem that a combination of sloppy research, hype, and sensationalism, all tied together by the reputation, is all that there is behind this modern day myth.


4. Bigfoot

Patterson–Gimlin

What’s Really Going On: Hoaxes And Misidentification

Bigfoot, Sasquatch, Yeti, The Abominable Snowman – it would seem that a great number of disparate cultures have a common myth of a giant, bipedal primate roaming the wildest, remotest parts of the planet.

So is there anything in it? There have been countless sightings, blurry photographs and wild theories from an army of Bigfoot believers over the years. Many sightings are probably made in good faith, but are largely down to a misidentification of a mangy or juvenile bear. As well as these honest mistakes, there have also been countless hoaxes, with everything from digitally altered photographs to a man in a gorilla suit, making it difficult to simply believe everything you hear about this enigmatic beast.

Many believers will provide a hypothesis that Gigantopithecus – an extinct species of giant primate – may still be alive and well in the remotest reaches of the Himalayas or the Rockies, much like the idea that prehistoric sea monsters may be pootling around the bottom of the ocean, but this is unlikely.

Due to climate and food supply issues, it would be nigh on impossible for many of the proposed habitats of Bigfoot to be able to support a creature of its size. The limited food supply and cold climate would mean that a creature is highly unlikely to grow to a size anywhere close to the supposed size of Bigfoot.

If we allow our inner cynics free reign for a moment, the myth probably has something to do with the multi-million dollar tourist industry that has sprung up around it. Just a thought.


3. Night Visitations

Creepypasta

What’s Really Going On: Sleep Paralysis

Almost all reports of a “haunting” include a story in which the person awakes to find a figure stood at the bottom of their bed, watching them sleep. Another common trope is to feel the sensation of being “held down” by demons or even strangled by an evil force.

These experiences are all classic symptoms of a common sleep disorder known as sleep paralysis. When we enter REM sleep (the “dreaming” phase of sleep), your brain temporarily paralyses your body to ensure that you don’t act out your dreams or sleep walk. If REM sleep is disturbed then sometimes what can happen is that the brain “wakes up” before the body does and you find yourself semi-conscious but unable to move.

It is common during these episodes to hallucinate whilst you still have one foot in reality and one in the land of dreams. Many report seeing a figure either moving about the room, stood over them or even sitting on them (possibly the brain’s attempt to rationalise the paralysis), often accompanied by the sense that this presence is evil or demonic.

For hundreds of years, these symptoms have been interpreted as visitations from evil spirits, demons, and incubi. Ironically, these beliefs can actually exacerbate the condition due to the stress caused by the thought of being visited by evil demons. Once somebody who suffers from sleep paralysis is aware of the cause, the hallucinations become much less frightening and the vicious circle of stress and sleep paralysis can be broken.


2. Poltergeist Activity

Paramount

What’s Really Going On: Carbon Monoxide Poisoning

Tales of haunted houses can be seriously creepy. Apparitions, unexplained noises, an evil atmosphere descending over a household – all sure signs that you are being visited from beyond the grave.

In 1921, a paper was published in the American Journal of Ophthalmology describing the experiences of a family known as the “H” family. They had become tormented by evil spirits in their home with slamming doors, disembodied footsteps and shifting furniture. One night, the lady of the house awoke to find two people watching her sleep, only for them to disappear before her eyes; A feeling of depression and evil fell over the house and even the plants started to wilt and die.

And all because of a dodgy furnace leaking carbon monoxide into their home.

Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colourless, odourless gas that, when breathed in, can be absorbed into the red blood cells and will slowly replace the oxygen in the body. CO poisoning can cause hallucinations, weakness, nausea, confusion and eventually death.

Another interesting case is that of a Redditor who thought his landlord was stalking him. He began finding mysterious post-it notes around his apartment with vaguely creepy messages such as “Our landlord isn’t letting me talk to you, but it’s important we do”, but when he checked the footage from a security webcam, he found that all of the files had been recently deleted.

After turning to Reddit for advice, most responses were regarding legal action he could take against his landlord – save for one sharp-eyed user who suggested he get a CO detector. The original poster followed his advice and discovered that he was breathing in dangerous levels of carbon monoxide. He had been entering a dissociative fugue state whenever he went to bed, and had simply been leaving the post-it notes for himself and forgetting.


1. Unbelievable Stories

Def Jam Records

What’s Really Going On: Liars

Hate to break it to you, but people lie.

Whether it’s the publicity, the money or simply boredom that makes them tell porkies, there are countless examples of supernatural hoaxes every year. Take, for example, the dramatic exposure of TV psychic, Peter Popoff (who was caught receiving information via an ear piece), or the Enfield haunting and that famous photograph of a young girl being thrown across the room by unseen hands (which, when put with the rest of the sequence of photos, looks for all the world like a girl jumping off her bed).

The incredible “personal accounts” of witnesses to supernatural phenomena can either come from those who got taken in by the trickery of others, and they are not to be derided, or they can come straight from the charlatans themselves in order to perpetuate the myth.

Science is not “out to get” mystics – in fact, if we could prove beyond reasonable doubt that the afterlife exists and humans could actually survive their own death, it would be one of the most exciting discoveries in the history of humanity. Unfortunately, the evidence just isn’t there.

Out of every haunting, psychic, faith healing, alien abduction or any other supernatural phenomenon, none of them has ever been proven to be true to a satisfactory scientific level. Of course, it is nigh on impossible (much like the proverbial teapot orbiting Mars) to disprove the existence of something. Far from this being a handy loophole, however, it just means that the burden of proof falls on those who make the claims.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence after all.

You could write for WhatCulture Science! Click here to find out how you could get paid to write about what you love.

If science gives you the warm fuzzies, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter to stay up to date.


In this post: 
Science
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Writer. Raconteur. Gardeners' World Enthusiast.