7 Psychological 'Tricks' That Are Total Bullsh*t

No, those classic rock albums will not turn teenagers into satanists.

DERREN BROWN
Channel 4

The internet, the newspapers and the self-help sections of book shops are all teeming with the latest psychological tips and tricks. Whether you want to slim down, swot up, catch a liar, or simply manipulate other people for your own nefarious ends, you will find no shortage of expert advice.

This swings wildly between genuine research, pseudoscience, misinterpreted data, and straight up b*llshit.

Although there definitely are ways to use human psychology to your advantage, the effects would probably be subtle at best. A good general rule is that if something sounds too good to be true, slightly dodgy or even like straight up witchcraft, then you should probably take it with a big old pinch of salt. Particularly if someone also happens to be trying to sell you something.

This is also useful information to have on hand when that eerie dude at the pub starts trying to convince you that he's some kind of mind control master because he's watched a couple of Derren Brown videos. You can either use it to administer a spectacular science take down, or just sit safe in the knowledge that he's probably not going to be able to read your mind or make you bark like a dog.


7. Looking To The Left Means The Person Is Lying

Ringu Eyes
Toho

There are a range of variations on this theme, but the general gist is that you can tell what a person is think by the direction that their eyes flick off to. The idea behind the "left means lying" myth is that the eyes dart left when trying to "construct" something and the eyes dart right when trying to "remember" something.

This is, of course, a load of dingo's kidneys.

It is true that a person will look away from you when they are trying to figure out or remember something, but this is because looking at a human face is too distracting to the brain, which is programmed to constantly try to read and decode any human face it catches sight of.

There is evidence to suggest that gaze aversion helps improve concentration, particularly in young children. So if you really want your kids to do well, get them to look away from you when they're answering difficult questions.


6. Tell People Your Goals

you tried simpsons
Fox

A popular little "hack" that usually does the rounds at new year time, is that you should tell people about your goals to lose weight/learn german/take up knitting. The theory is that, if other people know about your grand plans, you'll be more likely to stick to them so as not to let them down.

Where this all falls down, however, is that it doesn't work in the slightest, and could actually have the opposite effect.

The first problem is that, harsh as it might sound, nobody else cares enough about your personal goals for it to be a big deal when you eventually abandon them in favour of Netflix and cronuts. The second is that announcing your goals to the world might actually make you less likely to see them through.

This is because, in telling your friends that you're going to learn german, you're rewarded with a little kick of pleasure straight away. Your brain reacts as though you have taken steps to achieving your goal, when you haven't at all, and is more likely to lose motivation to actually do it. Why would you put in the effort to actually learn german, when you can get the same warm glow from just telling people about it?

The better strategy is to keep it to yourself, and use the


5. Subliminal Messaging Can Control Your Mind

Hungry Eat Popcorn Crop
Columbia Pictures

Fret not, you can safely allow your offspring to listen to classic rock albums without turning them into little satanists (unless that was your aim, in which case, bad luck). Similarly, you can let them watch movies without them becoming little capitalist gremlins, because things like subliminal advertising and backmasking do not work as brainwashing techniques.

Despite the controversy in the 80s, hiding demonic messages in music by playing it backwards has zero chance of opening people's hearts to satan. The brain won't register the backward sounds as words because, get this, they're different sounds.

The one and only study that claimed the "single frame flash" was an effective subliminal advertising technique is now thought to have been based on falsified data. Flashing up "Drink Coke" and "Eat Popcorn" on a cinema screen isn't what makes people want to do those things at the movies. It probably has more to do with all the delicious sugar.


4. “Instant” Hypnosis

Channel 4

Instant hypnosis induction is certainly a high impact bit of showmanship, but can you really put someone into a hypnotic trance by simply catching them by surprise and telling them to "sleep".

Yes and no, it depends on your definition of "hypnotic trance". What's certainly not happening, is that the unwitting victim is instantaneously losing conciousness.

Most often, these "instant inductions" will be performed in front of a crowd, which immediately places a pressure on the subject to "play along", even subconsciously - they will also likely know what an induction is "supposed" to look like and will expect it to happen. This is all really part of the process of "priming" someone for hypnosis, by placing them in a situation in which they will do what you want.

When a subject is told to "sleep", they're really just closing their eyes, perhaps nodding their head forward. Although it looks as though they have immediately conked out, the process of sending them into a state of relaxation actually began long before that moment, and continues long after it.


3. Lie Detector Tests

Lie Detector Meet The Parents
Universal Pictures

Put very simply, lie detector tests don't work. And even if they did, they would be very easily fooled.

Lie detectors, or polygraphs, measure things like heart rate, skin conductivity (sweating, basically) and breathing rate to sniff out a liar. The problem is that they make their measurements against a baseline control reading, which means that if you were highly motivated to lie, you could try to induce a stress response when answering the control questions, then the rest of your untruthful readings would match up.

You needn't bother, however, because they're so unreliable that the chances of catching a liar with a polygraph is little better than flipping a coin. It is for this reason that polygraph results are not admissible in a court of law, and so many people flip out at their lie detector results on Jeremy Kyle.


2. Mozart Makes You Smarter

Mozart portrait
Wikipedia

The music of Mozart is certainly beautiful, pleasant and relaxing, but exposing yourself or even your unborn child to those twiddly strings is, unfortunately, not going to bolster the old IQ.

This whole thing is based on a small bit of research that was conducted in the 90s, and snowballed from there.

The original 1993 study looked into the causal relationship between listening to music and a marginally improved performance in spatial-reasoning tasks. The study was only conducted on 36 people, none of which were in the womb, and only showed a small improvement in spatial reasoning for a liimited period of time.

Now, the scientifically minded amongst you will have noticed that this is not exactly the same thing as "playing Mozart to your unborn child will make them a legit genius". Not quite.


1. Brain Training

Brain switch
Pixabay

Not too long ago, we were all being told that, by playing some fun little games on our smartphones on a regular basis, we could train our brains, boost our intelligence and even ward off diseases such as Alzheimer's.

More recently, however, the headline-grabbing brain training breakthrough has had more holes poked in it than a colander.

For a start, the study that made the claims for brain training didn't have a proper control group - a big no no in science. The testing methods were also different between the groups and the researchers only used one kind of test to measure thier results.

Studies and meta-analyses since have so far failed to replicate the results of the original research and there is simply no solid evidence that brain training games improve your cognitive abilities. If you find them fun and diverting, go for it, but if you were hoping to boost your brain power, save your money.

You could write for WhatCulture Science! Click here to find out how you could get paid to write about what you love.

If science gives you the warm fuzzies, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter to stay up to date.


In this post: 
Science
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Writer. Raconteur. Gardeners' World Enthusiast.