5 Reasons Nazi Germany Could Never Have Won World War II
No, producing a boatload of V2 rockets wouldn't have saved Hitler's regime.
In popular history, the narrative of the Second World War in Europe is pretty well defined at this point.
After the seizing power in Germany, Hitler annexed Austria and the Sudetenland, with Britain and France promising to come to Poland's aid should the Nazi's attempt to extend their conquest for lebensraum further east.
Then British PM Neville Chamberlain received assurances that Hitler was content with his territory as it stood, which obviously turned out to be insincere. (The Nazi's were liars, who knew?)
The Soviet Union then shocked everyone in 1939 by signing the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, guaranteeing peace between the two countries and carving up Poland between them, leading to British and French intervention and starting the Second World War in the process.
Eventually though, Hitler would betray his nonaggression agreement, launching Operation Barbarossa and invading the Soviet Union (Again, if you hadn't been following along: Nazis = bad guys) with ultimately disastrous results.
And this is generally where the alternate history timelines tend to diverge from real life. It's not uncommon for people, generally on the internet, to armchair quarterback one of the largest war machines in human history and explain how, with some changes, the Nazis could have emerged victorious.
But the truth is, that just isn't the case. Though the war certainly could've been prolonged had different decisions been made, with the sides as they were, there was no way that fascism would have eventually prevailed.
5. Oil
Though now more-commonly discussed as something that wars are fought over, it isn't widely known outside historians just how big a role the need for oil played WW2.
In order to facilitate the rapid expansion of the Nazi empire across Europe, Hitler and co would need an almost ungodly amount of oil. Without a sufficient supply, the armoured divisions that had rolled both east and westward with such unprecedented success would be ground to an almost immediate halt, with Germany just not having the natural resources to remedy this.
With that in mind, Hitler knew he needed to source a supply of liquid gold right from the early stages of the war. Even while the German-Soviet pseudo-truce was ongoing and the two powers had agreed to carve up Poland between them in the 1939 'friendship' pact, Hitler was well aware of the acute oil shortages his regime faced, and how unlikely it was that a war on the scale of WW2 could be maintained without capturing a massive source of oil.
This is the primary reason that Hitler chose to invade the Soviet Union when he did. British naval blockades had starved the axis power of one of the war's most pivotal resources, and if the invasion of the USSR had been delayed any longer, Nazi Germany simply wouldn't have had the resources required to make the necessary advances.
This is also the reason Hitler was so fixated on capturing Stalingrad. Of course, it would've been nice for him to get one over on his fellow dictator by capturing a city named after the Soviet supreme, but it was what laid beyond the city, the oil-rich Caucasus area that was the true prize in the eyes of the Führer.
By failing to succeed in having Operation Barbarossa be the quick and fatal blow against the USSR as it was intended, the war had already turned decisively against Germany and though the regime could continue to wage war following that point, the opportunity to emerge with any kind of victory was all but lost from the defeat at Stalingrad onwards.
4. The Soviet Union
It might seem a little redundant to include the Soviet Union on a list of reasons why Nazi Germany couldn't win WW2. I mean, it is clear that the sacrifices of the communist superpower were instrumental in halting German dominance in continental Europe, but it has to be noted that even if events hadn't unfolded exactly as they did, Stalin and co would have always fought to the bitter end.
That brings us to one of the most compelling arguments as to how Germany could have won the war and that is by never launching Operation Barbarossa.
The issue with this idea is that to believe it requires a complete misunderstanding of the ideological motivations for much of Hitler's decision making to assume that the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact of 1939 would prevent war between the two powers from taking place.
Hitler saw the concepts of Judaism and Bolshevism as inseparable, and maintained a deep hatred for both, meaning that the conflict with the USSR was the one that took ideological precedence in the eyes of the German leader. While war with the Allied powers in the west was necessary as they opposed Hitler's territorial ambitions, invading the Soviet Union was the Nazi leader's ultimate aim.
So with the regime's oil supplies already insufficient to support the bulging Reich as previously discussed, the decision to invade was not as much of a strategic misstep as it was ultimately an inevitability right from the outset of the war.
