5 Reasons Joe Rogan Just Isn't The Same On Spotify

Is it just us, or is JRE different now? A breakdown of new platform changes.

joe rogan spotify
marketwatch

There have been a lot of changes for the Joe Rogan Experience against the backdrop of 2020, including a move to Texas and the complications of the Covid-19 pandemic. What may prove to be the most significant of all is the decision for the podcast to become a Spotify exclusive, effective as of December 2020.

Some eyebrows were raised at the sheer size of Spotify's outlay on securing the rights to the Joe Rogan Experience, which was first announced back in May. The deal is worth $100m, which is the equivalent of 26 billion songs streamed for musicians paid through Spotify's traditional payment model.

We are still to see the long-term effects of the partnership, with a very mixed picture painted by an impressive initial boost Spotify’s financial outlook, contrasting with fears that not as many YouTube viewers have made the migration to the new platform as had been hoped.

Some may be teething issues, some may prove to be popular in the long term, and some may even change the show forever, but its difficult to deny there have been a few changes in the general vibe of the show since the switch.

Read on as we comb through the reasons for that weird feeling that things are different now.

5. Lack Of Big Name Guests

Okay, so in light of the ongoing global pandemic, JRE has actually done really well in terms of keeping their volume of face-to-face output going, especially when it requires sometimes two or three healthy guests, as well as ensure its host is not out of action at any cost.

The lack of any mega high profile guests is therefore understandable, but it is noticeable that we haven’t seen an Elon Musk, or a Tyson Fury since the switch to Spotify.

There are some concerns, however, that this may be a longer term trend. Guests on JRE are not given a conventional appearance fee and in a lot of cases (particularly with more high profile interviewees), an appearance on the podcast was factored into a wider promotional tour, or work in California, with the old studio conveniently located close to the world’s film and pop music capitals in Los Angeles.

Rogan’s new studio just outside the city of Austin is in good position too, with the host himself noting this did make him more accessible for East Coast guests, and clearly the podcast is a huge pull in its own right. Only time will tell if this leads to a less celebrity-heavy JRE.


4. The Studio

Although this did happen a couple of months before the show went to Spotify exclusively, the move to Austin and change of platform do go hand in hand, and in retrospect we will probably look back on the two as part of the same process of metamorphosis that JRE went through at the end of 2020.

A lot of people don’t like change, and some things that receive an initially poor reaction can go onto be become timeless classics in their own right, for example, The Shawshank Redemption released to a relatively lukewarm response in the mid-‘90s. However, we’re now a couple of months in and people have generally, at best, learnt to live with the new backdrop.

The more rugged old Rogan set up was so iconic it would become unmistakeable as the shot that would appear on its thumbnails for YouTube videos, which have also now changed slightly on Spotify.

Maybe it just takes time to bed into a new studio, but as it stands, it just doesn’t have quite the same feeling, with a more clean-cut set up accentuating the idea in some people’s minds that the whole JRE operation has taken a decided turn to the corporate.


3. Censorship?

At the time of writing the jury’s still kind of out on this one. A good number of previous instalments of JRE never made it onto Spotify.

In defence of Spotify, its not like YouTube have had a relaxed approach to the content of high profile channels, with a few episodes of JRE going missing from the platform even before Rogan made his intentions to move to Spotify clear.

There have been a number of reliable reports of staff at Spotify pushing for further editorial control of the show, with some at the company uncomfortable with his choice of guests.

Whilst we couldn’t imagine Joe agreeing to this, and presumably the terms of contract are already set out, the subconscious assessments that now perhaps need to be made with the knowledge that conflict may be ahead could yet prove to have a stifling effect on conversation on JRE.


2. No Comments

Joe “I’m not married to anything...except my wife” Rogan.

I feel like Neil DeGrasse Tyson didn’t let the guest speak much.

In a parallel universe, DMT has a podcast and always brings up Joe Rogan.

There were some moments of gold from the YouTube comments section on JRE, and a good portion of them were gently mocking the host. Obviously, by percentage most of it was a horror show, but that is not a problem exclusive to Rogan’s channels.

Spotify doesn’t have the same provision for community engagement, and with the longer format of the show, it’s more likely viewers would have taken a look down at the comments than most YouTube videos.

Whilst this may not seem to be the biggest of issues, someone at JRE did read them at least occasionally (our money is on Young Jamie), and they have been referenced on the show before. Of course, Rogan does have a huge social media presence and presumably has not shortage of contact from fans, but this does create a slight disconnect between the direct audience and the team behind JRE that didn’t exist before.


1. Another Platform

A look at comments section, or lack thereof, on Spotify leads nicely into the wider point of this all being a bit of an inconvenience, particularly if you weren’t already using Spotify for music and/or podcasts, or if you were getting your JRE audio fix from Apple, for example.

This is a particular issue for those who might want to skip the ads, the price of premium subscriptions to both Spotify and YouTube is not insignificant, and suddenly having to deal with interruptions to JRE that you didn’t before can be quite jarring.

The fact that you are not linked to further videos, including shorter format ones is another minus for Spotify. The beautifully eclectic mix that makes up the JRE fan base created some fantastically weird suggestions through the YouTube algorithm, and cross-cultural conversation.

Whilst a lot of the points on this list can potentially be put down to teething problems, this is the one that could see the JRE train come unstuck slightly. Unfortunately, Spotify aren’t as transparent with its number of views on each video as YouTube, but early anecdotal evidence suggests a substantial number of JRE fans have not made the migration between platforms.


Contributor

Writer on international relations, political philosophy, and drunken cowboys in video games. Contributor at WhatCulture.