10 Biggest Controversies in Cricket History
Strap on your pads and get ready to face some nasty deliveries.
In light of the current saga surrounding the future of Kevin Pietersen, and the ongoing fallout from Tony Greigs Spirit of Cricket lecture (interpreted by some as an exercise in India-bashing), it seems a good time to look back on some of crickets most controversial moments. In this age of 24-hour rolling news and sensationalistic journalism, it can seem like an earth-shattering imbroglio every time a cricketer picks his nose. But which moments still touch a nerve with players and fans alike? One caveat before we start. By controversy we mean an event which caused a considerable divide in opinion, rather than something which simply got headlines. For that reason were not including incidents like Allan Donalds epic duel with Michael Atherton in 1998; though that prompted many column inches, events like this are generally held as having a positive impact on the game, and are remembered as fondly as a Don Bradman century. These are the moments which truly ruffled feathers on both sides and continue in some way to represent a black mark on the sports history. So strap on your pads and get ready to face some nasty deliveries. But, because cricketers are gentlemen (at least in theory), well start off with a gentle loosener
10. The Monkey Incident Australia vs. India, 2007-08
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnV1L3kBIR0 This is one of many examples on this list of a South African getting it wrong not Tony Greig on this occasion, but county cricket superstar-turned-match referee Mike Proctor. The second test between Australia and India at the Melbourne Cricket Ground in January 2008 was a heated battle, marred by allegations of poor sportsmanship and poor umpiring. But the proverbial really hit the fan during the third day, when Indian off-spinner Harbhajan Singh was batting with Sachin Tendulkar. After getting a lucky edge against fast bowler Brett Lee that went for four, Harbhajan tapped Lee on the backside with his bat and muttered: Hard luck. Aussie all-rounder Andrew Symonds ran in to give Harbhajan a piece of his mind, and Harbhajan allegedly retorted by calling Symonds a monkey. This was not the first time that Symonds, the only non-white player in the Aussie side, had been subjected to racial abuse. In the ODI series in India the previous year, he was booed and jeered with taunts of Symonds is a monkey as he walked out to bat in Mumbai, and fell first ball. On this occasion neither of the two umpires heard the remarks, and it was Aussie captain Ricky Ponting who reported Harbhajan to the match referee. Indian captain Anil Kumble attempted to diffuse the situation, but to no avail. Proctor conferred a three-match ban on Harbhajan, which led to allegations of Proctor being biased in favour of the Australians and the tour being suspended as relations between the camps broke down. The incident sparked a widespread discussion about the role of sledging or verbal intimidation on the field, with Pakistan legend Wasim Akram accusing the Australians of hypocrisy. These debates continued even after the ICC overturned Proctors decision, citing lack of evidence. What Happened Next: Harbhajan played in the third and final test, on the grounds that there was not enough time to lodge an appeal between matches. Proctor was criticised by Indian legend Sunil Gavaskar and his decision to ban Harbhajan was overturned by the ICC. Australia won the series 2-1.9. Youre Nothing But Cheats New Zealand vs. West Indies, 1979-80
When Imran Khan delivered the Spirit of Cricket Lecture back in 2010, he remarked how the idea of neutral umpires has become completely taken for granted. But when Khan was playing in the 1970s and 1980s, it was customary for the home side to provide the umpires, leading to a number of obviously biased decisions. Khan was ridiculed for campaigning for neutral umpires, with his contemporaries at test and domestic level believing that it all evens out in the end. Perhaps no test series illuminates this problem than the 1979-80 series between New Zealand and the West Indies. The West Indies had not lost a test series since 1975 and were growing in stature having thrashed England in England in 1976 (more on that later). But the 1979-80 series was marred by terrible umpiring in favour of the home side, resulting in the only series defeat ever inflicted on what is widely regarded as the greatest cricket team of all time a team that didnt lose another series until 1994. Two incidents from the tour made international headlines, both involving New Zealand-born umpire Fred Goodall. In the first test fast bowler Michael Holding lost his cool and kicked the stumps out of the ground after an appeal for caught behind was turned down. As Goodall remade the wicket and asked the WI skipper Clive Lloyd to have a word with his bowler, one of the slips shouted back at him: Youre nothing but cheats. In the second test, fast bowler Colin Croft elbowed Goodall in the back during his run-up, after two clear shouts for caught behind were turned down. What Happened Next: New Zealand won the three-test series 1-0, Goodall tarnished his reputation further by making racist comments in a post-series after-dinner speech, and discussions about neutral umpiring began at the higher levels of crickets governing body.
