Poor Andy, how come they managed to figure out a way to save Prue and not him? They're supposed to be the powerful Charmed Ones and they couldn't save Andy. It was a shame to see him go but at least you were left with Darryl who could sort of wrap his head around the whole witchcraft thing. But would you tell the guy that you're dating that you were a witch? He probably wouldn't take it very well either...