8 Times Harry Potter Was On Trial
Taking "if you spoil Harry Potter for me, I'll shoot you" to new heights of realism...
The Harry Potter series is unfathomably lucrative. In 2011, the Harry Potter brand was valued by Business Insider at over fifteen billion dollars. Fifteen billion that's more billions than double the number of people on this Earth. More than four-hundred million copies of Harry Potter books have been sold worldwide. There's a Warner Brothers helmed film franchise, a theme park, video games, and innumerable other kinds of merchandise. It's only natural, then, that certain people would see Rowling's vast success and want a share of that Gringotts Bank-tier profit. The temptation must be ridiculously strong. Any connection or similarity to anything in the Harry Potter series regardless of how slight has the potential to rake in hundreds of thousands, maybe even millions Of course, with great success comes great legal defence. Pursuing a claim with no legitimacy is practically financial suicide, but sometimes people just can't see beyond the pound signs in their eyes. Here are some of the most foolish examples of times when people tried to take Harry Potter to court.
8. A Canadian Folk Band Didn't Want To Be Mistaken For A Wizard Rock Band

7. An American Writer Claimed She Invented Muggles (Even Though They Were Mutants)
It's incredible just how quickly the credibility drops off on this one. In 1999, the American author Nancy Stouffer accused J. K. Rowling of stealing ideas from her own books, infringing her copyrights and trademarks. For a start, Stouffer had written a book that contained a race of beings known as Muggles. She had also written a book titled Larry Potter And His Best Friend Lillly. Okay, well Larry Potter sounds like Harry Potter...and Harry's mum was called Lily Lucky for Rowling, Stouffer's Muggles were a race of mutant humanoids. The similarities between Larry and Harry were that both wore glasses. And what else did she cite as proof of infringement? Both stories feature wooden doors. When it finally went to court, Stouffe was fined fifty-thousand dollars for bad conduct, including attempts to fraudulently update her stories with more frequent usage of the word Muggle.6. Rowling Was Accused Of Plagiarising The Adventures Of Willy The Wizard

5. China Published A Harry Potter Book That Was Just Tolkien's The Hobbit With Name Changes

4. Warner Brothers Reduced A Fifteen Year Old Harry Potter Fan To Tears

3. A Publisher Banned Consumers From Reading The Half-Blood Prince (Even Though They'd Already Bought It)
Surely this is the final evolutionary manifestation of spoiler culture. In 2005, Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince was on the cusp of being published throughout the world at large. Everywhere was on spoilers crackdown, with publishers ensuring that no part of Rowling's new book was leaked to the public. Unfortunately for Rowling, a Real Canadian Superstore grocery store mistakenly sold several copies of the book before the release date. Fair enough, you might think a regrettable mistake that is pretty much inevitable regardless. Rather than warn fans to be vigilant about spoilers, however, the book's Canadian publisher Raincoast Books managed to obtain an injunction from the Supreme Court of British Columbia which essentially banned the people who had bought the book early from reading it. This lead to a massive media and legal discussion over whether or not human beings have a right to read, and a right to freely access information. In the end, it was ruled that copyright law has basically nothing to say about what people can do with a book once they've bought it.2. Asda Accused Bloomsbury Of Charging Way Too Much For Harry Potter Books

1. A Security Guard Tried To Shoot A Journalist Over Harry Potter Spoilers