8. The Dirt in the Pocket England vs. South Africa, 1994
For fans of English cricket, playing South Africa often comes close to the Ashes. The matches are closely-fought contests with great displays of fast bowling and gutsy batting, and like the Ashes there is plenty of aggression and controversy. But for all the twists and turns in the Kevin Pietersen situation that is overshadowing this most recent series, this on-field incident is pretty hard to top. On the third day of the first test at Lords, South Africa were batting well and on course for a good total in their second innings. Englands bowlers looked below-par, snatching a wicket here and there but failing to keep pressure on the batsmen. And then, TV cameras caught the England captain and opening batsman Michael Atherton appearing to rub something from his trouser pocket onto the ball. Under the laws of cricket it is illegal to alter the ball using any artificial substance or ones fingers, e.g. lifting up the seam or scuffing it with ones fingernails. Atherton was reported to the match referee Peter Burge and denied using any substance to alter the ball. It later emerged that Atherton had kept some earth in his trouser pocket, which he claimed was to dry his sweaty hands and thereby keep the ball in good condition. There were widespread calls for Atherton to resign the captaincy, with Pakistan manager Intikhab Alam saying he had been caught red-handed. He has to be replaced. What Happened Next: Michael Atherton retained the England captaincy, but was fined £2000 by the Chairman of Selectors, Ray Illingworth, for not being totally honest with the match referee. South Africa won the test by 356 runs and the series was drawn 1-1.
7. Pakistan Spot-Fixing England vs. Pakistan, 2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QKhfUjMWP3Q Pakistan has always had a reputation surrounding match fixing, ranging from the accusations levied at Wasim Akram to the fall from grace of Saleem Malik and Basit Ali. In a recent interview, Imran Khan spoke about how he felt that allegations such as these meant that the team which won the 1992 World Cup never really fulfilled its potential. But for Khan, no event was more painful than the no-ball scandal of 2010, involving the Pakistan captain Salman Butt and fast bowlers Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir. During the fourth and final test at Lords, Asif and Amir both bowled huge no-balls, at the start of the third over and the end of the tenth over of play. Amirs no-ball was noticeable, as he overstepped by around a foot unusual for a bowler who had been so accurate up to that point. It subsequently transpired that a sting operation by the News of the World newspaper had produced footage of sports agent Mazhar Majeed, counting out bribe money and predicting no-balls on those exact deliveries in the match. The paper named Butt, Asif and Amir as being involved. The ICC suspended all three players on September 4th, five days after the match had ended in an innings defeat for Pakistan and England winning the series 3-1. Subsequent investigations led to all three players being banned and eventually jailed. The incidents raised real questions about the integrity of Pakistan cricket, and led to outbursts of support for the 18-year-old Amir, whom many believed had been tricked by Butt. Michael Holding, working as a pundit for Sky Sports, actually burst into tears on air after hearing about the allegations. What Happened Next: All three players were convicted of match fixing, with Butt being banned for ten years, Asif for seven and Amir for five. The subsequent investigations by Scotland Yard led to Butt being sentenced to 30 months in jail, Asif for one year, Amir for six months and Majeed for two years and eight months. Amir was released from prison in February 2012.6. Murali Being No-Balled Australia vs. Sri Lanka, 1995-96
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6J5hjUuE_m0 The amazing Sri Lankan off-spinner Muttiah Muralitharan remains a controversial figure in cricket. His unique bowling action, the result of a congenital deformity in his right arm, allowed him to impart enormous spin on the ball, leading to 800 test wickets and 534 ODI wickets, both of them being world records. But accusations that he chucks or throws the ball have dogged him throughout his career, and they all started at the Melbourne Cricket Ground in 1995. During the Boxing Day Test Match, Australian umpire Darrell Hair no-balled Murali seven times, believing that he was straightening his bowling arm during his delivery and thereby contravening the laws of cricket. Ten days later, in January 1996, Murali was no-balled a further seven times by umpire Ross Emerson during a triangular ODI against the West Indies in Brisbane. Murali was jeered by the Australian crowds, who would later make a habit of shouting No-ball! during his deliveries. Debate raged as to whether Murali was genuinely throwing the ball or whether his wristy action created the illusion of throwing. Sir Don Bradman, widely regarded as the greatest ever batsman, called it the worst example of umpiring I have ever seen, and against everything the game stands for. Murali underwent biomechanical testing on his bowling arm to determine whether his action was legal. In his Spirit of Cricket lecture in 2011, Sri Lanka captain Kumar Sangakkara cited this event as the moment which galvanised Sri Lanka into winning the subsequent World Cup. What Happened Next: Muralitharan was cleared by the ICC and allowed to continue bowling. Sri Lanka, spurred on by this incident, went on to beat Australia to win the 1996 World Cup.5. Hansie Cronjes Match-Fixing South Africa vs. England, 1999-2000
This example combines elements of both the #8 and #7 entries, seen as it involves a match between England and South Africa and accusations of match fixing. But while the Pakistan case was motivated purely by self-interest, the case of Hansie Cronje appeared at first to be in the interests of cricket. The fifth test of the 1999-2000 series at Centurion was poised to be a boring dead rubber. South Africa had already won the series 2-0, and after the first days play, three whole days had been lost to rain. The game was drifting towards a meaningless draw and the spectators were disappointed at not getting their moneys worth. But this all changed when South Africas captain Hansie Cronje asked the England captain, Nasser Hussein, if they would like to have a game. This resulted in South Africa declaring on 248/8, with each team forfeiting an innings and England having to chase 249 to win. They won by two wickets, ending South Africas 14-game unbeaten run. It subsequently emerged that Cronje had been offered 500,000 Rand from a bookmaker, along with a leather jacket, if he declared and made a game of it. The subsequent King Commission found Cronje guilty of match-fixing, sending shockwaves through South African cricket at the thought that one of its most popular and talented sportsmen could be capable of something so bad. What Happened Next: Cronje was banned from playing and coaching for life in October 2000. He unsuccessfully appealed the decision in 2001, and died in a plane crash in June 2002.