Some Russian scholarship even goes as far as suggesting that Hitler wasn't the only party interested in breaking the nonaggression pact, and that Stalin was actually planning on invading Germany in the summer of 1941, making the decision the invade the USSR a preemptive strike from the Nazi regime. If true, this means that one way or another, a communist versus fascist showdown in Eastern Europe was bound to take place.
3. The Royal Navy And Air Force
Though the British Expeditionary Force may have suffered a significant defeat during the early stages of the war, having being forced to withdraw back to the UK in the Dunkirk operation, the British Navy remained the premier naval force in the European theatre during this time period.
I mean, there's a reason the song says Britannia rules the waves, right?
Many arguments for how Nazi Germany could've won WW2 state that Hitler's regime could have prevented the Dunkirk evacuation by not making the decision to halt their advance towards the French shores on the 24 May 1940 and effectively disabled the British land army.
Other arguments claim that if the Germans had pushed forward following the evacuation with Operation Sea Lion and invaded Great Britain in September of 1940 that they could've effectively put an end to the Western Front and allowed them to solely focus on defeating the USSR.
The problem with this line of thinking is that even if the Germans had chosen to do both of those things, victory against the British was far from guaranteed.
In order to support an invasion into the British mainland, the German Navy would've needed to have some control over the channel crossing to allow the passage of troops and supplies. This would not have been possible due to the strength of the Royal Navy in the early part of the war, making the success of an amphibious invasion highly unlikely.
Some theorists have claimed that naval control of the English Channel wouldn't have been necessary and that the Germans could have launched an invasion from the air with paratroopers, but the Nazis had failed to seize control of British airspace during the Battle of Britain and even if they had, the effectiveness of trying to seize territory through an entirely airborne operation was proven to be limited to say the least in later Allied campaigns in Crete and Arnhem.
2. Their Allies
If you try to condense WW2 down as an analogous bar fight, it's probably fair to say that Nazi Germany was not very well supported by its friends in the grand scheme of things.
With the Nazis already finding themselves taking on a good portion of the patrons inside, their troubles would only be compounded when Imperial Japan decided to throw a sucker punch at the biggest dude in the bar with Pearl Harbour, and Fascist Italy struggling to hold their own in the scrap.
Pearl Harbour alone is a huge reason the Nazi regime was always going to struggle to come out of WW2 intact. As we've already discussed, Hitler was mainly concerned with expanding Lebensraum and eliminating the communist ideology to the east, and would've even probably have preferred to avoid, or at least delay, war with Britain and the US if possible, but Uncle Sam's involvement became inevitable after the Japanese bombing.
Suddenly, Nazi Germany was not only facing the prospect of trying to be the first civilisation to conquer Russia since the Mongols, but now also had to try to fight a war on two fronts without significant assistance from their allies.
Hitler tried to get the Japanese to invade the Soviet Union to force the USSR to also have to deal with the prospect of a war on two fronts, but they refused, leaving the Axis powers isolated in their own conflicts.
In a war spanning the entire world, Germany found itself at war against empires and superpowers that stretched onto every major inhabited continent, and the strain of war on multiple fronts without significant assistance from their allies was always going to be too much for the fascist regime.
1. Manpower
One of the most compelling arguments as to why Germany was never going to win World War II is simply that of a shortage of manpower. By the time the Axis power found itself in a war on two fronts, attrition had been revealed as the name of the game and much like the issue discussed earlier with oil shortages, Germany also only had a finite number of soldiers, and costly campaigns in the east had led to a massive scarcity of soldiers towards the latter years of the conflict.
In many ways, the initial portion of the German offensive into the Soviet Union was a great success in how it had claimed so much territory and dealt the Soviets such large losses in both troops and armour in a relatively short time.
However, even if Hitler had been successful in pushing through the Soviet lines at Stalingrad, the sheer number of soldiers that would be required to both continue the invasion, and maintain control over the occupied territories would've stretched the German army far too thin, especially while still fighting on other fronts.
What was initially unlikely became practically impossible after the US joined the war. Though Hitler had stated that he believed war with the superpower was an inevitable eventually, the conflict opening on another front was disastrous for a military that was already caught up in a brutal battle of attrition in the east. This is why during the final months of the war, and particularly in the Battle of Berlin, the remaining German forces consisted of both the young and elderly who had been forced to join the fight due to the death, capture, or dismemberment of the vast majority of fighting age Nazis.