4. I Intend To Make Them Grovel England vs. West Indies, 1976
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mQtW4OzbzKk The West Indies arrived in England in 1976 having been thumped 5-1 by Australia the year before. Australia had previously defeated England in the 1974-75 Ashes, a series dominated by the devastating pace of Dennis Lillee and Jeff Thomson, often regarded as the fastest bowler in history. England captain Tony Greig appeared on TV to discuss Englands build-up and how hard he thought the contest would be. Faced with an interviewer who was biased towards the West Indies, Greig retorted that he didnt think they offered any real threat. And then he made the remake that hung around his neck like an albatross throughout the tour: if theyre down, they grovel, and I intend, with the hope of and a few others to make them grovel. Greigs gaffe touched a nerve for three reasons. Firstly, the word grovel had strong connotations with the slave trade, in which Britain was instrumental right up to the mid-19th century. Secondly, they came in the middle of apartheid in South Africa: the South African cricket team was banned from competing at test level under the terms of the Gleneagles Agreement. And thirdly, Greig was a white South African, who had qualified to play for England by his Scottish parentage. Greigs words spurred the West Indies along, as their fast bowlers attacked Englands batsman with fast, short-pitched bowling and added yards to their run-up whenever Greig walked out to bat. Michael Holding had a brilliant series, bowling England out on a flat Oval pitch and almost killing 45-year-old Brian Close with a bouncer that just missed his head. Greig had a poor series with bat and ball, taking only five wickets and being frequently clean bowled. What Happened Next: The West Indies won the series 3-0. Greig retained the England captaincy, only to lose it a year later for his involvement in World Series Cricket (more on that later).3. The Underarm Incident Australia vs. New Zealand, 1981
If former Aussie captain Ian Chappell is to be believed, the Underarm Incident is New Zealands equivalent of Bodyline in other words, a time where the letter of the law clashed with the spirit of the game, tarnishing careers and creating deep divides in the process. Unlike most of the entries in this list, this incident took place in a one-day international specifically the third final of the 1981 Benson & Hedges World Series Cup. New Zealand had been set 236 to win, and needed 15 runs from the last over. Having lost two wickets in the over, New Zealand needed a six off the last ball to tie the match and keep the series at 1-1. Greg Chappell, the Australian captain, ordered his younger brother Trevor to bowl an underarm delivery for the last ball, to prevent New Zealand batsman Brian McKechnie from scoring the six runs needed. Trevor Chappell protested, believing that it wasnt in the spirit of the game. He bowled the delivery, Australia won the game and the teams walked off to booing and jeering. Bowling underarm was legal within the Benson & Hedges rulebook, but it was not considered sportsmanlike. The decision brought criticism from all sides. Ian Chappell criticised his brother on commentary, while Australian legend Richie Benaud called it one of the worst things I have ever seen done on a cricket field. The Prime Ministers of both nations waded in, accusing Australia of cowardice and poor sportsmanship. But there were two final bitter twists to the on-field action. The first was that, while neither Greg nor Trevor Chappell were censured for the incident, McKechnie was prosecuted for bringing the game into disrepute after hurling his bat away in disgust. The other is that as Chappell bowled the ball, Dennis Lillee was not standing inside the fielding circle: the Australians were using an illegal fielding position, so it was technically a no-ball all along. What Happened Next: The rules of cricket were changed by the ICC to make underarm bowling illegal in all formats of the game. Trevor Chappells career was forever tarnished, and to this day none of the three brothers are willing to discuss the matter.
2. World Series Cricket, 1977-79
With all the current talk about the IPL and the future of test cricket, it can be said that we are witnessing the greatest changes in cricket for a generation. Certainly thats how it must have felt in the late-1970s when World Series Cricket shook the game at its foundations. In 1977 Australian media mogul Kerry Packer hit upon the idea of a series of exhibition matches, attracting the finest international cricketers to play against each other for money. Originally intended as a contest between an Australian XI and a Rest of the World XI, he began secretly recruiting players around the time of the 1977 Ashes. In the process he offered a job to incumbent England captain Tony Greig (him again), offering him a job for life with Channel Nine if he acted as recruiting sergeant. World Series Cricket came at a time when TV coverage of cricket was in its infancy, and it was widely perceived that cricketers were underpaid compared to other sportsmen. The Packer Circus, as it was dubbed by British media, pitted the best of the best against each other and accelerated the development of great players like Viv Richards and Imran Khan. It also introduced many of the things we take for granted in the modern game, including floodlights, coloured clothing, coverage with on-pitch cameras, personal sponsorship of players, and helmets for batsmen. World Series Cricket resulted in a series of bitter court cases between Packer and the various cricket boards, over whether involvement in the World Series was a breach of contract. Although the establishment won several small victories (e.g. making him call the matches supertests rather than tests), the crowds eventually embraced Packers vision for the game, forcing the Australian Cricket Board to reconsider. In 1979 an agreement was reached between Packer and the ACB which secured both the financial future of the cricket board and coverage rights for Channel Nine. What Happened Next: World Series Cricket ended in 1979 with the formation of the World Series Cup. The way that TV stations covered cricket was changed forever, and its repercussions are still being felt, particularly on the one-day game.
1. Bodyline Australia vs. MCC (England), 1932-33
What else could be number one in this rundown? The Bodyline series remains one of the most controversial series in cricketing history, a series which is cemented into the history of the Ashes and which remains a bone of contention among fans. For England fans, it represents trying to win by any means within the rules of the game; for Australians, its an indicator that the Poms are terrible sportsmen who can only win by playing dirty. Bodyline, or fast leg theory, was a tactic created by England (specifically the MCC) to restrict the Australian great Sir Donald Bradman during the 1932-33 Ashes in Australia. Bradman had averaged 139.14 in the last series, which Australia won 2-1, and was still averaging over 100. Douglas Jardine, the MCC captain, came across footage from the Oval Test in 1930 which showed Bradman flinching at short, fast-pitched bowling on leg stump. Before the tour, Jardine enlisted Nottinghamshire bowlers Harold Larwood and Bill Voce, and instructed them to bowl fast and short on leg stump, i.e. in the line of the body. The idea was to restrict batsmen from playing on the off-side, forcing them into pull or hook shots which would be dealt with by a packed leg-side field.
Jardine used bodyline sparingly in the warm-up matches, and going into the third test at Adelaide the series was poised at 1-1. But then all hell broke loose as Australian captain Bill Woodfull was struck on the heart by Harold Larwood. Jardine responded by shouting Well bowled, Harold and immediately arranged his fielders into the bodyline field. The repeated use of bodyline almost led to riots in the crowd, who regarded it as kicking a man when he was down. After Woodfull was dismissed for 22, having sustained numerous bruises in a 90-minute stand, he retreated to the changing rooms and uttered those famous words: There are two teams out there, one is playing cricket. The other is making no attempt to do so. The day after Woodfulls barrage, Australian wicket-keeper Bert Oldfield had his skull fractured by a Larwood lifter. By now the ACB and MCC were in heated discussions via cable over the ethics of Bodyline, with the former party accusing the latter of bad sportsmanship and threatening to call off the other matches. Then their respective governments got involved, with the Governor of South Australia warning the British Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs that trade between the nations would decline unless the matter was sorted out. Things were eventually resolved when Australian Prime Minister Joseph Lyons met with the ACB, warning them of the economic hardship that would result from a British boycott of Australian trade. The ACB withdrew its complaint of bad sportsmanship and the other matches went ahead. Bodyline represented a departure from the Victorian notions of sportsmanship, foreshadowing the out-and-out aggression that would be typified by the West Indies in the 1970s and 1980s. It led to debates about the rules of cricket versus the spirit of the game, since there was nothing technically illegal in Englands tactics. It re-opened imperial wounds, with Britains quest for the Ashes coming to be seen as a fallen powers search to recapture some form of dominion. And it made cricket into an issue of national importance, for better or worse. What Happened Next: England won the series 4-1. Jardine resigned from the England captaincy after the 1934 tour to India. Larwood never played for England again, eventually emigrating to Australia where he was welcomed and rehabilitated. The MCC subsequently changed the laws of cricket to allow umpires to intervene if players were deemed to be getting hurt, and to restrict the number of fielders on the leg side.